Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Brazil

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tuttle only bombed the TVs in the first place because he hated Central Services Ducts and their commercials.
* The first time I watched this, having watched both ''TimeBandits'' and ''TheAdventuresOfBaronMunchausen'', I was rather shocked. The ending spirals into insanity as [[spoiler:he's rescued, then watches his idol devoured by the papers blown from the exploding Ministry of Information, running through a madcap city, dealing with his now young, sexy, and uninterested mother, and finally, finally, seeming to find a moment of happiness, escaping with his love interest, inexplicably alive again, into the country... Where it's interrupted by the faces of his interrogator and his former boss suddenly poking onto the screen, saying that he's gone, his mind snapped by the torture.]] I was... frankly quite traumatized, after the somewhat strange, even depressing, but ultimately optimistic endings of Baron Von Munchhausen and TimeBandits... when I realized the truth. The only reason we think of the strange ending as being a fantasy is because the rest of the movie has been predominantly fairly realistic. But there's no reason to believe one world over another. The movie is as we perceive it to be, so if I want a happy ending for this character, escaping from the cruel, industrial hell that he lives in, and being the hero he always wanted to be, that he would've been had he been in the other movies, then why not?--Ajoxer

to:

* Tuttle only bombed the TVs [=TV=]s in the first place because he hated Central Services Ducts and their commercials.
* The first time I watched this, having watched both ''TimeBandits'' ''Film/TimeBandits'' and ''TheAdventuresOfBaronMunchausen'', ''Film/TheAdventuresOfBaronMunchausen'', I was rather shocked. The ending spirals into insanity as [[spoiler:he's rescued, then watches his idol devoured by the papers blown from the exploding Ministry of Information, running through a madcap city, dealing with his now young, sexy, and uninterested mother, and finally, finally, seeming to find a moment of happiness, escaping with his love interest, inexplicably alive again, into the country... Where it's interrupted by the faces of his interrogator and his former boss suddenly poking onto the screen, saying that he's gone, his mind snapped by the torture.]] I was... frankly quite traumatized, after the somewhat strange, even depressing, but ultimately optimistic endings of Baron ''Baron Von Munchhausen Munchhausen'' and TimeBandits...''Film/TimeBandits''... when I realized the truth. The only reason we think of the strange ending as being a fantasy is because the rest of the movie has been predominantly fairly realistic. But there's no reason to believe one world over another. The movie is as we perceive it to be, so if I want a happy ending for this character, escaping from the cruel, industrial hell that he lives in, and being the hero he always wanted to be, that he would've been had he been in the other movies, then why not?--Ajoxer
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tuttle only bombed the tvs in the first place because he hated Central Services Ducts and their commerciaLS

to:

* Tuttle only bombed the tvs TVs in the first place because he hated Central Services Ducts and their commerciaLS commercials.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tuttle only bombed the tv's in the first place because he hated Central Services Ducts

to:

* Tuttle only bombed the tv's tvs in the first place because he hated Central Services Ducts and their commerciaLS
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Tuttle only bombed the tv's in the first place because he hated Central Services Ducts
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The first time I watched this, having watched both ''TimeBandits'' and ''{{The Adventures of Baron von Munchhausen}}'', I was rather shocked. The ending spirals into insanity as [[spoiler:he's rescued, then watches his idol devoured by the papers blown from the exploding Ministry of Information, running through a madcap city, dealing with his now young, sexy, and uninterested mother, and finally, finally, seeming to find a moment of happiness, escaping with his love interest, inexplicably alive again, into the country... Where it's interrupted by the faces of his interrogator and his former boss suddenly poking onto the screen, saying that he's gone, his mind snapped by the torture.]] I was... frankly quite traumatized, after the somewhat strange, even depressing, but ultimately optimistic endings of Baron Von Munchhausen and TimeBandits... when I realized the truth. The only reason we think of the strange ending as being a fantasy is because the rest of the movie has been predominantly fairly realistic. But there's no reason to believe one world over another. The movie is as we perceive it to be, so if I want a happy ending for this character, escaping from the cruel, industrial hell that he lives in, and being the hero he always wanted to be, that he would've been had he been in the other movies, then why not?--Ajoxer

to:

* The first time I watched this, having watched both ''TimeBandits'' and ''{{The Adventures of Baron von Munchhausen}}'', ''TheAdventuresOfBaronMunchausen'', I was rather shocked. The ending spirals into insanity as [[spoiler:he's rescued, then watches his idol devoured by the papers blown from the exploding Ministry of Information, running through a madcap city, dealing with his now young, sexy, and uninterested mother, and finally, finally, seeming to find a moment of happiness, escaping with his love interest, inexplicably alive again, into the country... Where it's interrupted by the faces of his interrogator and his former boss suddenly poking onto the screen, saying that he's gone, his mind snapped by the torture.]] I was... frankly quite traumatized, after the somewhat strange, even depressing, but ultimately optimistic endings of Baron Von Munchhausen and TimeBandits... when I realized the truth. The only reason we think of the strange ending as being a fantasy is because the rest of the movie has been predominantly fairly realistic. But there's no reason to believe one world over another. The movie is as we perceive it to be, so if I want a happy ending for this character, escaping from the cruel, industrial hell that he lives in, and being the hero he always wanted to be, that he would've been had he been in the other movies, then why not?--Ajoxer

Added: 252

Changed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from the YMMV page.



to:

* There's a SWAT team out looking for Jill, even though she's been declared dead; they eventually find and kill her. Sam should've realized that the bureaucracy is so inept and slow that falsifying the death report wouldn't be enough to save her.

!!FridgeHorror:

* Considering that information retrival charges can run you into bankrupcy in this world just imagine how student loans would work (at one point a guard urges Lowry to confess or he will have a good chance of ruining his credit history).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!FridgeBrilliance:



* The aspect of torture is shown as a fact of life in the world of Brazil and serves as part of the film's narrative/plot, ostensibly drawn from Orwell's 1984. Yet when you consider that Brazil was written by Gilliam as a satire and as an attack on bureaucracy in the modern world, it appears to be a brilliant, explicit metaphor: bureaucracy IS torture!!

to:

* The aspect of torture is shown as a fact of life in the world of Brazil and serves as part of the film's narrative/plot, ostensibly drawn from Orwell's 1984. Yet when you consider that Brazil was written by Gilliam as a satire and as an attack on bureaucracy in the modern world, it appears to be a brilliant, explicit metaphor: bureaucracy IS torture!!torture!!

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tuttle's catchphrase, "We're all in this together," is FridgeBrilliance: everyone in the movie, excepting possibly Lowry's mother, is under constant threat by their own dystopia. A MeaningfulBackgroundEvent in the form of a propaganda poster even implies that Tuttle's not the independent entity he claims. [[spoiler: His catchphrase, if not something he picked for irony, is one of the government's official mottoes.]]

to:

* Tuttle's catchphrase, "We're all in this together," is FridgeBrilliance: everyone in the movie, excepting possibly Lowry's mother, is under constant threat by their own dystopia. A MeaningfulBackgroundEvent in the form of a propaganda poster even implies that Tuttle's not the independent entity he claims. [[spoiler: His catchphrase, if not something he picked for irony, is one of the government's official mottoes.]]]]
* The aspect of torture is shown as a fact of life in the world of Brazil and serves as part of the film's narrative/plot, ostensibly drawn from Orwell's 1984. Yet when you consider that Brazil was written by Gilliam as a satire and as an attack on bureaucracy in the modern world, it appears to be a brilliant, explicit metaphor: bureaucracy IS torture!!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I'd say you hit on the actual point: even if it is a fantasy, then the ending is still happy. In his mind, he's free, and with the woman he loves. He doesn't see his prison, and he doesn't feel the torture. If nothing else, he denied them their last victory: they can't have his mind/soul. That belongs to him exclusively, and as long as it belongs to him, he is free.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tuttle's catchphrase, "We're all in this together," is FridgeBrilliance: everyone in the movie, excepting possibly Lowry's mother, is under constant threat by their own dystopia. An MeaningfulBackgroundEvent in the form of a propaganda poster even implies that Tuttle's not the independent entity he claims. [[spoiler: His catchphrase, if not something he picked for irony, is one of the government's official mottoes.]]

to:

* Tuttle's catchphrase, "We're all in this together," is FridgeBrilliance: everyone in the movie, excepting possibly Lowry's mother, is under constant threat by their own dystopia. An A MeaningfulBackgroundEvent in the form of a propaganda poster even implies that Tuttle's not the independent entity he claims. [[spoiler: His catchphrase, if not something he picked for irony, is one of the government's official mottoes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Harry Tuttle's portrayed in dashing, swashbuckling style... but he's clearly an HeroicSociopath, if he exists at all, giggling and killing two mooks by drowning them in their own feces.

to:

* Harry Tuttle's portrayed in dashing, swashbuckling style... but he's clearly an HeroicSociopath, a SociopathicHero, if he exists at all, giggling and killing two mooks by drowning them in their own feces.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When I saw that movie myself, I immediate went into a sort of Fridge Philosophy mode, thinking back and trying to pinpoint the exact moment when [[spoiler: his mind started to go.]] Of course, having watched the movie The Good Night the day before added a whole new level of perspective, since they share a similar theme even though the settings, plots, and characters are completely different. [[spoiler: Well, except that Sam from Brazil and Gary from The Good Night do have the same somewhat pacifistic/ineffectual nature.]]

to:

** When I saw that movie myself, I immediate went into a sort of Fridge Philosophy mode, thinking back and trying to pinpoint the exact moment when [[spoiler: his mind started to go.]] Of course, having watched the movie The ''The Good Night Night'' the day before added a whole new level of perspective, since they share a similar theme even though the settings, plots, and characters are completely different. [[spoiler: Well, except that Sam from Brazil ''Brazil'' and Gary from The ''The Good Night Night'' do have the same somewhat pacifistic/ineffectual nature.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Harry Tuttle's portayed in dashing, swashbuckling style... but he's clearly an HeroicSociopath, if he exists at all, giggling and killing two mooks by drowning them in their own feces.
** [[spoiler: Harry Tuttle's demise]] is also a mind blowing example of FridgeBrilliance; paper attaches to him and as much as he tries to shake them off they just envelop him and eventually consume him; initially I just justified it under the surreal context of [[spoiler: Sam's insanity]] but then it occurred to me that [[spolier: Harry's demise]] matched his plight with the Ministry of Information - the bureaucratic regime that flooded his profession with paperwork such that it confined him and prevented him from being a natural man of action to the point where it destroyed his very being.

to:

* Harry Tuttle's portayed portrayed in dashing, swashbuckling style... but he's clearly an HeroicSociopath, if he exists at all, giggling and killing two mooks by drowning them in their own feces.
** [[spoiler: Harry Tuttle's demise]] is also a mind blowing example of FridgeBrilliance; paper attaches to him and as much as he tries to shake them off they just envelop him and eventually consume him; initially I just justified it under the surreal context of [[spoiler: Sam's insanity]] but then it occurred to me that [[spolier: [[spoiler: Harry's demise]] matched his plight with the Ministry of Information - the bureaucratic regime that flooded his profession with paperwork such that it confined him and prevented him from being a natural man of action to the point where it destroyed his very being.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tuttle's catchphrase, "We're all in this together," is FridgeBrilliance: everyone in the movie, excepting possibly Lowry's mother, is under constant threat by their own dystopia. An ImportantBackgroundEvent in the form of a propaganda poster even implies that Tuttle's not the independent entity he claims. [[spoiler: His catchphrase, if not something he picked for irony, is one of the government's official mottoes.]]

to:

* Tuttle's catchphrase, "We're all in this together," is FridgeBrilliance: everyone in the movie, excepting possibly Lowry's mother, is under constant threat by their own dystopia. An ImportantBackgroundEvent MeaningfulBackgroundEvent in the form of a propaganda poster even implies that Tuttle's not the independent entity he claims. [[spoiler: His catchphrase, if not something he picked for irony, is one of the government's official mottoes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Harry Tuttle's demise is also a mind blowing example of FridgeBrilliance; paper attaches to him and as much as he tries to shake them off they just envelop him and eventually consume him; initially I just justified it under the surreal context of Sam's insanity but then it occurred to me that Harry's demise matched his plight with the Ministry of Information - the bureaucratic regime that flooded his profession with paperwork such that it confined him and prevented him from being a natural man of action to the point where it destroyed his very being.

to:

** [[spoiler: Harry Tuttle's demise demise]] is also a mind blowing example of FridgeBrilliance; paper attaches to him and as much as he tries to shake them off they just envelop him and eventually consume him; initially I just justified it under the surreal context of [[spoiler: Sam's insanity insanity]] but then it occurred to me that [[spolier: Harry's demise demise]] matched his plight with the Ministry of Information - the bureaucratic regime that flooded his profession with paperwork such that it confined him and prevented him from being a natural man of action to the point where it destroyed his very being.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Harry Tuttle's demise is also a mind blowing example of FridgeBrilliance; paper attaches to him and as much as he tries to shake them off they just envelop him and eventually consume him; initially I just justified it under the surreal context of Sam's insanity but then it occurred to me that Harry's demise matched his plight with the Ministry of Information - the bureaucratic regime that flooded his profession with paperwork such that it confined him and prevented him from being a natural man of action to the point where it destroyed his very being.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end, Sam is being shuttled around endlessly to bureaucrats who read to him his long list of crimes. If you pay attention, it's apparent that everything they're charging him with, he's done!

to:

* At the end, Sam is being shuttled around endlessly to bureaucrats who read to him his long list of crimes. If you pay attention, it's apparent that everything they're charging him with, he's done!done!
* Harry Tuttle's portayed in dashing, swashbuckling style... but he's clearly an HeroicSociopath, if he exists at all, giggling and killing two mooks by drowning them in their own feces.
* Tuttle's catchphrase, "We're all in this together," is FridgeBrilliance: everyone in the movie, excepting possibly Lowry's mother, is under constant threat by their own dystopia. An ImportantBackgroundEvent in the form of a propaganda poster even implies that Tuttle's not the independent entity he claims. [[spoiler: His catchphrase, if not something he picked for irony, is one of the government's official mottoes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When we see the young version of Sam's mother in the film's ending, for one brief shot Katherine Helmond is replaced by Kim Greist, who played Sam's dream girl Jill. On first inspection, this seemed like just a bit of directorial wankery. Then I realized the true implication: [[spoiler: From the beginning, Sam's dream girl was his mother. Jill just happened to look like a young version of her.]]

to:

** When we see the young version of Sam's mother in the film's ending, for one brief shot Katherine Helmond is replaced by Kim Greist, who played Sam's dream girl Jill. On first inspection, this seemed like just a bit of directorial wankery. Then I realized the true implication: [[spoiler: From the beginning, Sam's dream girl was his mother. Jill just happened to look like a young version of her.]]]]
* At the end, Sam is being shuttled around endlessly to bureaucrats who read to him his long list of crimes. If you pay attention, it's apparent that everything they're charging him with, he's done!

Top