Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / AmericanBeauty

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Who's to say she wasn't mentally deficient ''before'' the marriage, and Frank married her '''because''' her condition would help cover up his homosexuality?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, he almost spills his beer and she stops everything to chide him for it, and he loses his temper and blows up at her for being so materialistic. Needless to say, the mood is killed. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and go back to making love neatly spelled out ''everything'' wrong with their marriage.

to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, he almost spills his beer on the couch and she stops everything to chide him for it, and he loses his temper and blows up at her for being so materialistic. Needless to say, the mood is killed. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and go back to making love neatly spelled out ''everything'' wrong with their marriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, he almost spills his beer and she stops everything to chide him for it, and he utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. Needless to say, the mood is killed. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and go back to making love neatly spelled out ''everything'' wrong with their marriage.

to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, he almost spills his beer and she stops everything to chide him for it, and he utterly loses his temper and blows up at her for being so materialistic. Needless to say, the mood is killed. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and go back to making love neatly spelled out ''everything'' wrong with their marriage.

Added: 142

Changed: 260

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of the film, Carolyn was coming home with the absolute intention of [[spoiler:murdering Lester. However, upon arriving home, she found him already dead in the same manner she had intended to kill him. In that moment, she realized the difference between the satisfying, cathartic revenge and subsequent freedom she had been imagining and the reality: that a man she had once loved, and still cared for, had had his life taken away and that she would never have the chance to reconcile or repair anything. This is why she ends up wailing on the floor, clutching her husband's shirts. Perhaps if it had come down to it, Carolyn would have realized this on her own and stopped herself from killing him...but before she could have that revelation, someone took it from her. In short, Carolyn's moment of discovering her husband's body was her more brutal, violent version of the revelation Lester had in the kitchen when he realized that Angela was a vulnerable young girl and that he was on the verge of doing something terrible that he could never take back. Lester needed only to ''imagine'' how terrible it would be to take advantage of Angela in order to stop himself. Carolyn never had the chance to stop it but must live with the consequences anyway.]]

to:

* At the end of the film, Carolyn was coming seeming to come home with the absolute intention of [[spoiler:murdering Lester. However, upon arriving home, she found him already dead in the same manner she had intended to kill him. In that moment, she realized the difference between the satisfying, cathartic revenge and subsequent freedom she had been imagining and the reality: that a man she had once loved, and still cared for, had had his life taken away and that she would never have the chance to reconcile or repair anything. This is why she ends up wailing on the floor, clutching her husband's shirts. Perhaps if it had come down to it, Carolyn would have realized this on her own and stopped herself from killing him...but before she could have that revelation, someone took it from her. In short, Carolyn's moment of discovering her husband's body was her more brutal, violent version of the revelation Lester had in the kitchen when he realized that Angela was a vulnerable young girl and that he was on the verge of doing something terrible that he could never take back. Lester needed only to ''imagine'' how terrible it would be to take advantage of Angela in order to stop himself. Carolyn never had the chance to stop it but must live with the consequences anyway.]]



* Assuming, of course, Frank gets caught, but if he ever did, what would happen to Barbara? The woman is a shell, incapable of any thought for herself, if Frank ever left, since Ricky was booted...what would happen to her?
** There is bound to be a large police investigation, and it won't take long for them to find the video of Jane and Ricky discussing killing Lester - such an incriminating tape could so easily be used against them as evidence [[spoiler:and in the original script, it was probably the tape that sealed their conviction]] - the camera was turned off before they confirmed to each other that they were joking. They will probably also find Ricky's stash of cannabis, which will work against him too. Their only hope is if [[spoiler:Frank]] owns up or they find [[spoiler:his bloodied shirt]] - both unlikely (the latter is easily disposed of).

to:

* Assuming, of course, Frank gets caught, but if he ever did, what would happen to Barbara? The woman is a shell, incapable of any thought for herself, so if Frank ever left, since Ricky was booted...what would happen to her?
** There is bound to be a large police investigation, and it won't take long for them to find the video of Jane and Ricky discussing killing Lester - such an incriminating tape could so easily be used against them as evidence [[spoiler:and in the original script, it was probably the tape that sealed their conviction]] - the camera was turned off before they confirmed to each other that they were joking. They will probably also find Ricky's stash of cannabis, which will work against him him, too. Their only hope is if [[spoiler:Frank]] owns up or up, they find [[spoiler:his bloodied shirt]] - both shirt, or they investigate the bullet marks and compare it to the firearms in Frank's cabinet]]. Without any apparent motive for [[spoiler:Frank]] though, and with no witnesses, it's highly unlikely (the latter is easily disposed of).he would be investigated very thoroughly if at all.


Added DiffLines:

*** Unless she's simply showing signs of dementia and her mental illness is irrelevant to her marriage, in which case she's doomed regardless.

Added: 4

Changed: 48

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lester Burnham [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.

to:

* Lester Burnham [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.



* On first sight years ago it seemed that the reason [[spoiler:Frank did it]] was either because he was [[spoiler:rejected or that he still believed Lester was gay and had hurt Ricky, just liked younger boys]]. Just realized it was because [[spoiler:he couldn't let Lester live after the kiss, because it meant that someone knew Frank was closeted]].

to:

* On first sight years ago it seemed that the reason [[spoiler:Frank did it]] was either because he was [[spoiler:rejected or that he still believed Lester was gay and had hurt Ricky, just liked younger boys]]. Just realized it was because [[spoiler:he couldn't let Lester live after the kiss, because it meant that someone knew Frank was closeted]].closeted]].
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, he almost spills his beer and she stops everything to chide him for it, and he utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. Needless to say, the mood is killed. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and go back to making love was ''exactly'' what was wrong with their marriage.

to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, he almost spills his beer and she stops everything to chide him for it, and he utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. Needless to say, the mood is killed. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and go back to making love was ''exactly'' what was neatly spelled out ''everything'' wrong with their marriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, she chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and he utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and get back to making love was ''exactly'' what was wrong with their marriage.

to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, she chides him for nearly spilling he almost spills his beer on the couch, and she stops everything to chide him for it, and he utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. Needless to say, the mood is killed. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and get go back to making love was ''exactly'' what was wrong with their marriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of the film, Carolyn was coming home with the absolute intention of [[spoiler:murdering Lester. However, upon arriving home, she found him already dead in the same manner she had intended to kill him. In that moment, she realized the difference between the satisfying, cathartic revenge and subsequent freedom she had been imagining and the reality: that a man she had once loved, and still cared for, had had his life taken away and that she would never have the chance to reconcile or repair anything. Perhaps if it had come down to it, Carolyn would have realized this on her own and stopped herself from killing him...but before she could have that revelation, someone took it from her. In short, Carolyn's moment of discovering her husband's body was her more brutal, violent version of the revelation Lester had in the kitchen when he realized that Angela was a vulnerable young girl and that he was on the verge of doing something terrible that he could never take back. Lester needed only to ''imagine'' how terrible it would be to take advantage of Angela in order to stop himself. Carolyn never had the chance to stop it but must live with the consequences anyway.]]

to:

* At the end of the film, Carolyn was coming home with the absolute intention of [[spoiler:murdering Lester. However, upon arriving home, she found him already dead in the same manner she had intended to kill him. In that moment, she realized the difference between the satisfying, cathartic revenge and subsequent freedom she had been imagining and the reality: that a man she had once loved, and still cared for, had had his life taken away and that she would never have the chance to reconcile or repair anything. This is why she ends up wailing on the floor, clutching her husband's shirts. Perhaps if it had come down to it, Carolyn would have realized this on her own and stopped herself from killing him...but before she could have that revelation, someone took it from her. In short, Carolyn's moment of discovering her husband's body was her more brutal, violent version of the revelation Lester had in the kitchen when he realized that Angela was a vulnerable young girl and that he was on the verge of doing something terrible that he could never take back. Lester needed only to ''imagine'' how terrible it would be to take advantage of Angela in order to stop himself. Carolyn never had the chance to stop it but must live with the consequences anyway.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* At the end of the film, Carolyn was coming home with the absolute intention of [[spoiler:murdering Lester. However, upon arriving home, she found him already dead in the same manner she had intended to kill him. In that moment, she realized the difference between the satisfying, cathartic revenge and subsequent freedom she had been imagining and the reality: that a man she had once loved, and still cared for, had had his life taken away and that she would never have the chance to reconcile or repair anything. Perhaps if it had come down to it, Carolyn would have realized this on her own and stopped herself from killing him...but before she could have that revelation, someone took it from her. In short, Carolyn's moment of discovering her husband's body was her more brutal, violent version of the revelation Lester had in the kitchen when he realized that Angela was a vulnerable young girl and that he was on the verge of doing something terrible that he could never take back. Lester needed only to ''imagine'' how terrible it would be to take advantage of Angela in order to stop himself. Carolyn never had the chance to stop it but must live with the consequences anyway.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Almost all of the rest of the cast have a reason to [[spoiler:have committed Lester's murder]] and all of their dirty laundry is going to come out in the ensuing criminal investigation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, Carolyn chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and Lester utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and get back to making love was ''exactly'' what was wrong with their marriage.

to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, Carolyn she chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and Lester he utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and get back to making love was ''exactly'' what was wrong with their marriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, Carolyn chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and Lester utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and get on with making love showcases ''everything wrong with their marriage''.

to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, Carolyn chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and Lester utterly blows up at her for being so materialistic. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer aside and get on with back to making love showcases ''everything was ''exactly'' what was wrong with their marriage''.
marriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, Carolyn chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and Lester utterly blows up at her for caring more about furniture than their love life. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer on the coffee table and get on with lovemaking (possibly their first time in ages) neatly showcases ''everything wrong with their marriage''.

to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, Carolyn chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and Lester utterly blows up at her for caring more about furniture than their love life. being so materialistic. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer on the coffee table aside and get on with lovemaking (possibly their first time in ages) neatly making love showcases ''everything wrong with their marriage''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The beer scene. Lester and Carolyn make out in the living room, but before it progresses to sex, Carolyn chides him for nearly spilling his beer on the couch, and Lester utterly blows up at her for caring more about furniture than their love life. The fact that neither of them could just set the beer on the coffee table and get on with lovemaking (possibly their first time in ages) neatly showcases ''everything wrong with their marriage''.

Added: 146

Changed: 24

Removed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rearranged in alphabetical order (Fridge Brilliance before Fridge Horror — B before H).


[[AC:Fridge Horror]]

to:

[[AC:Fridge Horror]]!!FridgeBrilliance
* Lester Burnham [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.

!!FridgeHorror



* On first sight years ago it seemed that the reason [[spoiler:Frank did it]] was either because he was [[spoiler:rejected or that he still believed Lester was gay and had hurt Ricky, just liked younger boys]]. Just realized it was because [[spoiler:he couldn't let Lester live after the kiss, because it meant that someone knew Frank was closeted]].

[[AC:Fridge Brilliance]]
* Lester Burnham [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.

to:

* On first sight years ago it seemed that the reason [[spoiler:Frank did it]] was either because he was [[spoiler:rejected or that he still believed Lester was gay and had hurt Ricky, just liked younger boys]]. Just realized it was because [[spoiler:he couldn't let Lester live after the kiss, because it meant that someone knew Frank was closeted]].

[[AC:Fridge Brilliance]]
* Lester Burnham [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.
closeted]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* On first sight years ago it seemed that the reason [[spoiler:Frank did it]] was either because he was [[spoiler:rejected or that he still believed Lester was gay and had hurt Ricky, just liked younger boys]]. Just realized it was because [[spoiler:he couldn't let Lester live after the kiss, because it meant that someone knew Frank was closeted]].



* Lester Burnham [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.

to:

* Lester Burnham [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It ''is'' highly likely that, if Frank were to get caught and hauled off, his wife would "come out of her shell", with the lack of the constantly dominant and likely oppressing presence of his. It might take time, but she'd turn out okay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I doubt she was like that before the marriage. It takes a lot of effort, but even women who have been brutally abused (as is implied to have happened with Barbara) can make a recovery from the harm done to them. She'll undoubtedly have trauma issues for the rest of her life, but she's not irrecoverable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lester Burnham = Humbert Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.

to:

* Lester Burnham = Humbert [[SignificantAnagram =]] [[Literature/{{Lolita}} Humbert]] Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There is bound to be a large police investigation, and it won't take long for them to find the video of Jane and Ricky discussing killing Lester - such an incriminating tape could so easily be used against them as evidence [[spoiler:and in the original script, it was probably the tape that sealed their conviction]] - the camera was turned off before they confirmed to each other that they were joking. They will probably also find Ricky's stash of cannabis, which will work against him too. Their only hope is if [[spoiler:Frank]] owns up or they find [[spoiler:his bloodied shirt]] - both unlikely (the latter is easily disposed of).

to:

** There is bound to be a large police investigation, and it won't take long for them to find the video of Jane and Ricky discussing killing Lester - such an incriminating tape could so easily be used against them as evidence [[spoiler:and in the original script, it was probably the tape that sealed their conviction]] - the camera was turned off before they confirmed to each other that they were joking. They will probably also find Ricky's stash of cannabis, which will work against him too. Their only hope is if [[spoiler:Frank]] owns up or they find [[spoiler:his bloodied shirt]] - both unlikely (the latter is easily disposed of).of).

[[AC:Fridge Brilliance]]
* Lester Burnham = Humbert Learns. Literally floored me when I learned it. In 2012.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Fridge Horror]]
* Assuming, of course, Frank gets caught, but if he ever did, what would happen to Barbara? The woman is a shell, incapable of any thought for herself, if Frank ever left, since Ricky was booted...what would happen to her?
** There is bound to be a large police investigation, and it won't take long for them to find the video of Jane and Ricky discussing killing Lester - such an incriminating tape could so easily be used against them as evidence [[spoiler:and in the original script, it was probably the tape that sealed their conviction]] - the camera was turned off before they confirmed to each other that they were joking. They will probably also find Ricky's stash of cannabis, which will work against him too. Their only hope is if [[spoiler:Frank]] owns up or they find [[spoiler:his bloodied shirt]] - both unlikely (the latter is easily disposed of).

Top