Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / RingingBell

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** To add, "Churin" is the Japanese Onomatopoeia for the sound of a ringing bell. Churin wears a bell around his neck.

to:

*** To add, "Churin" "Chirin" is the Japanese Onomatopoeia for the sound of a ringing bell. Churin Chirin wears a bell around his neck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** To add, "Churin" is the Japanese Onomatopoeia for the sound of a ringing bell. Churin wears a bell around his neck.

Added: 65

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chirin goes straight to the wolf in anger after his mother is killed. And somehow, ''the wolf doesn't simply eat him''. Granted, the story would be over too quickly but the lack of intent of the wolf to make a meal of Chirin is odd.

to:

* Chirin goes straight to the wolf Woe in anger after his mother is killed. And somehow, ''the wolf doesn't simply eat him''. Granted, the story would be over too quickly but the lack of intent of the wolf to make a meal of Chirin is odd.


Added DiffLines:

** In the book and other versions, Woe's stomach is already full.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Or this is due to the likely fact that rams leave ewes to lead a life of their own.

to:

** Or this is due to the likely fact that rams leave ewes to lead a life of their own.farms are segregated by sex.

Added: 75

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The prototype version of the story fixes this by giving Chirin a father.



** Although they are shown mourning for Chrin's mother, it is very likely that they needed to give Chirin space. That or the writer's way of preventing the story coming to an end with Chirin finding comfort from the other sheep, since the original script and the book by Creator/TakashiYanase called for all of the sheep to be killed by the wolf with Chirin as the only survivor.

to:

** Although they are shown mourning for Chrin's mother, it is very likely that they needed to give Chirin space. That or the writer's way of preventing the story coming to an end with Chirin finding comfort from the other sheep, since the original script and the book by Creator/TakashiYanase called for all of the sheep to be killed by the wolf with Chirin as the only survivor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If he was already starting to feel his age, it's possible that he decided that having someone to hunt by his side might ultimately be worth more in the long run than a quick short-term snack, especially if he was already full from his previous kills.


Added DiffLines:

** Pretty sure the meat of carnivores such as dogs tends to be unsavory to other carnivores, so there's no reason he would eat the dogs unless he was starving. His going after Chirin is also justifiable, since lamb meat is tastier (he may also have been trying to secure a morsel he could easily drag off into the mountains to eat later). He didn't say anything about refusing to waste food, the kills just need to serve '''some''' kind of purpose. More delicious food is a purpose. Him commanding Chirin to slaughter the entire farm is harder to justify, but this might have just been a ploy to test how far Chirin was truly willing to go to become a predator. It is possible that, if Chirin had accepted, Wor would have been content of his loyalties and stopped him after one or two kills.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Does Chirin look like a ram should? No wonder the flock couldn't accept him.

to:

* Does Chirin look like how a ram should? No wonder the flock couldn't accept him.



** He does '''not''' look like a ram should at all. This may be {{Hand Wave}}d as a result of his grueling training, lifestyle completely antithetical to that of a normal sheep, diet potentially [[AscendedToCarnivorism boosted with meat]] and [[JapaneseSpirit sheer determination]] shaping him into a form honed for killing.

to:

** He does '''not''' look like how a ram should at all. This may be {{Hand Wave}}d as a result of his grueling training, lifestyle completely antithetical to that of a normal sheep, diet potentially [[AscendedToCarnivorism boosted with meat]] and [[JapaneseSpirit sheer determination]] shaping him into a form honed for killing.



** Adverted in the picture book where Chirin does introduce himself to Wor properly.

to:

** Adverted Averted in the picture book where Chirin does introduce himself to Wor properly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although they are shown mourning for Chrin's mother, it is very likely that they needed to give Chirin space. That or the writer's way of preventing the story coming to an end with Chirin finding comfort from the other sheep, since the original script and the book by Takashi Yanase called for all of the sheep to be killed by the wolf with Chirin as the only survivor.

to:

** Although they are shown mourning for Chrin's mother, it is very likely that they needed to give Chirin space. That or the writer's way of preventing the story coming to an end with Chirin finding comfort from the other sheep, since the original script and the book by Takashi Yanase Creator/TakashiYanase called for all of the sheep to be killed by the wolf with Chirin as the only survivor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Chirin goes straight to the wolf in anger after his mother is killed. And somehow, ''the wolf doesn't simply eat him''. Granted, the story would be over too quickly but the lack of intent of the wolf to make a meal of Chirin is odd.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Wolf’s speech about how “the weak die so the strong may survive” goes against his actions, at least on a “Everyone needs to eat” way. He at first goes after Chirin even when he has his mother’s carcass in front of him, and he still tries to go after the sheep inside the pen even though he also killed the dogs guarding it on the first place, which would, you know, provide the meat he wants. And that’s without mentioning how he wants Chirin to massacre ALL the sheep inside the pen for him, far more than he would need to eat (And also quite impractical, after all, if all the sheep are dead, he will lose his [[PragmaticVillany easiest and easiest way to acquire food]]) All in all, he seems to attack the sheep more [[ForTheEvulz for kicks]] instead of an actual need to eat. [[StrawHypocrite Hypocrite]], much?

to:

* The Wolf’s speech about how “the weak die so the strong may survive” goes against his actions, at least on a “Everyone needs to eat” way. He at first goes after Chirin even when he has his mother’s carcass in front of him, and he still tries to go after the sheep inside the pen even though he also killed the dogs guarding it on the first place, which would, you know, provide the meat he wants. And that’s without mentioning how he wants Chirin to massacre ALL the sheep inside the pen for him, far more than he would need to eat (And also quite impractical, after all, if all the sheep are dead, he will lose his [[PragmaticVillany [[PragmaticVillain easiest and easiest fastest way to acquire food]]) All in all, he seems to attack the sheep more [[ForTheEvulz for kicks]] instead of an actual need to eat. [[StrawHypocrite Hypocrite]], much?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Wolf’s speech about how “the weak die so the strong may survive” goes against his actions, at least on a “Everyone needs to eat” way. He at first goes after Chirin even when he has his mother’s carcass in front of him, and he still tries to go after the sheep inside the pen even though he also killed the dogs guarding it on the first place, which would, you know, provide the meat he wants. And that’s without mentioning how he wants Chirin to massacre ALL the sheep inside the pen for him, far more than he would need to eat (And also quite impractical, after all, if all the sheep are dead, he will lose his [[PragmaticVillany easiest and easiest way to acquire food]]) All in all, he seems to attack the sheep more [[ForTheEvulz for kicks]] instead of an actual need to eat. [[StrawHypocrite Hypocrite]], much?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Maybe he heard it mentioned somewhere. Or it was a lucky guess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Additionally, even herbivores will occasionally eat meat when the chance presents itself, with cows, deer etc. having been observed to eat birds and other small animals fairly often.


Added DiffLines:

** It's also possible that they don't particularly care, as long as their own lambs are safe.


Added DiffLines:

** After his transformation, Chirin is able to smash '''solid rock''' with his horns. That's the level of power it takes to take him down. He's just so strong that he's '''tougher''' than a tree.


Added DiffLines:

** He presumably ate the body of the first lamb he killed. The kill of Chirin's mother was accidental, he was going for the much smaller Chirin, whom he could have dragged off into the mountains to maybe eat later.


Added DiffLines:

** He does '''not''' look like a ram should at all. This may be {{Hand Wave}}d as a result of his grueling training, lifestyle completely antithetical to that of a normal sheep, diet potentially [[AscendedToCarnivorism boosted with meat]] and [[JapaneseSpirit sheer determination]] shaping him into a form honed for killing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The collar around Chirin's neck. It just seems to mysteriously get larger when we see him as a adult, it should have either fallen/broken off by then or cut into his neck.

to:

* The collar around Chirin's neck. It neck just seems to mysteriously get larger when we see him as a adult, it adult. It should have either fallen/broken off by then or cut into his neck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
answer

Added DiffLines:

** He may have simply hunted and killed animals alongside the wolf, not necessarily eating them afterward. Mountain vegetation is the diet of wild sheep species, after all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Does Chirin eat meat as he lives with a wolf? How did he thrive on a diet of animal flesh, which herbivores can't digest?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He kept his limits, most likely. Same for all of his prey.

to:

** He [[EvenEvilHasStandards Chirin kept his limits, most likely. Same for all of his prey.prey...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They knew it was not their place to interfere, similar scenes involving a crowd of people gathered around a person mourning the loss of a loved one can tell a person that

to:

** They knew it was not their place to interfere, similar scenes involving a crowd of people gathered around a person mourning the loss of a loved one can tell a person thatthat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Or this is due to the likely fact that rams leave ewes to lead a life of their own.


Added DiffLines:

** They knew it was not their place to interfere, similar scenes involving a crowd of people gathered around a person mourning the loss of a loved one can tell a person that
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The film mentioned that Wor was old. [[spoiler:We never actually see the wolf hunt by himself after Chirin grows up; for all we know, Wor's age caught up to him, leaving him feeble and slow. He may have lacked the reflexes and sheer strength to fend off Chirin. Wor also may have decided that death in battle was better than death by old age, especially if Wor's age prevented him from hunting large, aggressive prey by himself at that point in the film.]]

Added: 174

Changed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:Why did Wolf not put up much of a fight against Chirin in their final battle? SuicideByCop perhaps?]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Why did Wolf Wor not put up much of a fight against Chirin in their final battle? SuicideByCop perhaps?]]



* Why does Wolf apparently kill for sport? He doesn't seem to be interested in eating his kills.

to:

* Why does Wolf Wor apparently kill for sport? He doesn't seem to be interested in eating his kills.



** He does eat his kills as it is mentioned many times, but this may be due to censorship.




to:

* How does Wor know Chirin's name when he did not properly introduce himself to him?
** Adverted in the picture book where Chirin does introduce himself to Wor properly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although they are shown mourning for Chrin's mother, it is very likely that they needed to give Chirin space. That or the writer's way of preventing the story coming to an end with Chirin finding comfort from the other sheep, since the original script and the book by Tadashi Yanase called for all of the sheep to be killed by the wolf with Chirin as the only survivor.

to:

** Although they are shown mourning for Chrin's mother, it is very likely that they needed to give Chirin space. That or the writer's way of preventing the story coming to an end with Chirin finding comfort from the other sheep, since the original script and the book by Tadashi Takashi Yanase called for all of the sheep to be killed by the wolf with Chirin as the only survivor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Immaculate conception could be the answer. It is an animated film after all?

to:

** Immaculate conception could be the answer. It is an animated film after all?all.

Added: 668

Changed: 327

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Justified, since no humans are seen.



* Why did the sheep just sit there like useless idiots when Chirin breaks down into hysterical weeping over his mother's corpse? Why did they not even try to offer help or comfort to him?

to:

** Immaculate conception could be the answer. It is an animated film after all?
* Why did the sheep just sit there like useless idiots when Chirin breaks down into hysterical weeping over his mother's corpse? Why did they not even try to offer help or comfort to him?him?
** Although they are shown mourning for Chrin's mother, it is very likely that they needed to give Chirin space. That or the writer's way of preventing the story coming to an end with Chirin finding comfort from the other sheep, since the original script and the book by Tadashi Yanase called for all of the sheep to be killed by the wolf with Chirin as the only survivor.



** He kept his limits, most likely. Same for all of his prey.



** Elastic material, perhaps?




to:

** His unnatural form could be the cause of this since the horns of a regular ram are curved and Chirin's are straight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** At this part of the story, he seemed fond of Chirin and even tried to talk him down for a moment. While Woe didn't regret getting killed by Chirin, he probably liked having a powerful son. If Chirin had the ruthlessness to kill his own kind and remained loyal to Woe, the WeCanRuleTogether speech Chirin made would have been a reality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Does Chirin look like a ram should? No wonder the flock couldn't accept him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to English title.

Added DiffLines:

* Whoever owns that farm should simply repair the hole in the fence.
* Why are almost all the sheep ewes? Is Chirin the only male lamb out of his entire flock? Why are there no rams in the flock?
* Why did the sheep just sit there like useless idiots when Chirin breaks down into hysterical weeping over his mother's corpse? Why did they not even try to offer help or comfort to him?
* If Chirin could headbutt right through a thick tree, why was he unable to headbutt right through Wolf?
* [[spoiler:Why did Wolf not put up much of a fight against Chirin in their final battle? SuicideByCop perhaps?]]
* The collar around Chirin's neck. It just seems to mysteriously get larger when we see him as a adult, it should have either fallen/broken off by then or cut into his neck.
* Why does Wolf apparently kill for sport? He doesn't seem to be interested in eating his kills.
** Believe it or not, it can be TruthInTelevision.

----

Top