Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / AnOfficerAndASpy

Go To

OR

Added: 200

Changed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film centers on [[BasedOnATrueStory the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair]]. [[UsefulNotes/GaulsWithGrenades French army]] officer Marie-Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.

to:

The film centers on [[BasedOnATrueStory the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair]]. [[UsefulNotes/GaulsWithGrenades French army]] officer Marie-Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire.

Picquart risks decides to risk his career and his life, going against his hierarchy and struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Almost everyone is an antisemite, and indeed the fact that Dreyfus is Jewish played a big part to make him suspicious once the military started looking for a mole. Homophobia is common, too.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Almost everyone every army man in the film is an antisemite, and indeed the fact that Dreyfus is Jewish played a big part to make him suspicious once the military started looking for a mole. Homophobia is common, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAlcatraz: Devil's Island, the remote overseas penal colony Dreyfus is sent to.

to:

* TheAlcatraz: Devil's Island, the remote overseas penal colony off the coast of French Guiana Dreyfus is sent to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film centers on [[BasedOnATrueStory the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair]]. French officer Marie-Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.

to:

The film centers on [[BasedOnATrueStory the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair]]. [[UsefulNotes/GaulsWithGrenades French army]] officer Marie-Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Alphonse Bertillon (Creator/MathieuAmalric) is presented as a graphology expert, while he wasn't one in RealLife (rather he was a criminologist who basically pioneered biometry). His antisemitic opinions on the Dreyfus case are still depicted however.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Alphonse Bertillon (Creator/MathieuAmalric) is presented as a graphology expert, while he wasn't one in RealLife (rather he was a criminologist who basically pioneered biometry). His antisemitic opinions on the Dreyfus case are still depicted however.however, and while the real experts who proved he was a fraud are AdaptedOut, his InsaneTrollLogic still mitigates this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WreckedWeapon: The film opens with the infamous [[https://winners-files.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/sale_110-public/38_1.jpg public degradation of Dreyfus]], with an officer stripping him of his military grade insignias and breaking his officer's sword.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ANaziByAnyOtherName: When the Dreyfus Affair is at its boiling point in the French public opinion, some anti-Dreyfus people start burning piles of the newspaper L'Aurore (which defends Dreyfus) in the streets, then attack shops owned by Jews, even painting stars of David on the shops frontage they don't wreck. Sounds familiar?

to:

* ANaziByAnyOtherName: When the Dreyfus Affair is at its boiling point in the French public opinion, some anti-Dreyfus people start burning piles of the newspaper L'Aurore (which defends Dreyfus) in the streets, then attack shops owned by Jews, even painting stars of David on the shops frontage shop frontages they don't wreck. Sounds familiar?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreedyJew: Not played straight. Rather, a number of people in the army believe in corruption by "international Jewry" and are satisfied with Dreyfus being degraded and exiled, with some even actively trying to sweep Picquart's investigation under the rug and forging evidences.

to:

* GreedyJew: Not played straight. Rather, a number of people in the army believe in corruption by "international Jewry" and are satisfied with Dreyfus being degraded and exiled, with some even actively trying to sweep Picquart's investigation under the rug and forging evidences.evidences to keep Dreyfus where he is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ANaziByAnyOtherName: When the Dreyfus Affair is at its boiling point in the French public opinion, some anti-Dreyfus people start burning piles of the newspaper L'Aurore (which defends Dreyfus) in the streets, then attack shops owned by Jews, even painting stars of David on the shops frontages they don't break. Sounds familiar?

to:

* ANaziByAnyOtherName: When the Dreyfus Affair is at its boiling point in the French public opinion, some anti-Dreyfus people start burning piles of the newspaper L'Aurore (which defends Dreyfus) in the streets, then attack shops owned by Jews, even painting stars of David on the shops frontages frontage they don't break.wreck. Sounds familiar?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Picquart is eventually pitted against his hierarchy, and still won't stop doing his best to prove the innocence of Dreyfus.

to:

* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Picquart is eventually pitted against his hierarchy, and still won't stop doing his best to prove the innocence of Dreyfus.Dreyfus despite knowing the risks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ANaziByAnyOtherName: When the Dreyfus Affair is at its boiling poing in the French public opinion, some anti-Dreyfus people start burning piles of the newspaper L'Aurore (which defends Dreyfus) in the streets and start attacking shops owned by Jews, even painting stars of David on the shops frontages they don't break. Sounds familiar?

to:

* ANaziByAnyOtherName: When the Dreyfus Affair is at its boiling poing point in the French public opinion, some anti-Dreyfus people start burning piles of the newspaper L'Aurore (which defends Dreyfus) in the streets and start attacking streets, then attack shops owned by Jews, even painting stars of David on the shops frontages they don't break. Sounds familiar?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ANaziByAnyOtherName: When the Dreyfus Affair is at its boiling poing in the French public opinion, some anti-Dreyfus people start burning piles of the newspaper L'Aurore (which defends Dreyfus) in the streets and start attacking shops owned by Jews, even painting stars of David on the shops frontages they don't break. Sounds familiar?

Added: 349

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''{{Jaccuse}}'') is a French historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.

to:

''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''{{Jaccuse}}'') ''[[{{Jaccuse}} J'accuse]]'') is a French historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.


Added DiffLines:

* [[{{Jaccuse}} J'accuse]]: The very French title, being about the TropeNamer affair, with the famous headline of Emile Zola's article in the newspaper L'Aurore.


Added DiffLines:

* TitleDrop: The French title ''J'accuse'' is pronounced when the newspaper L'Aurore with Emile Zola's article and its famous headline is [[ExtraExtraReadAllAboutIt sold in the streets]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''J'accuse'' - "I accuse") is a French historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.

to:

''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''J'accuse'' - "I accuse") ''{{Jaccuse}}'') is a French historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.

Added: 688

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film centers on the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair. French officer Marie-Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.

to:

The film centers on [[BasedOnATrueStory the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair.Affair]]. French officer Marie-Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.


Added DiffLines:

* TheAlcatraz: Devil's Island, the remote overseas penal colony Dreyfus is sent to.


Added DiffLines:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Almost everyone is an antisemite, and indeed the fact that Dreyfus is Jewish played a big part to make him suspicious once the military started looking for a mole. Homophobia is common, too.
* DrivenToSuicide: commandant Hubert Henry kills himself in his prison cell after the forging of his evidence against Dreyfus is exposed.


Added DiffLines:

* TheHandler: Commandant Henry is the handler for a prime source of intelligence, a cleaning woman who works in the German embassy.
* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Everyone in the film, though there are missing people from the RealLife Dreyfus Affair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Alphonse Bertillon (Creator/MathieuAmalric) is presented as a graphology expert, while he wasn't one in RealLife. His antisemitic opinions on the Dreyfus case are still depicted however.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Alphonse Bertillon (Creator/MathieuAmalric) is presented as a graphology expert, while he wasn't one in RealLife.RealLife (rather he was a criminologist who basically pioneered biometry). His antisemitic opinions on the Dreyfus case are still depicted however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InsaneTrollLogic: The first evidence that is used against Dreyfus is proven to not have been written by him. The graphology expert accuses him nonetheless, stating that "Jewry" taught him how to hide his personal writing patterns...

to:

* InsaneTrollLogic: The first evidence that is used against Dreyfus is proven to not have been written by him. The graphology expert accuses him nonetheless, stating that "Jewry" taught him how to hide his personal writing patterns...patterns when writing...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Alphonse Bertillon (Creator/MathieuAmalric) is presented as a graphology expert, while he wasn't one in RealLife. His antisemitic opinions on the Dreyfus case are still depicted however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InsaneTrollLogic: The first evidence that is used against Dreyfus is proven to not have been written by him. The graphology expert accuses him nonetheless, stating that "Jewry" taught him how to hide his personal writing patterns...

Added: 157

Changed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmiesAreEvil: Picquart is pretty much the only figure of the French military who truly wants to stand for justice and honesty in the case of Dreyfus. Most of the others believe in antisemitic conspiracy theories and want the army to remain "clean" and the very idea of another scandal hitting it prompts them to churn out lies, fake proofs and cover-ups to maintain the disgrace of Dreyfus.

to:

* ArmiesAreEvil: Picquart is pretty much the only figure of the French military who truly wants to stand for justice and honesty in the case of Dreyfus. Most of the others believe in antisemitic conspiracy theories and want the army to remain "clean" and the very idea of another scandal hitting it prompts them to churn out lies, fake proofs evidences and cover-ups to maintain the disgrace of Dreyfus.



* GreedyJew: Not played straight. Rather, a number of people in the army believe in corruption by "international Jewry" and are satisfied with Dreyfus being degraded and exiled, with some even actively trying to sweep Picquart's investigation under the rug.

to:

* GreedyJew: Not played straight. Rather, a number of people in the army believe in corruption by "international Jewry" and are satisfied with Dreyfus being degraded and exiled, with some even actively trying to sweep Picquart's investigation under the rug.rug and forging evidences.


Added DiffLines:

* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Picquart is eventually pitted against his hierarchy, and still won't stop doing his best to prove the innocence of Dreyfus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmiesAreEvil: Picquart is pretty much the only military figure who truly wants to stand for justice and honesty in the case of Dreyfus. Most of the others believe in antisemitic conspiracy theories and want the army to remain "clean" and the very idea of another scandal hitting it prompts them to churn out lies, fake proofs and cover-ups to maintain the disgrace of Dreyfus.

to:

* ArmiesAreEvil: Picquart is pretty much the only figure of the French military figure who truly wants to stand for justice and honesty in the case of Dreyfus. Most of the others believe in antisemitic conspiracy theories and want the army to remain "clean" and the very idea of another scandal hitting it prompts them to churn out lies, fake proofs and cover-ups to maintain the disgrace of Dreyfus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TimeSkip: Several, mostly due to the years that the revision trials lasted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''J'accuse'' - "I accuse") is a 2019 historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.

to:

''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''J'accuse'' - "I accuse") is a 2019 French historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmiesAreEvil: Picquart is pretty much the only military figure who truly wants to stand for justice and honesty in the case of Dreyfus. Most of the others believe in antisemitic conspiracy theories and want the army to remain "clean" and the very idea of another scandal hitting it prompts them to churn out lies, fake proofs and cover-ups.

to:

* ArmiesAreEvil: Picquart is pretty much the only military figure who truly wants to stand for justice and honesty in the case of Dreyfus. Most of the others believe in antisemitic conspiracy theories and want the army to remain "clean" and the very idea of another scandal hitting it prompts them to churn out lies, fake proofs and cover-ups.cover-ups to maintain the disgrace of Dreyfus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GreedyJew: Not played straight. Rather, a number of people in the army believe in corruption by "international Jewry" and are satisfied with Dreyfus being degraded and exiled, with some even actively trying to sweep Picquart's investigation under the rug.

Added: 329

Changed: 386

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film centers on the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair. French officer Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.

to:

The film centers on the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair. French officer Georges Marie-Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.



* ClearMyName: Alfred Dreyfus and his family want to clear his name. Then Georges Picquart and several lawyers, politicians and journalists enter the fray to make the scandal known to the public and prove his innocence.

to:

* ArmiesAreEvil: Picquart is pretty much the only military figure who truly wants to stand for justice and honesty in the case of Dreyfus. Most of the others believe in antisemitic conspiracy theories and want the army to remain "clean" and the very idea of another scandal hitting it prompts them to churn out lies, fake proofs and cover-ups.
* ClearMyName: Alfred Dreyfus and his family want to clear his name. Then Georges Marie-Georges Picquart and several lawyers, politicians and journalists enter the fray to make the scandal known to the public and prove his innocence.innocence.
* GoodIsNotNice: Picquart doesn't like Jews, but he wants to prove the innocence of Dreyfus nonetheless.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


The film came out in France on November 13, 2019.

Added: 510

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''J'accuse'') is a 2019 historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.

to:

''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''J'accuse'') ''J'accuse'' - "I accuse") is a 2019 historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.


Added DiffLines:

----
!!This film provides examples of:

* ClearMyName: Alfred Dreyfus and his family want to clear his name. Then Georges Picquart and several lawyers, politicians and journalists enter the fray to make the scandal known to the public and prove his innocence.
* INeverGotAnyLetters: Among the primary sources of information for the late 19th French secret services, there's the interception of letters. Picquart is eventually victim of this.
* YourCheatingHeart: Pauline Monnier cheats on her husband with Picquart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film centers on the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair. French officer Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff, of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.

to:

The film centers on the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair. French officer Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff, staff (in which antisemitic conspiracy theories abund), of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/jaccuse.jpg]]
%%[[caption-width-right:300:some caption text]]

''An Officer and a Spy'' (French title ''J'accuse'') is a 2019 historical drama film written and directed by Creator/RomanPolanski and based on the Robert Harris book ''Literature/AnOfficerAndASpy''.

The film centers on the notorious 19th century Dreyfus Affair. French officer Georges Picquart (Creator/JeanDujardin) is appointed chief of the army's intelligence section (Deuxième Bureau, service de renseignement militaire) in 1895. He discovers that doctored evidence was used to convict Alfred Dreyfus (Louis Garrel), one of the few Jewish members of the French Army's general staff, of passing military secrets to the German Empire. Picquart risks his career and his life, struggling for a decade to expose the truth and liberate the wrongly convicted Dreyfus from the Devil's Island prison.
----

Top