Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / BlackHawkDown

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WouldHitAGirl: one of the Rangers hesitates to shoot a Somali woman who is picking up a rifle. His colleague kills her without hesitation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MonochromeCasting: With the exception of Kurth, all the other American characters are white.[[note]]The book explains that there are aren't many black rangers because few black candidates are able to pass the swimming requirements, a side-effect of American socioeconomics.[[/note]]

to:

* MonochromeCasting: With the exception of Kurth, all the other American characters are white.white, in real life the Ranger company only having 2 black members.[[note]]The book explains that there are aren't many black rangers because few black candidates are able to pass the swimming requirements, a side-effect of American socioeconomics.[[/note]]



* RealityIsUnrealistic: People have pointed out that the soldiers never use the downed helicopters' mounted miniguns to defend the crash sites. Miniguns do not work without electricity, making them functionally useless.

to:

* RealityIsUnrealistic: People have pointed out that the soldiers never use the downed helicopters' mounted miniguns to defend the crash sites. Miniguns do not work without electricity, making them functionally useless.useless (although Shughart did use their ammunition to reload his M14).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InterserviceRivalry: Between the Rangers and the Deltas. Steele outright accuses the Deltas of being undisciplined cowboys while Delta regards the Rangers as subpar (at least compared to the unquestionably elite Delta Force) soldiers hamstrung by conventional Army thinking.

to:

* InterserviceRivalry: Between the Rangers and the Deltas. Steele outright accuses the Deltas of being undisciplined cowboys while Delta regards the Rangers as subpar (at least compared to the unquestionably elite Delta Force) soldiers hamstrung by conventional Army thinking. Most military viewers tend to side with Steele, trying to keep discipline in a unit of 100 mostly teenage soldiers who idolise the older and more experienced Delta operators who are given much more leeway to do things there own way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cool Guns has been disambiguated.


* CoolGuns: Whereas the Rangers have only [=M16s=], some with [=M203=] grenade launchers, [=M249s=] and in one case an [=M60=], all with iron sights... the Deltas not only have different helmets and tactical vests but also Colt Model 727 (14.5" barrel) and 733 (11.5") carbines with red-dot optics and weapon lights. An older [=CAR-15=] and an anachronistic [=M4A1=] are also seen. Shughart, one of the Delta marksmen, carries an old-style scoped [=M14=], and his partner Gordon carries a suppressed and accessorized [=M733=], both with camouflage paint schemes. Captain Steele and a Ranger medic also use the [=M733=], but without any accessories. The Delta Force operators are also distinguished by their .45 caliber M1911 pistols, a notable contrast to the 9mm Beretta M9 pistols carried the rangers. The M9 was the standard issue pistol for the US Army at the time.
** According to the book, Shughart's use of the clumsy but powerful M14 is TruthInTelevision. The other operators would apparently tease him for insisting on it. Later on, while seething about his ammunition[[note]]high-velocity armor piercing rounds that passed right through his unarmored targets, causing minimal damage that could be shrugged off by fighters hopped up on khat[[/note]] (and everything else), SFC Howe would decide that Shughart was the smartest guy in the unit[[note]]the heavier 7.62x51mm rounds fired by the [=M14=] caused devastating wounds that couldn't be shrugged off[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Zigzagged in a deleted scene, in which a Ranger machine gunner ''does'' notice armed men moving inside a nearby building and opens fire... nearly hitting Sanderson and his fellow Delta operators, who were the source of said movement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SoldiersAtTheRear: One soldier has always been away from the fighting, a fact he says isn't his fault. It's because he has a rare and valuable skill beloved by the infantry that keeps him busy: he can type. [[note]]Although this might seem absurd to modern viewers, remember that in the early 90's, personal home computers were a relatively new thing and not everyone knew how to type or use those archaic, command line-based data entry systems.[[/note]]

to:

* SoldiersAtTheRear: One soldier has always been away from the fighting, a fact he says isn't his fault. It's because he has a rare and valuable skill beloved by the infantry that keeps him busy: he can type. [[note]]Although this might seem absurd to modern viewers, remember that in the early 90's, personal home computers were a relatively new thing and not everyone knew how to type or use those archaic, command line-based data entry systems.[[/note]][[/note]] Inverted when the rescue convoy is gearing up to fight its' way to the downed helicopters and rear echelon soldiers grab their rifles and jump onboard.



* SuspiciouslyAproposMusic: As the helicopters fly out a version of Voodoo Child is performed by Stevie Ray Vaughan, who died in a helicopter accident just a couple of years before the events of this film.

to:

* SuspiciouslyAproposMusic: As the helicopters fly out a version of Voodoo Child is performed by Stevie Ray Vaughan, who died in a helicopter accident just a couple of years before the events of this film. The final titles feature a version of 'The Minstrel Boy', a tune written by Irish composer Thomas Moore. A keen abolitionist he served in the British Admiralty whose Royal Navy squadrons crushed the African/Arabic slave trade, the centre of which was Mogadishu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added

Added DiffLines:

* SuspiciouslyAproposMusic: As the helicopters fly out a version of Voodoo Child is performed by Stevie Ray Vaughan, who died in a helicopter accident just a couple of years before the events of this film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added

Added DiffLines:

** The Somali militia knows that the troops are coming by simply having a kid sit at an overlook of the airport and call on a cell phone when he sees the helicopters have taken off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForDoomTheBellTolls: A tubular bell rings out when Hoot volunteers to take Pilla's place in the Humvee gunner's spot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''When I go home... and people ask me: "Hey, Hoot, why do you do it, man? Why? You some kind of war junkie?" I won't say a goddamn word. They won't understand why we do it. They won't understand it's about the men next to you. And that's it.''

to:

->''When ->''"When I go home... and people ask me: "Hey, 'Hey, Hoot, why do you do it, man? Why? You some kind of war junkie?" junkie?' I won't say a goddamn word. They won't understand why we do it. They won't understand it's about the men next to you. And that's it.''"''

Added: 102

Changed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trying to fix some example indentation


* ActionFilmQuietDramaScene: Not many, but a notable one is Hoot comforting Sgt. Eversmann after they were unable to save Smith.

to:

* ActionFilmQuietDramaScene: ActionFilmQuietDramaScene:
**
Not many, but a notable one is Hoot comforting Sgt. Eversmann after they were unable to save Smith.



-->'''Hassan''': You are the ranger who kills my people?\\

to:

-->'''Hassan''': --->'''Hassan''': You are the ranger who kills my people?\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, Aidid's fighters were banking on this tendency in the Americans. Yousuf Dahir Mo'alim told Bowden, for the book, that they felt the best way to hurt to Americans was to somehow shoot down one of the helicopters, which would make them rush to the scene where they could be bled.

to:

** Also, Aidid's fighters were banking on this tendency in the Americans. Yousuf Dahir Mo'alim told Bowden, for the book, that they felt the best way to hurt to the Americans was to somehow shoot down one of the helicopters, which would make them rush to the scene where they could be bled. attacked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MustHaveCaffeine: A group of Rangers and Delta operators are bunkered up inside of a building, besieged by Aidid's militia. Grimes copes with the stress of the situation by finding a coffee pot somewhere and brewing some coffee, which he offers to one of the Deltas.

to:

* MustHaveCaffeine: A group of Rangers and Delta operators are bunkered up inside of a building, besieged by Aidid's militia. Grimes copes with the stress of the situation by finding a coffee pot somewhere and brewing some coffee, which he offers to one of the Deltas. Doubles as an actually useful thing to do (rather than just something for Grimes to do to keep busy), as tired soldiers in a combat situation can definitely use a small hit of caffeine to keep their edge, especially if things stay quiet long enough for them to start crashing/coming down from the adrenaline high.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InterserviceRivalry: Between the Rangers and the Deltas. Steele outright accuses the Deltas of being undisciplined cowboys while Delta regards the Rangers as subpar (at least compared to the unquestionably elite Delta Force)soldiers hamstrung by conventional Army thinking.

to:

* InterserviceRivalry: Between the Rangers and the Deltas. Steele outright accuses the Deltas of being undisciplined cowboys while Delta regards the Rangers as subpar (at least compared to the unquestionably elite Delta Force)soldiers Force) soldiers hamstrung by conventional Army thinking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisasterDominoes: The convoy is being guided to the crash site by a surveillance plane overhead. However it does not speak directly to the convoy commander but to the headquarters then to the communications helicopter and then to Colonel McKnight. This causes a delay which means by the time they get the order to turn they have either missed the correct road or worse, turn down the wrong street entirely. Had the convoy been guided purely by the surveillance plane it could have secured the first crash site in time, freeing up other forces to head towards Durant's downed aircraft.

to:

* DisasterDominoes: The convoy is being guided to the crash site by a surveillance plane overhead. However it does not speak directly to the convoy commander but to the headquarters then to the communications helicopter and then to Colonel McKnight.[=McKnight=]. This causes a delay which means by the time they get the order to turn they have either missed the correct road or worse, turn down the wrong street entirely. Had the convoy been guided purely by the surveillance plane it could have secured the first crash site in time, freeing up other forces to head towards Durant's downed aircraft.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DangerDeadpan: The pilots of Super Six-One calmly report that they're going down after the chopper is hit, and the co-pilot even manages to make a deadpan joke to the pilot. Mike Durant of Super Six-Four is portrayed as a lot more nervous, but his voice is still calm and even as he reports that the chopper is going down. Super Six-One wasn't as badly hit as Super Six-Four, where the helicopter was damaged, but then lost the tail rotor, while Six-One essentially had an engine get destroyed, but still had more control over the aircraft.

to:

* DangerDeadpan: The pilots of Super Six-One calmly report that they're going down after the chopper is hit, and the co-pilot even manages to make a deadpan joke to the pilot. Mike Durant of Super Six-Four is portrayed as a lot more nervous, but his voice is still calm and even as he reports that the chopper is going down. Super Six-One wasn't as badly hit as Super Six-Four, where the helicopter was damaged, but then lost the tail rotor, while Six-One essentially had an engine get destroyed, but still had more control over the aircraft. TruthInTelevision, you don't get to be a professional pilot - much less a military pilot - if you panic easily, and pilots are specifically trained to stay as calm as possible and continue reporting the conditions as they change, to keep HQ aware of the situation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CavemenVsAstronautsDebate: A heated argument between soldiers near the beginning of the movie over whether or not "limo" is a real word, regardless of its presence or absence in the dictionary, and therefore legal to use in a game of ''TabletopGame/{{Scrabble}}''.

to:

* CavemenVsAstronautsDebate: A heated argument between soldiers near the beginning of the movie over whether or not "limo" is a real word, regardless of its presence or absence in the dictionary, and therefore legal to use in a game of ''TabletopGame/{{Scrabble}}''.''TabletopGame/{{Scrabble}}''[[note]]in case you're wondering, "limo" ''is'' legal to play in the game[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Galentine trying to raise them on coms. [[note]][[TruthInTelevision In real life]], radioman [=PFC=] Jason Moore couldn't talk to ''anybody'' on his backpack radio, as seen in the film when Galentine in his role tries to contact Capt Steele after Blackburn's fall. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine unknowingly clutched the wire to his radio mike between his rifle stock and the rope, and friction burned it through.[[/note]]

to:

** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Galentine trying to raise them on coms. [[note]][[TruthInTelevision In real life]], the chalk's radioman was [=PFC=] Jason Moore Moore, who couldn't talk to ''anybody'' on his backpack radio, as seen in the film when Galentine in his role tries to contact Capt Steele after Blackburn's fall. radio. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine Moore unknowingly clutched had the wire to his radio mike between his rifle stock and the rope, and friction burned it through.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Galentine trying to raise them on coms. [[note]][[TruthInTelevision In real life]], Galentine couldn't talk to ''anybody'' on his backpack radio, as seen in the film when he tries to contact Capt Steele after Blackburn's fall. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine unknowingly clutched the wire to his radio mike between his rifle stock and the rope, and friction burned it through.[[/note]]

to:

** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Galentine trying to raise them on coms. [[note]][[TruthInTelevision In real life]], Galentine radioman [=PFC=] Jason Moore couldn't talk to ''anybody'' on his backpack radio, as seen in the film when he Galentine in his role tries to contact Capt Steele after Blackburn's fall. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine unknowingly clutched the wire to his radio mike between his rifle stock and the rope, and friction burned it through.[[/note]]

Added: 121

Removed: 121

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DescriptionCut: "Convoy is encountering light resistance." Cut to the convoy getting shot and blown up every which way.



* DescriptionCut: "Convoy is encountering light resistance." Cut to the convoy getting shot and blown up every which way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DesecratingTheDead: There's a brief glimpse of the mob lifting Randy Shughart's body out of Durant's helicopter and carrying it like a trophy; he has already had his shirt ripped off. This hints at the real life events, where Shughart's and the bodies of the other dead at the crash site were stripped and dragged through the city. This was eventually broadcast on American television and resulted in popular opinion turning against the Somalia mission.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Galentine trying to raise them on coms. ([[TruthInTelevision In real life]], Galentine couldn't talk to ''anybody'' on his backpack radio, as seen when he tries to contact Capt Steele early on. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine unknowingly clutched the wire to his radio mike against the rope, and friction burned it through.)

to:

** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Galentine trying to raise them on coms. ([[TruthInTelevision [[note]][[TruthInTelevision In real life]], Galentine couldn't talk to ''anybody'' on his backpack radio, as seen in the film when he tries to contact Capt Steele early on. after Blackburn's fall. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine unknowingly clutched the wire to his radio mike against between his rifle stock and the rope, and friction burned it through.)[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Gallentine trying to raise them on coms. ([[TruthInTelevision In real life]], Galentine had trouble radioing ''anybody'', as seen when he tries to contact Capt Steele early on. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine accidentally clutched the wire to his radio mike against the rope, and the friction burned it through.)

to:

** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Gallentine Galentine trying to raise them on coms. ([[TruthInTelevision In real life]], Galentine had trouble radioing ''anybody'', couldn't talk to ''anybody'' on his backpack radio, as seen when he tries to contact Capt Steele early on. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine accidentally unknowingly clutched the wire to his radio mike against the rope, and the friction burned it through.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** General Garrison wanted [[AwesomePersonnelCarrier light armor]] and [[CoolPlane gunship support]][[note]]notably an AC-130[[/note]] for his men, but the request was denied so they were stuck with Humvees, Black Hawks and Little Birds.

to:

** General Garrison wanted [[AwesomePersonnelCarrier light armor]] and [[CoolPlane gunship support]][[note]]notably an AC-130[[/note]] for his men, but the request was denied so they were stuck with Humvees, Black Hawks and Little Birds.[[note]]In reality it was bureaucrats at the Pentagon itself who, having initially assigned some guships to the UN operation, pulled them out again before they had done more than blow up a few warehouses and driven Aidid underground.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Gallentine trying to raise them on coms.

to:

** When Nelson, Twombly, and Yurek leave the vicinity of the target building to go to the Super Six One crash site, they apparently don't hear Gallentine trying to raise them on coms. ([[TruthInTelevision In real life]], Galentine had trouble radioing ''anybody'', as seen when he tries to contact Capt Steele early on. When he fast-roped from the helicopter, Galentine accidentally clutched the wire to his radio mike against the rope, and the friction burned it through.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Retirony}}: According to the book, most of the men in the platoon were just married, intending to marry, intending to get a new job or a promotion, a new father, an expecting father, etc. Justified because marrying and having kids young is very common in the military for various reasons, most prominent being that they are in a career where they could be killed at any moment.

to:

* {{Retirony}}: According to the book, most of the men in the platoon were just married, intending to marry, intending to get a new job or a promotion, a new father, an expecting father, etc. Justified because marrying and having kids young is very common in the military for various reasons, most prominent being that they are in a career where they could be killed at any moment.reasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheWarlord: The objective of the Army Rangers is to capture the generals and lieutenants of Somali warlord Adid, to weaken Adid's power and possibly reveal Adid's hideouts. Adid's goons make a habit of butchering the locals and seizing humanitarian aid supplies for themselves. Of course, this mission [[GoneHorriblyWrong goes horribly wrong]], kicking off the events of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Pretty sure the trope is In-Universe only


* HeadbuttOfLove: Non-romantic example. At the end of the movie, two Rangers who have just returned safely to their base do this as a sort of manly, utterly exhausted alternative to a hug. [[AndKnowingIsHalfTheBattle In real life, when done with helmets on, this is known as "Turtle Fucking".]]

to:

* HeadbuttOfLove: Non-romantic example. At the end of the movie, two Rangers who have just returned safely to their base do this as a sort of manly, utterly exhausted alternative to a hug. [[AndKnowingIsHalfTheBattle In real life, when done with helmets on, this is known as "Turtle Fucking".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CavemenVsAstronautsDebate: A heated argument between soldiers near the beginning of the movie over whether or not "limo" is a real word, regardless of its presence or absence in the dictionary, and therefore legal to use in a game of Scrabble.

to:

* CavemenVsAstronautsDebate: A heated argument between soldiers near the beginning of the movie over whether or not "limo" is a real word, regardless of its presence or absence in the dictionary, and therefore legal to use in a game of Scrabble.''TabletopGame/{{Scrabble}}''.

Added: 430

Removed: 430

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FailedState: The film dramatizes the US Army's effort to remove violent warlords from Somalia, where bands of thugs are hoarding relief supplies meant for the sick and starving people. [[TruthInTelevision As was true in real life]], the government of Somalia exists pretty much in name only, with the rival warlords having carved up the country into fiefdoms, with their armed militias imposing thug law on the helpless masses.



* FailedState: The film dramatizes the US Army's effort to remove violent warlords from Somalia, where bands of thugs are hoarding relief supplies meant for the sick and starving people. [[TruthInTelevision As was true in real life]], the government of Somalia exists pretty much in name only, with the rival warlords having carved up the country into fiefdoms, with their armed militias imposing thug law on the helpless masses.

Top