Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicIDW

Go To



* So if Discord was actually a NobleDemon who was unwilling to cause serious harm, what could he have done that was bad enough to warrant [[TakenForGranite petrifying him]]? Even if it was due to blaming him for Cosmos' actions, why wait as long as [[https://derpibooru.org/2027857 the comic implies]] as opposed to immediately afterward? (I don't buy the "Discord was lying" theory as the current mess was caused by his hiding the truth and AesopAmnesia in the middle of the Aesop is as contrived. And why wouldn't the comic show if this was the case?)

to:

* So if Discord was actually a NobleDemon who was unwilling to cause serious harm, what could he have done that was bad enough to warrant [[TakenForGranite petrifying him]]? Even if it was due to blaming him for Cosmos' actions, why wait as long as [[https://derpibooru.org/2027857 the comic implies]] as opposed to immediately afterward? (I don't buy the "Discord was lying" theory as the current mess was caused by his hiding the truth and AesopAmnesia in the middle of the Aesop is as contrived. contrived, plus why lie if he had already beeb forgiven for such? And why wouldn't the comic show if this was the case?)


[[folder: MLP:FiM #48 - #50 (Cosmos)]]

to:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #48 #75 - #50 #78 (Cosmos)]]


* So Starlight, already (somehow) powerful enough to match an Alicorn, can even [[spoiler:shield herself from the freaking '''''Elements of Harmony''''' -- i.e., the top dogs on the SuperWeight scale]]?

to:

* So Starlight, already (somehow) powerful enough to match an Alicorn, can even [[spoiler:shield shield herself from the freaking '''''Elements of Harmony''''' -- i.e., the top dogs on the SuperWeight scale]]?scale?


Added DiffLines:

** The Elements are like the [[DispelMagic Star Beam]] from ''VideoGame/PaperMario64'', they negate dark/corruptive magic from otherwise invincibly powerful foes and the stories revolve around finding/using them, but [[CripplingOverspecialization they have no power/utility outside that narrow, but impressive, function]] as far as we've seen. The Star Beam was temporarily negated by a comparatively mundane power boost, and Starlight was the only character who tried countering it with a mundane shield spell. In short, we fans incorrectly, but understandably, assumed they were omnipotent forces of good when in reality they were merely powerful yet fallible tools.
* Season 7, which the very next comics tie into, revealed the Elements were grown by one who also had and overly orderly mindset. And it took until Season 8 for the source of the Element to gain sapience which would let it let it tell right from wrong.


* So if Discord was actually a NobleDemon who was unwilling to cause serious harm, what could he have done that was bad enough to warrant [[TakenForGranite sealing him away]]? Even if it was due to blaming him for Cosmos' actions, why wait as long as [[https://derpibooru.org/2027857 the comic implies]] as opposed to immediately afterward? (I don't buy the "Discord was lying" theory as the current mess was caused by his hiding the truth and AesopAmnesia in the middle of the Aesop is as contrived. And why wouldn't the comic show if this was the case?)

to:

* So if Discord was actually a NobleDemon who was unwilling to cause serious harm, what could he have done that was bad enough to warrant [[TakenForGranite sealing him away]]? petrifying him]]? Even if it was due to blaming him for Cosmos' actions, why wait as long as [[https://derpibooru.org/2027857 the comic implies]] as opposed to immediately afterward? (I don't buy the "Discord was lying" theory as the current mess was caused by his hiding the truth and AesopAmnesia in the middle of the Aesop is as contrived. And why wouldn't the comic show if this was the case?)case?)
** The last two panels suggest he allowed himself to be petrified out of guilt ([[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS4E2PrincessTwilightSparklePart2 which he had planned on being temporary]]), so maybe hid did something to provoke this.


* One of the brothers said that the resort was closed due it being the off season in "The Greatest Gift" special.

to:

* ** One of the brothers said that the resort was closed due it being the off season in "The Greatest Gift" special.



* If Queen Novo was around over 1000 years ago, how can she have siblings, who don't show the special powers that would make them LongLived, be around at present?

to:

* If Queen Novo was around over 1000 years ago, how can she have siblings, a sibling, who don't doesn't show the special powers that would make them LongLived, be around at present?


Added DiffLines:

* So if Discord was actually a NobleDemon who was unwilling to cause serious harm, what could he have done that was bad enough to warrant [[TakenForGranite sealing him away]]? Even if it was due to blaming him for Cosmos' actions, why wait as long as [[https://derpibooru.org/2027857 the comic implies]] as opposed to immediately afterward? (I don't buy the "Discord was lying" theory as the current mess was caused by his hiding the truth and AesopAmnesia in the middle of the Aesop is as contrived. And why wouldn't the comic show if this was the case?)

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: MLP:FiM #48 - #50 (Cosmos)]]
* If Queen Novo was around over 1000 years ago, how can she have siblings, who don't show the special powers that would make them LongLived, be around at present?
** Novo's never mentioned by name. Maybe it's an ancestor with StrongFamilyResemblance?
[[/folder]]




Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Holidays 2014 ("Equestria Girls Holiday Special")]]
* Why did they continue to frame Sunset as Anon-a-Miss after achieving their original goal? They say if was because others students were asking for more, but why do it? If it was to be popular with them, the whole point of Anon-a-Miss was it was making who the students thought it was (Sunset) the opposite of popular, while they got none of the "popularity". So why continue as long as they did?
[[/folder]]

Added DiffLines:

* If they retrieved the Elements of Harmony from the Tree of Harmony, why didn't they do so when Discord was teamed up with Tirek? That seems as much a GodzillaThreshold.


* FridgeLogic: In the ''Dungeons and Dragons'' analogue, "elves" and "dwarves" are treated as add-on adjectives, i.e. "dwarf mule" and "elf pony". This is in addition to their classes, i.e. "dwarf mule barbarian". Shouldn't "elf" and "dwarf" be species alongside mules and ponies?

to:

* FridgeLogic: In the ''Dungeons and Dragons'' analogue, "elves" and "dwarves" are treated as add-on adjectives, i.e. "dwarf mule" and "elf pony". This is in addition to their classes, i.e. "dwarf mule barbarian". Shouldn't "elf" and "dwarf" be species alongside mules and ponies?


Added DiffLines:

[[folder: MLP:FiM #27 - #28 (Root of the Problem)]]
* Why doesn't Twilight Sparkle used her authority as a Princess to stop Well-To-Do's toxic "progress" plans?
* If the land was so polluted the dear couldn't grow anything even with their magic, how are the biogenic, but presumably non-magical, milkshakes Well-To-Do was selling in the park able to do so?
[[/folder]]

Added DiffLines:

* One of the brothers said that the resort was closed due it being the off season in "The Greatest Gift" special.

Added DiffLines:

* On a related topic, now that [[spoiler: Sombra]] is a normal pony. Does he have a cutie mark now? Or will he have to work to acquire one like other ponies do? (even reformed he was wearing his robe, making it hard to tell)


* So Twilight Sparkle is too busy with the School of Friendship to visit Applewood, so how is everypony else, over half of the schools staff, able to find time to do so, much less get involved in a film production that Applejack says straight faced would take months?

to:

* So Twilight Sparkle is too busy with the School of Friendship to visit Applewood, so how is everypony else, over half of the schools staff, able to find time to do so, much less get involved in a film production that Applejack says would take months?
** Related, Applejack claim she had no plans "for the next few months". What about the school, or her farm? I'd assume she's being sarcastic but she said it
straight faced would take months?(problem with the art?) and did seriously get involved with the project.

Added DiffLines:

** Part of their motive was revenge against the Apples, which ratting Radiant out wouldn't accomplish. And is their any reason to believe a bounty system exists in Equestria, given how absurdly everything gets forgiven?


Added DiffLines:


[[folder: MLP:FiM #66]]
* So Twilight Sparkle is too busy with the School of Friendship to visit Applewood, so how is everypony else, over half of the schools staff, able to find time to do so, much less get involved in a film production that Applejack says straight faced would take months?
[[/folder]]

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Holidays Special 2017]]
* Why are the Flim-Flam Brothers selling holiday merchandise in Ponyville? The [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS6E20VivaLasPegasus last time]] they appeared in the show (which the comics are supposedly trying to form a stronger continuity with), they'd gained control over an entire resort in Las Pegasus. Surely that would earn them more money than their scheme here?
[[/folder]]

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: MLP:FiM #58]]
* According to this comic, Mage Meadowbrook never had foals, implying Cattail, repeatedly stated to be her dependent, is related through Mage Meadowbrook's sister, making her his distant aunt. I've never seen ancestry (which implies straight line of decent) work this way. Anything?
[[/folder]]

Showing 15 edit(s) of 68

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report