Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / CrimsonTide

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChromosomeCasting: Besides Hunter's wife appearing very briefly at the beginning of the film, the rest of the cast are all men.

Added: 717

Changed: 70

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** During the discussion on whether the Russians have already launched their missiles, Zimmer claims (in somewhat more colorful language) that one doesn't prep nuclear missiles without the intent to immediately use them. This ignores the entirety of the UsefulNotes/ColdWar, where both sides armed their missiles at various points but never used them.

to:

** During the discussion on whether the Russians have already launched their missiles, Zimmer claims (in somewhat more colorful language) that one doesn't prep nuclear missiles without the intent to immediately use them. [[note]]"You don't put on a condom unless you're gonna fuck!"[[/note]] This ignores the entirety of the UsefulNotes/ColdWar, where both sides armed their missiles at various points but never used them.


Added DiffLines:

--->'''Anderson:''' My primary concern here is the breakdown in the system. In this instance, the system failed because the two senior officers did not work to resolve their differences while preserving the chain of command. Now you may have been proven right, Mr. Hunter, but in so far as the letter of the law is concerned, you were both right -- and you were also both wrong. [...] Off the record, you've both created one hell of a mess. A mutiny aboard a United States nuclear submarine. Violation of nuclear launch protocol. For the record, it is the conclusion of this panel that your actions aboard the ''Alabama'' were consistent with the best traditions of the Navy and in the interests of the United States.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Dougherty punishing the sailor for not being able to answer the question who played the enemy commander in Film/TheEnemyBelow would be punished himself for punishing an enlisted sailor for no reason. Fact: Superior officers, commissioned or non-commissioned, or enlisted superior are never permitted to arbitrarily punish junior sailors with physical exercise such as a basic training drill instructor would do. This is considered abusive treatment, an illegal order, and the subordinate is not obligated to obey. Further, the officer can be reprimanded for misusing their authority.

to:

** Dougherty punishing the sailor for not being able to answer the question who played the enemy commander in Film/TheEnemyBelow ''Film/TheEnemyBelow'' would be punished himself for punishing an enlisted sailor for no reason. Fact: Superior officers, commissioned or non-commissioned, or enlisted superior are never permitted to arbitrarily punish junior sailors with physical exercise such as a basic training drill instructor would do. This is considered abusive treatment, an illegal order, and the subordinate is not obligated to obey. Further, the officer can be reprimanded for misusing their authority.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To be fair, in a deleted scene which slightly extends the Court Martial scene, we see Zimmer walking out of what would seem to have been his hearing ... and he very much looks like the board were entirely unimpresed with his conduct and made sure he knew.

to:

** To be fair, in a deleted scene which slightly extends the Court Martial scene, we see Zimmer walking out of what would seem to have been his hearing ... and he very much looks like the board were entirely unimpresed with took a hammer to his conduct and made sure he knew.career.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HotSubOnSubAction: The ''Akula'' class. Or is it? Bum bum bum.

to:

* HotSubOnSubAction: The ''Alabama'' gets into a skirmish with an ''Akula'' class. Or is it? Bum bum bum.class hunter-killer. The first round damages the comms on the ''Alabama''; round 2 ends with the destruction of the ''Akula'' and the near-sinking of the ''Alabama''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OnlyKnownByTheirNickname: Chief Walters is only ever referred to as "COB", his rank as Chief of the Boat[[note: senior enlisted advisor to the CO and XO[[/note]]. We don't even get his first name.

to:

* OnlyKnownByTheirNickname: Chief Walters is only ever referred to as "COB", his rank as Chief of the Boat[[note: Boat[[note]] senior enlisted advisor to the CO and XO[[/note]]. We don't even get his first name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HighTurnoverRate: It's briefly mentioned that Ramsey has gone through eight or nine [[NumberTwo XOs]] in 1994.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OnlyKnownByTheirNickname: Chief Walters is only ever referred to as "COB", his rank as Chief of the Boat[[note: senior enlisted advisor to the CO and XO[[/note]]. We don't even get his first name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DutchAngle: Noticeably used a couple of times in the latter half of the movie.

to:

* DutchAngle: Noticeably used a couple of times in the latter half of the movie.movie, and sometimes [[JustifiedTrope justified]]: some of the dutch angles are a result of the camera staying "level" while the submarine manoeuvres. The Alabama's bridge set was built on a gigantic hydraulic gimbal so that it could actually be tilted, to add a dash of realism, or possibly EnforcedMethodActing, depending on your perspective.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*{{Novelization}}: By co-writer Richard P. Henrick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Modern sub-launched ballistic missiles are solid-fueled; the setup time is things like getting the guidance systems aligned and such.


* ActivationSequence: It takes eight minutes to fuel a submarine's nuclear missiles. It doesn't show the fuel actually flowing through the pipes, but there are progress reports during a scuffle between the captain and XO on the bridge. It's also mentioned that the Soviet missiles, being much larger [=ICBMs=], need fourteen minutes to fuel up. It was an intel report that the Soviet fuel-up order had been given which motivated the Captain and his loyalists to begin the ''Alabama's'' launch protocol.

to:

* ActivationSequence: It takes eight 14 minutes to fuel a submarine's nuclear missiles. It doesn't show for the fuel actually flowing through the pipes, but there are progress reports during a scuffle between the captain and XO on the bridge. ''Alabama'''s missiles to become ready to launch. It's also mentioned that the Soviet missiles, being much larger [=ICBMs=], need fourteen minutes would take a full hour to fuel up. It was an intel report that the Soviet fuel-up order had been given which motivated the Captain and his loyalists to begin the ''Alabama's'' launch protocol.prepare for launch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StoutStrength: COB Walters is a chubby man (a deleted scene even has Ramsey concerned about how overweight he is), but one who seems to have some muscle and proves stedfast during the Mutinies.

to:

* StoutStrength: COB Walters is a chubby man (a deleted scene even has Ramsey concerned about how overweight he is), but one who seems to have some muscle and proves stedfast steadfast during the Mutinies.



-->'''Ramsey:''' "Mr. Hunter, I've made my decision, I'm captain of this boat, [[PrecisionFStrike NOW SHUT THE FUCK UP!]]"

to:

-->'''Ramsey:''' "Mr. Mr. Hunter, I've made my decision, I'm captain of this boat, [[PrecisionFStrike NOW SHUT THE FUCK UP!]]"UP!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The conflict between Ramsey and Hunter demonstrates why there ''are'' two keys necessary to launch the missiles, so that one of them can stop the other from starting WorldWarIII.
** In addition, when the launch order comes in, two officers are required to authenticate it. One reads a random series of letters printed on the order while the other one reads a series of letters from an authenticator kept aboard ship. If both sequences match, the order is authentic.

to:

** The conflict between Ramsey and Hunter demonstrates why there ''are'' two keys necessary to launch the missiles, so that one of them can stop the other from starting WorldWarIII.
** In addition, when
WorldWarIII. The launch trigger itself is kept behind a ''third'' lock with only the weapons officer having access.
** When a
launch order comes in, two officers the communications officer and operations officer are required both needed to authenticate it. One reads a random series of letters printed on the order while the other one reads a series of letters from an authenticator The authenticators are kept aboard ship. If both sequences match, behind two safe doors and each officer only has one of the combinations. And then those two, plus the CO and XO, have to agree that the order is authentic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Rivetti:''' 'Cause it takes a thousand yards for the torpedoes to arm! Jesus, who'd you fuck to get on this ship?!

to:

'''Rivetti:''' 'Cause it takes a thousand yards for the torpedoes to arm! Jesus, [[AskAStupidQuestion who'd you fuck to get on this ship?!ship]]?!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Note on the title: "Crimson Tide" is the nickname for the sports teams at the University of Alabama.

to:

Note on the title: "Crimson Tide" is the nickname for the sports teams at the [[UsefulNotes/CollegiateAmericanFootballConferences University of Alabama.
Alabama]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add

Added DiffLines:

** Picking Hunter as XO of a SSBN would not be by just by the Captain through a simple interview but by a Navy board or even the SSBN squadron commander, senior to Captain Ramsey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Improve


** The officer punishing the sailor for not being able to answer the question who played the enemy commander in Film/TheEnemyBelow would one, be punished for punishing an enlisted sailor for no reason.

to:

** The officer Dougherty punishing the sailor for not being able to answer the question who played the enemy commander in Film/TheEnemyBelow would one, be punished himself for punishing an enlisted sailor for no reason.reason. Fact: Superior officers, commissioned or non-commissioned, or enlisted superior are never permitted to arbitrarily punish junior sailors with physical exercise such as a basic training drill instructor would do. This is considered abusive treatment, an illegal order, and the subordinate is not obligated to obey. Further, the officer can be reprimanded for misusing their authority.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add

Added DiffLines:

** The officer punishing the sailor for not being able to answer the question who played the enemy commander in Film/TheEnemyBelow would one, be punished for punishing an enlisted sailor for no reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NervesOfSteel: Hunter is almost always calm under pressure, be it arguing with Captain Ramsey, getting ''punched'' by Captain Ramsey or in a fight with the ''Akula'' - he ''never'' looses his cool.

to:

* NervesOfSteel: Hunter is almost always calm under pressure, be it arguing with Captain Ramsey, getting ''punched'' by Captain Ramsey or in a fight with the ''Akula'' - he ''never'' looses loses his cool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrueCompanions: Rear Admiral Anderson and Captain Ramsey, judging by the unshakable trust between them.
-->'''Rear Admiral Anderson''': I have known Captain Ramsey for almost 30 years. We served together on more than a few occasions. If he is lying this will be the first I've heard of it.

Added: 186

Changed: 332

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a technical bit of artistic license, and removed inaccurate information. Trident II D5 missiles used on Ohio-class submarines are entirely capable of first-strike accuracy.


** An SSBN would not be called upon to conduct the kind of nuclear strike the situation calls for. One, to avoid the very communications issue we see happen and two, because submarine-launched ballistic missiles are not considered accurate enough to take out hardened [=ICBM=] silos like the ones the renegades control. In reality, the U.S. would use its own [=ICBMs=], or if time was really of the essence, nuclear-tipped missiles from ships off the coast or stealth bombers.

to:

** An SSBN would not be called upon to conduct the kind of nuclear strike the situation calls for. One, for, due to avoid the very communications issue we see happen and two, because submarine-launched ballistic missiles are not considered accurate enough to take out hardened [=ICBM=] silos like the ones the renegades control. In reality, the U.S. would use its own [=ICBMs=], or if time was really of the essence, nuclear-tipped missiles from ships off the coast or stealth bombers.happen.


Added DiffLines:

** American [=SLBMs=][[note]]Submarine-Launched Ballistic Missiles[[/note]] use solid fuels that do not require fueling, but the fueling sequence allows for a better RaceAgainstTheClock.

Added: 467

Changed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwoKeyedLock: The conflict between Ramsey and Hunter demonstrates why there ''are'' two keys necessary to launch the missiles.

to:

* TwoKeyedLock: TwoKeyedLock:
**
The conflict between Ramsey and Hunter demonstrates why there ''are'' two keys necessary to launch the missiles.missiles, so that one of them can stop the other from starting WorldWarIII.
** In addition, when the launch order comes in, two officers are required to authenticate it. One reads a random series of letters printed on the order while the other one reads a series of letters from an authenticator kept aboard ship. If both sequences match, the order is authentic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As much of the film tries to present the situation as BothSidesHaveAPoint (including the final court martial), the reality is that Ramsey performed greater atrocities for the sake of performing his assumed orders than Hunter does trying to prevent them (he certainly didn't threatened to kill anybody).

to:

** As much of the film tries to present the situation as BothSidesHaveAPoint (including the final court martial), the reality is that Ramsey performed committed greater atrocities for the sake of performing his assumed orders than Hunter does trying to prevent them (he (Hunter certainly didn't threatened threaten to kill anybody).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmericaSavesTheDay: [[SettingUpdate After a fashion]]. The plot is loosely based on/inspired by events aboard the Soviet submarine B-59 during the Cuban Missile Crisis, with Ramsey playing the part of Captain Valentin Savitsky, and Hunter playing the second-in-comand Vasily Arkhipov. In this case, saving the day means [[MindScrew not]] firing a nuke and triggering a nuclear war. To the film's merit, the script justifies the Americans' involvement, and in the end it's the Russian government's own troops who take back the rebel base.


Added DiffLines:

* MakeTheBearAngryAgain: By way of RenegadeRussian General Radchenko, though in this case the angryness is extinguished by the bear itself before it goes completely and irreversibly angry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected information.


->''"The three most powerful men in the world: the President of the United States of America; the President of the Russian Republic; and the Captain of a United States ballistic missile submarine."''

to:

->''"The three most powerful men in the world: the President of the United States of America; the President of the Russian Republic; and the Captain of a United States ballistic nuclear missile submarine."''

Added: 180

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Hunter''': Well I'm Captain Kirk, you're Scotty, I need more power.

to:

-->'''Hunter''': --->'''Hunter''': Well I'm Captain Kirk, you're Scotty, I need more power.


Added DiffLines:

* SirSwearsALot: Okay, pretty much all the sailors swear like, well, sailors, but Ramsey is the worst offender.
-->"I'M THE COMMANDER OF THIS FUCKING SHIP! GIMME THE GODDAMN KEY!!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CantKillYouStillNeedYou: Captain Ramsay threatens Weps with a gun to get the launch trigger. Weps is the only person on the ship that knows the combination to the safe with the launch trigger in it, and refuses to open it. The captain counts to three, but curses when he realizes that if he kills Weps, ''no one'' will be able to open the safe. [[IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure So he points his gun at another sailor's head]], [[JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope and states that the sailor will die on the count of three]]. Weps is clearly horrified and relents, opening the safe. [[spoiler: Fortunately, the delay cased is enough that Hunter is able to remove the launch key in the CIC, disabling the launch system.]]

to:

* CantKillYouStillNeedYou: Captain Ramsay threatens Weps with a gun to get the launch trigger. Weps is the only person on the ship that knows the combination to the safe with the launch trigger in it, and refuses to open it. The captain counts to three, but curses when he realizes that if he kills Weps, ''no one'' will be able to open the safe. [[IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure So he points his gun at another sailor's head]], [[JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope and states that the sailor will die on the count of three]]. Weps is clearly horrified and relents, opening the safe. [[spoiler: Fortunately, the delay cased caused is enough that Hunter is able to remove the launch key in the CIC, disabling the launch system.]]



** Commander Hunter makes for a competent skipper during his short stint in command. In the end, Ramseys recomendation (which is agreed by the board) is that Hunter should be given his first formal command at the earliest possible date given his performance in this crisis.

to:

** Commander Hunter makes for a competent skipper during his short stint in command. In the end, Ramseys Ramsey's recomendation (which is agreed by the board) is that Hunter should be given his first formal command at the earliest possible date given his performance in this crisis.



* DeathGlare: Hunter gives one to the four officers, especially to his long term best friend Weps, who busted the Captain out and led him into control at gunpoint to seize control. Every single one of them flinches from it. Weps can't even meet it.

to:

* DeathGlare: Hunter gives one to the four officers, especially to his long term long-term best friend Weps, who busted the Captain out and led him into control at gunpoint to seize control. Every single one of them flinches from it. Weps can't even meet it.



** Hunter clearly feelt this towards Weps when he saw him standing with the other officers against him.

to:

** Hunter clearly feelt feels this towards Weps when he saw upon seeing him standing with the other officers against him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AloofLeaderAffableSubordinate: [[TheCaptain Captain Ramsey]] is the hardass in contrast to the more reasonable [[NumberTwo XO Hunter]].

Added: 507

Changed: 259

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RenegadeRussian: Vladimir Radchenko. Ramsey even notes that this guy is playing a whole different game than the good old-fashioned commies did.

to:

* RenegadeRussian: Vladimir Radchenko. Ramsey even notes that this guy is playing a whole different game than the good old-fashioned commies did. A deleted scene elaborates on this, showing him (quite seriously) telling a reporter that he believes Russia should conquer the Japanese islands, and that a suitable foreign policy would be to kill ''900,000'' people for every Russian killed by a foreigner.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Retirony}}: A deleted scene reveals that Walters is on his last cruise. [[spoiler:He doesn't die though.]]


Added DiffLines:

* SkewedPriorities: A deleted scene shows several members of the crew watching Radchenko on the news, and showing more interest in the size of the reporters breasts than the threats Radchenko is making.


Added DiffLines:

* StoutStrength: COB Walters is a chubby man (a deleted scene even has Ramsey concerned about how overweight he is), but one who seems to have some muscle and proves stedfast during the Mutinies.

Added: 1231

Changed: 392

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: Ramsey notes to Hunter as the Alabama is leaving port that he cannot and will not abide kiss-asses...



* CantKillYouStillNeedYou: Captain Ramsay threatens Weps with a gun to get the launch trigger. Weps is the only person on the ship that knows the combination to the safe with the launch trigger in it, and refuses to open it. The captain counts to three, but curses when he realizes that if he kills Weps, ''no one'' will be able to open the safe. [[IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure So he points his gun at another sailor's head]], [[JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope and states that the sailor will die on the count of three]]. Weps is clearly horrified and relents, opening the safe. [[spoiler: Fortunately, the delay is long enough that Hunter is able to remove the launch key in the CIC.]]

to:

* CantKillYouStillNeedYou: Captain Ramsay threatens Weps with a gun to get the launch trigger. Weps is the only person on the ship that knows the combination to the safe with the launch trigger in it, and refuses to open it. The captain counts to three, but curses when he realizes that if he kills Weps, ''no one'' will be able to open the safe. [[IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure So he points his gun at another sailor's head]], [[JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope and states that the sailor will die on the count of three]]. Weps is clearly horrified and relents, opening the safe. [[spoiler: Fortunately, the delay cased is long enough that Hunter is able to remove the launch key in the CIC.CIC, disabling the launch system.]]



** Commander Hunter makes for a competent skipper during his short stint in command.

to:

** Commander Hunter makes for a competent skipper during his short stint in command. In the end, Ramseys recomendation (which is agreed by the board) is that Hunter should be given his first formal command at the earliest possible date given his performance in this crisis.



* DeathGlare: Hunter gives one to the four officers, especially to his long term best friend Weps, who busted the Captain out and led him into control at gunpoint to seize control. Every single one of them flinches from it. Weps can't even meet it.



* EtTuBrute: Ramsey is surprised and disappointed that Master Chief Walters is among the mutineers.

to:

* EtTuBrute: EtTuBrute:
**
Ramsey is surprised and disappointed that Master Chief Walters is among the mutineers.mutineers.
** Hunter clearly feelt this towards Weps when he saw him standing with the other officers against him.



** Nevertheless, the men have a near fanatical devotion to Ramsey.

to:

** Nevertheless, some of the men have a near fanatical devotion to Ramsey.



** Averted insomuch as its noted that the rebels more or less folded when the Russian Army stormed in, with less than a hundred killed in the clash before loyalist control was restored.



** To be fair, in a deleted scene which slightly extends the Court Martial scene, we see Zimmer walking out of what would seem to have been his hearing ... and he very much looks like the board were entirely unimpresed with his conduct and made sure he knew.



* NervesOfSteel: Hunter is almost always calm under pressure, be it arguing with Captain Ramsey, or in a fight with the ''Akula''.

to:

* NervesOfSteel: Hunter is almost always calm under pressure, be it arguing with Captain Ramsey, getting ''punched'' by Captain Ramsey or in a fight with the ''Akula''.''Akula'' - he ''never'' looses his cool.


Added DiffLines:

** He also casts away any doubt about being unable to make the big decisions when he gives the men inside the bilge bay every second he can, but ultimatly firmly gives the order to seal them in to drown to save the ship.

Top