Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / ParanormalActivity

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**If it makes you feel better, just assume that demon means "Inherently evil ghost"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Dan found the picture in the second movie and burned it himself, apparently as a way to make the demon go for Katie. Apparently it just wasn't destroyed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** So, here's the real question- what, exactly, was so special about that ''one particular demonologist'' that he was the only one who could keep things from going all pear-shaped? Seriously, it's not like there's a shortage or something.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Spoilers just to be safe. In the first movie, Katie flips out when [[spoiler:Micah finds an old picture of her]] because [[spoiler:it was supposed to be destroyed in a house fire]]. So how is Dan able to [[spoiler:retrieve and burn the picture]] in the second movie?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** They're saying that they couldn't take the movie seriously because it's a lot easier for them to believe in a ghost than a demon. Definitely a personal thing, for some people it's the other way around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Did either of them ever hear of a church? This troper would've slept in one and bathed in holy water.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[Enfant Terrible]] Aaaaaaaah!

to:

** [[Enfant Terrible]] Aaaaaaaah![[EnfantTerrible Aaaaaaaah!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[Enfant Terrible]] Aaaaaaaah!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** What?

to:

** What?What? I'm not trying to be rude, but that stament is very confusing. Could you please clarigy so that I can make an appropriate response?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**What?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Why the huge hate-on for Micah? To me, it just seemed he was possessed by a [[IncrediblyLamePun "spirit of experimentation"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
If you want to talk about why the movie was bad, then go use the review system please.


* Why the ''fuck'' was ''anyone'' actually scared by this piece of shit movie? Three year olds could fall asleep watching it. I mean, I've seen ''comedy'' horrors that were scarier, like ''DragMeToHell''. I mean, sure, they advertised it to be really scary and maybe it was just the placebo effect. However, I saw through it all along; I never thought it would be scary (mainly because I'm pretty critical of the whole horror genre.) Most of the film was clearly just trying to build up to a big scare later that didn't come until the end. Though, the ending was only a huge surprise just because something finally happened. This, however, does not justify how boring the whole movie was up to that scene. It was simply cheap, and they didn't even manage to do cheap, easy scares correctly. The ''ANightmareOnElmStreet'' remake was ''nothing'' except cheap scares, for example, but still scared me half to death in the theater.
** The reason why people thought it was scary was because of the "suspense", I guess you could call it. Modern horror films tell us that any long, silent, quiet, drawn out scene will include a jump scare at some point. Paranormal Activity used this to its advantage by putting in a lot of scenes that included all of the elements of a scene that would include such a scare, so that people would get tense waiting for it, but only rarely did it ever actually act on it; not really until the surprise body at the end. That might be why the ending was changed from the Katie-walks-in-the-room-with-the-knife thing to her throwing [[spoiler: Micah's]] body at the camera. It was more surprising, and the audience would hopefully have, at this point, stopped expecting a jump scare, thus amplifying the shock factor.
*** Maybe I fell asleep from boredom, but I don't recall any suspenseful scenes. All I saw were a bitch and an asshole screaming at each other for an hour and a half.
** Also depends greatly on what scares you. Many people are more freaked out by quiet, unseen horrors than by jump scares or on-screen gore. There's a reason the NothingIsScarier trope exists. There's also the fact that they were fighting a being that they couldn't even ''see'' or ''touch'' unless it wanted them to - that alone can be a major source of NightmareFuel.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Regardless, that wouldn't stop the demon from eventually possessing her. Whether she leaves or stays, she's screwed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If we take what was said in the prequel as true, it is quite possible that Katie was from a relatively wealthy family. Apparently, some ancestor of Katie made a deal with the demon of giving her firstborn for wealth, or something of the sort. Since the prequel was all about the demon trying to receive the payment for its services, we can conclude that it kept its side of the bargain. So yeah, it's quite possible that she inherited it, or her family helped her purchase it, etc etc etc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The fact that the entity is explicitly stated to be a demon rather than a ghost. Maybe this is just personal preference. Ghost? Scary. Demon? A little too far out of the realm of possibility for me to willingly suspend my disbelief. Same reason I couldn't help but roll my eyes at the GhostHunters during the first couple of seasons when they'd start talking about "demonic" hauntings as opposed to the other kind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Nearly every night the characters go to sleep, they leave the bed room door open with Katie sleeping closest to the door. The night after the Demon walks into the room, stands right next to Katie's side of the bed (as evidenced by the foot prints), and "fiddles" with the sheets (as evidenced by the video recording of that night), they go to sleep with The Door Open and Katie Sleeping Closest To The Door! You'd think that even if they weren't going to leave, Micah might suggest they switch positions in bed, possibly close the door and lock it. They both knew it was there, even if it could smash the door open or walk through walls, no sense making it easy on the damn thing! But NOOOOO, even after the Demon DRAGS KATIE OUT OF BED KICKING AND SCREAMING, INTO THE HALLWAY, AND BITES HER ON THE LEG....

to:

** Nearly every night the characters go to sleep, they leave the bed room door open with Katie sleeping closest to the door. The night after the Demon walks into the room, stands right next to Katie's side of the bed (as evidenced by the foot prints), and "fiddles" with the sheets (as evidenced by the video recording of that night), they go to sleep with The '''The Door Open Open''' and Katie Sleeping '''Sleeping Closest To The Door! Door'''! You'd think that even if they weren't going to leave, Micah might suggest they switch positions in bed, possibly close the door and lock it. They both knew it was there, even if it could smash the door open or walk through walls, no sense making it easy on the damn thing! But NOOOOO, even after the Demon DRAGS KATIE OUT OF BED KICKING AND SCREAMING, INTO THE HALLWAY, AND BITES HER ON THE LEG....



* He's also a major JERK, because he kept toying and making fun of the entity without thinking that this entity ''was after his girlfriend. And Katie? Was she into self-harming or what? Why didn't she just move out? The demon would still be after her, but she wouldn't have an asshole who kept on messing things for her.

to:

* He's also a major JERK, because he kept toying and making fun of the entity without thinking that this entity ''was after his girlfriend.girlfriend''. And Katie? Was she into self-harming or what? Why didn't she just move out? The demon would still be after her, but she wouldn't have an asshole who kept on messing things for her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Nearly every night the characters go to sleep, they leave the bed room door open with Katie sleeping closest to the door. The night after the Demon walks into the room, stands right next to Katie's side of the bed (as evidenced by the foot prints), and "fiddles" with the sheets (as evidenced by the video recording of that night), they go to sleep with The Door Open and Katie Sleeping Closest To The Door! You'd think that even if they weren't going to leave, Micah might suggest they switch positions in bed, possibly close the door and lock it. They both knew it was there, even if it could smash the door open or walk through walls, no sense making it easy on the damn thing! But NOOOOO, even after the Demon DRAGS KATIE OUT OF BED KICKING AND SCREAMING, INTO THE HALLWAY, AND BITES HER ON THE LEG....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also depends greatly on what scares you. I myself, for example, am more freaked out by unseen horrors than by jump scares. I agree that the characters could have cooperated a little better, especially after it was obvious that the demon was ''real,'' but otherwise it was one of the most frightening movies I've seen.

to:

** Also depends greatly on what scares you. I myself, for example, am Many people are more freaked out by quiet, unseen horrors than by jump scares. I agree scares or on-screen gore. There's a reason the NothingIsScarier trope exists. There's also the fact that the characters could have cooperated they were fighting a little better, especially after it was obvious being that the demon was ''real,'' but otherwise they couldn't even ''see'' or ''touch'' unless it was one wanted them to - that alone can be a major source of the most frightening movies I've seen.
NightmareFuel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Maybe I fell asleep from boredom, but I don't recall any suspensful scenes. All I saw were a bitch and an asshole screaming at each other for an hour and a half.

to:

*** Maybe I fell asleep from boredom, but I don't recall any suspensful suspenseful scenes. All I saw were a bitch and an asshole screaming at each other for an hour and a half.
** Also depends greatly on what scares you. I myself, for example, am more freaked out by unseen horrors than by jump scares. I agree that the characters could have cooperated a little better, especially after it was obvious that the demon was ''real,'' but otherwise it was one of the most frightening movies I've seen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Besides, nothing said that the demon ''had'' to be active only at night. A few things ''did'' happen in the daytime... [[spoiler:Namely, Katie's possession.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** And then there's the whole "it's-only-after-me-thing". Sure, Micah is a jerk, but he is her boyfriend and you have to assume that she loves him. Since the demon would follow her if she moved, it would at least make sure Micah was left alone. One would think that his safety would be quite important to his girlfriend.

Added: 213

Changed: 165

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Maybe I fell asleep from boredom, but I don't recall any suspensful scenes. All I saw were a bitch and an asshole screaming at each other for an hour and a half.


Added DiffLines:

* Did anybody else think the "scary noises" in the middle of the night just sounded like the demon was playing the drums? It seemed less like a threatening presence in the house and more like an annoying roommate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

***it might not get stronger from sleep deprivation but any person deprived of sleep is certainly weaker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** And how would that have helped the situation?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
derp i can type


** The reason why people thought it was scary was because of the "suspense", I guess you could call it. Modern horror films tell us that any long, silent, quiet, drawn out scene will include a jump scare at some point. Paranormal Activity used this to its advantage by putting in a low of scenes that included all of the elements of a scene that would include such a scare, so that people would get tense waiting for it, but only rarely did it ever actually act on it; not really until the surprise body at the end. That's most likely why the ending was changed from the Katie-walks-in-the-room-with-the-knife thing to her throwing [[spoiler: Micah's]] body at the camera. It was more surprising, and the audience would hopefully have, at this point, stopped expecting a jump scare, thus amplifying the shock factor.

to:

** The reason why people thought it was scary was because of the "suspense", I guess you could call it. Modern horror films tell us that any long, silent, quiet, drawn out scene will include a jump scare at some point. Paranormal Activity used this to its advantage by putting in a low lot of scenes that included all of the elements of a scene that would include such a scare, so that people would get tense waiting for it, but only rarely did it ever actually act on it; not really until the surprise body at the end. That's most likely That might be why the ending was changed from the Katie-walks-in-the-room-with-the-knife thing to her throwing [[spoiler: Micah's]] body at the camera. It was more surprising, and the audience would hopefully have, at this point, stopped expecting a jump scare, thus amplifying the shock factor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The reason why people thought it was scary was because of the "suspense", I guess you could call it. Modern horror films tell us that any long, silent, quiet, drawn out scene will include a jump scare at some point. Paranormal Activity used this to its advantage by putting in a low of scenes that included all of the elements of a scene that would include such a scare, so that people would get tense waiting for it, but only rarely did it ever actually act on it; not really until the surprise body at the end. That's most likely why the ending was changed from the Katie-walks-in-the-room-with-the-knife thing to her throwing [[spoiler: Micah's]] body at the camera. It was more surprising, and the audience would hopefully have, at this point, stopped expecting a jump scare, thus amplifying the shock factor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Sure, if they moved to another house the new people wouldn't believe them. But if they woke up in the middle of the night to find their new tenant being dragged down the hall by absolutely nothing whatsoever, then they -would- believe...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why the ''fuck'' were people actually scared by this piece of shit movie? I've seen ''comedy'' horrors that were scarier, like ''DragMeToHell''. I mean, sure, they advertised it to be really scary and maybe it was just the placebo effect. However, I saw through it all along; I never thought it would be scary (mainly because I'm pretty critical of the whole horror genre.) Most of the film was clearly just trying to build up to a big scare later that didn't come until the end. Though, the ending was only a huge surprise just because something finally happened. This, however, does not justify how boring the whole movie was up to that scene. It was simply cheap, and they didn't even manage to do cheap, easy scares correctly. The ''ANightmareOnElmStreet'' remake was ''nothing'' except cheap scares, for example, but still scared me half to death in the theater.

to:

* Why the ''fuck'' were people was ''anyone'' actually scared by this piece of shit movie? Three year olds could fall asleep watching it. I mean, I've seen ''comedy'' horrors that were scarier, like ''DragMeToHell''. I mean, sure, they advertised it to be really scary and maybe it was just the placebo effect. However, I saw through it all along; I never thought it would be scary (mainly because I'm pretty critical of the whole horror genre.) Most of the film was clearly just trying to build up to a big scare later that didn't come until the end. Though, the ending was only a huge surprise just because something finally happened. This, however, does not justify how boring the whole movie was up to that scene. It was simply cheap, and they didn't even manage to do cheap, easy scares correctly. The ''ANightmareOnElmStreet'' remake was ''nothing'' except cheap scares, for example, but still scared me half to death in the theater.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Why the ''fuck'' were people actually scared by this piece of shit movie? I've seen ''comedy'' horrors that were scarier, like ''DragMeToHell''. I mean, sure, they advertised it to be really scary and maybe it was just the placebo effect. However, I saw through it all along; I never thought it would be scary (mainly because I'm pretty critical of the whole horror genre.) Most of the film was clearly just trying to build up to a big scare later that didn't come until the end. Though, the ending was only a huge surprise just because something finally happened. This, however, does not justify how boring the whole movie was up to that scene. It was simply cheap, and they didn't even manage to do cheap, easy scares correctly. The ''ANightmareOnElmStreet'' remake was ''nothing'' except cheap scares, for example, but still scared me half to death in the theater.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** For one, she wouldn't be put in danger by an asshole who only wants to record something cool.

Top