Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GirlGenius

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Even from the start Tarvek's MORALITY is clearly established. He's a light shade of gray. He doesn't like to hurt people for no reason (like "Madame Olga"), he tries to do right by people he feels he needs to exploit (like paying for Tinka), and he even goes out of his way and puts himself in danger later on to save someone he has no need to save (Jorgi). He's willing to be underhanded when necessary and will get violent when angry or threatened, but genuinely doesn't seem like he does that except as a last resort.

His allegiances and goals, however seem to change as the story progresses.
*** Initially he hates The Baron and Gil (but respects the former). He wants to be Storm King (though these aspirations could likely be a result of his family indoctrinating him). He does what his father asks but doesn't seem to really want to. He's ultimately loyal to his family.
*** As the story continues, he seems to lose loyalty to his family as they start turning on each other and him, they start to approach success in bringing The Other back, and his plans to be Storm King fall apart. He sides with Lucrezia to save himself and, while he seems to like Agatha, ultimately views her as a tool.
*** By the time they reach England, he seems to have totally abandoned his family and sided firmly with Agatha out of genuine love rather than practicality. He seems to have come to respect, and even like, Gil (their rivalry for Agatha notwithstanding). He's never abandoned his plans to be Storm King (it seems like he IS the rightful heir after all) but now seems more interested in helping Agatha and defeating the Other. It also seems like he's more interested in earning his title on his own than relying on his family and their plots.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** She didn't have a reason to do it in that situation, as she was preoccupied by her squabble with Claus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** But she gains control, however briefly, in the Corbettite monastery ''after'' Agatha drank from the Dyne, which considering she activated the transformation within a couple of frames, gave her more than enough time to do so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She tells it herself: she's never done it before and also grew accustomed to clank brains that cannot Spark at all. Also, Agatha had to drink from Dyne first, and after that all Lucrezia's manifestations were preoccupied with other things.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mistake


** It's probably not a coincidence that so far every Spark who's been able to achieve a [[EnlightenmentSuperpowers second breakthrough]] and gain [[PhysicalGoddess godlike powers]] - [[GodEmperor Queen Albia]], the other "God-Queens" and Lucrezia/Agatha - has been female.

to:

** It's probably not a coincidence that so far every Spark who's been able to achieve a [[EnlightenmentSuperpowers second breakthrough]] and gain [[PhysicalGoddess godlike powers]] - [[GodEmperor Queen Albia]], the other "God-Queens" and Lucrezia/Agatha - has been female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Lucrezia's Second Breakthrough]]
* During the Londinium arc, Lucrezia/Agatha is [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20191023 seen]] initiating her 'second breakthrough' that grants her [[EnlightenmentSuperpowers godlike powers]] similar to those of [[GodEmperor Albia]], fairly quickly and seemingly at will, without any special equipment or resources - so why did she [[NewPowersAsThePlotDemands wait until then]] to trigger it, if she knew how? Agatha hasn't changed in any significant way or gained relevant information since Lucrezia was last in control, and Lucrezia's typical blend of [[ItsAllAboutMe arrogance]] and [[ChronicVillainy megalomania]] makes it seem out of character for her to hold back a transformation into a PhysicalGoddess for whatever reason.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's probably not a coincidence that so far every Spark who's been able to achieve a [[EnlightenmentSuperpowers second breakthrough]] and gain [[PhysicalGoddess godlike powers]]- [[GodEmperor Queen Albia]], the other "God-Queens" and Lucrezia/Agatha - has been female.

to:

** It's probably not a coincidence that so far every Spark who's been able to achieve a [[EnlightenmentSuperpowers second breakthrough]] and gain [[PhysicalGoddess godlike powers]]- powers]] - [[GodEmperor Queen Albia]], the other "God-Queens" and Lucrezia/Agatha - has been female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It's probably not a coincidence that so far every Spark who's been able to achieve a [[EnlightenmentSuperpowers second breakthrough]] and gain [[PhysicalGoddess godlike powers]]- [[GodEmperor Queen Albia]], the other "God-Queens" and Lucrezia/Agatha - has been female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** We now have the answer. Anekiva is in his room, and he is obeying her commands. Sleep!

to:

** We now have the answer. Anekiva Anevka is in his room, and he is obeying her commands. Sleep!




to:

** Since it's Lucrezia in Anevka's body, most likely she knows how to replicate her commanding voice perfectly (she spent eons in clank bodies, after all), and adjusted the voicebox off-screen.

Added: 374

Changed: 116

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Actually, for a Spark both his reasoning and his plans are well thought-out, noted both in- and out-of-universe.


Added DiffLines:

** Albia ''did'' intend to question Agatha about the mirrors (Martellus hasn't shown up in England by this point), but plenty of more urgent things happened and everyone got distracted. Most likely he will actually be questioned (or surrender the information on his own accord) a little bit later, when the gang has the time to remember about this and the question comes up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ...what are you talking about? [[MsFanservice Zeetha's]] nudity (well, not quite, but whatever) was played for laughs ''twice''. Gil got one in a perfectly logical situation (Mama Gkika's), and then he and Tarvek got a slightly less justified one in the castle. These all lasted about two panels each. Is ''that'' what you mean? Note that my first anime/manga were ''Manga/MahouSenseiNegima'' and ''Anime/{{Witchblade}}'', so I'm desensitized. I literally don't know what you mean.

to:

** ...what are you talking about? [[MsFanservice Zeetha's]] nudity (well, not quite, but whatever) was played for laughs ''twice''. Gil got one in a perfectly logical situation (Mama Gkika's), and then he and Tarvek got a slightly less justified one in the castle. These all lasted about two panels each. Is ''that'' what you mean? Note that my first anime/manga were ''Manga/MahouSenseiNegima'' ''Manga/NegimaMagisterNegiMagi'' and ''Anime/{{Witchblade}}'', so I'm desensitized. I literally don't know what you mean.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Unlikely. She has been seen in less than her turtleneck and did not bear any neck scars at that time. The scars did not appear until her arrival in Londinium, and appear to be part of her 'Europan of Piratical Descent' guise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[/folder]]



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Martellus and the Mirrors]]
* OK, as I understand it, this is everything we know about the mirrors: A long time ago, immortal queens used [[ClarkesThirdLaw "magic"]] mirrors to teleport all over the world. Then the mirrors stopped working and nobody has been able to fix them. However, Martellus used a pair of mirrors to teleport himself and Agatha from Mechanicsburg to his mountain palace. So... Why hasn't anyone simply asked Martellus how he got his mirrors working?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Is Bang a Construct?]]
*for a long while, Bang only ever appeared in a roll-neck sweater, which was presumably meant to look nautical like the rest of her outfit (although there is no actual evidence anywhere, that she IS a sea-captain - she seems to be an airship pirate, although they share a lot of nautical characteristics). Lately, though, she has been appearing in a tank-top and there is a visible seam around her neck. Does this mean that she is a Construct? Does it, perhaps mean that she did NOT survive the encounter with Zeetha in which her crew was killed, and does she know, one way or the other? Zeetha probably wouldn’t know; Klaus certainly would, as he would have been (most likely) responsible for her reconstruction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A minor quibble, but how did one cup of coffee in Mechanicsburg accomplish CaffeineBulletTime when massive loads of stimulants administered in Sturmhalten(presumably, one of the Moveit formulations) didn't?

to:

* A minor quibble, but how did one cup of coffee in Mechanicsburg accomplish CaffeineBulletTime when massive loads of stimulants administered in Sturmhalten(presumably, Sturmhalten (presumably, one of the Moveit formulations) didn't?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worth noting that, although Klaus shut up when ordered to, he then ''started talking without recieveing further orders''. It's possible the wasp died before being able to perform permanent alterations.

to:

** It's worth noting that, although Klaus shut up when ordered to, he then ''started talking without recieveing receiving further orders''. It's possible the wasp died before being able to perform permanent alterations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For Tarvek's Morality: He's on whichever side will be best for Tarvek. Wild Card. He likes Agatha. But, at the same time, he looks out for Tarvek. He sides with Lucrezia because she'll kill him otherwise...but realizing that she's insane, promptly betrays her when he can. He'll work for the Wulfenbachs if he has to do it to avoid getting shot...but will promptly betray them if he can get out from under everyone's thumb. His ultimate goal is, presumabely, to end up the one sitting in the throne. Fortunately, he's recognized that Agatha is the heroine...and he LIKES her, so...he's a good guy. And he's not one to unnecessarially kick the dog. (As they put. "He's allied with whoever is listening").

to:

** For Tarvek's Morality: He's on whichever side will be best for Tarvek. Wild Card. He likes Agatha. But, at the same time, he looks out for Tarvek. He sides with Lucrezia because she'll kill him otherwise...but realizing that she's insane, promptly betrays her when he can. He'll work for the Wulfenbachs if he has to do it to avoid getting shot...but will promptly betray them if he can get out from under everyone's thumb. His ultimate goal is, presumabely, presumably, to end up the one sitting in the throne. Fortunately, he's recognized that Agatha is the heroine...and he LIKES her, so...he's a good guy. And he's not one to unnecessarially kick the dog. (As they put. "He's allied with whoever is listening").



** ? He was probably just a decent scientist as far as non-sparks go (he has a doctorate, after all), even if he would waste his time and ability if left alone to his own devices (seriously, cheese? From chalk?). Consider that he and the others were able to construct Wulfenbach's machine up to a reasonable point, given both the fact that they were normal humans and that the machine was never designed to work. That's probably all the reason Beetle would need to keep him around; he needs a competent person to whom to delegate less important task which didn't require his spark genius.

to:

** ? He was probably just a decent scientist as far as non-sparks go (he has a doctorate, after all), even if he would waste his time and ability if left alone to his own devices (seriously, cheese? From chalk?). Consider that he and the others were able to construct Wulfenbach's machine up to a reasonable point, given both the fact that they were normal humans and that the machine was never designed to work. That's probably all the reason Beetle would need to keep him around; he needs a competent person to whom to delegate less important task which didn't require his spark genius.



** Also bear in mind the era we are talking about here. The opinions of the monarch where very important and well respected in our world at that era. I mean you can imagine that a spark could amplify that Royalty to a palpable level. That would also explain why Britain is literally closed to Klaus, absolutely everyone would distrust and report him.

to:

** Also bear in mind the era we are talking about here. The opinions of the monarch where were very important and well respected in our world at that era. I mean you can imagine that a spark could amplify that Royalty to a palpable level. That would also explain why Britain is literally closed to Klaus, absolutely everyone would distrust and report him.



** One of JamesPHogan's books points out that science that works is engineering. Science that doesn't work is bunk. [[InsaneTrollLogic Objectively, that means ]]'''''[[InsaneTrollLogic science does not exist!]]''''' [[IceCreamKoan Hear the sound of one hand clapping!]]

to:

** One of JamesPHogan's Creator/JamesPHogan's books points out that science that works is engineering. Science that doesn't work is bunk. [[InsaneTrollLogic Objectively, that means ]]'''''[[InsaneTrollLogic science does not exist!]]''''' [[IceCreamKoan Hear the sound of one hand clapping!]]



** It finished! And, sure enough, they tied pretty much everything up there...so they could turn the setting on it's head.

to:

** It finished! And, sure enough, they tied pretty much everything up there...so they could turn the setting on it's its head.



* Whenabouts does this actually take place? A lot of our familiar milestones are probably meaningless - most of Europe being ruled by a baron rules out familiar dynasties, sparks ruin eras in thought, the apparently atheistic invocations we see probably rule out Christ, but, for instance, how long has it been since the death of Caesar? Did this world even have Caesar? Charlemagne? Othar's Twitter mentions Voltaire, but he lived much later than the architecture and fashions seem to indicate. Hell, Phil and Kaja coming to our world would almost seems to imply it's been about [[MedievalStasis 2,750 years since the founding of Rome]]...

to:

* Whenabouts does this actually take place? A lot of our familiar milestones are probably meaningless - most of Europe being ruled by a baron rules out familiar dynasties, sparks Sparks ruin eras in thought, the apparently atheistic invocations we see probably rule out Christ, but, for instance, how long has it been since the death of Caesar? Did this world even have Caesar? Charlemagne? Othar's Twitter mentions Voltaire, but he lived much later than the architecture and fashions seem to indicate. Hell, Phil and Kaja coming to our world would almost seems to imply it's been about [[MedievalStasis 2,750 years since the founding of Rome]]...



* Why are Gil and Tarvek completely or nearly useless in this arc? Gil destroyed the main incoming force of a rival military force with two blows. Tarvek has been manipulating the people within Castle Heterodyne, and coordinating a coup on the outside with masterful precision. Once Agatha comes along-to which I hold no fault to her for, mind you-they start getting severely gimped. Tarvek is made useless due to a disease, then Gil. Tarvek is thrown about like a fool by Violetta-which has been actually been at the brunt of my dislike pile as of recent events (To keep a long story short; THEY DID EVERYTHING THEY COULD about the poison, despite them being men of actual chivalry and honor)-and Gil was nearly eaten by a plant. Is anyone else but me getting annoyed at this yet?

to:

* Why are Gil and Tarvek completely or nearly useless in this arc? Gil destroyed the main incoming force of a rival military force with two blows. Tarvek has been manipulating the people within Castle Heterodyne, and coordinating a coup on the outside with masterful precision. Once Agatha comes along-to along- to which I hold no fault to her for, mind you-they you- they start getting severely gimped. Tarvek is made useless due to a disease, then Gil. Tarvek is thrown about like a fool by Violetta-which Violetta- which has been actually been at the brunt of my dislike pile as of recent events (To keep a long story short; THEY DID EVERYTHING THEY COULD about the poison, despite them being men of actual chivalry and honor)-and honor)- and Gil was nearly eaten by a plant. Is anyone else but me getting annoyed at this yet?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** According to ''Agatha H and the Siege of Mechanicsburg'', careful testing determined that a Mechanicsburg league is 5.556km.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Bullet Point to "Coffee" Folder



to:

** Another factor to consider is that the coffee from Mechanicsburg is probably made with water from the Dyne. Even if the river gets watered down (har har) when all the energy is captured in the Great Movement Chamber, there could still be some residual effects that get amplified when it's mixed with stimulants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Of course, this ''IS'' Castle Heterodyne that we're talking about. It probably hasn't said anything about that night because [[YouDidntAsk we haven't seen anyone bother to ask it what happened.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A very, very nice explosion.


Added DiffLines:

** Seems like it's memory of that event is damaged, so it's in the dark too.


Added DiffLines:

** It's Frozen Maiden. F was obscured for the gag.

Added: 11

Changed: 229

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The flashback panel on [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20050128#.V_6yafArKUk this]] page makes it seem as if the crab clank grabbed Olga's body off the ground. The figure on the receiving end of the death ray on [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20041129#.V_6zFfArKUk this]] page isn't holding the blaster Agatha was holding for the duration of the battle, either. The crab clank did just take a hit to it's main engine, so it was probably flailing about wildly and blasted the first thing it could get a hold of.
* They pulled a cheat. There's a time-skip between the panels.

to:

* ** The flashback panel on [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20050128#.V_6yafArKUk this]] page makes it seem as if the crab clank grabbed Olga's body off the ground. The figure on the receiving end of the death ray on [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20041129#.V_6zFfArKUk this]] page isn't holding the blaster Agatha was holding for the duration of the battle, either. The crab clank did just take a hit to it's main engine, so it was probably flailing about wildly and blasted the first thing it could get a hold of.
* ** They pulled a cheat. There's a time-skip between the panels.



* LoopholeAbuse: Dimo hasn't been ''healed'' by anyone, just fitted with a prosthetic.

to:

* ** LoopholeAbuse: Dimo hasn't been ''healed'' by anyone, just fitted with a prosthetic.



** Dimo is the last remaining general, and everything has gone to hell. HE NEEDS THE ARM![[/folder]]

to:

** Dimo is the last remaining general, and everything has gone to hell. HE NEEDS THE ARM![[/folder]]
ARM!
** Remember the point of this rule is to keep Heterodyne secrets out of the hands of outsiders. The arm was most likely made by Punch, a Heterodyne construct who probably already knows most of those secrets anyway.

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** About the 'commanding' thing: If Klaus ''was'' infected, he could, if he wanted to fight Lucrezia @ other (that is if the storyline gives him a chance) he could [[CrowningMomentOfFunny wear earmuffs]] (In a world of inventors, earmuffs are ''bound'' to exist, and also they probably be pink and fluffy for irony, and, in Klaus' case, be custom-fitted with custom-mini-weapons designed to work against the other (and practically anyone else).

to:

** About the 'commanding' thing: If Klaus ''was'' infected, he could, if he wanted to fight Lucrezia @ other (that is if the storyline gives him a chance) he could [[CrowningMomentOfFunny [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments wear earmuffs]] (In a world of inventors, earmuffs are ''bound'' to exist, and also they probably be pink and fluffy for irony, and, in Klaus' case, be custom-fitted with custom-mini-weapons designed to work against the other (and practically anyone else).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Either Klaus had not put the brain inside yet or they let her go since she was no use to them whatsoever. She wouldn't be the same Olga anyway so there is no reason for her to contact Master Payne or any of the other characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

***Albia is a "God Queen," one of once what was a sisterhood spread across the planet. Her science is so advanced that, even by GG standards, it seems more like magic. She's been alive for at least a few thousand years, though some things like the Mirrors elude even her. That's about all we've seen of her at this point.

Added: 243

Changed: 304

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Actually it's mentioned a few times that the Heterodynes only really control Mechanicsburg. Their family does not have vast swaths of land that need defending, and what they do have is taken care of by a fully-functional Castle Heterodyne.




to:

** Agatha [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20160701 actually asks]] a variant of this exact question. [[http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20160704 The answer]] is all about public relations and opinion, and the fact that most associate Jaegers with the old, evil Heterodynes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***It's actually a bit of FridgeBrilliance as to why Klaus would repair the locket. He thought she was a potential danger even before Lucrezia got inside Agatha's head, and then he found the locket made by Barry. The decrypted notes from Beetle would have let him know exactly what it did, and maybe even that Agatha was oblivious to the locket's true purpose. So he fixes it and gets to present her locket as a peace offering and as a way to neutralize her Spark.

Top