Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Scrooge1951

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This film makes a change very common to adaptations of the story, by including a scene where Belle (here "Alice") and Scrooge fall in love.


Added DiffLines:

* MaternalDeathBlameTheChild: Why Scrooge's father abandoned him at boarding school. This is a change from the book where Fan is expressly stated to be Scrooge's younger sister.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Heading the cast are Alastair Sim as Ebenezer Scrooge and Michael Hordern as Jacob Marley; both would reprise their respective roles in the 1971 animated film ''WesternAnimation/AChristmasCarol1971''. Brian Desmond Hurst was the director, and the screenplay was written by Noel Langley (''Film/TheWizardOfOz'').

to:

Heading the cast are Alastair Sim as Ebenezer Scrooge and Michael Hordern as Jacob Marley; both would reprise their respective roles in the 1971 animated film ''WesternAnimation/AChristmasCarol1971''. Brian Desmond Hurst was the director, and the screenplay was written by Noel Langley (''Film/TheWizardOfOz'').
(''Film/TheWizardOfOz''). A young Creator/PatrickMacnee appears as the younger, living version of Jacob Marley.

Added: 341

Changed: 390

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IWasQuiteALooker: Scrooge and Marley were quite handsome in their younger days. Oddly enough when we see Alice in the present day, [[BeautyIsNeverTarnished she still looks the same]].

to:

* HonoraryUncle: In the epilogue, Tiny Tim calls Scrooge "Uncle Scrooge."
* IWasQuiteALooker: Scrooge and Marley were quite handsome in their younger days. Oddly enough when we see Alice in the present day, [[BeautyIsNeverTarnished she still looks the same]].same, just with slightly grayer hair]].



* ThrowingOffTheDisability: The epilogue shows a fully healthy, crutch-free Tiny Tim running to greet Scrooge in the street.



* TruerToTheText: This movie includes the sequence where Scrooge threatens to swallow a toothpick while talking with Marley, something very few film adaptations do.

to:

* TruerToTheText: This Even though this movie takes its own set of liberties that other adaptations don't, it still includes quite a bit of dialogue from the book that often tends to be left out. For example, it includes the sequence where Scrooge threatens to swallow a toothpick while talking with Marley, something very few film adaptations do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDistillation: In this version, the BadFuture saves the men talking about Scrooge's death for last.

to:

* AdaptationDistillation: In this version, the BadFuture starts with the Cratchits mourning Tiny Tim's death, then moves on to the thieves selling Scrooge's belongings, then saves the men talking about Scrooge's death for last.last. In the book, these happen in the opposite order. This makes our realization that Scrooge is the despised, robbed dead man more gradual, instead of it being fairly obvious from the start.

Added: 110

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDistillation: In this version, the BadFuture saves the men talking about Scrooge's death for last.



* CorruptCorporateExecutive: Mr. Jorkin; during Scrooge's past at the Amalgamated Mercantile Society, the ledger registers a liability of 3200 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence ([[OldBritishMoney £3200, 8 / 10 d]]), with assets of 11 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence (£11, 8 / 10d), resulting in a deficit of £3189.

to:

* CorruptCorporateExecutive: Mr. Jorkin; during Scrooge's past at the Amalgamated Mercantile Society, the ledger registers a liability of 3200 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence ([[OldBritishMoney £3200, (£3200, 8 / 10 d]]), d), with assets of 11 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence (£11, 8 / 10d), resulting in a deficit of £3189.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Adds an extended StartOfDarkness sequence depicting how Scrooge was corrupted by an unscrupulous mentor luring them away from Fezziwig's good influence.

to:

** Adds an extended StartOfDarkness sequence depicting how Scrooge was corrupted by an unscrupulous mentor luring them away him from Fezziwig's good influence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComicallyMissingThePoint: This exchange on Scrooge's staircase after he catches up with Mrs. Dilber and gives her a guinea:

to:

* ComicallyMissingThePoint: This exchange on Scrooge's staircase after he catches up with Mrs. Dilber and gives her a guinea:guinea.



* DeadpanSnarker: Scrooge.

to:

* DeadpanSnarker: Scrooge.Pre-reformation Scrooge is full of snark, as is the corrupt businessman Mr. Jorkin.



* MarketBasedTitle: Was released as ''A Christmas Carol'' in some markets.

to:

* MarketBasedTitle: Was released as ''A Christmas Carol'' in some markets.markets, including the US.



* SarcasticConfession: Mr. Jorkin, when confronted on charges of embezzlement:

to:

* SarcasticConfession: Mr. Jorkin, when confronted on charges of embezzlement:embezzlement.



* StartOfDarkness: The Christmas Past sequence explores this.

to:

* StartOfDarkness: The Christmas Past sequence explores this.this in more detail than the book.



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Played with. In the original novel the Christmas Past sequence shows that Belle married someone else and had a family, which is the last we see of her. This adaptation shows her counterpart Alice in the Christmas Present, helping feed the poor on Christmas Day. It's never confirmed whether or not she did have a family.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Played with. In the original novel the Christmas Past sequence shows that Belle married someone else and had a family, which is the last we see of her. This adaptation shows her counterpart Alice in the Christmas Present, helping feed the poor on Christmas Day. It's never confirmed Day, but whether or not she did have had a family. family is unaddressed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Marley already worked there when scrooge was introduced to him


** Adds an extended StartOfDarkness sequence depicting how Scrooge and Marley were corrupted by an unscrupulous mentor luring them away from Fezziwig's good influence.

to:

** Adds an extended StartOfDarkness sequence depicting how Scrooge and Marley were was corrupted by an unscrupulous mentor luring them away from Fezziwig's good influence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InformedAttribute: Tiny Tim is supposed to be very ill, but he looks perfectly healthy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Later, much older Scrooge has Marley delivering a warning with his last breaths, but it's pretty much over his head. Scrooge even waited until business was over to bother visiting him; his maid incredulously declares "I'll see if I can get him to hold out, I'm sure!"
* AscendedExtra: Mrs Dilber, as noted above, receives more screen time. A lot of adaptations tend to leave her out.
* CanonForeigner: The PredatoryBusiness which buys out Fezziwig is personified by Mr. Jorkin. Jorkin serves as an EvilMentor to Scrooge and Marley both, pairing them up in an ominous scene. He is later caught embezzling from his own banking house; Scrooge and Marley bail him out in return for 51% of the stock share, effectively a hostile takeover. Mr. Jorkin is adapted from Mr. Jorkins, a character from ''Literature/DavidCopperfield''.

to:

** Later, much older Scrooge has Marley delivering a warning with his last breaths, but it's pretty much over his head. Scrooge even waited waits until business was is over to bother visiting him; his maid incredulously declares "I'll see if I can get him to hold out, I'm sure!"
* AscendedExtra: Mrs Dilber, as noted above, Dilber receives more screen time. A lot of adaptations tend to leave her out.
time; in the book she's only seen in the future pawning off Scrooge's items.
* CanonForeigner: The PredatoryBusiness which buys out Fezziwig is personified by Mr. Jorkin.Jorkin, adapted from Mr. Jorkins, a character from ''Literature/DavidCopperfield''. Jorkin serves as an EvilMentor to Scrooge and Marley both, pairing them up in an ominous scene. He is later caught embezzling from his own banking house; Scrooge and Marley bail him out in return for 51% of the stock share, effectively a hostile takeover. Mr. Jorkin is adapted from Mr. Jorkins, a character from ''Literature/DavidCopperfield''.



* HeelRealization: Starts when Scrooge describes his old boss Fezziwig, he stops, noting that he wishes he could talk to his clerk, Bob Cratchit.

to:

* HeelRealization: Starts when When Scrooge describes his old boss Fezziwig, he stops, noting that he wishes he could talk to his clerk, Bob Cratchit.Cratchit, and apologize.



* KilledMidSentence: Marley dies while attempting to warn Scrooge of his fate and to "save himself".
* LargeHam: Marley is a big one.

to:

* KilledMidSentence: Marley dies while attempting to warn Scrooge of his fate and telling him to "save himself".
save himself.
* LargeHam: Marley is a big one.one, and Scrooge is one after his reformation.



* StepfordSmiler: When Bob Cratchitt comes home in the Christmas Yet To Come part, he tries to pretend that he's happy about an imagined goodbye from Tiny Tim. But he quickly collapses into his wife's arms in tears.

to:

* StepfordSmiler: When Bob Cratchitt Cratchit comes home in the Christmas Yet To Come part, he tries to pretend that he's happy about an imagined goodbye from Tiny Tim. But he quickly collapses into his wife's arms in tears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
i've seen this onstage but rarely on film

Added DiffLines:

* TruerToTheText: This movie includes the sequence where Scrooge threatens to swallow a toothpick while talking with Marley, something very few film adaptations do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IWasQuiteALooker: Scrooge and Marley essentially. Oddly enough when we see Alice in the present day, [[BeautyIsNeverTarnished she still looks the same]].

to:

* IWasQuiteALooker: Scrooge and Marley essentially.were quite handsome in their younger days. Oddly enough when we see Alice in the present day, [[BeautyIsNeverTarnished she still looks the same]].



* MaybeEverAfter: In contrast to the novel where she has a family of her own, Alice/Belle's romantic situation isn't addressed. She's shown in the Christmas Present sequence - where she isn't in the novel. Although it isn't said, this does leave things open for Scrooge to reconcile with her if she isn't married.

to:

* MaybeEverAfter: In contrast to the novel where she has a family of her own, Alice/Belle's romantic situation isn't addressed. She's also shown in the Christmas Present sequence - sequence, where she isn't in the novel. Although it isn't said, explicitly stated, this does leave things open for Scrooge to reconcile with her if she isn't married.



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Played with. In the original novel the Christmas Past sequence shows that Belle married someone else and had a family - which is the last we see of her. This adaptation shows her counterpart Alice in the Christmas Present, helping feed the poor on Christmas Day. It's never confirmed whether or not she did have a family.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Played with. In the original novel the Christmas Past sequence shows that Belle married someone else and had a family - family, which is the last we see of her. This adaptation shows her counterpart Alice in the Christmas Present, helping feed the poor on Christmas Day. It's never confirmed whether or not she did have a family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Heading the cast are Alastair Sim as Ebenezer Scrooge and Michael Hordern as Jacob Marley; both would reprise their respective roles in the 1971 animated film ''WesternAnimation/AChristmasCarol''. Brian Desmond Hurst was the director, and the screenplay was written by Noel Langley (''Film/TheWizardOfOz'').

to:

Heading the cast are Alastair Sim as Ebenezer Scrooge and Michael Hordern as Jacob Marley; both would reprise their respective roles in the 1971 animated film ''WesternAnimation/AChristmasCarol''.''WesternAnimation/AChristmasCarol1971''. Brian Desmond Hurst was the director, and the screenplay was written by Noel Langley (''Film/TheWizardOfOz'').
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
What other versions of the story do isn't relevant to whether this version of the story is an example.


** This film shows Marley’s death seven years earlier. The other adaptations that have a similar scene are the [[Film/AChristmasCarolTheMusical 2004 TV musical]] and ''Ebbie''.

to:

** This film shows Marley’s death seven years earlier. The other adaptations that have a similar scene are the [[Film/AChristmasCarolTheMusical 2004 TV musical]] and ''Ebbie''.



** This movie covers Fan's DeathByChildbirth, as well as her final moments with her brother. The only other adaptation to attempt this was ''Ebbie'', which aired in 1995.

to:

** This movie covers Fan's DeathByChildbirth, as well as her final moments with her brother. The only other adaptation to attempt this was ''Ebbie'', which aired in 1995.



* StartOfDarkness: The Christmas Past sequence explores this, more so than other adaptations.

to:

* StartOfDarkness: The Christmas Past sequence explores this, more so than other adaptations.this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TimeshiftedActor: [[{{Minder}} George Cole]] as Young Ebenezer Scrooge and [[Series/TheAvengers Patrick Macnee]] as Young Jacob Marley.

to:

* TimeshiftedActor: [[{{Minder}} [[Series/{{Minder}} George Cole]] as Young Ebenezer Scrooge and [[Series/TheAvengers Patrick Macnee]] as Young Jacob Marley.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This film shows Marley’s death seven years earlier. The other adaptations that have a similar scene are the [[Film/AChristmasCarolTheMusical 2004 TV musical]] and ''Ebbie''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
examples of things that only happen in the 1971 version go on the page for the 1971 version


* RoleReprisal: Alistair Sim and Michael Hordern would reprise their roles as Scrooge and Marley twenty years later in an animated version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RoleReprisal: Alistair Sim and Michael Hordern would reprise their roles as Scrooge and Marley twenty years later in an animated version.


Added DiffLines:

* ShownTheirWork:
** The tune that Mr Jorkin is whistling when he offers Scrooge a job is "The Lincolnshire Poacher" - about a poacher who enjoys unlawfully entering property and trapping game there.
** After Marley's death scene, Christmas Past calls Scrooge a "squeezing, wrenching, grasping, covetous old sinner" - exactly as Charles Dickens describes him in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MajorityShareDictator: Scrooge and Marley obtain their wealth by offering to cover the expenses of their owner's embezzlement scandal in return for the right to buy up to 51% of the company's shares. Naturally this gives them absolute power over the day-to-day business of the company.

Changed: 131

Removed: 88

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonForeigner: The PredatoryBusiness which buys out Fezziwig is personified by Mr. Jorkin. Jorkin serves as an EvilMentor to Scrooge and Marley both, pairing them up in an ominous scene. He is later caught embezzling from his own banking house; Scrooge and Marley bail him out in return for 51% of the stock share, effectively a hostile takeover.
** Mr. Jorkin is adapted from Mr. Jorkins, a character from Literature/DavidCopperfield.

to:

* CanonForeigner: The PredatoryBusiness which buys out Fezziwig is personified by Mr. Jorkin. Jorkin serves as an EvilMentor to Scrooge and Marley both, pairing them up in an ominous scene. He is later caught embezzling from his own banking house; Scrooge and Marley bail him out in return for 51% of the stock share, effectively a hostile takeover.
**
takeover. Mr. Jorkin is adapted from Mr. Jorkins, a character from Literature/DavidCopperfield.''Literature/DavidCopperfield''.



--> '''Mrs. Dilber''': A guinea? For me? What for?
--> '''Ebenezer''': I'll give you a guess!
--> '''Mrs. Dilber''': [[{{Beat}} [pause]]] To keep me mouth shut?
* CorruptCorporateExecutive: Mr. Jorkin; during Scrooge's past at the Amalgamated Mercantile Society, the ledger registers a liability of 3200 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence [[OldBritishMoney (£3200, 8 / 10 d,)]] with assets of 11 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence (£11, 8 / 10d), resulting in a deficit of £3189.
-->'''Jorkin''': At least the 10 pences cancel each other out.\\
'''Rosehed''': How much of this is the company's capital?\\
'''Snedrig''': All of it, Mr. Rosehed.\\
'''Rosehed''': In short, sir, you're not only a bankrupt, you're also an embezzler of the company's funds.

to:

--> -->'''Mrs. Dilber:''' A guinea? For me? What for?\\
'''Ebenezer:''' I'll give you a guess!\\
'''Mrs. Dilber''': A guinea? For me? What for?
--> '''Ebenezer''': I'll give you a guess!
--> '''Mrs. Dilber''': [[{{Beat}} [pause]]]
Dilber:''' ''[[[{{Beat}} pause]]]'' To keep me mouth shut?
shut?
* CorruptCorporateExecutive: Mr. Jorkin; during Scrooge's past at the Amalgamated Mercantile Society, the ledger registers a liability of 3200 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence [[OldBritishMoney (£3200, ([[OldBritishMoney £3200, 8 / 10 d,)]] d]]), with assets of 11 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence (£11, 8 / 10d), resulting in a deficit of £3189.
-->'''Jorkin''':
£3189.
-->'''Jorkin:'''
At least the 10 pences cancel each other out.\\
'''Rosehed''': '''Rosehed:''' How much of this is the company's capital?\\
'''Snedrig''': '''Snedrig:''' All of it, Mr. Rosehed.\\
'''Rosehed''': '''Rosehed:''' In short, sir, you're not only a bankrupt, you're also an embezzler of the company's funds.



--> '''Scrooge''': Forgive me, Fan!

to:

--> '''Scrooge''': '''Scrooge:''' Forgive me, Fan!



-->'''Rosehed''': In short, sir, you're not only a bankrupt, you're an embezzler of the company's funds.\\
'''Jorkin''': I also beat my wife and skewer innocent babies when in my cups.

to:

-->'''Rosehed''': -->'''Rosehed:''' In short, sir, you're not only a bankrupt, you're an embezzler of the company's funds.\\
'''Jorkin''': '''Jorkin:''' I also beat my wife and skewer innocent babies when in my cups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SarcasticConfession: Mr. Jorkin, when confronted on charges of embezzlement:
-->'''Rosehed''': In short, sir, you're not only a bankrupt, you're an embezzler of the company's funds.\\
'''Jorkin''': I also beat my wife and skewer innocent babies when in my cups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Mr. Jorkin is adapted from Mr. Jorkins, a character from Literature/DavidCopperfield.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CorruptCorporateExecutive: Mr. Jorkin; during Scrooge's past at the Amalgamated Mercantile Society, the ledger registers a liability of 3200 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence [[OldBritishMoney (£3200, 8 / 10 d,)]] with assets of 11 pounds, 8 shillings and 10 pence (£11, 8 / 10d), resulting in a deficit of £3189.
-->'''Jorkin''': At least the 10 pences cancel each other out.\\
'''Rosehed''': How much of this is the company's capital?\\
'''Snedrig''': All of it, Mr. Rosehed.\\
'''Rosehed''': In short, sir, you're not only a bankrupt, you're also an embezzler of the company's funds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonForeigner: The PredatoryBusiness which buys out Fezziwig is personified by Mr. Jawking. Jawking serves as an EvilMentor to Scrooge and Marley both, pairing them up in an ominous scene. He is later caught embezzling from his own banking house; Scrooge and Marley bail him out in return for 51% of the stock share, effectively a hostile takeover.

to:

* CanonForeigner: The PredatoryBusiness which buys out Fezziwig is personified by Mr. Jawking. Jawking Jorkin. Jorkin serves as an EvilMentor to Scrooge and Marley both, pairing them up in an ominous scene. He is later caught embezzling from his own banking house; Scrooge and Marley bail him out in return for 51% of the stock share, effectively a hostile takeover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It stars Alastair Sim as Ebenezer Scrooge and Michael Hordern as Jacob Marley; both would reprise their respective roles in the 1971 animated film ''WesternAnimation/AChristmasCarol''. Brian Desmond Hurst was the director, and the screenplay was written by Noel Langley (''Film/TheWizardOfOz'').

to:

It stars Heading the cast are Alastair Sim as Ebenezer Scrooge and Michael Hordern as Jacob Marley; both would reprise their respective roles in the 1971 animated film ''WesternAnimation/AChristmasCarol''. Brian Desmond Hurst was the director, and the screenplay was written by Noel Langley (''Film/TheWizardOfOz'').
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[caption-width-right:300:Alastair Sim as Scrooge.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It is against the rules to talk about the audience reaction in this section.


''Scrooge'' is a 1951 British film adaptation of the novel ''Literature/AChristmasCarol'', regarded by many as the finest screen version of Dickens's classic.

to:

''Scrooge'' is a 1951 British film adaptation of the novel ''Literature/AChristmasCarol'', regarded by many as the finest screen version of Dickens's classic.
''Literature/AChristmasCarol''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Scrooge'' is a 1951 British film adaptation of the novel ''Literature/AChristmasCarol'', regarded by many as the finest screen version of Dickens' classic.

to:

''Scrooge'' is a 1951 British film adaptation of the novel ''Literature/AChristmasCarol'', regarded by many as the finest screen version of Dickens' Dickens's classic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/scrooge_1951_alastair_sim.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Scrooge'' is a 1951 British film adaptation of the novel ''Literature/AChristmasCarol''.

to:

''Scrooge'' is a 1951 British film adaptation of the novel ''Literature/AChristmasCarol''.
''Literature/AChristmasCarol'', regarded by many as the finest screen version of Dickens' classic.


Added DiffLines:

Top