Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / PatroniInWinterfell

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope renamed and redefined per TRS


* OutDamnedSpot: [[spoiler:After killing Robert, Cersei unconsciously scrubs her hands.]]

Added: 640

Changed: 343

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Patroni in Winterfell'' is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/{{Milarqui}} that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...



''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/patroni-in-winterfell-an-asoiaf-hp-crossover.315157/ Patroni in Winterfell]]'' is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/{{Milarqui}} that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...

to:

''[[https://www.And soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...

It can be found [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/19881811/chapters/47088298 here]] on Website/ArchiveOfOurOwn and there's the [[https://www.
alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/patroni-in-winterfell-an-asoiaf-hp-crossover.315157/ Patroni in Winterfell]]'' is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/{{Milarqui}} that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...
original discussion thread]] on Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom

Added: 170

Changed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoomedByCanon: [[spoiler:Robert, but he dies well before he did in the books.]]



** The tourney has [[spoiler:Jaime get his leg broken during his joust with Gregor Clegane, leaving him unable to fight or ride a horse (much like Willas Tyrell)]], while [[spoiler:Sandor Clegane strikes Gregor in such a way that it breaks his neck, leaving the Mountain a tetraplegic.]]
** [[spoiler:Cersei kills Robert.]]

to:

** The tourney has During the tourney, [[spoiler:Jaime get breaks his leg broken during his joust with after Gregor Clegane, leaving Clegane unhorses him, making it impossible for him unable to fight or even ride a horse (much like Willas Tyrell)]], horse]], while [[spoiler:Sandor Clegane strikes leaves Gregor in such a way that it breaks his neck, leaving permanently paralyzed from the Mountain a tetraplegic.neck down.]]
** [[spoiler:Cersei kills Robert.Robert with her own hands.]]


Added DiffLines:

* OutDamnedSpot: [[spoiler:After killing Robert, Cersei unconsciously scrubs her hands.]]

Added: 302

Changed: 1395

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBrotherInstinct: When he learns that Joffrey nearly killed Ginny at the Ruby Ford, Ron [[TranquilFury requests Ginny]] to tell him where the camp is so he can find Joffrey and pummel him.



* CurbStompBattle: Ginny destroys Joffrey in a duel, even though she is only using a stick while Joffrey has Lion's Tooth.

to:

* CurbStompBattle: Ginny destroys Ginny, armed with a stick, versus Joffrey in a duel, even though she is only using a stick while Joffrey has with Lion's Tooth.Tooth. Ginny easily wins by using her training and Joffrey's impulsiveness against him, disarming him and sending him packing.



** While Bran [[InSpiteOfANail still falls from the Broken Tower]], Hermione's rapid intervention prevents him from becoming paraplegic.
** The confrontation at the Ruby Ford involves only Ginny.

to:

** While Bran [[InSpiteOfANail still falls from the Broken Tower]], Hermione's rapid intervention prevents him from becoming paraplegic.
cripple.
** The confrontation at the Ruby Ford involves only Ginny.Ginny, thus averting Lady's death and Arya forcing Nymeria to run away.



** The tourney has [[spoiler:Jaime break his leg in such a way that he won't be able to fight again and Gregor Clegane become a tetraplegic.]]

to:

** The tourney has [[spoiler:Jaime break get his leg broken during his joust with Gregor Clegane, leaving him unable to fight or ride a horse (much like Willas Tyrell)]], while [[spoiler:Sandor Clegane strikes Gregor in such a way that he won't be able to fight again and Gregor Clegane become it breaks his neck, leaving the Mountain a tetraplegic.]]



** When Robert tells [[spoiler:Joffrey]] he's no better than a Targaryen [[spoiler:for arranging Bran's murder]], Ned struggles not to point out that Robert had no trouble with [[spoiler:Tywin having Elia Martell and her children murdered by Gregor Clegane]].

to:

** When Robert tells [[spoiler:Joffrey]] he's no better than a Targaryen [[spoiler:for arranging Bran's murder]], Ned struggles not to point out that mentally remembers how Robert had no trouble with [[spoiler:Tywin having Elia Martell and her children murdered by Gregor Clegane]].



** The Stark retainers and Syrio Forel survive their stay in King's Landing, since they leave the city before the Lannisters order their deaths.

to:

** The Stark retainers and Syrio Forel survive their stay in King's Landing, since they leave the city before the Lannisters order their deaths.Cersei can send her men to kill them.



* TheStationsOfTheCanon: It passes several (Jon Arryn's death, Robert coming to Winterfell, Ned becoming the Hand, Bran's fall...) but it soon starts to diverge (Bran's would-be killer is captured alive, for starters).
** [[WordOfGod The author]] explictly stated that he wanted to step away from the usual chain of events, thinking that treading the same path even with a new element brought in was absurd. The capture of the catspaw is a big one, but what really shows the change is [[spoiler:Gregor crippling Jaime during the Hand's Tourney and getting horribly crippled by Sandor in exchange]].
* TookALevelInKindness: Sansa, thanks to Hermione and Ginny, becomes a lot nicer. This also dovetails into Arya being less of an AnnoyingYoungerSibling.
* WhamEpisode: "Long May He Reign", where [[spoiler:Cersei gets into Robert's rooms and kills him by slitting his throat.]]

to:

* TheStationsOfTheCanon: It passes several (Jon Jon Arryn's death, Robert coming to Winterfell, Bran falling/being pushed from the Broken Tower and Ned becoming the Hand, Bran's fall...) but it Hand are events that take place. However, the storyline soon starts begins to diverge (Bran's would-be killer from canon (the catspaw is captured alive, for starters).
and Lady and Nymeria reach King's Landing).
** [[WordOfGod The author]] explictly stated that he wanted to step away from one of his objectives in writing the usual chain of events, thinking that story is to avert treading the same path even with a new element brought in was absurd. The capture of canon path, since doing so would be boring. As an example, apart from the catspaw is a above mentioned change, one big one, but what really shows divergence is [[spoiler:Sandor Clegane facing Loras Tyrell in the change is [[spoiler:Gregor crippling Jaime during the Hand's Tourney of the Hand instead of Jaime Lannister, who has to joust against Gregor Clegane and getting horribly crippled by Sandor breaks his leg in exchange]].
the process.]]
* TookALevelInKindness: Sansa, thanks to Hermione and Ginny, becomes a lot nicer. This also dovetails nicely into Arya being less of an AnnoyingYoungerSibling.
** Jon is also somewhat less entitled than he was in the books.
* WhamEpisode: "Long May He Reign", where [[spoiler:Cersei gets into Robert's rooms and kills him Robert in his sleep by slitting slashing his throat.]]

Added: 936

Changed: 712

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AndIMustScream: Gregor Clegane [[spoiler:is left completely unable to move below the neck.]]
* BringIt: Ginny does a mental version of this [[spoiler:as the Starks and their retainers escape King's Landing in the nick of time.]]
* CoolTeacher: Syrio Forel, who teaches Arya, Sansa, Ginny and Harry the Water Dance.



** Bran doesn't lose the ability to walk thanks to magic.
** The confrontation at the Ruby Ford involves only Ginny, so both Nymeria and Lady are still with Arya and Sansa.

to:

** While Bran doesn't lose [[InSpiteOfANail still falls from the ability to walk thanks to magic.
Broken Tower]], Hermione's rapid intervention prevents him from becoming paraplegic.
** The confrontation at the Ruby Ford involves only Ginny, so both Nymeria and Lady are still with Arya and Sansa.Ginny.



** [[spoiler:Cersei kills Robert herself.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Cersei kills Robert herself.Robert.]]



* LadyMacbeth: Cersei, much like in canon, but worse. [[spoiler:Up to, and including, killing her husband with her own hands just so he won't disinherit Joffrey.]]



* PayEvilUntoEvil: [[spoiler:Sandor Clegane hits his brother in the head so brutally that his neck is broken enough to leave him tetraplegic.]]
* RefugeInAudacity: After winning the Tourney of the Hand, Sandor names Ginny (whom he likes for how she humiliated Joffrey) the Queen of Love and Beauty and the next morning leaves to take his home back, laughing in Joffrey's face after he demands him to stay behind as his guard.

to:

* PayEvilUntoEvil: [[spoiler:Sandor Clegane hits leaves his brother in Gregor tetraplegic with a brutal lance strike to the head so brutally that his neck is broken enough to leave him tetraplegic.head.]]
* RefugeInAudacity: After winning the Tourney of the Hand, Sandor names Ginny (whom he likes for how she humiliated Joffrey) the Queen of Love and Beauty Beauty, and when he leaves the next morning leaves to take his home back, laughing he laughs in Joffrey's face after he demands him to stay behind as his guard.guard.
* SlashedThroat: [[spoiler:How Cersei kills Robert.]]
* SparedByTheAdaptation: Lady averts being killed because Nymeria never attacked Joffrey.
** The Stark retainers and Syrio Forel survive their stay in King's Landing, since they leave the city before the Lannisters order their deaths.
** Similarly, as Catelyn learns the truth about Bran's would-be murderer (who does survive attacking Bran), she doesn't take Tyrion to the Eyrie, averting Ser Vardis' death.



** [[WordOfGod The author]] explictly stated that he wanted to step away from the usual chain of events, with [[spoiler:Jaime breaking his leg and Gregor Clegane being left tetraplegic]] being the biggest demonstration.
* TookALevelInKindness: Sansa, thanks to Hermione and Ginny, becomes a lot nicer.

to:

** [[WordOfGod The author]] explictly stated that he wanted to step away from the usual chain of events, thinking that treading the same path even with [[spoiler:Jaime breaking his leg a new element brought in was absurd. The capture of the catspaw is a big one, but what really shows the change is [[spoiler:Gregor crippling Jaime during the Hand's Tourney and Gregor Clegane being left tetraplegic]] being the biggest demonstration.
getting horribly crippled by Sandor in exchange]].
* TookALevelInKindness: Sansa, thanks to Hermione and Ginny, becomes a lot nicer. This also dovetails into Arya being less of an AnnoyingYoungerSibling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance: The wizards and witches clearly see things differently from how the Westerosi do. For example, Hermione and Ginny dislike how women are treated as lesser than men, and Harry points out that jousting is too violent.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: The wizards WhamEpisode: "Long May He Reign", where [[spoiler:Cersei gets into Robert's rooms and witches clearly see things differently from how the Westerosi do. For example, Hermione and Ginny dislike how women are treated as lesser than men, and Harry points out that jousting is too violent.kills him by slitting his throat.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TookALevelInKindness: Sansa, thanks to Hermione and Ginny, becomes a lot nicer.

to:

* TookALevelInKindness: Sansa, thanks to Hermione and Ginny, becomes a lot nicer.nicer.
* ValuesDissonance: The wizards and witches clearly see things differently from how the Westerosi do. For example, Hermione and Ginny dislike how women are treated as lesser than men, and Harry points out that jousting is too violent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActionGirl: Hermione and Ginny, by virtue of being powerful witches who are willing to learn how to fight.



** [[WordOfGod The author]] explictly stated that he wanted to step away from the usual chain of events, with [[spoiler:Jaime breaking his leg and Gregor Clegane being left tetraplegic]] being the biggest demonstration.

to:

** [[WordOfGod The author]] explictly stated that he wanted to step away from the usual chain of events, with [[spoiler:Jaime breaking his leg and Gregor Clegane being left tetraplegic]] being the biggest demonstration.demonstration.
* TookALevelInKindness: Sansa, thanks to Hermione and Ginny, becomes a lot nicer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OutsideContextProblem: Harry and his friends are one in Westeros.

Added: 704

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/patroni-in-winterfell-an-asoiaf-hp-crossover.315157/ Patroni in Winterfell]]'' is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/Milarqui that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...

to:

''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/patroni-in-winterfell-an-asoiaf-hp-crossover.315157/ Patroni in Winterfell]]'' is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/Milarqui Tropers/{{Milarqui}} that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...


Added DiffLines:

* ADayInTheSpotlight: Several characters get a POV chapter. Howland Reed is just the first of them.


Added DiffLines:

* LaserGuidedKarma: Gregor Clegane made a sport of killing defenceless people. [[spoiler:He's left defenceless himself when Sandor defeats him in the joust, ending up tetraplegic.]]
* PayEvilUntoEvil: [[spoiler:Sandor Clegane hits his brother in the head so brutally that his neck is broken enough to leave him tetraplegic.]]
* RefugeInAudacity: After winning the Tourney of the Hand, Sandor names Ginny (whom he likes for how she humiliated Joffrey) the Queen of Love and Beauty and the next morning leaves to take his home back, laughing in Joffrey's face after he demands him to stay behind as his guard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 900

Changed: 1293

Removed: 483

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Harry Potter is now a century and a half old. All of his friends and his wife are already dead, and he is looking forward to the next great adventure.

When he dies, though, Death herself (quite the nice lass) asks Harry if he can do one favor to her: go to a land where a civil war is imminent, but the worst is yet to come. Harry, who even after so long in his life, is still the hero he's always been, agrees to help, and neither his wife Ginny Weasley nor his friends Hermione and Ron are willing to let him go alone.

Thus, the four wizards and witches find themselves reincarnated in their eleven year old bodies, in the middle of a placed called "the Neck".

''Patroni in Winterfell'' is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/Milarqui that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...

to:

Harry Potter is now a century and a half old. All of his friends and his wife are already dead, and he is looking forward to the next great adventure.

adventure. When he dies, though, Death herself (quite the nice lass) asks Harry if he can do one favor to her: go to a land where a civil war is imminent, but the worst is yet to come. Harry, who even after so long in his life, is still the hero he's always been, agrees to help, and neither his wife Ginny Weasley nor his friends Hermione and Ron are willing to let him go alone.

alone. Thus, the four wizards and witches find themselves reincarnated in their eleven year old bodies, in the middle of a placed called "the Neck".

''Patroni
Neck", and soon they find themselves deep in Winterfell'' ensuring the survival of the people that can fight the incoming apocalypse.

''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/patroni-in-winterfell-an-asoiaf-hp-crossover.315157/ Patroni in Winterfell]]''
is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/Milarqui that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...



* CurbStompBattle: Ginny destroys Joffrey in a duel, even though she is only using a stick while Joffrey has Lion's Tooth.
* DeathByAdaptation: [[spoiler:Robert dies way earlier than he did in canon.]]



** Sansa is far more capable at seeing through Joffrey's façade than her canon self.

to:

** Sansa is far more capable at seeing through Joffrey's façade than her canon self.



* {{Hypocrite}}: Sandor Clegane considers Cersei this, as she had no trouble with his brother Gregor's brutality until it ended with [[spoiler:Jaime breaking a leg in such a way that he will never be able to fight again]].
** When Robert tells [[spoiler:Joffrey]] he's no better than a Targaryen [[spoiler:for arranging Bran's murder]], Ned struggles not to point out that Robert had no trouble with [[spoiler:Tywin having Elia Martell and her children murdered by Gregor Clegane]].



* TheStationsOfTheCanon: It passes several (Jon Arryn's death, Robert coming to Winterfell, Ned becoming the Hand, Bran's fall...) but it soon starts to diverge (Bran's would-be killer is captured alive, for starters).

to:

* TheStationsOfTheCanon: It passes several (Jon Arryn's death, Robert coming to Winterfell, Ned becoming the Hand, Bran's fall...) but it soon starts to diverge (Bran's would-be killer is captured alive, for starters).starters).
** [[WordOfGod The author]] explictly stated that he wanted to step away from the usual chain of events, with [[spoiler:Jaime breaking his leg and Gregor Clegane being left tetraplegic]] being the biggest demonstration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Harry Potter is now a century and a half old. All of his friends and his wife are already dead, and he is looking forward to the next great adventure.

When he dies, though, Death herself (quite the nice lass) asks Harry if he can do one favor to her: go to a land where a civil war is imminent, but the worst is yet to come. Harry, who even after so long in his life, is still the hero he's always been, agrees to help, and neither his wife Ginny Weasley nor his friends Hermione and Ron are willing to let him go alone.

Thus, the four wizards and witches find themselves reincarnated in their eleven year old bodies, in the middle of a placed called "the Neck".

''Patroni in Winterfell'' is a Franchise/HarryPotter[=/=]Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire {{Crossover}} written by Tropers/Milarqui that has Harry Potter and his friends appearing in Westeros a few years before the beginning of the books, and soon they start to make their impact in this new world, particularly when they know Winter Is Coming...

!!''Patroni in Winterfell'' has examples of the following Tropes:
* ActuallyPrettyFunny: Death thinks it's hilarious that people thought the Deathly Hallows would give them power over her.
* DeadpanSnarker: The Hogwarts crew tend to do this.
* ForWantOfANail: The intervention of Harry and his friends leads to several changes.
** Sansa and Arya slowly patch up their relationship.
** Sansa is far more capable at seeing through Joffrey's façade than her canon self.
** Bran doesn't lose the ability to walk thanks to magic.
** The confrontation at the Ruby Ford involves only Ginny, so both Nymeria and Lady are still with Arya and Sansa.
** The catspaw that tried to kill Bran is captured alive - which allows the Starks to find out that it was [[spoiler:Joffrey]] behind the attack.
*** This diverts Catelyn's arrest/kidnapping of Tyrion, as she knows the truth. In fact, she ends up going with Tyrion to King's Landing.
** Sansa (and Harry and Ginny) join the lessons with Syrio Forel.
** The tourney has [[spoiler:Jaime break his leg in such a way that he won't be able to fight again and Gregor Clegane become a tetraplegic.]]
** [[spoiler:Cersei kills Robert herself.]]
* IHaveNoSon: Robert makes it clear he will disinherit Joffrey after [[spoiler:he finds out that Joffrey tried to have Bran killed.]]
* SpotlightStealingSquad: {{Averted}}. The Westeros characters have as much protagonism as the Hogwarts crew.
* TheStationsOfTheCanon: It passes several (Jon Arryn's death, Robert coming to Winterfell, Ned becoming the Hand, Bran's fall...) but it soon starts to diverge (Bran's would-be killer is captured alive, for starters).

Top