Follow TV Tropes

Following

History FanFic / CrosswindsOfFate

Go To

OR

Added: 285

Removed: 278

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sorry used the villainous version on the neutral one.


* InTheBlood: The Ollivander family and by extention in her Formalcraft paper, Luna's theory is that one's magical affinity can be traced to one's genetic information. This is why Ollivander's tape-measure measure's seemingly irrelevant thing's such as the length of one's nose.


Added DiffLines:

* ItRunsInTheFamily: The Ollivander family and by extention in her Formalcraft paper, Luna's theory is that one's magical affinity can be traced to one's genetic information. This is why Ollivander's tape-measure measure's seemingly irrelevant thing's such as the length of one's nose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArcWords: In a fairly lighthearted example, "blood pops" show up several times throughout the story, alluding to Zelretch's implied FetchQuest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InTheBlood: The Ollivander family and by extention in her Formalcraft paper, Luna's theory is that one's magical affinity can be traced to one's genetic information. This is why Ollivander's tape-measure measure's seemingly irrelevant thing's such as the length of one's nose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UndyingLoyalty: Sakura will follow Shirou wherever he goes and will support him in all that he does. This is to the point that she actually switches from kyuudo[note]Japanese archery[/note] to European archery just because Shirou did.
** Rider is of course so loyal to Sakura that she has already deployed Bloodfort Andromeda to digest the entirety of the castle, [[WouldHurtAChild students included]], if Sakura were ever threatened.

to:

* UndyingLoyalty: Sakura will follow Shirou wherever he goes and will support him in all that he does. This is to the point that she actually switches from kyuudo[note]Japanese archery[/note] kyuudo[[note]]Japanese archery[[/note]] to European archery just because Shirou did.
** Rider is of course so loyal to Sakura that she has already deployed Bloodfort Andromeda to digest the entirety of the castle, [[WouldHurtAChild students included]], if Sakura were ever threatened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UndyingLoyalty: Sakura will follow Shirou wherever he goes and will support him in all that he does. This is to the point that she actually switches from kyuudo[note]Japanese archery[/note] to European archery just because Shirou did.
** Rider is of course so loyal to Sakura that she has already deployed Bloodfort Andromeda to digest the entirety of the castle, [[WouldHurtAChild students included]], if Sakura were ever threatened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FixFic: Has shades of this.
** On the ''Harry Potter'' side of things, several major sources of conflict and angst from the fifth book have been defused, such as Dumbledore keeping important information from Harry, or Harry, Fred, and George receiving a ban from Quidditch.
** On the ''Fate'' side of things, all three heroines plus Rider are in a relationship with Shirou despite things following the ''Unlimited Blade Works'' good ending.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnotherDimension: The ''Fate'' cast used the Second Magic to travel to the {{Potterverse}}. Unusually, they reveal this fact straight away, as the [[{{Masquerade}} alternative]] would be tedious.

to:

* AnotherDimension: The ''Fate'' cast used the Second Magic to travel to the {{Potterverse}}.Potter universe. Unusually, they reveal this fact straight away, as the [[{{Masquerade}} alternative]] would be tedious.

Added: 255

Removed: 251

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OddBedfellows: Downplayed, While Dumbledore and Rin are not enemies, their ideological differences regarding the bloodline matter do somewhat put them at odds with each other; they still work together, without prior planning, to discredit Umbridge.


Added DiffLines:

* StrangeBedfellows: Downplayed, While Dumbledore and Rin are not enemies, their ideological differences regarding the bloodline matter do somewhat put them at odds with each other; they still work together, without prior planning, to discredit Umbridge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OddBedfellows: Downplayed, While Dumbledore and Rin are not enemies, their ideological differences regarding the bloodline matter do somewhat put them at odds with each other; they still work together, without prior planning, to discredit Umbridge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DimensionalTravelers: The ''Fate'' cast, by means of the Second Magic.

to:

* DimensionalTravelers: {{Dimensional Traveler}}s: The ''Fate'' cast, by means of the Second Magic.



* {{Masquerade}}: Defied. Rin opens the interview with Dumbledore by telling him that her group is from another universe. When asked why they're so forthcoming, she explains that the alternative of [[FandomSpecificPlot pretending to be natives would inevitably be seen through, and make the truth seem less believable.]]

to:

* {{Masquerade}}: Defied. Rin opens the interview with Dumbledore by telling him that her group is from another universe. When asked why they're so forthcoming, she explains that the alternative of [[FandomSpecificPlot pretending to be natives would inevitably be seen through, and make the truth seem less believable.]]]] The standard "hide magic from muggles" masquerade still stands, though.

Added: 625

Changed: 641

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnotherDimension: The ''Fate'' cast claim to be from one very early on.
* BackgroundMagicField: The magi characters observe that the one in the Potterverse is stronger than the one in their home universe. For them, it means increased effects for their magecraft at the same cost, but they have yet to figure out what this means for the locals' magic.

to:

* AnotherDimension: The ''Fate'' cast claim used the Second Magic to travel to the {{Potterverse}}. Unusually, they reveal this fact straight away, as the [[{{Masquerade}} alternative]] would be from one very early on.
tedious.
* BackgroundMagicField: The magi characters observe that the one in the Potterverse is stronger than stronger. For the one in their home universe. For them, ''Fate'' characters, it means increased effects for their magecraft at the same cost, but they have yet to figure out what this means for the locals' magic.



* CultureClash: Examined in depth and played with. After unifying the two magical systems (with which there's quite a bit of overlap, regardless), the differences in culture could be considered the other major theme of the story.

to:

* CultureClash: Examined in depth and played with. After unifying the two magical systems (with which there's quite a bit of overlap, regardless), the differences in depth. The culture could be considered the other difference is a major theme of driving force in the story.story for both character interaction and plot development.



** When the topic of magical pedigree gets brought up in class at one point, the magi idea that some bloodlines can be inherently stronger than others (through magical crests and eugenics) interact in interesting ways with the blood purity issue in Harry Potter.

to:

** When the topic of magical pedigree gets brought up in class at one point, the magi idea that some bloodlines can be inherently stronger than others (through magical crests and eugenics) interact interacts in interesting ways with the blood purity issue in Harry Potter.



* DimensionalTravelers: The ''Fate'' cast, by means of the Second Magic.



* {{Doorstopper}}: Shaping up to be one, as it's already at 130,000 words already despite being only eight chapters in length as of this writing.

to:

* {{Doorstopper}}: Shaping up to be one, as it's already at 130,000 words already despite being only eight chapters in length as of this writing.



* {{Masquerade}}: Defied. Rin opens the interview with Dumbledore by telling him that her group is from another universe. When asked why they're so forthcoming, she explains that the alternative of [[FandomSpecificPlot pretending to be natives would inevitably be seen through, and make the truth seem less believable.]]



* OhCrap: Dawlish has this reaction after Shirou throws a Black Key at him. Before this, he only fired individual spells. Afterwards, he puts as many conjured objects (and failing that, distance) as he can between himself and Shirou.



* WrongContextMagic: The central premise of the fic is the magi characters trying to unify two very different systems of magic. Exacerbated by the fact that while the ''Harry Potter'' characters can learn the Type-Moon cast's magecraft, the opposite does not hold.

to:

* WrongContextMagic: The central premise of the fic ''Fate'' cast's goal is the magi characters trying to try and unify the two very different systems of magic. differing magical systems. Exacerbated by the fact that while the ''Harry Potter'' Potterverse characters can learn the Type-Moon cast's magecraft, Nasuverse magic, the opposite does not hold.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalInnuendo: "I'm going to stab you (with Rule Breaker), and then you'll feel better (because it'll break the curse on you)."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: While training him in Occlumency, Moody makes Harry experience a false memory of eating extremely hot soup.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CouldSayItBut: Or "could do it", in Dumbledore's case when Harry asks him for some emergency Portkeys.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OurVampiresAreDifferent: This trope results in the ''Fate'' cast taking Flitwick's initial description of the Whomping Willow to mean it is like the Forest of Einnashe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


* PokeInTheThirdEye: Harry pulls this on Snape when the latter gives him some poorly-timed Occlumency training. When Snape tries to get into his mind, Harry redirects the attack to a memory of the potions master blundly grabbing at the air in an attempt to catch him out after curfew.

to:

* PokeInTheThirdEye: Harry pulls this on Snape when the latter gives him some poorly-timed Occlumency training. When Snape tries to get into his mind, Harry redirects the attack to a memory of the potions master blundly blindly grabbing at the air in an attempt to catch him out after curfew.



* TornadoMove: Lorelei uses four tornadoes when fighting against Rider. Since they're fighting in Unlimited Blade Works, they become (in Shirou's own words) ''swornadoes''.

to:

* TornadoMove: Lorelei uses four tornadoes when fighting against Rider. Since they're fighting in Unlimited Blade Works, they become (in Shirou's own words) ''swornadoes''.''swordnadoes''.

Added: 317

Changed: 468

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OffTheRails: Various early changes to the story have ensured that the battle over the prophecy at the Ministry will never happen. Sirius has freed Kreacher, Harry has already made significant progress in Occlumency, and most damning of all, [[spoiler:Harry has already retrieved the prophecy from the Department of Mysteries]].

to:

* OffTheRails: Established from the onset. The very first thing we see of the ''Harry Potter'' cast is Dumbledore and Harry discussing the latter's summer living arrangements now that Voldemort has circumvented Lily's blood protection.
**
Various early changes to the story have ensured that the battle over the prophecy at the Ministry will never happen. Sirius has freed Kreacher, Harry has already made significant progress in Occlumency, and most damning of all, [[spoiler:Harry has already retrieved the prophecy from the Department of Mysteries]].

Added: 921

Changed: 962

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackgroundMagicField: The magi characters observe that the one in the Potterverse is stronger than the one in their home universe. For them, it means increased effects for their magecraft at the same cost, but they have yet to figure out what this means for the locals' magic.



* {{Irony}}: Umbridge is a victim of the seldom-used Socratic irony at the hands of Dumbledore and the staff.
** When Saber visits [=McGonagall's=] office she spots a tapestry depicting Cú Chulainn, William Wallace, and a third man she does not recognize. When asked, the professor tells her that the man is King Arthur.

to:

* {{Irony}}: Umbridge is Dumbledore, Rin, and to a victim lesser degree the rest of the seldom-used staff use Socratic irony at the hands of Dumbledore Irony to expose Umbridge's ignorance by constantly patronizing her and the staff.
treating her as a foremost expert in her field.
** When Saber visits [=McGonagall's=] office she spots a tapestry depicting Cú Chulainn, William Wallace, and a third man she does not recognize. When asked, the professor tells her that the man is King Arthur. Made more ironic by the fact that Saber had been described as an expert in Arthurian lore not long before, and [=McGonagall's=] obvious disbelief in Saber's explanation of the artist taking liberties.



* NotHelpingYourCase: After deciding not to issue a Sealing Designation on Shirou, Lorelei is accidentaly cursed after grasping a cursed sword in the middle of a fight and Shirou attempts to use Rule Breaker to get rid of the curse. After hearing the explanation of what Rule Breaker does, Lorelei asks him not to give her more reasons to regret not assigning a Sealing Designation on him.

to:

* NormalFishInATinyPond: The ''Fate'' cast. While certainly nothing to sneeze at back home, they are utterly overpowered in the new setting. Shirou's combat assessment with Dawlish really drives it home, as his expectations from his home world mean it takes him a while to realize that Dawlish's slow, weak attacks aren't part of a feint, and are actually him fighting seriously.
* NotHelpingYourCase: After deciding not to issue a Sealing Designation on Shirou, Lorelei is accidentaly accidentally cursed after grasping a cursed sword in the middle of a fight and Shirou attempts to use Rule Breaker to get rid of the curse. After hearing the explanation of what Rule Breaker does, Lorelei asks him not to give her more reasons to regret not assigning a Sealing Designation on him.


Added DiffLines:

* SufficientlyAnalyzedMagic: A key difference between the two settings. Rin has trouble accepting that wizards can cast spells without knowing how they work, and Hermione is quite surprised by Rin's use of the scientific method to experiment with magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCameo: [[VisualNovel/{{Tsukihime}} Arcueid and Ciel]] make a brief appearance in a cutaway gag after the narration obliquely mentions one of them in chapter 6.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OffTheRails: Various early changes to the story have ensured that the battle over the prophecy at the Ministry will never happen. Sirius has freed Kreacher, Harry has already made significant progress in Occlumency, and most damning of all, [[spoiler:Harry has already retrieved the prophecy from the Department of Mysteries]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoodleIncident: At some point between the ''Unlimited Blade Works'' good end and the present, something analogous to the events of ''Heaven's Feel'' happened, leaving Sakura with access to her dark form, Rin in possession of her version of the Jeweled Sword of Zelretch,which he names the Jeweled Sword of Tohsaka, and Rider resummoned despite having been killed off in the Grail War.

to:

* NoodleIncident: At some point between the ''Unlimited Blade Works'' good end and the present, something analogous to the events of ''Heaven's Feel'' happened, leaving Sakura with access to her dark form, Rin in possession of her version of the Jeweled Sword of Zelretch,which Zelretch, which he names the Jeweled Sword of Tohsaka, and Rider resummoned despite having been killed off in the Grail War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Unmarked spoilers for all three routes of VisualNovel/FateStayNight below'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoodleIncident: At some point between the ''Unlimited Blade Works'' good end and the present, something analogous to the events of ''Heaven's Feel'' happened, leaving Sakura with access to her dark form, Rin in possession of the jeweled sword of Zelretch, and Rider resummoned despite having been killed off in the Grail War.

to:

* NoodleIncident: At some point between the ''Unlimited Blade Works'' good end and the present, something analogous to the events of ''Heaven's Feel'' happened, leaving Sakura with access to her dark form, Rin in possession of her version of the jeweled sword Jeweled Sword of Zelretch, Zelretch,which he names the Jeweled Sword of Tohsaka, and Rider resummoned despite having been killed off in the Grail War.

Added: 242

Removed: 242

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
g before m.


* IgnorantOfTheirOwnIgnorance: Umbridge shows how ignorant she is of the world by stating that "Muggle" biology has no bearing on the Magical World, or how just repeating a belief verbatim does not make it true without any empirical evidence.



* IgnorantOfTheirOwnIgnorance: Umbridge shows how ignorant she is of the world by stating that "Muggle" biology has no bearing on the Magical World, or how just repeating a belief verbatim does not make it true without any empirical evidence.

Added: 191

Removed: 191

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
And numbers go before letters


* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: What the ''Fate'' cast's home universe is relative to the world they're visiting. The fic follows the books' timeline, resulting in about a twenty year time gap.



* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: What the ''Fate'' cast's home universe is relative to the world they're visiting. The fic follows the books' timeline, resulting in about a twenty year time gap.

Added: 526

Removed: 526

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Common words (The, A and An) are not considered part of the alphabetical listing


* UnderestimatingBadassery: The ''Fate'' cast invoke this by going to great lengths to conceal their talents. Rin and Sakura teach branches of magecraft outside their specialties, while Shirou and Saber hold back in combat. Rider is kept completely hidden. It's also inverted, as the ''Fate'' cast assume the wizards are doing the same, and consequently ''overestimate'' them.
** Yet somehow, Umbridge manages to further underestimate them by mistaking Shirou's CurbStompBattle with Dawlish for the auror holding back too much.



* UnderestimatingBadassery: The ''Fate'' cast invoke this by going to great lengths to conceal their talents. Rin and Sakura teach branches of magecraft outside their specialties, while Shirou and Saber hold back in combat. Rider is kept completely hidden. It's also inverted, as the ''Fate'' cast assume the wizards are doing the same, and consequently ''overestimate'' them.
** Yet somehow, Umbridge manages to further underestimate them by mistaking Shirou's CurbStompBattle with Dawlish for the auror holding back too much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChronicHeroSyndrome: How Harry ends up [[spoiler: meeting Rider]].

Added: 1010

Changed: 535

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeadDesk: Rin supresses the urge of doing this when she learned that wizards don't need to learn the details of how a certain spell works in order to cast it.
* ImpossiblyDeliciousFood: A special blend of tea Sakura made with input from the other members of the ''Fate'' verse. It received unanimous praise from every single character who tasted it. The Hogwarts faculty fell in love with it and Lorelei wonders if they drugged it or something due to how delicious it is.



* NotHelpingYourCase: After deciding not to issue a Sealing Designation on Shirou, Lorelei is accidentaly cursed after grasping a cursed sword in the middle of a fight and Shirou attempts to use Rule Breaker to get rid of the curse. After hearing the explanation of what Rule Breaker does, Lorelei asks him not to give her more reasons to regret assigning a Sealing Designation on him.

to:

** When trying to convince Rin to accept going to the Potterverse, Zelretch talks about the academic value of the expedition and how she'll be away from the Association long enough for the dust to settle after one of her "escapades". It apparently involved Luvia trying to steal Shirou away from Rin.
* NotHelpingYourCase: After deciding not to issue a Sealing Designation on Shirou, Lorelei is accidentaly cursed after grasping a cursed sword in the middle of a fight and Shirou attempts to use Rule Breaker to get rid of the curse. After hearing the explanation of what Rule Breaker does, Lorelei asks him not to give her more reasons to regret not assigning a Sealing Designation on him.


Added DiffLines:

* RageBreakingPoint: Lorelei in the sidestory. As things go on she finds it harder to keep her IceQueen mask on but finally snaps in rage at the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RightForTheWrongReasons: Umbridge is able to guess Saber is not human, though she thinks that she's a form of half-breed rather than the spirit of King Arthur in a magical body.

Added: 1602

Changed: 283

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalInnuendo: "I'm going to stab you (with Rule Breaker), and then you'll feel better (because it'll break the curse on you)."



* BookDumb: Ron, but not to the normal stupid levels shown in most fanfiction, he's just unmotivated.

to:

* BlatantLies: Zelretch claiming that he had nothing to do with a NoodleIncident in the Sophia-Ri estate and Shirou stating that he has no idea what Rin is talking about when she mentions the dangers of learning magic incorrectly. The narration points it out in both instances.
* BookDumb: Ron, but not to the normal stupid levels shown in most fanfiction, he's just unmotivated. unmotivated.
* ChickMagnet: Shirou. In the sidestory, Rin actually considers for a second the possibility that Lorelei may have stayed for dinner because she was interested in Shirou.


Added DiffLines:

* DirtyOldMan: Subverted. Zelretch isn't one, and everyone is shocked by that.


Added DiffLines:

* IsThisWhatTheyreCallingItNow: When Luvia tries to justify blackmailing Shirou for sex as an incentive to accepting her offer and calling it "the carrot and the stick", Zelretch wonders if "take the carrot" is this.


Added DiffLines:

* MundaneUtility: The possibility of teleporting (which requires leaving and re-entering a dimension using True Magic) to ''save commute time'' is discussed.


Added DiffLines:

** In the sidestory, Zelretch had something to do with an incident at the Sophia-Ri estate. It involved teleportation, as Lorelei figured out it was him after learning that he can teleport.
* NotHelpingYourCase: After deciding not to issue a Sealing Designation on Shirou, Lorelei is accidentaly cursed after grasping a cursed sword in the middle of a fight and Shirou attempts to use Rule Breaker to get rid of the curse. After hearing the explanation of what Rule Breaker does, Lorelei asks him not to give her more reasons to regret assigning a Sealing Designation on him.


Added DiffLines:

* TornadoMove: Lorelei uses four tornadoes when fighting against Rider. Since they're fighting in Unlimited Blade Works, they become (in Shirou's own words) ''swornadoes''.

Top