Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Oppenheimer

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because it was a race against time with the Germans who were developing their own bomb and it was considered worth the risk. In reality it turned out German research was years behind the Allies (partly due to Allied sabotage), but given the circumstances the Allies were understandably unwilling to take that chance.

to:

** Because it was a race against time with the Germans who were developing their own bomb and it was considered worth the risk. In reality it turned out German research was years behind the Allies (partly due to Allied sabotage), sabotage, partly because of their own infighting and refusal to accept contributions of Jewish scientists), but given the circumstances the Allies were understandably unwilling to take that chance.
** Classic case of BunnyEarsLawyer; when you're developing something as crazy as an atomic weapon and are doing it in a time crunch, you really need all the talent you can get, even the weird ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Oppenheimer remembered as the "father" of the atomic bomb, it seems that many others contributed?

to:

* Why is Oppenheimer remembered as the "father" of the atomic bomb, when it seems that many others contributed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On a personal level, if the United States government does not consider you trustworthy enough to work on projects related to national security, that is damaging on both a reputational level (since it heavily implies you are untrustworthy, especially in an incredibly paranoid time like the 1960s) and a career level (since many institutions will not consider you trustworthy enough to work for them, and may be prevented from employing you anyway depending on any connections or involvement they have in government projects).

to:

** On a personal level, if the United States government does not consider you trustworthy enough to work on projects related to national security, that is damaging on both a reputational level (since it heavily implies you are untrustworthy, especially in an incredibly paranoid time like the 1960s) 1950s) and a career level (since many institutions will not consider you trustworthy enough to work for them, and may be prevented from employing you anyway depending on any connections or involvement they have in government projects).

Added: 529

Changed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because it was a race against time with the Germans who were developing their own bomb and it was considered worth the risk. In reality it turned out German research was years behind the Allies (partly due to Allied sabotage).

to:

** Because it was a race against time with the Germans who were developing their own bomb and it was considered worth the risk. In reality it turned out German research was years behind the Allies (partly due to Allied sabotage).
sabotage), but given the circumstances the Allies were understandably unwilling to take that chance.


Added DiffLines:

** On a personal level, if the United States government does not consider you trustworthy enough to work on projects related to national security, that is damaging on both a reputational level (since it heavily implies you are untrustworthy, especially in an incredibly paranoid time like the 1960s) and a career level (since many institutions will not consider you trustworthy enough to work for them, and may be prevented from employing you anyway depending on any connections or involvement they have in government projects).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Essentially he was the civilian/scientific face of the project. Whilst obviously an incredible genius he didn't actually invent the atomic bomb, that was more of a group effort. Oppenheimer's strengths were his skills as a co-ordinator, mentor and mediator between the various scientists and the military. He was also extremely innovative, in the film he is referred to as the "King of the Improvisers". For instance refining uranium required vast amounts of copper which was in extremely short supply in wartime America as it was used to manufacture brass for munitions. So the Manhattan Project borrowed millions of dollars worth of silver bullion from the US Mint and utilised this instead (this lead to the legend of "Teller's Treasure", that the now radioactive silver was buried in the desert to cool off but due to the devastation caused by the later H-bomb tests the exact location was lost and it was never recovered). Oppenheimer was always uncomfortable with the title whilst Edward Teller revelled in being called "The Father of the H-bomb".

to:

** Essentially he was the civilian/scientific face of the project. Whilst obviously an incredible genius he didn't actually invent the atomic bomb, that was more of a group effort. Oppenheimer's strengths were his skills as a co-ordinator, coordinator, mentor and mediator between the various scientists and the military. He was also extremely innovative, in the film he is referred to as the "King of the Improvisers". For instance refining uranium required vast amounts of copper which was in extremely short supply in wartime America as it was used to manufacture brass for munitions. So the Manhattan Project borrowed millions of dollars worth of silver bullion from the US Mint and utilised this instead (this lead to the legend of "Teller's Treasure", that the now radioactive silver was buried in the desert to cool off but due to the devastation caused by the later H-bomb tests the exact location was lost and it was never recovered). Oppenheimer was always uncomfortable with the title whilst Edward Teller revelled in being called "The Father of the H-bomb".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

** Because without the clearance, he would not be able to steer the nuclear program in a direction that would limit the risk of wholesale nuclear war. Because he was denied the clearance, Teller took over, hydrogen bombs were made, and the world got to enjoy several close calls (such as the Cuban Missile Crisis) with nuclear annihilation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
She has a name


* What really happened to Oppenheimer's lover?

to:

* What really happened to Oppenheimer's lover?lover Jean?


Added DiffLines:

* What was so bad about Oppenheimer losing his security clearance?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Unknown, her death was written off as a suicide and despite numerous conspiracy theories there is nothing to suggest otherwise.

to:

** Unknown, her death was written off as a suicide and despite numerous conspiracy theories there is nothing to suggest otherwise.otherwise.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Essentially he was the civilian/scientific face of the project. Whilst obviously an incredible genius he didn't actually invent the atomic bomb, that was more of a group effort. Oppenheimer's strengths were his skills as a co-ordinator, mentor and mediator between the various scientists and the military. He was also extremely innovative, in the film he is referred to as the "King of the Improvisers". For instance refining uranium required vast amounts of copper which was in extremely short supply in wartime America as it was used to manufacture brass for munitions. So the Manhattan Project borrowed millions of dollars worth of silver bullion from the US Mint and utilised this instead (this lead to the legend of "Teller's Treasure", that the now radioactive silver was buried in the desert to cool off but due to the devastation caused by the later H-bomb tests the exact location was lost and it was never recovered). Oppenheimer was always uncomfortable with the title whilst Edward Teller revelled in being called "The Father of the H-bomb".

to:

** Essentially he was the civilian/scientific face of the project. Whilst obviously an incredible genius he didn't actually invent the atomic bomb, that was more of a group effort. Oppenheimer's strengths were his skills as a co-ordinator, mentor and mediator between the various scientists and the military. He was also extremely innovative, in the film he is referred to as the "King of the Improvisers". For instance refining uranium required vast amounts of copper which was in extremely short supply in wartime America as it was used to manufacture brass for munitions. So the Manhattan Project borrowed millions of dollars worth of silver bullion from the US Mint and utilised this instead (this lead to the legend of "Teller's Treasure", that the now radioactive silver was buried in the desert to cool off but due to the devastation caused by the later H-bomb tests the exact location was lost and it was never recovered). Oppenheimer was always uncomfortable with the title whilst Edward Teller revelled in being called "The Father of the H-bomb".



Because it was a race against time with the Germans who were developing their own bomb and it was considered worth the risk. In reality it turned out German research was years behind the Allies (partly due to Allied sabotage).

to:

** Because it was a race against time with the Germans who were developing their own bomb and it was considered worth the risk. In reality it turned out German research was years behind the Allies (partly due to Allied sabotage).



Unknown, her death was written off as a suicide and despite numerous conspiracy theories there is nothing to suggest otherwise.

to:

** Unknown, her death was written off as a suicide and despite numerous conspiracy theories there is nothing to suggest otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why is Oppenheimer remembered as the "father" of the atomic bomb, it seems that many others contributed?
Essentially he was the civilian/scientific face of the project. Whilst obviously an incredible genius he didn't actually invent the atomic bomb, that was more of a group effort. Oppenheimer's strengths were his skills as a co-ordinator, mentor and mediator between the various scientists and the military. He was also extremely innovative, in the film he is referred to as the "King of the Improvisers". For instance refining uranium required vast amounts of copper which was in extremely short supply in wartime America as it was used to manufacture brass for munitions. So the Manhattan Project borrowed millions of dollars worth of silver bullion from the US Mint and utilised this instead (this lead to the legend of "Teller's Treasure", that the now radioactive silver was buried in the desert to cool off but due to the devastation caused by the later H-bomb tests the exact location was lost and it was never recovered). Oppenheimer was always uncomfortable with the title whilst Edward Teller revelled in being called "The Father of the H-bomb".
* How did people with such obvious security problems get into the top secret Manhattan Project?
Because it was a race against time with the Germans who were developing their own bomb and it was considered worth the risk. In reality it turned out German research was years behind the Allies (partly due to Allied sabotage).
* What really happened to Oppenheimer's lover?
Unknown, her death was written off as a suicide and despite numerous conspiracy theories there is nothing to suggest otherwise.

Top