Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / BabylonFive

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Connected to the previous, Centauri pilots and Londo specifically are noted to be ''complete madmen'' in dangerous situations. Taking turns so violent the pilot blacks out but has an advantagous position when he comes too is apparently standard procedure according to what we hear during a Starfury training exercise. If they already know in advance if they'll die in combat or not, either way they'll naturally act like they have nothing to lose.

Added: 697

Changed: 505

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Londo established early on that many Centauri have prophetic dreams about their fate. When reviewing the career of the Centauri Emperor Turhan - who ends Centauri mistreatment of Narns, kept making peace offerings to them, and allowing the Narns to claim more and more Centauri territory as a means of atonement - it's likely that Turhan saw his death would signal the beginning of another Centauri/Narn War and sought to do whatever he could to prevent it or at least give the Narns a fighting chance.
** Look at how Turhan behaves during his episode: he departs for Babylon 5 acting as though he knew he wasn't coming back; and he keeps asking to see Kosh, because he knew he wouldn't die until he'd actually met a Vorlon (to ask the question "How will it all end?").
** Borders on FridgeHorror because Turhan might have foreseen his departure would mean the death of his closest friend the Prime Minister (whose own prophetic dreams probably told him the same thing).
** And as an example of UnintendedConsequences, Turhan's overtures to the Narns weakened Centauri position among the galactic races and instigated too many court plots and plans for war against Narn the first chance they could get.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added an entry on fridge brilliance regarding the green & purple drazi

Added DiffLines:

* Speking of the Green and Purple Drazi from Geometry of Shadows, on hindsight, the conflict between the two seemed like a foreshadowing of the Shadow war? The Greens are the Vorlons and the Purples the Shadows. Both sides respected the rules of combat, but then the Greens started killing the Purples (the Vorlons started using planet killers in order to "kill" those influenced by the Shadows).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reebo and Zooty



to:

* In ''Day of the Dead'' Londo can't understand how Reebo and Zooty are supposed to be comedic. Meanwhile, humans find the duo uproariously funny. The viewer doesn't get to see much of their routine, but will probably have a hard time "getting it", just like Londo. Now think of this: Humanitys culture hasn't been stagnant for centuries like Centauri culture, it has remained ever-changing (just think of 200 years worth of internet memes). Londo is conservative, so he doesn't understand, while Reebo and Zooty are the hippest beings in space for lightyears. ''Neither Londo nor the viewer understands Reebo and Zootys humor because they are 200 years behind!''

Added: 727

Changed: 431

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* At the beginning of "Atonement", Ivanova is headed to a Drazi festival wearing the Green Leader sash. A few scenes later, we see Ivanova on crutches, clearly the worse for wear. It's more than one Drazi year since "The Geometry of Shadows", but this is likely the direct result of her "solution" in that episode (she had all the green sashes dyed purple), and the "festival" may have been the official ending of the conflict.






* Micheal Garibaldi, the brilliant security chief, failed to realize that forcibly seceding from the Earth Alliance would result in a disruption of his postal service? The same postal service provided by the Earth Alliance? Seems like a bit of an odd blindspot for his deductive skills.

to:

* Micheal Michael Garibaldi, the brilliant security chief, failed to realize that forcibly seceding from the Earth Alliance would result in a disruption of his postal service? The same postal service provided by the Earth Alliance? Seems like a bit of an odd blindspot for his deductive skills.



* In "Legacies" the command staff is rattled by a Minbari ship approaching with open gun ports until Delenn explains the gesture. So after a misinterpretation of the gun ports open approach caused the Earth/Minbari War - ten years later the fact that the warrior caste does this has STILL not been explained to the humans?

to:

* In "Legacies" the command staff is rattled by a Minbari ship approaching with open gun ports until Delenn explains the gesture. So after a misinterpretation of the gun ports open approach caused the Earth/Minbari War - ten years later the fact that the warrior caste does this has STILL not been explained to the humans?humans?
** Likely the standard Minbari protocol when dealing with outside races has been changed to "keep gunports closed" in order to prevent such a misunderstanding from happening again. Neroon's ship was a special circumstance; it was carrying the body of Shai Alyt Bramner, and Neroon himself is shown to be a racist from the get-go (believing humans inferior, and [[PoorCommunicationKills refusing to explain his actions to them]]), so it's not a stretch to believe that he saw Minbari traditions as taking precedence over outside-contact protocol. Delenn, of course, has firsthand knowledge of the pitfalls of this particular tradition, and once she realized what was happening, she moved quickly to prevent a misunderstanding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter. Please write in one voice and preferably one brief paragraph, and Repair Dont Respond.


*** Actually, Sinclair was the last Commander of B5. Both Sheridan and Lochley were Captains. JMS mentions giving them this rank to make the narration internally consistent.
**** That's somewhat of a MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank. That also ignores Sheridan's accomplishments towards Babylon 5's greatness. While Sinclair did [[spoiler: go back in time to become Valen - and do all that implies]], that was not done on Babylon 5, if we're getting into technicalities.
**** Actually, if we want to get ''really'' technical, the last person to bear the title of Commander and be part of B5 command staff was Commander Susan Ivonova.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Actually, if we want to get ''really'' technical, the last person to bear the title of Commander and be part of B5 command staff was Commander Susan Ivonova.

to:

**** Actually, if we want to get ''really'' technical, the last person to bear the title of Commander and be part of B5 command staff was Commander Susan Ivonova.Ivonova.
* In "Legacies" the command staff is rattled by a Minbari ship approaching with open gun ports until Delenn explains the gesture. So after a misinterpretation of the gun ports open approach caused the Earth/Minbari War - ten years later the fact that the warrior caste does this has STILL not been explained to the humans?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** That's somewhat of a MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank. That also ignores Sheridan's accomplishments towards Babylon 5's greatness. While Sinclair did [[spoiler: go back in time to become Valen - and do all that implies]], that was not done on Babylon 5, if we're getting into technicalities.

to:

**** That's somewhat of a MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank. That also ignores Sheridan's accomplishments towards Babylon 5's greatness. While Sinclair did [[spoiler: go back in time to become Valen - and do all that implies]], that was not done on Babylon 5, if we're getting into technicalities.technicalities.
**** Actually, if we want to get ''really'' technical, the last person to bear the title of Commander and be part of B5 command staff was Commander Susan Ivonova.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Why, in the pilot, did Kosh expose himself at all to "Sinclair" on his arrival? It seems like a strange, forced thing for a super-secretive Vorlon to do that right out the gate - it's not like it would have been out of character for him to just stare at a hand extended in greeting. It's because [[spoiler:Kosh may have had a moment of weakness on meeting someone who is, to him, probably an old friend: Valen]]. That moment of initial contact could also have been useful to [[spoiler:telepathically manipulate or plant a piece of himself in Sinclair secretly]], especially since Vorlons tend to be very controlling in their indirect, cryptic, almost deniable way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In Dust to dust Londo makes Vir promise not to let anyone think of his job at Minbar as a joke. On rewatch it's possible to tell that there was something Vir wasn't telling Londo when he made the promise. Vir was using his position to save Narns, which makes the whole scene ironic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also it has been suggested by Arthur C. Clarke that linguistic drift stopped once it became possible to record the human voice (which happened about a decade before the Whitechapel murders). So it's quite possible that whenever English is being spoken no translation is being done. Since it's possible for a modern English speaker to understand Jane Austen, they should be able to understand Sebastian (especially since he knows he's talking to someone of a different background, so would make his speech as general as possible, avoiding all colloquialism).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* After Sheridan is captured in season four, we see him being worked over by Clark's men, who use drugs and torture in an attempt to get him to work with them. You would naturally wonder why they don't use telepaths, who have the ability to overwrite part of people's personality, like they did with Garibaldi in the same season. We discover in the next season that carrying Kosh inside him made Sheridan invulnerable to telepathic manipulation. (It also gave him the ability to read Vorlon, which was revealed even earlier)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** That's somewhat of a MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank. That also ignores Sheridan's accomplishments. While Sinclair did [[spoiler: go back in time to become Valen - and do all that implies]], that was not done on Babylon 5, if we're getting into technicalities.

to:

**** That's somewhat of a MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank. That also ignores Sheridan's accomplishments.accomplishments towards Babylon 5's greatness. While Sinclair did [[spoiler: go back in time to become Valen - and do all that implies]], that was not done on Babylon 5, if we're getting into technicalities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** That's somewhat of a MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank.

to:

**** That's somewhat of a MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank. That also ignores Sheridan's accomplishments. While Sinclair did [[spoiler: go back in time to become Valen - and do all that implies]], that was not done on Babylon 5, if we're getting into technicalities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** That's somewhat of a MathmaticiansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank.

to:

**** That's somewhat of a MathmaticiansAnswer MathematiciansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** That's somewhat of a Mathmatician'sAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank.

to:

**** That's somewhat of a Mathmatician'sAnswer MathmaticiansAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Actually, Sinclair was the last Commander of B5. Both Sheridan and Lochley were Captains. JMS mentions giving them this rank to make the narration internally consistent.

to:

*** Actually, Sinclair was the last Commander of B5. Both Sheridan and Lochley were Captains. JMS mentions giving them this rank to make the narration internally consistent.consistent.
**** That's somewhat of a Mathmatician'sAnswer - while technically true that Sinclair was the last person to run B5 with the rank of "Commander", military tradition refers to someone who commands a unit as the commander (of that unit), whatever their rank.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** HumansAreSpecial was not the point I was making. The point was the Vorlons' influence slowed progress to the point where it took an outside perspective to advance forward. What other races did was irrelevant to the point as Minbari society was the only society we know of that had long term Vorlon influence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
finxing a sinclair to sheridan.


*** Actually, Sinclair was the last Commander of B5. Both Sinclair and Lochley were Captains. JMS mentions giving them this rank to make the narration internally consistent.

to:

*** Actually, Sinclair was the last Commander of B5. Both Sinclair Sheridan and Lochley were Captains. JMS mentions giving them this rank to make the narration internally consistent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, in Londo's narration that opens ''The Gathering,'' he states that B5 achieved its greatness "under the leadership of its final commander." It shows admirable foresight from JMS that he didn't name that commander. The problem is, the last commander of B5 we see is ''Lochley.''

to:

** Also, in Londo's narration that opens ''The Gathering,'' he states that B5 achieved its greatness "under the leadership of its final commander." It shows admirable foresight from JMS that he didn't name that commander. The problem is, the last commander of B5 we see is ''Lochley.''''
*** Actually, Sinclair was the last Commander of B5. Both Sinclair and Lochley were Captains. JMS mentions giving them this rank to make the narration internally consistent.

Added: 1628

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Vorlon method of teaching the younger races doesn't work and never would! Just look at the Minbari, the only race we know to have significant long term influence by the Vorlons, they seem to have barely progressed technologically in the thousand years since the last Shadow war. The Vorlon teachings make a society so disciplined and rigid that there's little room for creative thought which leads to few innovations and improvements. Sure, to a Vorlon taking a few thousand years to progress is not a concern, but their immortal, the younger races can't do that because they don't live long enough to benefit from that kind of lifestyle. You'll notice that every single advancement we know of from the minbari occured due to direct alien influence (Valen restructured Minbari society and made all the castes equal, the Vorlons allowed the Minbari to use some of their technology to creat the White Stars and everything that happens to them during the series happens due to Delenn's constant contact with humans). Notice how humanity managed to come up with ships that can fight and destroy White Stars in a little over a decade after being completely ineffective against the Minbari during their war? And all they had to work with was one Shadow ship for a couple of years, while the Minbari had Vorlon access for centuries and still needed the Vorlons to directly give them the technology. While the Shadows' methods go too far as well their methods actually do get results it's just they go too far and get themselves destroyed.

to:

* The Vorlon method of teaching the younger races doesn't work and never would! Just look at the Minbari, the only race we know to have significant long term influence by the Vorlons, they seem to have barely progressed technologically in the thousand years since the last Shadow war. The Vorlon teachings make a society so disciplined and rigid that there's little room for creative thought which leads to few innovations and improvements. Sure, to a Vorlon taking a few thousand years to progress is not a concern, but their immortal, the younger races can't do that because they don't live long enough to benefit from that kind of lifestyle. You'll notice that every single advancement we know of from the minbari Minbari occured due to direct alien influence (Valen restructured Minbari society and made all the castes equal, the Vorlons allowed the Minbari to use some of their technology to creat the White Stars and everything that happens to them during the series happens due to Delenn's constant contact with humans). Notice how humanity managed to come up with ships that can fight and destroy White Stars in a little over a decade after being completely ineffective against the Minbari during their war? And all they had to work with was one Shadow ship for a couple of years, while the Minbari had Vorlon access for centuries and still needed the Vorlons to directly give them the technology. While the Shadows' methods go too far as well their methods actually do get results it's just they go too far and get themselves destroyed.destroyed.
** While that's a nice HumansAreSpecial notion, it is actually not really true. Most of humanity's advanced technology is of alien origin. Canonically, they initially obtained jump gate[=/=]drive technology from the Centauri. The Narns sold them Centauri knock-off weaponry during the Earth-Minbari War. They were ''given'' artificial gravity technology when they joined the Interstellar Alliance. Sheriden convinced the Minbari to also provide the technology that went into building the ''[[Series/{{Crusade}} Excalibur]]''. Anna Sheriden worked for Interplanetary Expeditions, a corporation that did alien archaeology for the express purpose of finding technology. Plus the Shadows furnished some technology behind the scenes as well, in addition to what Earth was able to locate and study. Trading for alien technology was a common part of interstellar commerce. So, really, most of humanity's major advances were the result of reverse-engineering or direct technology transfer from alien sources. The pace of development ''seemed'' very rapid. But that was because there was a ''lot'' more alien technology that exceeded humanity's than there was that exceeded the Minbari's. Really, the ''only'' technology more advanced than the Minbari's own was that of the various First One races. Hence they had to do more of their own R&D, and had fewer sources of advanced tech that they could simply study. If the Shadow's philosophy was better, it was only because it had caused so many other races to advance so far that by the time humans first encountered the Centauri, there was a ''huge'' amount of alien technology to be had.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, Londo isn't just an alcoholic. He is also addicted to power and prestige. In his constant effort to gain more respect he allies himself with other power hungry men, never notices how much damage they are doing to others, and when he realizes what he has done, he can never turn his back on his allies because he can't cope with loosing their respect. He lies to what few friends he has left, to hide his association with other conspirators, and when openly accused becomes violently angry and makes up justifications for what he did. And every time he manages to break free, it takes only a tiny nudge by a former ally or a personal tragedy to forget about all his promises to himself to never get drawn into it again. Mr. Morden also uses the classic drug dealer tactic of offering some first tastes of great power for free, but later makes increasingly greater demands for his continued service as Londos ace in the hole.

to:

** Also, Londo isn't just an alcoholic. He is also addicted to power and prestige. In his constant effort to gain more respect he allies himself with other power hungry men, never notices how much damage they are doing to others, and when he realizes what he has done, he can never turn his back on his allies because he can't cope with loosing losing their respect. He lies to what few friends he has left, to hide his association with other conspirators, and when openly accused becomes violently angry and makes up justifications for what he did. And every time he manages to break free, it takes only a tiny nudge by a former ally or a personal tragedy to forget about all his promises to himself to never get drawn into it again. Mr. Morden also uses the classic drug dealer tactic of offering some first tastes of great power for free, but later makes increasingly greater demands for his continued service as Londos ace in the hole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**David is conceived in season Five (2262), and if Delenn's gestation is similar to humans, he'd have been born late in that year or (more likely) early in 2263. Sheridan went to Zha'ha'dum in late 2260 and was given 20 years of resurrected life, putting "Sleeping in Light" in early 2281. David's 18 at most when his father dies (Sheridan specifically says in "Objects at Rest" he won't be around when his child "comes of age" at 21) and if he inherited either species' normal lifespan, it's likely he's still alive by "Deconstruction." Of course accidents happen to Rangers, and it's possible a hybrid wouldn't live as long as either parent species, but there's no reason to think David wouldn't survive and as Delenn's repeatedly referred to as "half human, half Minbari" even if she culturally identifies as Minbari, David's 3/4 human and likely compatible with humans.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's pretty much stated that Sebastian has been awakened from time to time for similar purposes, so it's entirely possible that at least some of his speech patterns have evolved over time as he's experienced future time periods. The Vorlons seem also to have extended his life, so Sebastian may have ''experienced'' [[OlderThanTheyLook more years than his appearance would suggest]], even taking his [[HumanPopsicle periods of long sleep]] into account.

to:

** It's pretty much stated that Sebastian has been awakened from time to time for similar purposes, so it's entirely possible that at least some of his speech patterns have evolved over time as he's experienced future time periods. The Vorlons seem also to have extended his life, so Sebastian may have ''experienced'' [[OlderThanTheyLook more years than his appearance would suggest]], even taking his [[HumanPopsicle periods of long sleep]] into account.account.
* If the opening narration from Seasons 1-3 is supposed to be some kind of historical record, like diary entries or what have you, there should be no reference from Sinclair to "the dawn of the Third Age of Mankind." He was long gone before the Old Ones bugged out.
** Also, in Londo's narration that opens ''The Gathering,'' he states that B5 achieved its greatness "under the leadership of its final commander." It shows admirable foresight from JMS that he didn't name that commander. The problem is, the last commander of B5 we see is ''Lochley.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Though Ivanova's convinced it was due to a NoodleIncident involving them and a smuggler.

Added: 457

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In "A Late Delivery From Avalon," Marcus proposes that Mckintyre might actually be the real King Arthur, preserved by the Vorlons in much the same way that Sebastian a/k/a Jack the Ripper was. Franklin objects, saying that 'Arthur's' speech patterns are too modern by about 1400 years. A very logical objection...except that Sebastian's speech patterns should be about 350 years out of date as well (of course, the only major character he interacts with for a significant length of time is Delenn, and [[TranslationConvention their entire conversation may have been in Minbari]]). Consider how well Shakespeare's works or the original King James Bible holds up for modern English readers to see what a difference this should make.

to:

* In "A Late Delivery From Avalon," Marcus proposes that Mckintyre McIntyre might actually be the real King Arthur, preserved by the Vorlons in much the same way that Sebastian a/k/a Jack the Ripper was. Franklin objects, saying that 'Arthur's' speech patterns are too modern by about 1400 years. A very logical objection...except that Sebastian's speech patterns should be about 350 years out of date as well (of course, the only major character he interacts with for a significant length of time is Delenn, and [[TranslationConvention their entire conversation may have been in Minbari]]). Consider how well Shakespeare's works or the original King James Bible holds up for modern English readers to see what a difference this should make.make.
** It's pretty much stated that Sebastian has been awakened from time to time for similar purposes, so it's entirely possible that at least some of his speech patterns have evolved over time as he's experienced future time periods. The Vorlons seem also to have extended his life, so Sebastian may have ''experienced'' [[OlderThanTheyLook more years than his appearance would suggest]], even taking his [[HumanPopsicle periods of long sleep]] into account.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Everyone we see answer Morden's question ("What do you want?") gets what he asked for; Londo gets a return to Centauri Empire's imperialist days, and later G'kar gets to see the Centauri Empire bombed to rubble, and in between, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking Vir gets to wiggle his fingers at Morden's head on a spike]]. Of them, though, Vir was the only one who asked for something which, by the time the request was fulfilled, actually ''wanted''.

to:

* Everyone we see answer Morden's question ("What do you want?") gets what he asked for; Londo gets a return to Centauri Empire's imperialist days, and later G'kar gets to see the Centauri Empire bombed to rubble, and in between, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking Vir gets to wiggle his fingers at Morden's head on a spike]]. Of them, though, Vir was the only one who asked for something which, by the time the request was fulfilled, he actually ''wanted''.

Added: 199

Changed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Everyone gets what they want from Morden; Londo gets a return to Centauri Empire's imperialist days, and later G'kar gets to see the Centauri Empire bombed to rubble, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking Vir gets to wiggle his fingers at Morden's head on a spike]]. Of course, only Vir actually appreciates what he gets.

to:

* Everyone we see answer Morden's question ("What do you want?") gets what they want from Morden; he asked for; Londo gets a return to Centauri Empire's imperialist days, and later G'kar gets to see the Centauri Empire bombed to rubble, and in between, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking Vir gets to wiggle his fingers at Morden's head on a spike]]. Of course, them, though, Vir was the only Vir one who asked for something which, by the time the request was fulfilled, actually appreciates ''wanted''.
** There's also a theory that Morden reacted so badly to Vir's answer because he knew that, one way or another, the Shadows saw to it that everyone who answered that question got
what he gets.they asked for.

Changed: 384

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''War Without End'', after they are informed of the special devices to protect them during time travel, Ivanova mentions the pilot who died of old age after being exposed to the time rift, then looks at Sinclair, significantly aged since his last appearance, and declares that he must have been lucky during his own visit. That could also be the reason for Garibaldi going bald.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I don't think he had missed the fact that postal service would be disrupted, he was just pissed about the extra fees.

Top