Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets

Go To

OR

Tabs MOD

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking disambiguation page


* The throwaway mention of Flitwick having been a duelling champion in his youth makes a lot of sense when you look at him or read a description of him. He probably fought with Charms, repurposed non-combat magic you wouldn't normally think would be used for duels. Not to mention, an effect of his goblin ancestry is that he's just ''three feet tall''. Of ''course'' most adult wizards would have trouble beating him in a duel. As a highly intelligent Charms user, he probably thought outside the box in ways that most would-be duellists wouldn't see coming. But more importantly, his low profile probably made him ''much'' harder even to hit with a spell. In [[JustForPun short]], he's a master of the wizarding equivalent of ConfusionFu.

to:

* The throwaway mention of Flitwick having been a duelling champion in his youth makes a lot of sense when you look at him or read a description of him. He probably fought with Charms, repurposed non-combat magic you wouldn't normally think would be used for duels. Not to mention, an effect of his goblin ancestry is that he's just ''three feet tall''. Of ''course'' most adult wizards would have trouble beating him in a duel. As a highly intelligent Charms user, he probably thought outside the box in ways that most would-be duellists wouldn't see coming. But more importantly, his low profile probably made him ''much'' harder even to hit with a spell. In [[JustForPun short]], short, he's a master of the wizarding equivalent of ConfusionFu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Nevermind that incident just a year earlier with Hermione nearly getting killed in one of the bathrooms by the troll let loose by Quirell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Harry sees Floo Powder for the first time, he's freaked out by it. Understandable given that it is fire that apparently consumes someone to ashes in seconds, but the real kicker? It is ''green'', and what is Harry's earliest memory? Seeing his mother die from the Killing Curse, which takes the form of a ''brilliant green light''.

to:

* When Harry sees Floo Powder for the first time, he's freaked out by it. Understandable given that it is fire that apparently consumes seems to turn someone to ashes in seconds, but the real kicker? It is ''green'', and what is Harry's earliest memory? Seeing his mother die from the Killing Curse, which takes the form of a ''brilliant green light''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Moreover, the reason Hermione got petrified rather than dying after figuring it out was that she bumped into Penelope Clearwater specifically. The mirror found with both girls is a small one-- probably used for touching up make-up. Hermione is twelve and unconcerned with her appearance, while Penelope is sixteen with a secret boyfriend she's been having snogging sessions with. It's far more likely her mirror, used to look nice for her boyfriend and then fix her lipstick afterwards. And why did Penelope listen when a second year came up to her in a panic, asking for a mirror to check corners with? Because said boyfriend is Percy. She's heard of how clever his brothers friend is and how obsessed with the petrifications they are. Thus, instead of blowing her off, Penelope figures Hermione has a good chance of being right, pulls out her compact, checks the corner with Hermione leaning in to see-- and they both get petrified rather than turning the corner blindly and walking straight into the basilik's undiluted vision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Accidental double post


* Of course spiders would flee before a basilisk. They see in all directions and can't close their eyes, so something that kills via eye contact would be particularly dangerous to them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Riddle engages in BondVillainStupidity when Harry enters the Chamber. He lets Harry think they're on the same side, confiscates his wand, and reveals that he is the real Heir of Slytherin. We find out that it's not because he's mentally a sixteen-year old on his way to advocating for genocide; it's that Voldemort simply likes to monologue and gloat. He's always been arrogant and smug that he couldn't get caught. Voldemort didn't learn from his mistakes in book two because this Tom Riddle was essentially a clone of him, created from the diary.   Not only that, but it's a copy of him as a teenager, rather than a fully-grown adult who might be expected to know better.

to:

* Riddle engages in BondVillainStupidity when Harry enters the Chamber. He lets Harry think they're on the same side, confiscates his wand, and reveals that he is the real Heir of Slytherin. We find out that it's not because he's mentally a sixteen-year old on his way to advocating for genocide; it's that Voldemort simply likes to monologue and gloat. He's always been arrogant and smug that he couldn't get caught. Voldemort didn't learn from his mistakes in book two because this Tom Riddle was essentially a clone of him, created from the diary.   Not only that, but it's a copy of him as a teenager, rather than a fully-grown adult who might be expected to know better.




to:

* Of course spiders would flee before a basilisk. They see in all directions and can't close their eyes, so something that kills via eye contact would be particularly dangerous to them.



** Fortunately a bit of Brillians kicks in if you think about it. The Mandrakes aren't actually possessed of human like intelligence, they're simply mimicks that put on a facade of humanity to get humans guard down. And then the horror comes back around with the reality that this is so they can kill humans who will then fertilize the ground.

to:

** Fortunately a bit of Brillians kicks in if you think about it. The Mandrakes aren't actually possessed of human like intelligence, they're simply mimicks that put on a facade of humanity to get humans humans' guard down. And then the horror comes back around with the reality that this is so they can kill humans who will then fertilize the ground.

Added: 108

Changed: 402

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** No doubt he also wants to make himself look better by acting as if he'd suspected the culprit all along.



* The real reason Hermione is so annoyed with Harry and Ron for flying the car to Hogwarts? She is not known to have other friends at this point and may have had to be on her own the whole train ride.

to:

* The real reason Hermione is so annoyed with Harry and Ron for flying the car to Hogwarts? She is not known to have other friends at this point and may have had to be on her own the whole train ride. This would be especially prominent given that she'd just made friends very recently after, it's implied, a childhood being alone as well.



** A Ford Anglia has no electronics.

to:

** A Ford Anglia has no electronics.electronics, but it's possible that it still made the engine go crazy.



** His [[ChickMagnet appeal]] to multiple female demographics. Middle-aged women tend to be most attracted to celebrities who have either [[SilverFox aged very gracefully]] or are still in their prime. Lockhart fits the latter bill. Conversely, teenaged girls' celebrity crushes tend to be a bit older than them, but not too much. Again, Lockhart fits the bill.

to:

** His [[ChickMagnet appeal]] to multiple female demographics. Middle-aged women tend to be most attracted to celebrities who have either [[SilverFox aged very gracefully]] or are still in their prime. Lockhart fits the latter bill. Conversely, teenaged girls' celebrity crushes tend to be a bit older than them, but not too much. Again, Lockhart fits the bill. Furthermore, he's (we're fairly certain) the ''only'' young male Hogwarts professor around, other than Snape. Who, Alan Rickman's compelling performance aside, is definitely not going to attract anyone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If memory serves Professor Lupin mentions in future books that during his childhood the Wolfsbane Potion hadn't yet been invented and thus there was no cure for lycanthropy. It would seem that much like the rabies vaccine for muggles theres a lycanthropy potion brewed from Wolfsbane that, if administered in a timely manner, can cure the condition. Future books also show it being used to nesr perfectly control the psychological symptoms in older cases which are passed the point of curing entirely.

to:

** If memory serves Professor Lupin mentions in future books that during his childhood the Wolfsbane Potion hadn't yet been invented and thus there was no cure for lycanthropy. It would seem that much like the rabies vaccine for muggles theres a lycanthropy potion brewed from Wolfsbane that, if administered in a timely manner, can cure the condition. Future books also show it being used to nesr near perfectly control the psychological symptoms in older cases which are passed the point of curing entirely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Diary!Riddle becomes the dominant soul fragment being in better more complete condition. Then finds and either absorbs or kills/imprisons the older worn out version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If memory serves Professor Lupin mentions in future books that during his childhood the Wolfsbane Potion hadn't yet been invented and thus there was no cure for lycanthropy. It would seem that much like the rabies vaccine for muggles theres a lycanthropy potion brewed from Wolfsbane that, if administered in a timely manner, can cure the condition. Future books also show it being used to nesr perfectly control the psychological symptoms in older cases which are passed the point of curing entirely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Fortunately a bit of Brillians kicks in if you think about it. The Mandrakes aren't actually possessed of human like intelligence, they're simply mimicks that put on a facade of humanity to get humans guard down. And then the horror comes back around with the reality that this is so they can kill humans who will then fertilize the ground.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A less horrifying idea is that it was someone with an Animagus wolf form pretending to be a werewolf.

Top