Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / MyLittlePonyFiendshipIsMagic

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given that Sombra's story involve him rejecting LoveRedeems, it's easy to see why Cadance (the Princess of Love), would fail to find sympathy for him in spite of his tragic backstory.

to:

* Given that Sombra's story involve involved him rejecting LoveRedeems, it's easy to see why Cadance (the Princess of Love), would fail to find sympathy for him in spite of his tragic backstory.



* That said, if the origin isn't made up, then it means that Changelings are effectively a replacement for Windigos; otherworldly {{Emotion Eater}}s who prey on ponies for their emotional nature. However, whereas Windigos feed on ThePowerOfHate and are killed by ThePowerOfLove, Changelings feed on love itself.

to:

* ** That said, if the origin isn't made up, then it means that Changelings are effectively a replacement for Windigos; otherworldly {{Emotion Eater}}s who prey on ponies for their emotional nature. However, whereas Windigos feed on ThePowerOfHate and are killed by ThePowerOfLove, Changelings feed on love itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Umbrum wants to be released, so it created Sombra to do so. What's to say that it's the only time it created a foal for this plan? Remember, Sombra was found in the snow as a foal, instead of dying from exposure to the cold. Perhaps Sombra wasn't the first, but rather, the first to survive and be adopted into the Crystal Empire.

Added: 264

Changed: 127

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This also explains why the otherwise perfect Mirror!Sombra would allow for their relationship despite the danger it put their worlds in. [[NotSoAboveItAll He was in an equally distraught frame of mind,]] [[StepfordSmiler but hid it better]].

to:

** This also explains why the otherwise perfect Mirror!Sombra Mirror Sombra would allow for their relationship despite the danger it put their worlds in. [[NotSoAboveItAll He was in an equally distraught frame of mind,]] [[StepfordSmiler but hid it better]].



* Princess Amore is allegedly not dead, despite being [[TakenForGranite petrified]] [[LiterallyShatteredLives and shattered to pieces]]. Discord was shown to [[AndIMustScream be conscious during his petrification]], [[AFateWorseThanDeath if Amore is likewise...]]



*** Plus, the tree itself. Where did it come from? Is it related to the Tree of Harmony?

to:

*** Plus, would that imply her good MirrorUniverse selfs origins involve the tree itself. Where did it come from? Is it related to the Tree of Harmony?same but with '''living ponies'''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Even worse if you recall he already had RealityWarper traits (making a whole kingdom vanish for 1,000 years, making {{Pocket Dimension}}s of stairs and traps, etc.). And even ''worse'': [[spoiler:his horn survived and holds his spirit, meaning he may still get to fully use his new power someday.]]

to:

*** Even worse if you recall he already had RealityWarper traits (making a whole kingdom vanish for 1,000 years, making {{Pocket Dimension}}s of stairs and traps, etc.). And even ''worse'': [[spoiler:his horn survived and holds has his spirit, meaning he may still get to fully use his new power someday.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Given how soundly Celestia bested the changelings last time, there is a list of highly possible reasons why she was caught off guard. 1), she might not have known they had escaped their [[SealedEvilInACan imprisonment]] (they would have had good reason to keep a low profile afterward). 2). she didn't think they would [[NeverRecycleYourSchemes reuse there previous, failed, invasion plan]], And 3), she figured she could defeat them easily enough if they did show up.


to:

** Given how soundly Celestia bested the changelings last time, there is a list of highly possible reasons why she was caught off guard. 1), she might not have known they had escaped their [[SealedEvilInACan imprisonment]] (they would have had good reason to keep a low profile afterward). 2). she didn't think they would [[NeverRecycleYourSchemes reuse there their previous, failed, invasion plan]], And 3), she figured she could defeat them easily enough if they did show up.

Added: 278

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The PowerOfLove was Nightmare Moons undoing in her issue. This was also her undoing when she returned in the main comics "Nightmare Arc", where she [[DangerouslyGenreSavvy went to a lot of effort]] to prevent it from being used against her, she's realized the threat it poses.



** Now we know what could have happened to Rainbow Dash if she agreed to her temptation with the the Shadowbolts, [[AndIMustScream not present]].
** This also explains why Luna never revealed their existence or tried to confront them prior to the "Nightmare Arc" in the mane comic series. AND makes their attempts to break her by claiming this was all her fault a lot more powerful, given how much truth is shown to be behind those accusations. Small wonder Luna spent most of the story distraught, and would have succumbed to their {{Breaking Lecture}}s if not for [[YouAreNotAlone others standing up to help her]].

to:

** Now we know what could have happened to Rainbow Dash if she agreed to her temptation with the the Shadowbolts, [[AndIMustScream not present]].
pleasant]].
** This also explains why Luna never revealed their existence or tried to confront them prior to the "Nightmare Arc" in the mane main comic series. AND makes their attempts to break her by claiming this was all her fault a lot more powerful, given how much truth is shown to be behind those accusations. Small wonder Luna spent most of the story distraught, and would have succumbed to their {{Breaking Lecture}}s if not for [[YouAreNotAlone others standing up to help her]].

Added: 309

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Nightmare Moons accessing dreams would explain how [[VillainsBlendInBetter she seemed more up to date culturally then Luna]]. It also shows why Celestia used [[TricksterMentor such discreet methods to prepare for her return]]. If Twilight Sparkle or anyone else knew of the plan, Nightmare Moon would know of it through them, and be more direct in dealing with the Mane 6, perhaps using her [[DreamWeaver powers]] to preemptively [[MindRape break, corrupt, and/or demoralize them]].

to:

* Nightmare Moons accessing dreams would explain how [[VillainsBlendInBetter she seemed more up to date up-to-date culturally then Luna]]. It also shows why Celestia used [[TricksterMentor such discreet methods to prepare for her return]]. If Twilight Sparkle or anyone else knew of the plan, Nightmare Moon would know of it through them, and be more direct in dealing with the Mane 6, perhaps using her [[DreamWeaver powers]] to preemptively [[MindRape break, corrupt, and/or demoralize them]].


Added DiffLines:

* Not only did Chrysalis successfully manipulate and best Twilight Sparkle, but she ''avoided'' the [[VillainBall needless cruelty to Twilight that led to her undoing]] the last two times. Not only is she free, she's learned from her mistakes, [[DangerouslyGenreSavvy and is that much more dangerous for it]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The above seem uncharacteristically vicious of Celestia? The first time she was seen in her fiery SuperMode was confronting her evil MirrorUniverse self (she establish that any injuries [[{{Synchronization}} one sustained would effect the other]]), ''[[RageBreakingPoint when she became so enraged that she stopped caring]] [[TakingYouWithMe that it would kill them both.]]'' What had happened [[OOCIsSeriousBusiness to put Celestia in that mindset]]? Did she regret it such that she held it back during her rematch with Chrysalis?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chrysalis' invasion of Trot would explain the seemingly [[IdiotBall less-then-intellegent]] actions she and Celestia made during "A Canterlot Wedding":

to:

* Chrysalis' invasion of Trot would could explain the seemingly [[IdiotBall less-then-intellegent]] actions she and Celestia made during "A Canterlot Wedding":



** Given how soundly Celestia bested the changelings last time, there is a list of reasons why she was caught off guard. 1), she didn't know they had escaped their [[SealedEvilInACan imprisonment]] (they would have had good reason to keep a low profile afterward). 2). she didn't think they would [[NeverRecycleYourSchemes reuse there previous, failed, invasion plan]], And 3), she figured she could defeat them easily enough if they did show up.


to:

** Given how soundly Celestia bested the changelings last time, there is a list of highly possible reasons why she was caught off guard. 1), she didn't know might not have known they had escaped their [[SealedEvilInACan imprisonment]] (they would have had good reason to keep a low profile afterward). 2). she didn't think they would [[NeverRecycleYourSchemes reuse there previous, failed, invasion plan]], And 3), she figured she could defeat them easily enough if they did show up.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Even more unnerving is that, assuming that changelings are not TheAgeless and generations of them has passed since their first emerged form the ooze (as evidence by the Changeling in Trot who believed Chrysalis' crown was an antenna), it could be assumed these holes have now been passed down to their children, becoming some sort of genetic trait amongst their kind!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This also explains why Luna never revealed their existence or tried to confront them prior to the "Nightmare Arc" in the mane comic series. AND makes their attempts to break her by claiming this was all her fault a lot more powerful, given how much truth is shown to be behind those accusation. Small wonder Luna spent most of the story distraught, and would have succumbed to their {{Breaking Lecture}}s if not for others standing up to help her.

to:

** This also explains why Luna never revealed their existence or tried to confront them prior to the "Nightmare Arc" in the mane comic series. AND makes their attempts to break her by claiming this was all her fault a lot more powerful, given how much truth is shown to be behind those accusation. accusations. Small wonder Luna spent most of the story distraught, and would have succumbed to their {{Breaking Lecture}}s if not for [[YouAreNotAlone others standing up to help her.her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Now we know what could have happened to Rainbow Dash if she agreed to her temptation with the the Shadowbolts, [[AndIMustScream not present]].
** This also explains why Luna never revealed their existence or tried to confront them prior to the "Nightmare Arc" in the mane comic series. AND makes their attempts to break her by claiming this was all her fault a lot more powerful, given how much truth is shown to be behind those accusation. Small wonder Luna spent most of the story distraught, and would have succumbed to their {{Breaking Lecture}}s if not for others standing up to help her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Nightmare Moons accessing dreams would explain how [[VillainsBlendInBetter she seemed more up to date culturally then Luna]]. It also shows why Celestia used [[TricksterMentor such discreet methods to prepare for her return]]. If Twilight Sparkle or anyone else knew of the plan, Nightmare Moon would know of it through them, and be more direct in dealing with the Mane 6, perhaps using her [[DreamWeaver powers]] to preemptively [[MindRape break, corrupt, and/or demoralize them]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chrysalis draining Incitatus' [[{{Narcissist}} so called love]] did not give her the power boost to stand up to Celestia like Shining Armors real love did, showing why someone who consumed ThePowerOfLove would underestimate it both as a power-up and a threat.


to:

** Chrysalis draining Incitatus' [[{{Narcissist}} so called love]] did not give her the power boost to stand up to Celestia like Shining Armors real love did, showing why someone who consumed ThePowerOfLove would underestimate it both as a power-up and a threat.

threat. That her identical invasion plan failed prior, to her frustration, shows why she was [[KickTheDog excessively cruel]] in dealing with Twilight Sparkle [[SpannerInTheWorks when she threatened it]], or have the experience to realize [[NiceJobFixingItVillain how it could backfire]].
** Given how soundly Celestia bested the changelings last time, there is a list of reasons why she was caught off guard. 1), she didn't know they had escaped their [[SealedEvilInACan imprisonment]] (they would have had good reason to keep a low profile afterward). 2). she didn't think they would [[NeverRecycleYourSchemes reuse there previous, failed, invasion plan]], And 3), she figured she could defeat them easily enough if they did show up.

Added: 263

Changed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Chrysalis' invasion of Trot would explain the seemingly [[IdiotBall less-then-intellegent]] actions she and Celestia made during "A Canterlot Wedding":
** Chrysalis draining Incitatus' [[{{Narcissist}} so called love]] did not give her the power boost to stand up to Celestia like Shining Armors real love did, showing why someone who consumed ThePowerOfLove would underestimate it both as a power-up and a threat.

Added: 437

Changed: 183

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Discord is implied to be native to Tireks homeland - he was part of his father's court. Like them, he's a MixAndMatchCritter, [[UpToEleven only more so]].
* Further explaining why Discord was sent to deal with Tirek at first, he's known Tirek since he was at least an angsty centaur teen, and had the best understanding of how his powers worked. This also explains how Tirek knew Discord well enough to [[ManipulativeBastard play him]].



* Now we know why Discord was sent to deal with Tirek at first - he was part of his father's court. He's literally known Tirek since he was a kid (or at least an angsty centaur teen).

to:

* Now we know why Discord was sent to deal with Tirek at first - he was part of his father's court. He's literally known Tirek since he was a kid (or at least an angsty centaur teen).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chrysalis orders her changelings to hibernate, so they aren't "wasting energy". This isn't just Chrysalis demonstrating that EvenEvilHasLovedOnes, it's ''also'' step one in her [[MagnificentBitch escape plan]]: instead of thousands of prisoners just barely scraping by with carefully doled-out rations, we have a single prisoner gorging herself on as much food as she wants (with more than enough left over to convince the guards she's on a hunger strike), while her troops remain at nearly full strength. Cue Twilight bumbling into a locked cell with a full-power, ''very'' unhinged Chrysalis, and cue Twilight getting [[CurbStompBattle curb-stomped]] in a matter of seconds.

to:

* Chrysalis orders her changelings to hibernate, so they aren't "wasting energy". This isn't just Chrysalis demonstrating that EvenEvilHasLovedOnes, While a case of EvenEvilHasLovedOnes on Chrysalis' part for her subjects can be argued, it's ''also'' step one in her [[MagnificentBitch escape plan]]: instead of thousands of prisoners just barely scraping by with carefully doled-out rations, we have a single prisoner gorging herself on as much food as she wants (with more than enough left over to convince the guards she's on a hunger strike), while her troops remain at nearly full strength. Cue Twilight bumbling into a locked cell with a full-power, ''very'' unhinged Chrysalis, and cue Twilight getting [[CurbStompBattle curb-stomped]] in a matter of seconds.



* Now we know why Discord was sent to deal with Tirek at first - he was part of his father's court. He's literally know Tirek since he was a kid (or at least an angsty centaur teen).

to:

* Now we know why Discord was sent to deal with Tirek at first - he was part of his father's court. He's literally know known Tirek since he was a kid (or at least an angsty centaur teen).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Now we know why Discord was sent to deal with Tirek at first - he was part of his father's court. He's literally know Tirek since he was a kid (or at least an angsty centaur teen).

Changed: 535

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In considering the two known previously plans Chrysalis had for establishing a source of nourishment for her and the changelings (via Tibucktu, and via Trot), this possibly retroactively makes her line "This day is going to be just perfect" from "This Day Aria" in "A Canterlot Wedding" more poignant: there were lessons learned from those plans so that her takeover of Canterlot would go without any flaws (outside of her ability to convince Twilight she was the real Cadance, and even then she dealt with that problem effectively).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chrysalis orders her changelings to hibernate, so they aren't "wasting energy". This isn't just Chrysalis demonstrating that EvenEvilHasLovedOnes, it's ''also'' step one in her [[MagnificentBitch escape plan]]: instead of thousands of prisoners just barely scraping by with carefully doled-out rations, we have a single prisoner gorging herself on as much food as she wants, while her troops remain at nearly full strength. Cue Twilight bumbling into a locked cell with a full-power, ''very'' unhinged Chrysalis, and cue Twilight getting [[CurbStompBattle curb-stomped]] in a matter of seconds.

to:

* Chrysalis orders her changelings to hibernate, so they aren't "wasting energy". This isn't just Chrysalis demonstrating that EvenEvilHasLovedOnes, it's ''also'' step one in her [[MagnificentBitch escape plan]]: instead of thousands of prisoners just barely scraping by with carefully doled-out rations, we have a single prisoner gorging herself on as much food as she wants, wants (with more than enough left over to convince the guards she's on a hunger strike), while her troops remain at nearly full strength. Cue Twilight bumbling into a locked cell with a full-power, ''very'' unhinged Chrysalis, and cue Twilight getting [[CurbStompBattle curb-stomped]] in a matter of seconds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Chrysalis orders her changelings to hibernate, so they aren't "wasting energy". This isn't just Chrysalis demonstrating that EvenEvilHasLovedOnes, it's ''also'' step one in her [[MagnificentBitch escape plan]]: instead of thousands of prisoners just barely scraping by with carefully doled-out rations, we have a single prisoner gorging herself on as much food as she wants, while her troops remain at nearly full strength. Cue Twilight bumbling into a locked cell with a full-power, ''very'' unhinged Chrysalis, and cue Twilight getting [[CurbStompBattle curb-stomped]] in a matter of seconds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chrysalis' story makes her VillainousBreakdown when Twilight defeated her (and likely ALSO why she seems to hate Twilight's ascension so much) in the Return of Queen Chrysalis make more sense: the only ponies who have ever actually defeated Chrysalis in her entire life that we know of (Celestia and a Cadence empowered Shining Armor) were both Alicorns. Chrysalis couldn't comprehend the idea of a mere mortal pony actually defeating her, and now Twilight's an ''Alicorn''. Of course Chrysalis wouldn't take either well.

to:

* Chrysalis' story makes her VillainousBreakdown when Twilight defeated her (and likely ALSO why she seems to hate Twilight's ascension so much) in the Return of Queen Chrysalis make more sense: the only ponies who have ever actually defeated Chrysalis in her entire life that we know of (Celestia and a Cadence empowered with help from Shining Armor) were both Alicorns. Chrysalis couldn't comprehend the idea of a mere mortal pony actually defeating her, and now Twilight's an ''Alicorn''. Of course Chrysalis wouldn't take either well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Chrysalis' story makes her VillainousBreakdown when Twilight defeated her (and likely ALSO why she seems to hate Twilight's ascension so much) in the Return of Queen Chrysalis make more sense: the only ponies who have ever actually defeated Chrysalis in her entire life that we know of (Celestia and a Cadence empowered Shining Armor) were both Alicorns. Chrysalis couldn't comprehend the idea of a mere mortal pony actually defeating her, and now Twilight's an ''Alicorn''. Of course Chrysalis wouldn't take either well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* If the origin story is true, who is to say just how many changelings first spawned from their primordial ooze? Thousands, millions maybe? How much have their numbers grown through breeding? Who's to say they have not splintered and there are other kingdoms/colonies out there in the world?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* That said, if the origin isn't made up, then it means that Changelings are effectively a replacement for Windigos; otherworldly {{Emotion Eater}}s who prey on ponies for their emotional nature. However, whereas Windigos feed on ThePowerOfHate and are killed by ThePowerOfLove, Changelings feed on love itself.

Added: 418

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Secondary to the above, if the sirens had died, would Sunset Shimmer continue to be poorly treated by everyone at Canterlot High, including her friends? Remember, Rainbow Rocks was also about the Redemption of Sunset Shimmer as a character.

to:

* ** Secondary to the above, if the sirens had died, would Sunset Shimmer continue to be poorly treated by everyone at Canterlot High, including her friends? Remember, Rainbow Rocks was also about the Redemption of Sunset Shimmer as a character.


Added DiffLines:

*** Plus, the tree itself. Where did it come from? Is it related to the Tree of Harmony?


Added DiffLines:

* Chrysalis had a changeling morph into her likeness as part of her plan to escape. What's stopping her from doing it again? If they run into Chrysalis again, how can they be sure it's really her and not another imposter? Plus, what's stopping Chrysalis from escaping by impersonating a regular changeling and being BeneathNotice?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This ''also'' means that despite capturing an entire army, Celestia was ''holding back'' to not try and kill anyone. What would Celestia capable of if she ''was''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The original Chrysalis gave for herself and the changeling is possibly made-up. There's no way she could know they were birthed from a nut that fell into a swamp, unless one insists the nut was somehow sapient and she inherited its consciousness, which is silly for obvious reasons. Moreover, she tells Twilight this story after Twilight began to get excited about Chrysalis perhaps having a chance for redemption after all and feeling guilty for her current state; Chrysalis lying to Twilight about her origins to claim she's MadeOfEvil could just be her mocking Twilight's feelings to rub salt in the wound.

to:

* Chrysalis cringing when Celestia fired her beam at her in "A Canterlot Wedding" makes a lot more sense now that we know that the holes in the Changelings' bodies are the result of a past attack by Celestia.
* The original origin Chrysalis gave for herself and the changeling is possibly made-up. There's no way she could know they were birthed from a nut that fell into a swamp, unless one insists the nut was somehow sapient and she inherited its consciousness, which is silly for obvious reasons. Moreover, she tells Twilight this story after Twilight began to get excited about Chrysalis perhaps having a chance for redemption after all and feeling guilty for her current state; Chrysalis lying to Twilight about her origins to claim she's MadeOfEvil could just be her mocking Twilight's feelings to rub salt in the wound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The changelings have ragged wings and holes in their legs, but not torsos or heads. That means, whatever Celestia unleashed against them was not a random, magical "grapeshot", but something that could be aimed - Celestia captured an entire army by methodically kneecapping every single enemy soldier.

Top