Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DantesInferno

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why didn't the game have [[Creator/SteveBlum Steve Blum]] as the voice for Lucifer like in the animated movie?
Tabs MOD

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking disambiguation page


* Why the [[JustForPun hell]] is it that you cannot absolve or punish Temptresses, Hoarder/Wasters, Heretics, Pagans or Damned Crusaders in the game? especially since you can still absolve or punish the Gluttons and almost all variations of demons in the game? what sense does that make?

to:

* Why the [[JustForPun hell]] hell is it that you cannot absolve or punish Temptresses, Hoarder/Wasters, Heretics, Pagans or Damned Crusaders in the game? especially since you can still absolve or punish the Gluttons and almost all variations of demons in the game? what sense does that make?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removing sinkhole


** Biblical figures were often seen nude in artwork and Lucifer probably hasn't been able to put on pants since, you know, he's been trapped and probably wouldn't care about being decent anyway. [[TheWikiRule Infernopedia]] [[https://dantesinferno.fandom.com/wiki/Infernopedia notices that]] his huge dong is always flaccid and proposes that that is meant to symbolize Lust.

to:

** Biblical figures were often seen nude in artwork and Lucifer probably hasn't been able to put on pants since, you know, he's been trapped and probably wouldn't care about being decent anyway. [[TheWikiRule Infernopedia]] [[https://dantesinferno.fandom.com/wiki/Infernopedia Infernopedia notices that]] his huge dong is always flaccid and proposes that that is meant to symbolize Lust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why the [[JustForPun hell]] is it that you cannot absolve or punish Temptresses, Hoarder/Wasters, Heretics, Pagans or Damned Crusaders in the game? especially since you can still absolve or punish the Gluttons and almost all variations of demons in the game? what sense does that make?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* It has been said that Dante had committed every one of the sins of the circles of hell, but exactly what did Dante do that would be him committing heresy or greed? he has definitely shown to have committed acts of lust, gluttony, anger, violence, fraud and treachery, but not quite anything to do with greed or heresy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Lucifer's appearance is based on satyrs from Greek mythology. who were quite famous for sporting comically large dongs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Biblical figures were often seen nude in artwork and Lucifer probably hasn't been able to put on pants since, you know, he's been trapped and probably wouldn't care about being decent anyway. [[TheWikiRule Infernopedia]] [[https://dantesinferno.fandom.com/wiki/Infernopedia notices that]] his huge dong is always flaccid and proposes that that is meant to symbolize Lust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why did they make Lucifer be butt naked with a massive weiner just hanging out like a horse? what were the developers thinking?

Added: 181

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding


***Technically, the uncommitted don't even go into Hell, but remain on the shores of Acheron (a.k.a. the vestibule) for eternity, so it's even more appropriate that Pilate be there.



*** Dante is one of the few damned souls suitable to free Lucifer because unlike most, he has commited ''every'' one of the sins of the circles, meaning he has a place in each level of Hell, but he also believed he would be absolved. Attila, Alexander and such could have met the criteria as well, but only Dante had both the badassery and determination to actually ''reach'' Lucifer's prison.

to:

*** Dante is one of the few damned souls suitable to free Lucifer because unlike most, he has commited committed ''every'' one of the sins of the circles, meaning he has a place in each level of Hell, but he also believed he would be absolved. Attila, Alexander and such could have met the criteria as well, but only Dante had both the badassery and determination to actually ''reach'' Lucifer's prison.

Changed: 850

Removed: 433

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** You killed King Minos- the judge of the damned. They never got sentenced because the sentence-giver can't do it anymore, and I doubt Hell has back-up cashiers.
*** Not until you get to him (''after'' you've already absolved, punished, or ignored Pilate and Orpheus), and even then, that only explains why ''new arrivals'' won't be sentenced, not why people dead since the 2nd century at the latest are up there while contemporaries of Dante are down in the circles.
*** In the poem, there are many people who are outside of Hell proper, and Pilate is implied (though not directly stated) to be one of them. These are people who, for all intents and purposes, weren't good enough for Heaven but not bad enough for Hell. This includes angels who didn't join in rebelling with Satan or confirm their allegiance to God but stayed neutral. Their afterlife is to eternally chase a flag but never catch it.

to:

** You killed King Minos- the judge of the damned. They never got sentenced because the sentence-giver can't do it anymore, and I doubt Hell has back-up cashiers.
*** Not until you get to him (''after'' you've already absolved, punished, or ignored Pilate and Orpheus), and even then, that only explains why ''new arrivals'' won't be sentenced, not why people dead since the 2nd century at the latest are up there while contemporaries of Dante are down in the circles.
*** In the poem, there are many people who are outside of
The first level, before Hell proper, is Limbo. Dante describes it as "a place of sighs, not screams". This is where unbaptized infants and noble unbelievers go. Dante placed Orpheus here.
** Also in Limbo are the "uncommitted",
and Pilate is implied (though not directly stated) to be one of them. These are people who, for all intents and purposes, weren't good enough for Heaven but not bad enough for Hell. This includes angels who didn't join in rebelling with Satan or confirm their allegiance to God but stayed neutral. Their afterlife is to eternally chase a flag but never catch it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Who could call her out? The guy trying to save her? The angel? The thing is Beatrice did not have a presence until Purgatory/Paradiso in the original poem where she served as a guide (since Vergil cannot leave Inferno, given that he´s a heretic from the Age of Gods), so she was the obvious weakpoint of the plot.

to:

** Who could call her out? The guy trying to save her? The angel? The thing is Beatrice did not have a presence until Purgatory/Paradiso Paradiso in the original poem where she served as a guide (since Vergil (Vergil was granted leave to escort Dante through Purgatario but his place is in Limbo, and he cannot leave Inferno, enter Paradiso, given that he´s a heretic pagan from the Age of Gods), so she was the obvious weakpoint of the plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Discussion

Added DiffLines:

** To be fair, this is actually in line with contemporary portrayals of Lucifer at the time. The devil was often portrayed as incompetent and only truly evil or foolish mortals would fall for his schemes. Beatrice was just that desperate for Dante’s safety.


Added DiffLines:

** Entering a bit of WMG territory here, but perhaps Lucifer’s formerly human subordinates had the sheer will to refuse to be part of the rest of the rabble of tormented souls. So, at some point, Marc Antony and Cleopatra died, but rather than become part of the scenery in torture, their combined Lust enabled them to exert power in their Circle of Hell. They’re still being tortured, of course, but they’re capable of moving around Hell and interact with others, so it’s a step up.


Added DiffLines:

** Perhaps it’s part of a bigger plan by God. Gabriel implies that Dante’s journey through Hell was part of a design; that God is moving pieces into play for an end that Dante himself can’t see. Hence, while Lucifer is trying to lure souls down to Hell to free him, Lancelot, Atilla, or Lucifer’s demons would get struck down by Angels if they actually made progress. Dante was permitted to break the chains, because it was part of God’s plan for Dante to do so. Presumably, the sequel would see further development of that plan.

Changed: 161

Removed: 260

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lucifer. Just Lucifer. How is he supposed to be manipulative if he is a raving lunatic that looks ObviouslyEvil? Are people in that universe so stupid that they fall for every demon stereotype every conceived?
** Why should a 14th century KnightTemplar be GenreSavvy? There´s no way he would know.
*** You mean to tell me a person whose entire "career" is based on purging the church's enemies wouldn't recognise someone who looked like every demon stereotype as a demon?

to:

* Lucifer. Just Lucifer. How is he supposed to be manipulative if he is a raving lunatic that looks ObviouslyEvil? Are people in that universe so stupid that they fall for every demon stereotype every conceived?
** Why should a 14th century KnightTemplar be GenreSavvy? There´s no way he would know.
***
You mean to tell me a person whose entire "career" is based on purging the church's enemies wouldn't recognise someone who looked like every demon stereotype as a demon?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**By God's Authority, of course.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Or Lucifer might be messing with you.

to:

Or **Or Lucifer might be messing with you.

Top