History Headscratchers / AmericanHorrorStory

* What happened to the exterminator who [[spoiler: found Violet's corpse?]]

* In the second episode, Constance says she had four children. We see Adelaide, [[spoiler: Tate]], and [[spoiler: Beau]], so what happened to the fourth?

*** Tate ''hasn't'' been dead for over two decades. Tate died in 1994 which would make him dead seventeen years in 2011 and he was about seventeen at the time of his death. Presumably either Constance was exaggerating since he was dead around the same amount of time or he's been dead for a few days/weeks/months longer than he lived. And Adelaide was a child in 1978 so of course she'd be around when Tate was older.

*** Tate hasn't been dead for over two decades. Tate died in 1994 which would make him dead seventeen years in 2011 and he was seventeen at the time of his death. Presumably either Constance was exaggerating since he was dead around the same amount of time or he's been dead for a few days/weeks/months longer than he lived. And Adelaide was a child in 1978 so of course she'd be around when Tate was older.

* How is it possible that Constance has a photograph of Tate and Addie together. Judging from when Addie was a little girl she should not have been old enough to appear as an adult in a photo together with Tate, because Tate has been dead for over two decades (in Re-birth) Constance says Tate has been in his grave for longer than he was alive. He died in high school so how is it possible that the picture even exists. Unless ghosts can be photographed...
** Addie was older than she looked. We saw for sure that she and Tate were alive together during the flashback to him burning Larry.

* How is it possible that Constance has a photograph of Tate and Addie together. Judging from when Addie was a little girl she should not have been old enough to appear as an adult in a photo together with Tate, because Tate has been dead for over two decades (in Re-birth) Constance says Tate has been in his grave for longer than he was alive. He died in high school so how is it possible that the picture even exists. Unless ghosts can be photographed...

** The nurses seem too intent on being scary to converse or make friends. A lot of ghost seem to have snapped or remain on loop in the house, kind of like how Nora keeps going back and forth from being sane(ish) and weeping over the loss of her child.

* So I understand why Chad and Patrick and Nora and Charles and the twins and Larry's wife weren't invited to Christmas, but the dead nurses don't get to join the festivities?

** Considering Constance came to California to be a starlet, she probably threw on a different accent to fool him.

**** Hayden wasn't lying. The dog is alive and well in "Afterbirth" and has been adopted by Marcy.

* In the second episode, Home Invasion, Ben calls Mrs Langdon to tell her he can't treat Tate anymore. Who was he actually calling? Was he speaking to Constance, and if so, why didn't he recognise her voice? Did Constance get someone else to speak on the phone like Billie Dean? Just who was he talking to?

** Since seeing her running around on Halloween, he now thinks that Hayden and Larry faked the whole thing.

* I feel like I missed something...Ben knows that [[spoiler: Hayden was murdered, he buried her under the gazeebo.]] Why is he OK with her coming back like nothing happened? He does not know about the ghosts yet...

* I feel like I missed something...Ben knows that Hayden was murdered, he buried her under the gazeebo. Why is he OK with her coming back like nothing happened? He does not know about the ghosts yet...

** She didn't want to be a ghost, either.

** No. Constance failed to get her to the house grounds on time.

* [[spoiler: Shouldn't Addie be a ghost?]]

* [[spoiler: Shouldn't Addie have a ghost?]]

*** Problem with that is that [[spoiler: Tate does know he's dead]], yet he can still change his clothes.

** I think it depends on if the ghost knows he/she is dead. [[spoiler: Tate can change since he doesn't know he's dead and would be in different outfits each theorpy session.]] While Gladys knows she's dead therefore is always in what she died in.