Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MyHeroAcademia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One of Nana's last requests to the two of them was to ''not'' get involved with her son's life. She assumed that All For One would be more interested in One For All itself and not target her family if she cut ties with them. Unfortunately, she greatly underestimated AFO's willingness to play dirty and the negative impact leaving would have on her son.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the end, All For One's motive is exactly what he had told All Might- that he wanted to become the all-powerful devil. He wants to rule the world from the shadows as the most powerful man of all time, but that is only the means to his true end- to enjoy himself at the expense of everyone, forever and ever. Plain and simple.


Added DiffLines:

** The Paranormal Liberation Arc reveals that Tomura underwent months of painful surgery and body enhancement to have the All For One Quirk transplanted into him. Unfortunately, this also means that All For One the villain has hijacked Tomura's body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** His Quirk (at least in the early stages) decays whatever he's touching ''with all of his fingers'', and by that it means he has to be touching the same unbroken surface or object with all five of his fingers at once, whereas if he touches, say, three of his fingers on a wall, while his pinky and thumb are on the ground, neither of those will decay since he isn't touching either surface or object with all five fingers. Gloves, due to how they cover each finger seperately, would be immune to decaying since they essentially create small seperate surfaces that each finger is individually touching, and by extension, since he isn't making direct contact with anything while wearing gloves, he can't decay anything until he takes them off. With his Quirk much more flexible now, it's likely this is not the case anymore, but in Decay's less controlled stages, gloves wouldn't trigger it. Another example is that if Tomura were touching someone's neck with ''four'' of his fingers, but his thumb were on their shirt, that wouldn't trigger his Quirk either. His Quirk needs a "clear path" of sorts to spread out and decay an object that is in contact with all five of his fingers, with as little distance as possible and no obstruction, and in a sense, the parts he's touching have to be "level" with each other, rather than seperated by their shape, like the finger-parts of gloves are.

to:

** His Quirk (at least in the early stages) decays whatever he's touching ''with all of his fingers'', and by that it means he has to be touching the same unbroken surface or object with all five of his fingers at once, whereas if he touches, say, three of his fingers on a wall, while his pinky and thumb are on the ground, neither of those will decay since he isn't touching either surface or object with all five fingers. Gloves, due to how they cover each finger seperately, would be immune to decaying since they essentially create small seperate surfaces that each finger is individually touching, and by extension, since he isn't making direct contact with anything while wearing gloves, he can't decay anything until he takes them off. With his Quirk much more flexible now, it's likely this is not the case anymore, but in Decay's less controlled stages, gloves wouldn't trigger it. Another example is that if Tomura were touching someone's neck with ''four'' of his fingers, but his thumb were on their shirt, that wouldn't trigger his Quirk either. His Quirk needs a "clear path" of sorts to spread out and decay an object that is in contact with all five of his fingers, with as little distance as possible and no obstruction, and in a sense, the parts he's touching have to be "level" with each other, other and "fully connected", rather than seperated by their shape, like the finger-parts of gloves are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** His Quirk (at least in the early stages) decays whatever he's touching ''with all of his fingers'', and by that it means he has to be touching the same unbroken surface or object with all five of his fingers at once, whereas if he touches, say, three of his fingers on a wall, while his pinky and thumb are on the ground, neither of those will decay since he isn't touching either surface or object with all five fingers. Gloves, due to how they cover each finger seperately, would be immune to decaying since they essentially create small seperate surfaces that each finger is individually touching, and by extension, since he isn't making direct contact with anything while wearing gloves, he can't decay anything until he takes them off. With is Quirk much more flexible now, it's likely this is not the case anymore, but in Decay's less controlled stages, gloves wouldn't trigger it. Another example is that if Tomura were touching someone's neck with ''four'' of his fingers, but his thumb were on their shirt, that wouldn't trigger his Quirk either. His Quirk needs a "clear path" of sorts to spread out and decay an object that is in contact with all five of his fingers, with as little distance and no obstruction as possible.

to:

** His Quirk (at least in the early stages) decays whatever he's touching ''with all of his fingers'', and by that it means he has to be touching the same unbroken surface or object with all five of his fingers at once, whereas if he touches, say, three of his fingers on a wall, while his pinky and thumb are on the ground, neither of those will decay since he isn't touching either surface or object with all five fingers. Gloves, due to how they cover each finger seperately, would be immune to decaying since they essentially create small seperate surfaces that each finger is individually touching, and by extension, since he isn't making direct contact with anything while wearing gloves, he can't decay anything until he takes them off. With is his Quirk much more flexible now, it's likely this is not the case anymore, but in Decay's less controlled stages, gloves wouldn't trigger it. Another example is that if Tomura were touching someone's neck with ''four'' of his fingers, but his thumb were on their shirt, that wouldn't trigger his Quirk either. His Quirk needs a "clear path" of sorts to spread out and decay an object that is in contact with all five of his fingers, with as little distance as possible and no obstruction as possible.
obstruction, and in a sense, the parts he's touching have to be "level" with each other, rather than seperated by their shape, like the finger-parts of gloves are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Answered the "Shigaraki can wear full gloves..." question.



to:

** His Quirk (at least in the early stages) decays whatever he's touching ''with all of his fingers'', and by that it means he has to be touching the same unbroken surface or object with all five of his fingers at once, whereas if he touches, say, three of his fingers on a wall, while his pinky and thumb are on the ground, neither of those will decay since he isn't touching either surface or object with all five fingers. Gloves, due to how they cover each finger seperately, would be immune to decaying since they essentially create small seperate surfaces that each finger is individually touching, and by extension, since he isn't making direct contact with anything while wearing gloves, he can't decay anything until he takes them off. With is Quirk much more flexible now, it's likely this is not the case anymore, but in Decay's less controlled stages, gloves wouldn't trigger it. Another example is that if Tomura were touching someone's neck with ''four'' of his fingers, but his thumb were on their shirt, that wouldn't trigger his Quirk either. His Quirk needs a "clear path" of sorts to spread out and decay an object that is in contact with all five of his fingers, with as little distance and no obstruction as possible.

Added: 516

Changed: -76

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It seems that whenever someone discusses Nana Shimura’s decision to give up her son Kotaro, it’s always described as a “mistake,” and that her grandson Tenko’s corruption at the hands of OFA was to some degree a result of that mistake. But is that a fair assessment in context? We hear that Nana’s husband was murdered, which was the impetus for her giving Kotaro up for adoption. I’ve always read the implication that at that point AFO had discovered Nana as the latest bearer of OFA, and was killing off her loved ones just for the twisted pleasure, meaning her son was indeed in danger. Aside from that, Nana’s letter she wrote to Kotaro implies that she expected to die soon herself, so she would have had to take some steps to protect her son. Letting Torino or Toshinori look after Kotaro would still put him in AFO’s sights, even after her own death, so giving him up for adoption/foster care seems like the safest, if most heartbreaking option. If there is anyone else to blame for young Tenko’s corruption (aside from OFA of course), it would be Kotaro himself. Yes, as a child Kotaro wouldn’t understand his mother’s reasons for giving him up and grow bitter and angry at her and heroes in general (similarly to Kota). But I’m sorry, when we see him next he is a grown-ass adult who should have gained some understanding or insight into the circumstances of his childhood. Even if he still hates his mother, there’s no excuse for letting his mommy issues lead to abuse of his own family, which only ended up making the young Tenko more susceptible to AFO's manipulations. This is made even more damning by the fact that Kotoro still has his mother’s letter, where she explains at least some of her reasoning why she gave him up (ie: he knows she didn’t hate him or “abandon” him). Given Nana’s situation, I can’t see her doing anything other than what she did, even though AFO’s inexhaustible cruelty made her sacrifice in vain.

to:

* It seems that whenever someone discusses Nana Shimura’s decision to give up her son Kotaro, it’s always described as a “mistake,” and that her grandson Tenko’s corruption at the hands of OFA AFO was to some degree a result of that mistake. But is that a fair assessment in context? We hear that Nana’s husband was murdered, which was the impetus for her giving Kotaro up for adoption. I’ve always read the implication that at that point AFO had discovered Nana as the latest bearer of OFA, and was killing off her loved ones just for the twisted pleasure, meaning her son was indeed in danger. Aside from that, Nana’s letter she wrote to Kotaro implies that she expected to die soon herself, so she would have had to take some steps to protect her son. Letting Torino or Toshinori look after Kotaro would still put him in AFO’s sights, even after her own death, so giving him up for adoption/foster care seems like the safest, if most heartbreaking option. If there is anyone else to blame for young Tenko’s corruption (aside from OFA AFO of course), it would be Kotaro himself. Yes, as a child Kotaro wouldn’t understand his mother’s reasons for giving him up and grow bitter and angry at her and heroes in general (similarly to Kota). But I’m sorry, when we see him next he is a grown-ass adult who should have gained some understanding or insight into the circumstances of his childhood. Even if he still hates his mother, there’s no excuse for letting his mommy issues lead to abuse of his own family, which only ended up making the young Tenko more susceptible to AFO's manipulations. This is made even more damning by the fact that Kotoro still has his mother’s letter, where she explains at least some of her reasoning why she gave him up (ie: he knows she didn’t hate him or “abandon” him). Given Nana’s situation, I can’t see her doing anything other than what she did, even though AFO’s inexhaustible cruelty made her sacrifice in vain.


Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Shigaraki can wear full gloves without decaying them?]]
* A flashback to Shigaraki as a kid shortly after his quirk awakened and All For One took him on as an apprentice shows him wearing gloves. Not artist gloves or those type of gloves that expose some of the fingers, but regular gloves that cover all fingers. Since his quirk can decay anything he touches with all five fingers, shouldn't he be incapable of wearing full gloves due to how wearing them means touching them with all his fingers?

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[StatingTheObvious Apparently not]]. It's been established that the teacher has lost control of her students. They may be well-behaved at home (and keep in mind that Quirk usage is legal when you're at home), but the idea that they could do anything got into their heads (likely due to the "ringleader"). Handling a kid sounds fairly easy, if not AdultFear inducing, but can you really handle one with superpowers?

to:

** [[StatingTheObvious Apparently not]]. It's been established that the teacher has lost control of her students. They may be well-behaved at home (and keep in mind that Quirk usage is legal when you're at home), but the idea that they could do anything got into their heads (likely due to the "ringleader"). Handling a kid sounds fairly easy, if not AdultFear Adult Fear inducing, but can you really handle one with superpowers?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As of chapter 350 it is ''definitely'' implied that AFO had a hand in the whole event being hush-hush. Gakurai reveals that he and AFO were on the lookout for 'warped, twisted seeds' suitable to serve as his 'next me' and had actually collected enough potential candidates to form a small OrphanageOfLove. It's not shown, but is is ''greatly'' implied AFO has an extensive information network in place to locate and monitor these children so he can step in and take advantage of their misfortunes to twist them to his will, possibly even giving said misfortunes a 'nudge' as the case may be. Toya's self-immolation was an honest accident, and not the intended outcome from the duo's POV, but nonetheless, before even Endeavour himself made it to the scene, AFO was already on the mountaintop and aware of where to find Toya's horribly-charred body. Gakurai outright says that he remembers Toya's case in part simply because he was already too twisted up by Endevour's crappy parenting to serve their purpose, implicitly implying that all those kids were 'rescued' by AFO in a similar manner to Toya and Tenko, at their darkest hour of need so he could appear as a saviour and bolster their loyalty that way. In such cases, AFO must have had some way to silence or obscure any information that could lead to the kid's whereabout and his plans for him, considering how important they were for his [[ImmortalitySeeker long term goals]] so it makes sense for him to stifle any clues that might alert the heroes to this particular one of his myriad evil plans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That would ''still'' be considered illegal if we take Japan's quirk regulations into consideration, since he doesn't have a license and it wasn't under self-defense.

to:

*** That would I might be misinterpreting what Hori said on them, but it would ''still'' be considered illegal if we take Japan's quirk regulations into consideration, since he doesn't have a license and it wasn't under self-defense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** That would ''still'' be considered illegal if we take Japan's quirk regulations into consideration, since he doesn't have a license and it wasn't under self-defense.

Added: 321

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Possibly RuleOfDrama. But there may be some actual explanations: It's likely Tenk simply ran away/wandered off immediately after the incident, which is possible since he was a small child in a mental breakdown. Or maybe he ''was'' under some sort of authority figure or service for a while after killing his family but somehow, easy to think due to the CrapsackWorld, ended in the streets. Last but not the least, is possible that [[TheChessmaster All For One]] was acting somehow to make make sure everything ended the way it did. As for how AFO got the hands all he would need to do was getting to watever authority was investigating and bribe them/blackmail them into giving them to him.

to:

** Possibly RuleOfDrama. But there may be some actual explanations: It's likely Tenk Tenko simply ran away/wandered off immediately after the incident, which is possible since he was a small child in a mental breakdown. Or maybe he ''was'' under some sort of authority figure or service for a while after killing his family but somehow, easy to think due to the CrapsackWorld, ended in the streets. Last but not the least, is possible that [[TheChessmaster All For One]] was acting somehow to make make sure everything ended the way it did. As for how AFO got the hands all he would need to do was getting to watever authority was investigating and bribe them/blackmail them into giving them to him.


Added DiffLines:

** You answered your own question. They didn't keep track of him, period. The world of MHA is a pretty dangerous place and Shimura is a pretty common name. Even if they saw the news, assuming that the incident reached the news (remember CrapsackWorld and AFO's manipulations),they may simply not have made the connection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Possibly RuleOfDrama. But there may be some actual explanations: It's likely Tenk simply ran away/wandered off immediately after the incident, which is possible since he was a small child in a mental breakdown. Or maybe he ''was'' under some sort of authority figure or service for a while after killing his family but somehow, easy to think due to the CrapsackWorld, ended in the streets. Last but not the least, is possible that [[TheChessmaster All For One]] was acting somehow to make make sure everything ended the way it did. As for how AFO got the hands all he would need to do was getting to watever authority was investigating and bribe them/blackmail them into giving them to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Questions about Deaths of the Shimura Family]]
* How is it that in the aftermath of young Tenko killing his family and destroying his house, a.) Tenko was able to just walk away and b.) AFO was able to dig through the scene for the victims' hands? Were there not any poilce or heroes in the vicinity that were alerted by the house collapsing and immediately went to investigate, and even so did none of the neighbors rush over to see what happened or even call the authorities[[note]]more likely the latter given society's dependency on heroes[[/note]]? How were neither of these events witnessed by anyone?
* After the fight with between All Might and AFO, All Might and Gran Torino mention that they didn't keep track of Nana Shimura's son after she told them to not get him involved in heroes. This implies neither of them were aware that said son has been dead for about fifteen years. Was the incident never reported on the news? Something like, "Shimura Family found dead in the wreckage of their home!" or something like that. It feels weird that neither of them had ever caught wind of this incident in some way.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** We only see the last part of Uraraka and Aoyama's test, after they've already been pinned down by Thirteen. Presumably, he could've been more helpful before. Also, Uraraka "attacked" Thirteen, which won them the test, after talking to Aoyama, so perhaps Aizawa and the other teachers thought they were planning it together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Aoyama in the final exam]]
* Why didn't Aoyama fail the final exam? Aizawa points out that he and Uraraka passed by the skin of their teeth, but it's shown that if a partner doesn't contribute enough, they can still fail, like Sero did after Midnight sedated him. Since Aoyama didn't appear to contribute much to the exam and Uraraka was mainly responsible for taking Thirteen down (most other victories wouldn't have been possible without both participants working together), he probably should have failed on the same grounds as Sero.
[[/folder]]

Added: 1884

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Regarding Hagakure and Yosetsu, the exam also awarded points for rescues, as well as incapacitating the robots. Hagakure is exceptionally good at stealth, so could easily slip past the boys and get people out, or hit some kind of shutoff/incapacitation device (which in the real field would be synonymous with something like a nerve strike or submission hold from stealth). Yosetsu has it even easier, in that as soon as he can touch a robot, he can Weld it to whatever it's touching (including itself). He gets the legs, the bot is completely inmmobilized, and if he gets the arms as well, it's out of action.

to:

*** Regarding Hagakure and Yosetsu, the exam also awarded points for rescues, as well as incapacitating the robots. Hagakure is exceptionally good at stealth, so could easily slip past the boys and get people out, or hit some kind of shutoff/incapacitation device (which in the real field would be synonymous with something like a nerve strike or submission hold from stealth). Yosetsu has it even easier, in that as soon as he can touch a robot, he can Weld it to whatever it's touching (including itself). He gets the legs, the bot is completely inmmobilized, immobilized, and if he gets the arms as well, it's out of action.action.
** Later chapters show exactly what happens when people think that support gear alone is enough to beat hardened villains: it goes very poorly. Any villain of worth can easily avoid or overwhelm the sort of gear that would be feasible to provide. You'd have to break out cruise missiles to match the destructive power of people like Muscular, much less AFO himself. Even mid-level villains would require millions of dollar's worth of material to put down and likely require trucks to carry. Far beyond anything that a normal person could carry on their person, let alone afford. Especially not some random middle class kid in middle school. Yeah, Batman makes it seem simple, but he's written with unlimited time and money on top of a genius level intellect and decades of impossible training. He's basically superhuman, despite the bragging that he's a "normal man".



** It's a Japanese comic. It's only natural that the action would be centered in Japan, in the same way that American super-hero comics are focused on the US. To be fair, in the MHA universe, the US was the first nation to issue hero licesnses, and is popularly referred to as "the home of the heroes," which would seem to indicate that they have a lot (which would be natural with such a large, diverse population).

to:

** It's a Japanese comic. It's only natural that the action would be centered in Japan, in the same way that American super-hero comics are focused on the US. To be fair, in the MHA universe, the US was the first nation to issue hero licesnses, licenses, and is popularly referred to as "the home of the heroes," which would seem to indicate that they have a lot (which would be natural with such a large, diverse population).


Added DiffLines:

** Midoryia was extremely nervous and very distracted all day. That would almost certain help to tank his performance in most atheletic competitions, even if he was in good enough shape to be competitive with the students that don't have relevant Quirks for atheletics.


Added DiffLines:

** The series answered that question with a firm "no". Monoma can copy any Quirk as long as he touches someone else, but ''only'' the [[ExactWords the Quirk itself]]. Any additional benefits it accumulated over time are not transferred. He tried to copy Izuku who we know has multiple Quirks in One For All, but ended up with nothing but One for All itself. The other Quirks it gained over the years either aren't considered fundamental to the Quirk itself, or required all the power it gained from over a century of existence to be apparent. All For One would almost certainly end up nearly as useless to him. Even if he did mange to take a power with it, his own Quirk can only mimic it for such a brief time that that he would gain no benefit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bakugo was definitely bullying Izuku, but he technically never used his Quirk against him. He did scorch his notebook and did get physical, but he never directly struck him or even put an explosion close to making contact. When he did scorch the notebook, we can see that it was nowhere near his real power since the book survived. Combine that with his youth and the obvious favoritism and you can see how he manged to get by without doing enough to force discipline from the instructors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** "Izuku can pass the exam and the test without OFA" How? "They can trap the water villains and make a run for it" HOW!? "Then going to block Shiggy with a bar of metal or similar" First, where would get Izuku get a bar of metal? Second, once Shigaraki decays the bar of metal, what can Izuku do? And sure thing, Stain wrecked Izuku while using the power of one of the strongest Quirks in existence, which greatly enhahnced his strength and speed, but he'll do better with a capture weapon. "Muscular is easy, blind him and run away" oh sure, because Muscular is just a dumbass who's going to stand there let Izuku do that, right? But apparently, canon Izuku is a dumbass for not thinking in such an obvious solution. Dude, no matter how many Quirkless Izuku fics you have read, there's no way Izuku wouldn't have been either expelled from UA or killed without OFA.


Added DiffLines:

** That's something that used to bug me as well, until I rewatched the attack on the USJ. When Izuku is worried for Aizawa, who's about to fight an horde of villains in the open while he normally ambushes single enemies in the dark, Aizawa replied that no Pro Hero worth their salt is a one trick pony. Now, this is speculation on my part with no basis on canon, but my guess is that in the case of people with Quirks that didn't have applications to physical exercises, like Kaminari, Kyoka, Hagakure or Koda, Aizawa wanted to see how was their physical shape, or what would they do in a siatuation where their Quirks would be of no use. Like a cop or a firefighter, being fit is a must for a hero. It still doesn't explain how the four I mentioned above still ranked higher than Izuku when he was trained for 10 months by All Might while everybody else presumably trained on their own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** First of all, "20% of the world population being Quirkless" does not equal "20% chance of being born Quirkless". The manga established that being Quirkless is becoming rarer and rarer with each passing generation, and that Izuku might as well be among the last Quirkless persons ever born. Second, this is something a lot of people forget, but while the ''world's'' Qurikless population is 20%, it's pointed out that ''Japan's'' is a measly 3%. And combined with the previous point, most people in that demographic are likely from All Might's generation (age 50 and up). So yes, it would be extremely rare for somebody in the youngest generation to be born Quirkless, which would explain why other kids would treat Izuku as something unique.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spoilers off


** Considering that it's been revealed that One For All is so high-maintenance that it [[spoiler:[[RapidAging drains the user's vitality]] if they have a quirk of their own in addition to it]], we have official confirmation that All Might is ''completely'' Quirkless. Not even a useless cosmetic Quirk, he has nothing.

to:

** Considering that it's been revealed that One For All is so high-maintenance that it [[spoiler:[[RapidAging [[RapidAging drains the user's vitality]] if they have a quirk of their own in addition to it]], it, we have official confirmation that All Might is ''completely'' Quirkless. Not even a useless cosmetic Quirk, he has nothing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* When talking about Haya Yuyu's design, Horikoshi said that her dyed hair would be against the dress code in a real school, but that it's fine in the story...but why mention it specifically anyway when in this particular setting you can't throw a rock at a group of people without hitting at least three characters with AmazingTechnicolorHair?
** Answering myself on this one: maybe it was to show that she has kind of a delinquent streak and that it's fine in-story precisely because of an abundance of technicolor-haired characters?

to:

* When talking about Haya Yuyu's design, Horikoshi said that her dyed hair would be against the dress code in a real school, but that it's fine in the story...but why mention it specifically anyway when in this particular setting you can't throw a rock at a group of people without hitting at least three characters with AmazingTechnicolorHair?
technicolor hair?
** Answering myself on this one: maybe Maybe it was to show that she has kind of a delinquent streak and that it's fine in-story precisely because of an abundance of technicolor-haired characters?

Changed: 701

Removed: 650

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: Why didn't Nao Shimura put her foot down earlier when her children were getting mistreated? And I say children because Hana knowing to deny that she wants to be a hero implies that Kotaro likely abused her in a similar manner before she learned to avoid his wrath. The moment Kotaro started locking the kids out of the house should have been Nao's cue to start the divorce process rather than waiting until her son's TraumaticSuperpowerAwakening.]]
** [[spoiler: From what I understand, Nao Shimura was in the same situation a lot of people in an abusive household are in: She was too afraid to do it/felt trapped by her circumstances, and it wasn't until things went way beyond the norm that she GrewASpine. Relationships are complicated and abusive ones, whether you are the direct victim or not, are not as simple as "Do the right thing when someone does something wrong". It is just not that simple, even in [[TruthInTelevision real life]], or we wouldn't have cases where children are abused by one parent and the other is very much ''not'' okay with it, or at least, they wouldn't go on for very long. Kotaro was clearly a very harsh and disciplined man, so likely any disobediance, even without punishment or threat, would be hard to do in his household, just by virtue of having that viewpoint hammered into your head by just living with him. That is also more likely why Hana would deny wanting to be a hero as well, even if she wasn't punished herself. That, and she would know what makes her father angry regardless, as the family clearly did know about the abuse. Essentially, living with a controlling and abusive person who has a significant place in your life, such as being your spouse, gives them influence on you, whether you like it or not, and it often either affects your thinking, restricts you in more material ways, or a combination of both. Just running/leaving is not easy for those who've lived like that, as any abused person will tell you.]]
** There's also the ValuesDissonance of what is and isn't considered abuse in Japan. To a Western audience, [[spoiler:locking your kids out of the house]] would undoubtedly be considered abuse, but it's not necessarily true in Japan. The very first chapter/episode of ''Franchise/SailorMoon'' has [[spoiler:Usagi's mother locking her out of the house for getting a bad grade on a test, but is nevertheless portrayed as a loving mother]]. It's possible that Nao might have been uncomfortable with it, but didn't actually see it as abuse.

to:

* [[spoiler: Why didn't Nao Shimura put her foot down earlier when her children were getting mistreated? And I say children because Hana knowing to deny that she wants to be a hero implies that Kotaro likely abused her in a similar manner before she learned to avoid his wrath. The moment Kotaro started locking the kids out of the house should have been Nao's cue to start the divorce process rather than waiting until her son's TraumaticSuperpowerAwakening.]]
TraumaticSuperpowerAwakening.
** [[spoiler: From what I understand, Nao Shimura was in the same situation a lot of people in an abusive household are in: She was too afraid to do it/felt trapped by her circumstances, and it wasn't until things went way beyond the norm that she GrewASpine. Relationships are complicated and abusive ones, whether you are the direct victim or not, are not as simple as "Do the right thing when someone does something wrong". It is just not that simple, even in [[TruthInTelevision real life]], or we wouldn't have cases where children are abused by one parent and the other is very much ''not'' okay with it, or at least, they wouldn't go on for very long. Kotaro was clearly a very harsh and disciplined man, so likely any disobediance, even without punishment or threat, would be hard to do in his household, just by virtue of having that viewpoint hammered into your head by just living with him. That is also more likely why Hana would deny wanting to be a hero as well, even if she wasn't punished herself. That, and she would know what makes her father angry regardless, as the family clearly did know about the abuse. Essentially, living with a controlling and abusive person who has a significant place in your life, such as being your spouse, gives them influence on you, whether you like it or not, and it often either affects your thinking, restricts you in more material ways, or a combination of both. Just running/leaving is not easy for those who've lived like that, as any abused person will tell you.]]
you.
** There's also the ValuesDissonance of what is and isn't considered abuse in Japan. To a Western audience, [[spoiler:locking locking your kids out of the house]] house would undoubtedly be considered abuse, but it's not necessarily true in Japan. The very first chapter/episode of ''Franchise/SailorMoon'' has [[spoiler:Usagi's Usagi's mother locking her out of the house for getting a bad grade on a test, but is nevertheless portrayed as a loving mother]].mother. It's possible that Nao might have been uncomfortable with it, but didn't actually see it as abuse.



** Adding to the above, human adoration is fickle and tempestuous.
Look at how people react even today with celebrities. When, say, a star player is on your team, they're an idol, the greatest of the greats, etc. But then they leave your team, and people turn against them, spewing hate and vitriol, burning merchandise, wishing ills on them, and so on. Once someone is no longer benefitting you and yours (heroes no longer beating back the bad guys to keep a perceived peace), people turn on them, even if their reasons are faulty. In this case, people are lashing out on the misconception that without heroes, there wouldn't be villains, and thus now that the heroes aren't winning, they're the root of the problem.

to:

** Adding to the above, human adoration is fickle and tempestuous. \n Look at how people react even today with celebrities. When, say, a star player is on your team, they're an idol, the greatest of the greats, etc. But then they leave your team, and people turn against them, spewing hate and vitriol, burning merchandise, wishing ills on them, and so on. Once someone is no longer benefitting you and yours (heroes no longer beating back the bad guys to keep a perceived peace), people turn on them, even if their reasons are faulty. In this case, people are lashing out on the misconception that without heroes, there wouldn't be villains, and thus now that the heroes aren't winning, they're the root of the problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given how later arcs make a big deal about how strict Quirk usage laws are in Japan, such as during the Stain Arc, wouldn't someone at their Middle School step in and punish him for essentially using Explosion to intimidate Izuku? [[ValuesDissonance I get that Japan has a vastly different view on bullying and how to handle it]] but [[EarlyInstallmentWeirdness it's bizarre in retrospect]].

to:

* Given how later arcs make a big deal about how strict Quirk usage laws are in Japan, such as during the Stain Arc, wouldn't someone at their Middle School step in and punish him or at least call him out for essentially using Explosion to intimidate Izuku? [[ValuesDissonance I get that Japan has a vastly different view on bullying and how to handle it]] but [[EarlyInstallmentWeirdness it's bizarre in retrospect]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Katsuki using his quirk against Izuku in Chapter 1]]
* Given how later arcs make a big deal about how strict Quirk usage laws are in Japan, such as during the Stain Arc, wouldn't someone at their Middle School step in and punish him for essentially using Explosion to intimidate Izuku? [[ValuesDissonance I get that Japan has a vastly different view on bullying and how to handle it]] but [[EarlyInstallmentWeirdness it's bizarre in retrospect]].
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Adding to the above, human adoration is fickle and tempestuous.
Look at how people react even today with celebrities. When, say, a star player is on your team, they're an idol, the greatest of the greats, etc. But then they leave your team, and people turn against them, spewing hate and vitriol, burning merchandise, wishing ills on them, and so on. Once someone is no longer benefitting you and yours (heroes no longer beating back the bad guys to keep a perceived peace), people turn on them, even if their reasons are faulty. In this case, people are lashing out on the misconception that without heroes, there wouldn't be villains, and thus now that the heroes aren't winning, they're the root of the problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Let me say this as a Korean, most people from East Asia lacks the gene that is responsible for body odor. Yes, that's an actual thing and to my knowledge, a very, very, ''VERY'' small percentage of East Asians have this gene, which is why deodorant isn't a common good sold there. So tl;dr, most likely not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Piggybacking some the previous bullets by mentioning that Chapter 328 has All Might requesting aid from non-Japanese heroes in the fallout of the WarArc and the sole one who accepts it is from the U.S.

to:

*** Piggybacking some the previous bullets by mentioning that Chapter 328 has All Might requesting aid from non-Japanese heroes in the fallout of the WarArc and the sole one who accepts it is not only from the U.S., but also is the #1 Hero there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Piggybacking some the previous bullets by mentioning that Chapter 328 has All Might [[spoiler:requesting aid from non-Japanese heroes and the sole one who accepts it is from the U.S.]]

to:

*** Piggybacking some the previous bullets by mentioning that Chapter 328 has All Might [[spoiler:requesting requesting aid from non-Japanese heroes in the fallout of the WarArc and the sole one who accepts it is from the U.S.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Piggybacking some the previous bullets by mentioning that Chapter 328 has All Might [[spoiler:requesting aid from non-Japanese heroes and the sole one who accepts it is from the U.S.]]


Added DiffLines:

*** No he didn't. All Horikoshi said is that the robots just have to be disabled in order to gain points, which is what Mineta did. The switches are pure {{fanon}}.

Added: 1032

Changed: 256

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It may also be that Aizawa's Quirk ISN'T directly tied to his blinking, but rather operates on a set timer similar to Monoma's (in his case, it can remain active for roughly a minute max), and he just ties it to his blinking as his metric (similar to Monoma using the watches on his costume).



** Another thing that Bakugo might consider as Midoriya "looking down on him" is that Midoriya DOESN'T respond to his bullying/taunting. To someone like Bakugo, continuing to see him as something less than a hated rival is tantamount to Midoriya seeing him as beneath notice, especially since Midoriya was apparently hiding an incredibly strong Quirk. The fact that Izuku NEVER decided ti try and pick a fight or even retaliate is, to Bakugo, a slight that basically says "you're not worth my time, loser"

to:

** Another thing that Bakugo might consider as Midoriya "looking down on him" is that Midoriya DOESN'T respond to his bullying/taunting. To someone like Bakugo, continuing to see him as something less than a hated rival is tantamount to Midoriya seeing him as beneath notice, especially since Midoriya was apparently hiding an incredibly strong Quirk. The fact that Izuku NEVER decided ti to try and pick a fight or even retaliate is, to Bakugo, a slight that basically says "you're not worth my time, loser"



** Also, it may be that, in the MHA universe, Japan is considered to be the cream of the crop for Heroes. So being the #1 Hero in Japan, or being one of the most promising up-and-comers is considered a BIG deal

to:

** Also, it may be that, in the MHA universe, Japan is considered to be the cream of the crop for Heroes. So being the #1 Hero in Japan, or being one of the most promising up-and-comers is considered a BIG dealdeal, akin to, say, being the #1 soccer player in Europe (which has produced the creme de la creme of players). After all, Japan has produced All Might, Endeavour, Crimson Riot, Hawks, Miruko, etc, so being a top Hero in Japan puts you on that same footing.


Added DiffLines:

** Another reason All for One loses to All Might is a matter of mastery. AfO has a lot of quirks, but only at the barest minimum of understanding (he figures out how to use them, and that's it). All Might has only one Quirk, but has trained and experimented enough with it to understand all sorts of ways to use it (as has Deku, who turned "Super Strength" into things like Superspeed (Shoot Form), air bullets (Delaware Smash), etc). All Night's power is basic on the surface, but he knows how to use it, whereas All for One has many possible powers, but only uses them on a superficial level (only considering the very fundamental use (using a strength quirk only as "Punch hard", using emissive quirks only to blast at things, etc)

Top