Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MyHeroAcademia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Considering how physical the exam is, it's almost impossible to pass without a Quirk. And even if somebody did it in a fluke, they would most likely get expelled by the likes of Aizawa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well, he just did that, although the absorbers also slightly increase his Full Cowl power. 100% One For All is still too much for his body even with them though, so he still needed to change fighting styles anyway.

to:

** Well, he just did that, although the absorbers also slightly increase his Full Cowl power. 100% One For All is still too much for his body even with them though, so he still needed to change fighting styles anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, he just did that, although the absorbers also slightly increase his Full Cowl power. 100% One For All is still too much for his body even with them though, so he still needed to change fighting styles anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Aizawa's got dry eyes anyway, so this doesn't look like it would be efficient for him.

to:

** Aizawa's got dry eyes anyway, which is what actually prevents his Quirk from being always in use, so this doesn't look like it would be efficient for him.is a waste of time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Aizawa's got dry eyes anyway, so this doesn't look like it would be efficient for Aizawa.

to:

** Aizawa's got dry eyes anyway, so this doesn't look like it would be efficient for Aizawa.him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Aizawa's got dry eyes anyway, so this doesn't look like it would be efficient for Aizawa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I dunno, people have successfully trained themselves to do things like [[http://tech.mit.edu/V129/N41/ignobels.html crack the knuckles on only one hand for their entire life]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That would require an insane level of training, coordination, and effort, which wouldn't be very practical in an actual battlefield situation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler:Eraserhead and blinking]]

to:

[[spoiler:Eraserhead [[folder:Eraserhead and blinking]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[spoiler:Eraserhead and blinking]]
* We see when he saves Tsuyu's life from Tomura that he only needs one eye pointed at a person to nullify their Quirk. If that's so, could he train himself to blink one eye at a time so that his Quirk would remain indefinitely activated?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*In the anime, Midoriya says that U.A. doesn't require a quirk anymore in order to take the hero entrance exam and he's still officially registered as having no quirk when he took the exam, meaning that having a Quirk isn't actually necessary to be a hero but it gives you an advantage in the exam.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** First of all it should be noted that U.A isn't a normal high school, the ability to teach Heroics/responsible Quirk use is likely the priority. However that doesn't mean that the Teachers never studied to do anything else, it's very possible that all of them are qualified to teach those subjects, and if there's a gap then U.A would likely hire a normal teacher to fill in the gaps.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** U.A. is not really opening applications for Quirkless students, but rather scooping for users of HeartIsAnAwesomePower like Shinsou. Because fighting ability is an essential metric, there's not much of a point of having a Quirkless hero when you have hundreds of seemingly useless Quirk users that could potentially undergo the same training. It's also worth noting that Stain is a direct example of the second point, his equipment and fighting style is exactly designed to allow him to use his Quirk more efficiently as his speed, ambushes and blades make it easier for him to have access to a victim's blood. The danger of his Quirk is really underestimated.

to:

*** U.A. is not really opening applications for Quirkless students, but rather scooping for users of HeartIsAnAwesomePower like Shinsou. Because fighting ability is an essential metric, there's not much of a point of having a Quirkless hero when you have hundreds of seemingly useless Quirk users in line that could potentially undergo the same training.turn out to be a big asset. It's also worth noting that Stain is a direct example of the second point, his equipment and fighting style is exactly designed to allow him to use his Quirk more efficiently as his speed, ambushes and blades make it easier for him to have access to a victim's blood. The danger of his Quirk is really underestimated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** U.A. is not really opening applications for Quirkless students, but rather scooping for users of HeartIsAnAwesomePower like Shinsou. Because fighting ability is an essential metric, there's not much of a point of having a Quirkless hero when you have hundreds of seemingly useless Quirk users that could potentially undergo the same training. It's also worth noting that Stain is a direct example of the second point, his equipment and fighting style is exactly designed to allow him to use his Quirk more efficiently as his speed, ambushes and blades make it easier for him to have access to a victim's blood.

to:

*** U.A. is not really opening applications for Quirkless students, but rather scooping for users of HeartIsAnAwesomePower like Shinsou. Because fighting ability is an essential metric, there's not much of a point of having a Quirkless hero when you have hundreds of seemingly useless Quirk users that could potentially undergo the same training. It's also worth noting that Stain is a direct example of the second point, his equipment and fighting style is exactly designed to allow him to use his Quirk more efficiently as his speed, ambushes and blades make it easier for him to have access to a victim's blood. The danger of his Quirk is really underestimated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** U.A. is not really opening applications for Quirkless students, but rather scooping for users of HeartIsAnAwesomePower like Shinsou. Because fighting ability is an essential metric, there's not much of a point of having a Quirkless hero when you have hundreds of seemingly useless Quirk users that could potentially undergo the same training. It's also worth noting that Stain is a direct example of the second point, his equipment and fighting style is exactly designed to allow him to use his Quirk more efficiently as his speed, ambushes and blades make it easier for him to have access to a victim's blood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** 2) In the current hero business, popularity is as important, if not even more important, than actual competence, which is one of the reasons Stain grew disillusioned with modern heroes. No matter how skilled, someone without a Quirk to attract attention to would have a hard time making ends meet.

to:

*** 2) In the current hero business, popularity is as important, if not even more important, than actual competence, which is one of the reasons Stain grew disillusioned with modern heroes.competence. No matter how skilled, someone without a Quirk to attract attention to would have a hard time making ends meet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Point number four doesn't really hold water. We already have examples of characters who can kick incredible amounts of ass even without using their Quirks. Take Stain, for instance. Sure, if he can lick a person's blood, they get paralyzed and are effectively helpless, but until he draws blood, he's effectively no different from Quirkless person. Nevertheless, he managed to kill or disable dozens of pro heroes and managed to hold off Iida's SuperSpeed, Midoriya's SuperStrength and Todoroki's massive AreaOfEffect ElementalPowers with only training, mundane weaponry and a normal human body. He lost in the end, but only because he got impatient and even then, Midoriya believes that Stain could have still killed him had he really wanted to. The Quirks of those three students are well above average, particularly Midoriya and Todoroki's. Most Quirks don't even have a fraction of the power of One for All or Fire and Ice, like Ojiro's Tail, which just gives him a strong tail. It isn't inconceivable that a sufficiently armed BadassNormal could defeat most villains given enough effort. The real reasons there are no Quirkless heroes are probably twofold:
1) The whole point of a hero license in the first place is to allow heroes to use their Quirks against other people, something that not even the police have the permission to do. A Quirkless person would receive no benefit from the license, nor would a hero academy's heavily Quirk development focused curriculum help them in any way. It would just be a waste of time when they can just become a policeman instead.
2) In the current hero business, popularity is as important, if not even more important, than actual competence, which is one of the reasons Stain grew disillusioned with modern heroes. No matter how skilled, someone without a Quirk to attract attention to would have a hard time making ends meet.
Even so, despite these two factors, UA recently allowed applications from Quirkless prospective students, showing that they are at least open to the idea. Lets not forget that in the original draft of the manga, Midoriya was going to stay Quirkless. A Quirkless hero might appear in time, it's just that nobody with the right amount of skill and motivation has appeared yet.

to:

*** Point number four doesn't really hold water. We already have examples of characters who can kick incredible amounts of ass even without using their Quirks. Take [[spoiler:Take Stain, for instance. Sure, if he can lick a person's blood, they get paralyzed and are effectively helpless, but until he draws blood, he's effectively no different from Quirkless person. Nevertheless, he managed to kill or disable dozens of pro heroes and managed to hold off Iida's SuperSpeed, Midoriya's SuperStrength and Todoroki's massive AreaOfEffect ElementalPowers with only training, mundane weaponry and a normal human body. He lost in the end, but only because he got impatient and even then, Midoriya believes that Stain could have still killed him had he really wanted to. The Quirks of those three students are well above average, particularly Midoriya and Todoroki's. ]] Most Quirks don't even have a fraction of the power of One for All or Fire and Ice, like Ojiro's Tail, which just gives him a strong tail. It isn't inconceivable that a sufficiently armed BadassNormal could defeat most villains given enough effort. The real reasons there are no Quirkless heroes are probably twofold:
1) ***1) The whole point of a hero license in the first place is to allow heroes to use their Quirks against other people, something that not even the police have the permission to do. A Quirkless person would receive no benefit from the license, nor would a hero academy's heavily Quirk development focused curriculum help them in any way. It would just be a waste of time when they can just become a policeman instead.
2) ***2) In the current hero business, popularity is as important, if not even more important, than actual competence, which is one of the reasons Stain grew disillusioned with modern heroes. No matter how skilled, someone without a Quirk to attract attention to would have a hard time making ends meet.
Even ***Even so, despite these two factors, UA recently allowed applications from Quirkless prospective students, showing that they are at least open to the idea. Lets not forget that in the original draft of the manga, Midoriya was going to stay Quirkless. A Quirkless hero might appear in time, it's just that nobody with the right amount of skill and motivation has appeared yet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding a point

Added DiffLines:

*** Point number four doesn't really hold water. We already have examples of characters who can kick incredible amounts of ass even without using their Quirks. Take Stain, for instance. Sure, if he can lick a person's blood, they get paralyzed and are effectively helpless, but until he draws blood, he's effectively no different from Quirkless person. Nevertheless, he managed to kill or disable dozens of pro heroes and managed to hold off Iida's SuperSpeed, Midoriya's SuperStrength and Todoroki's massive AreaOfEffect ElementalPowers with only training, mundane weaponry and a normal human body. He lost in the end, but only because he got impatient and even then, Midoriya believes that Stain could have still killed him had he really wanted to. The Quirks of those three students are well above average, particularly Midoriya and Todoroki's. Most Quirks don't even have a fraction of the power of One for All or Fire and Ice, like Ojiro's Tail, which just gives him a strong tail. It isn't inconceivable that a sufficiently armed BadassNormal could defeat most villains given enough effort. The real reasons there are no Quirkless heroes are probably twofold:
1) The whole point of a hero license in the first place is to allow heroes to use their Quirks against other people, something that not even the police have the permission to do. A Quirkless person would receive no benefit from the license, nor would a hero academy's heavily Quirk development focused curriculum help them in any way. It would just be a waste of time when they can just become a policeman instead.
2) In the current hero business, popularity is as important, if not even more important, than actual competence, which is one of the reasons Stain grew disillusioned with modern heroes. No matter how skilled, someone without a Quirk to attract attention to would have a hard time making ends meet.
Even so, despite these two factors, UA recently allowed applications from Quirkless prospective students, showing that they are at least open to the idea. Lets not forget that in the original draft of the manga, Midoriya was going to stay Quirkless. A Quirkless hero might appear in time, it's just that nobody with the right amount of skill and motivation has appeared yet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How do the staff of Yuei balances their classes with their hero careers, their side business and their personal lifes? Can they at least temporally retire from crime-fighting? And how do professional heroes end teaching in a high school, apparently with degrees allowing to teach Literature or Maths?

to:

* How do the staff of Yuei balances their classes with their hero careers, their side business and their personal lifes? Can they at least temporally retire from crime-fighting? And how do professional heroes end teaching in at a high school, apparently with degrees allowing them to teach Literature or Maths?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Heroes and teachers]]

* How do the staff of Yuei balances their classes with their hero careers, their side business and their personal lifes? Can they at least temporally retire from crime-fighting? And how do professional heroes end teaching in a high school, apparently with degrees allowing to teach Literature or Maths?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Fourth, the only reason BadassNormal heroes are a thing in western comics is mostly due to author fiat and favoritism having to write around to keep the squishy normals from getting owned by villains with super powers. This setting doesn't have that; trying to be a BadassNormal when there are quirks that are are good at mass destruction on even freaking purse snatchers is only going to get you killed. Even Midoriya himself admitted that him wanting to be a super hero without a Quirk was mostly wishful thinking on his part after All Might told him straight out that getting into Heroics without powers was dangerous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Where and how could you modify it though? The stress is from his own muscles on his bones and cartilage. So unless his "Costume" was to go full Wolverine and have his bones replaced with "Superstrong, Doesn't Exist in Real Life" metal... There's not much that the costume could do besides act as a splint. Boxing wraps only work because they are keeping the wrists from incorrectly distributing the force. That isn't supposed to by Midoriya's problem. It's that there is just ''too much'' force for his body to handle no matter what he does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Third, equipment can't effectively replace Quirks, because it often gets lost, stolen, broken down, etc. It probably costs a lot too, especially because that stuff is often customized. The students and teachers can get away with it because U.A. funds them.

to:

** Third, adding to the above, equipment can't effectively replace Quirks, because it often gets lost, stolen, broken down, etc. It probably costs a lot too, especially because that stuff is often customized. The students and teachers can get away with it because U.A. funds them.

Changed: 125

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Second, most equipment tends to be built around the Quirks themselves, so you still need the Quirk in the first place in order to use it. For example, Bakugou's Grenade Blasters that store his nitroglycerin sweat. So far, only Aizawa appears to have equipment that does not revolve around his Quirk.

to:

** Second, most equipment tends to be built around the Quirks themselves, so you still need the Quirk in the first place in order to use it. For example, Bakugou's Grenade Blasters that store his nitroglycerin sweat. So far, only Aizawa appears to have equipment that does not revolve around his Quirk.Quirk and is sufficiently strong to overshadow a lot of other Quirks. Everything else are Quirk amplifiers or side-effect reducers.

Changed: 121

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Second, most equipment tends to be built around the Quirks themselves, so you still need the Quirk in the first place in order to use it. For example, Bakugou's Grenade Blasters.

to:

** Second, most equipment tends to be built around the Quirks themselves, so you still need the Quirk in the first place in order to use it. For example, Bakugou's Grenade Blasters.Blasters that store his nitroglycerin sweat. So far, only Aizawa appears to have equipment that does not revolve around his Quirk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Third, equipment can't effectively replace Quirks, because it often gets lost, stolen, broken down, etc. It probably costs a lot too, especially because that stuff is often customized.

to:

** Third, equipment can't effectively replace Quirks, because it often gets lost, stolen, broken down, etc. It probably costs a lot too, especially because that stuff is often customized. The students and teachers can get away with it because U.A. funds them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:

** First of all, Mei Hatsume is not in the hero course. She's in the support development.
** Second, most equipment tends to be built around the Quirks themselves, so you still need the Quirk in the first place in order to use it. For example, Bakugou's Grenade Blasters.
** Third, equipment can't effectively replace Quirks, because it often gets lost, stolen, broken down, etc. It probably costs a lot too, especially because that stuff is often customized.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't Midoriya have his hero uniform made with someone to absorb the shock from One for All? I know he wanted to use what his mom gave him, but there's no reason he couldn't have had it modified.

to:

* Why didn't Midoriya have his hero uniform made with someone something to absorb the shock from One for All? I know he wanted to use what his mom gave him, but there's no reason he couldn't have had it modified.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Quirk Necessity]]
* Why is it that Quirks are so necessary for superherodom? It's already been shown there's technology that outright replicates Quirks - take Eraserhead's carbon-fiber tethers that he can seemingly control with his -mind- that are NOT part of his Quirk! This makes [[spoiler:Ragdoll's forced retirement from being one of the Pussycats after the loss of her 'Radar' Quirk seem weirder to me when she could be set up with tech to make her into a Gadget Heroine and keep her with her beloved team]] seem even more awful. Heck, one of the students in the Tournament who was ACCEPTED TO UAA HAS A QUIRK THAT IS JUST "SEE FAR" - despite it having low combat potential and being easily replicated by tech, this student was allowed to be a hero solely on her technological merits that carried her through the entrance exam, NOT her quirk.

*In total - why did even All Might himself say to give up being a hero without a Quirk when you very clearly CAN BE A HERO WITHOUT A QUIRK IF YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TECH?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[foldercontrol]]

[[folder:Midoriya's Recoil]]
* Why didn't Midoriya have his hero uniform made with someone to absorb the shock from One for All? I know he wanted to use what his mom gave him, but there's no reason he couldn't have had it modified.
[[/folder]]

Top