Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DoctorWho2022CENThePowerOfTheDoctor

Go To

OR

Added: 670

Changed: 652

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively, (content note:suicidal ideation) [[spoiler:in ''The Timeless Children'', the Master pretty clearly wants to die, either from his murder of Ashad triggering the Death Particle or the Doctor blowing him up—but for whatever reason, doesn't want to either kill himself or let Ko Sharmus do it. So maybe this is just an elaborate and slow form of suicide where he lives through one more regeneration as himself, then dies and regenerates as David Tennant and poof, Master erased. (Not even "one more regeneration as himself", if he can convince himself that he's the Doctor—this is why he's so desperate to convince an objective witness like Yaz that he's the Doctor.)]]

to:

*** A running theme in ''The Timeless Children'' is that the Doctor is ''special'' and the Master resents her for it. If he becomes the Doctor, then ''he'' is the special one.
** Alternatively, (content note:suicidal ideation) [[spoiler:in ''The Timeless Children'', the Master pretty clearly wants to die, either from his murder of Ashad triggering the Death Particle or the Doctor blowing him up—but for whatever reason, doesn't want to either kill himself or let Ko Sharmus do it. So maybe this is just an elaborate and slow form of suicide where he lives through one more regeneration as himself, then dies and regenerates as David Tennant and poof, Master erased. (Not even "one more regeneration as himself", if he can convince himself that he's the Doctor—this is why he's so desperate to convince an objective witness like Yaz that he's the Doctor.of that.)]]

Added: 683

Changed: 1533

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What is the difference between the Master regenerating into the Doctor's body and the Master murdering and then cosplaying as the Doctor? He goes to such a lot of effort to achieve the same effect as simply [[WhyDontYouJustShootHim killing]] and dressing up as her.
** The Doctor is the Timeless Child and has theoretically infinite regenerations. The Master has put a lot of time, pain, and effort into staying alive despite his Timelord-standard regeneration cap. Stealing the infinitely regenerating body is absolutely a thing the Classic Series Master would do. (This does bring with it the assumption that if you were to shoot the Master!Doctor in the head, he would then regenerate into another Master rather than into David Tennant—or at least, that's what the Master thinks would happen.)
** Alternatively, (content note:suicidal ideation) [[spoiler:in ''The Timeless Children'', the Master pretty clearly wants to die, either from his murder of Ashad triggering the Death Particle or the Doctor blowing him up—but for whatever reason, doesn't want to either kill himself or let Ko Sharmus do it. So maybe this is just an elaborate and slow form of suicide where he lives through one more regeneration as himself, then dies and regenerates as David Tennant and poof, Master erased.]]

to:

* What is the difference between the Master regenerating into the Doctor's body and the Master murdering and then cosplaying as the Doctor? He goes to such a lot of effort to achieve the same effect as simply [[WhyDontYouJustShootHim killing]] dressing up as her.
** Part of it is that he isn't just dressing up as her, he's ''killing her''
and dressing up as her. The Doctor is about as good as the Master at surviving certain death; by stealing her body, he severely limits her ability to still secretly be alive somewhere where he can't see her.
** The Doctor is the Timeless Child and has theoretically infinite possibly infinite, and probably more than twelve, regenerations. The Master has put a lot of time, pain, and effort into staying alive despite his Timelord-standard regeneration cap. Stealing the infinitely regenerating body is absolutely a thing the Classic Series Master would do. (This does bring with it the assumption that if you were to shoot the Master!Doctor in the head, he would then regenerate into another Master rather than into David Tennant—or at least, that's what the Master thinks would happen.)
** Alternatively, (content note:suicidal ideation) [[spoiler:in ''The Timeless Children'', the Master pretty clearly wants to die, either from his murder of Ashad triggering the Death Particle or the Doctor blowing him up—but for whatever reason, doesn't want to either kill himself or let Ko Sharmus do it. So maybe this is just an elaborate and slow form of suicide where he lives through one more regeneration as himself, then dies and regenerates as David Tennant and poof, Master erased.]] (Not even "one more regeneration as himself", if he can convince himself that he's the Doctor—this is why he's so desperate to convince an objective witness like Yaz that he's the Doctor.)]]

Added: 3105

Changed: 458

Removed: 1103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Merging this and the Doctor Who 2022 Specials page.


** In the [[https://www.bbc.co.uk/writers/scripts/tv-drama/doctor-who BBC script]], there are some deleted scenes indicating that the Master caused the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunguska_event Tunguska event]] while he was creating and/or testing out the Cyber planet and that he spent eight years fixing it after that. So from the authors' point of view, he has to be in Russia in the early 1900s because that's where and when the Tunguska event happened. From his point of view, he was probably looking for a time and place where the Doctor wouldn't find him while he was working. Siberia has very few people, the early twentieth century doesn't have a lot of global surveillance, and he was probably planning to either leave before WWI or thought it would make a good distraction.



*** That's easy--after escaping he went back in time to when the new UNIT headquarters was being built and put it there as insurance in case the Cybermen betrayed him and never showed up.
* What is the difference between the Master regenerating into the Doctor's body and the Master cosplaying as the Doctor? He goes to such a lot of effort to achieve the same effect as simply dressing up as her.
** Probably dealing the Doctor a blow by using up one regeneration in the Doctor's new regeneration cycle? "But Timeless Child!", you might be saying - there's no evidence that the Doctor from Hartnell-Smith had the Timeless Child's regeneration capacities (they wouldn't have - after all, there's the fob watch at the end of ''The Vanquishers'') or that the Time Lords who granted an extra regeneration cycle to Smith knew about (the Doctor being) the Timeless Child.
** The fact that the Doctor, in their true form, ceases to exist.

to:

*** ** That's easy--after escaping he went back in time to when the new UNIT headquarters was being built and put it there as insurance in case the Cybermen betrayed him and never showed up.
* What is the difference between the Master regenerating into the Doctor's body and the Master cosplaying as the Doctor? He goes to such a lot of effort to achieve the same effect as simply dressing up as her.
** Probably dealing the Doctor a blow by using up one regeneration in the Doctor's new regeneration cycle? "But Timeless Child!", you might be saying - there's no evidence that the Doctor from Hartnell-Smith had the Timeless Child's regeneration capacities (they wouldn't have - after all, there's the fob watch at the end of ''The Vanquishers'') or that the Time Lords who granted an extra regeneration cycle to Smith knew about (the Doctor being) the Timeless Child.
** The fact that the Doctor, in their true form, ceases to exist.
up.



** Presumably the Master "regenerating into the Doctor" would lead to his biodata being read as the Doctor's, if he got to the point of being accosted and having his biodata assessed.

to:

** Presumably Addressing both this question and the next, presumably the Master "regenerating into the Doctor" would lead to his biodata being read as the Doctor's, if he got to the point of being accosted and having his biodata assessed.assessed.
* What is the difference between the Master regenerating into the Doctor's body and the Master murdering and then cosplaying as the Doctor? He goes to such a lot of effort to achieve the same effect as simply [[WhyDontYouJustShootHim killing]] and dressing up as her.
** The Doctor is the Timeless Child and has theoretically infinite regenerations. The Master has put a lot of time, pain, and effort into staying alive despite his Timelord-standard regeneration cap. Stealing the infinitely regenerating body is absolutely a thing the Classic Series Master would do. (This does bring with it the assumption that if you were to shoot the Master!Doctor in the head, he would then regenerate into another Master rather than into David Tennant—or at least, that's what the Master thinks would happen.)
** Alternatively, (content note:suicidal ideation) [[spoiler:in ''The Timeless Children'', the Master pretty clearly wants to die, either from his murder of Ashad triggering the Death Particle or the Doctor blowing him up—but for whatever reason, doesn't want to either kill himself or let Ko Sharmus do it. So maybe this is just an elaborate and slow form of suicide where he lives through one more regeneration as himself, then dies and regenerates as David Tennant and poof, Master erased.]]
*** Or [[spoiler:MurderSuicide. He was planning to refuse to regenerate, as he did in "Last of the Time Lords", but without the Disciples of Saxon to bring him back. No more Master, no more Doctor.]]
** Alternatively-alternatively, if you think that Missy's reform has left the Master capable of feeling guilt but without any particularly good coping mechanisms for it, if he turns into the Doctor, then suddenly he isn't actually responsible for any of the terrible things the Master has done. Back in ''The Rebel Flesh/The Almost People'' in Series 6, the ganger!Doctor has the same memories and personality as the original Doctor, but he knows that he's ''not'' actually the one who did all the things the Doctor regrets, with the result that the ganger!Doctor is much nicer and happier than the original Doctor. The Master might think that his forced regeneration plan might let him feel the same way. (This doesn't even need the Master to really ''be'' the Doctor in any objective sense—just to believe himself to be so.)



** Presumably the Doctor picked her up and dropped her on Earth off-screen.



** Mel is confirmed to be returning in Series 14. Presumably her return to Earth will be explored there – [=RTD=] did tease it...
** In the 60th Anniversary Special "The Giggle", Mel is said to have come back to Earth by getting "a lift off a Zingo". It is unclear what a Zingo is, and knowing [=RTD=], it is unlikely we'll ever know; [=RTD=] likes to name-drop funny/cool-sounding technobabble without elaborating.

to:

** Mel is confirmed to be returning in Series 14. Presumably her return to Earth will be explored there – [=RTD=] did tease it...
** In the 60th Anniversary Special "The Giggle", ''The Giggle,'' Mel is said to have come back to Earth by getting "a explicitly addresses this. Apparently, she actually stayed with Glitz until his death at the ripe old age of 101. She then got a lift off from a Zingo". Zingo and returned to Earth. [[NoodleIncident It is unclear what a Zingo is, is]], and knowing [=RTD=], it is unlikely we'll ever know; [=RTD=] likes to name-drop funny/cool-sounding technobabble without elaborating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the 60th Anniversary Special "The Giggle", Mel is said to have come back to Earth by getting "a lift of a Zingo". It is unclear what a Zingo is, and knowing [=RTD=], it is unlikely we'll ever know; [=RTD=] likes to name-drop funny/cool-sounding technobabble without elaborating.

to:

** In the 60th Anniversary Special "The Giggle", Mel is said to have come back to Earth by getting "a lift of off a Zingo". It is unclear what a Zingo is, and knowing [=RTD=], it is unlikely we'll ever know; [=RTD=] likes to name-drop funny/cool-sounding technobabble without elaborating.

Added: 284

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the 60th Anniversary Special "The Giggle", Mel is said to have come back to Earth by getting "a lift of a Zingo". It is unclear what a Zingo is, and knowing [=RTD=], it is unlikely we'll ever know; [=RTD=] likes to name-drop funny/cool-sounding technobabble without elaborating.



** The super-charged baseball bat was broken when the Doctor used it to smash the Dalek transmat system in the Coal Hill School basement.

to:

** *** The super-charged baseball bat was broken when the Doctor used it to smash the Dalek transmat system in the Coal Hill School basement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The super-charged baseball bat was broken when the Doctor used it to smash the Dalek transmat system in the Coal Hill School basement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Or maybe they did, but they were uncertain about whether this applies to a regenerating Cyberman as much as it does to a Time Lord.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't the train people shoot the CyberMasters mid-regeneration? It is known that killing a Time Lord mid-regeneration kills them for good.

to:

* Why didn't the train people shoot the CyberMasters [=CyberMasters=] mid-regeneration? It is known that killing a Time Lord mid-regeneration kills them for good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Steel melts at a lower temperature than rock. The plugs shouldn't hold up for long enough to impede normal volcanic activity in future, they just stopped ''this'' round of eruptions.

to:

** Steel melts at a lower temperature than rock. The plugs shouldn't hold up for long enough to impede normal volcanic activity in future, they just stopped ''this'' round of eruptions.eruptions.
* Why didn't the train people shoot the CyberMasters mid-regeneration? It is known that killing a Time Lord mid-regeneration kills them for good.
** Perhaps they didn't know that killing a Time Lord mid-regeneration kills them for good? The Universe is a big place.
** They were probably too shocked by the sight of a regenerating Cyberman to really act further.

Added: 218

Changed: 9

Removed: 218

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The idea seems to be the Cyber-Moon will cyber-convert the entire planet back in 1916, then when the Cybermen have finished making use of Earth's resources the Daleks will finish the job by destroying Earth in 2022.



** Mel is confirmed to be returning in [=RTD2=], in Series 14. Presumably her return to Earth will be explored there – [=RTD=] did tease it...

to:

** Mel is confirmed to be returning in [=RTD2=], in Series 14. Presumably her return to Earth will be explored there – [=RTD=] did tease it...


Added DiffLines:

** The idea seems to be the Cyber-Moon will cyber-convert the entire planet back in 1916, then when the Cybermen have finished making use of Earth's resources the Daleks will finish the job by destroying Earth in 2022.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Presumably it just 'plugged' the erupting magma rather than turning the Earth's core into steel.

to:

** Presumably it just 'plugged' the erupting magma rather than turning the Earth's core into steel.steel.
** Steel melts at a lower temperature than rock. The plugs shouldn't hold up for long enough to impede normal volcanic activity in future, they just stopped ''this'' round of eruptions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Isn't it the same baseball bat? Presumably it never lost all its mojo from the Hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Presumably the Master "regenerating into the Doctor" would lead to his biodata being read as the Doctor's, if he got to the point of being accosted and having his biodata assessed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mel is confirmed to be returning in [=RTD2=], in Series 14. Presumably her return to Earth will be explored there – [=RTD=] did tease it...

to:

* ** Mel is confirmed to be returning in [=RTD2=], in Series 14. Presumably her return to Earth will be explored there – [=RTD=] did tease it...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mel is confirmed to be returning in [=RTD2=], in Series 14. Presumably her return to Earth will be explored there – [=RTD=] did tease it...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The idea seems to be the Cybermen will have cyberconvert the entire human population back in 1916, then when they've finished making use of Earth's resources the Daleks will finish the job by destroying Earth in 2022.

to:

** The idea seems to be the Cybermen Cyber-Moon will have cyberconvert cyber-convert the entire human population planet back in 1916, then when they've the Cybermen have finished making use of Earth's resources the Daleks will finish the job by destroying Earth in 2022.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The idea seems to be the Cybermen will have cyberconvert the entire human population back in 1916, then when they've finished making use of Earth's resources the Daleks will finish the job by destroying Earth in 2022.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What is the impact on Earth's tectonics of the magma/lava of every volcano being converted into frozen steel?

to:

* What is the impact on Earth's tectonics of the magma/lava of every volcano being converted into frozen steel?steel?
** Presumably it just 'plugged' the erupting magma rather than turning the Earth's core into steel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** That's easy--after escaping he went back in time to when the new UNIT headquarters was being built and put it there as insurance in case the Cybermen betrayed him and never showed up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It honestly wouldn't be out of character for him to set up the entire charade just to be able to pull off that dance number.


Added DiffLines:

** They're British. They're too polite to comment on anything like that. As for the lack of collateral damage, no doubt the self-destruct was precisely calibrated by UNIT.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Cybermen aren't very fond of Earth, so they wouldn't have many qualms with its destruction. Presumably the plan is for the Daleks to destroy Earth ''after'' the Cybermen have converted everyone/as many people as possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The fact that the Doctor, in their true form, ceases to exist.

Added: 97

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Since we never see her land, it's possible she either landed on something soft enough to cushion her from obvious injury or she landed in a way that prevented her from getting to badly hurt.

to:

** Since we never see her land, it's possible she either landed on something soft enough to cushion her from obvious injury or she landed in a way that prevented her from getting to too badly hurt.hurt.
** The original script had Tegan more seriously injured following the fall (walking with a limp).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since we never see her land, it's possible she either landed on something soft enough to cushion her from obvious injury or she landed in a way that prevented her from getting to badly hurt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The baseball bat appears to have only broken off the Dalek's eye stalk, unlike the total destruction of the Dalek's casing with a hit of the Hand-of-Omega-powered baseball bat in ''Remembrance of the Daleks''. The Dalek was finally done in with the explosive Nitro-999.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Intriguingly, the original script clearly establishes that the Master ''is'' the historical Rasputin, by having a scene in which Prince Yusupov dumps the Master, aka Rasputin, into a sack which is then thrown into a river. With this scene not making it to the final episode, it is now more ambiguous as to whether the Master is Rasputin or is simply masquerading as him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Probably dealing the Doctor a blow by using up one regeneration in the Doctor's new regeneration cycle? "But Timeless Child!", you might be saying - there's no evidence that the Doctor from Hartnell-Smith had the Timeless Child's regeneration capacities (they wouldn't have - after all, there's the fob watch at the end of ''The Vanquishers'') or that the Time Lords who granted an extra regeneration cycle to Smith knew about (the Doctor being) the Timeless Child.


Added DiffLines:

** Presumably the Doctor picked her up and dropped her on Earth off-screen.
** In the Classic Series Season 26 collection announcement minisode '24 Karot', Langford reprises her role as Mel, revealing the character now heads up an interstellar recruitment drive for potential investments. At the end of the minisode, she is reunited with the Seventh Doctor and once again becomes his companion, heading out into the galaxy aboard the TARDIS. It's entirely possible she is dropped back on Earth at the close of these unseen new adventures. However, like all expanded Who media, the canonicity of this minisode is debatable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Click [[Headscratchers/DoctorWho here]] to go back to the main page.

'''Warning! Spoilers on Headscratchers page are unmarked.'''

* Why is the Master posing as Rasputin? Is it just to get the palace as the base of his operations? And why is he in 1916 of all times?
* Ace had her jacket placed in the secret floor compartment with weapons, right where she'd need it? Why?
* How did Tegan survive the fall?
* Why did the Master clone Ashad rather than just have a normal cyber leader? It seems like it was just done for the trailer.
** Probably because Cyberleaders are boring. Ashad, in contrast, has enough of a personality for the Master to get a kick out of being his abusive boss.
* The Master's TCE/teleport was in the cell with him the whole time? Why was it there rather than with Ashad to give it to him and how was it put there?
* What is the difference between the Master regenerating into the Doctor's body and the Master cosplaying as the Doctor? He goes to such a lot of effort to achieve the same effect as simply dressing up as her.
* Why should anyone believe that some random man doing bad things is the Doctor? They are well known for doing good deeds and anyone seeing the footage is going to doubt it. The Master gives them to believe that he is anything more than someone out to tarnish the Doctor's name--which he is!
* The new UNIT headquarters, a stone skyscraper in the middle of London, is destroyed and not only is there very little damage or dust cloud of collateral damage but no one seems to bat an eyelid at it.
* Why is Mel on Earth when she was last seen in deep space, time period unspecified, with Glitz?
* How does Ace manage to beat up a Dalek with an ordinary baseball bat? The baseball bat was only effective in ''Remembrance of the Daleks'' because it had been powered by the Hand of Omega, an extraordinary piece of Gallifreyan technology.
* What's the point of the Daleks and the Cybermen working together? The Cybermen are going to convert everyone on Earth... while the Daleks are going to destroy Earth by setting off every volcano?
* What is the impact on Earth's tectonics of the magma/lava of every volcano being converted into frozen steel?

Top