Follow TV Tropes

Following

History DieForOurShip / MarvelCinematicUniverse

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* Many Steve/Tony fics depict Bruce as an emotionally abusive coward who's only with Tony because Tony protects him; while many Bruce/Tony fics depict Steve as a self-righteous, bigoted asshole who treats Tony like shit or slut-shames him. And then there's the Loki/Tony ones where Pepper/Steve/Bruce/whoever is bashed so that Tony can run into Loki's arms, or Thor (who is depicted as being in a relationship with Loki, although the two are brothers) being bashed so that Loki can run into the arms of Tony. And then there's the inclusion of Tony's pre-Avengers best friend Rhodey, and how he's often villainized to keep Tony with the Avengers.

to:

* Many Steve/Tony fics depict Bruce as an emotionally abusive coward who's only with Tony because Tony protects him; him, while many Bruce/Tony fics depict Steve as a self-righteous, bigoted asshole who treats Tony like shit or slut-shames him. And then there's there are the Loki/Tony ones where Pepper/Steve/Bruce/whoever is bashed so that Tony can run into Loki's arms, or Thor (who is depicted as being in a relationship with Loki, although the two are brothers) being is bashed so that Loki can run into the arms of Tony. And then there's the inclusion of Tony's pre-Avengers best friend Rhodey, and how he's often villainized to keep Tony with the Avengers.



* Usually averted with Pepper - she's a popular enough character that fanfic writers will usually just [[ShipMates pair her up with whatever guy]] Tony isn't banging or [[SlashFic Natasha]], which also quite conveniently keeps Natasha out of the way of [[FanPreferredCouple Hawkeye/Coulson]] (in which fics she is almost invariably PlatonicLifePartners or BetterAsFriends with Clint).
* Speaking of the MCU, lots of fangirls tend to do this with Theoric, who in the comics was engaged to Loki's wife Sigyn before Loki pulled a UriahGambit on him. If Theoric shows up in an MCU fanfic, he's almost always an abusive asshole who deserves to get Uriahed, despite the original comic story actually had some of Sigyn's friends complaining he was too noble. This is especially hilarious because the fangirls could always just, you know, not bring him into an MCU story since he's a comics-only character with no basis in mythology.

to:

* Usually averted with Pepper - she's Pepper--she's a popular enough character that fanfic writers will usually just [[ShipMates pair her up with whatever guy]] Tony isn't banging or [[SlashFic Natasha]], which also quite conveniently keeps Natasha out of the way of [[FanPreferredCouple Hawkeye/Coulson]] (in which fics case she is almost invariably PlatonicLifePartners or BetterAsFriends with Clint).
* Speaking of the MCU, lots of fangirls tend to do this with Theoric, who in the comics was engaged to Loki's wife Sigyn before Loki pulled a UriahGambit on him. If Theoric shows up in an MCU fanfic, he's almost always an abusive asshole who deserves to get Uriahed, despite the the original comic story actually had some of Sigyn's friends complaining he was too noble. This is especially hilarious because the fangirls could always just, you know, not bring him into an MCU story since he's a comics-only character with no basis in mythology.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleaning up Word Cruft changed wording slightly for clarity


* For a long time Peggy Carter avoided this fate, as she was originally intended to be a RomanticFalseLead to Sharon Carter (see above) and her romance with Steve in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheFirstAvenger The First Avenger]]'' was simultaneously regarded as surprisingly well-written and also subjected to a pretty thorough ShipSinking in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier The Winter Soldier]]'', so she was well-liked and not considered a threat to other Steve ships. Then ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' unexpectedly refloated the Steve/Peggy ship by [[spoiler:having Steve choose to travel back in time to be with her]], and Peggy's popularity with shippers suddenly took a massive nosedive. [[RevengeFic Revenge fics]] where Steve goes to the past, breaks up with her, and immediately returns to the future to be with someone else materialized just days after the movie's release, and the more extreme haters started claiming she was either a willing HYDRA collaborator[[note]]While ''Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier'' revealed she knowingly worked with Arnim Zola after Operation Paperclip as part of the film's big message of HeWhoFightsMonsters, it's never stated how well they got along as opposed to TeethClenchedTeamwork, and Old Peggy's speech implies that she disapproved of and regretted the darker actions she took in service of SHIELD[[/note]] or an abusive PsychoExGirlfriend [[note]]While her shooting at Steve's shield after finding him with another woman was admittedly an extreme response, she knew the shield was bulletproof and had no intention to seriously hurt let alone ''kill'' him[[/note]]. The 2020s saw an increase in appearances and spinoffs focused on Peggy, later entries recharacterizing the Steve/Peggy romance in various controversial ways, and at least one confirmed instance of a Peggy fan being a WriterOnBoard[[note]][[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRBdzlsQWkk&t=220s An interview]] with the ''What If?'' creative team revealed that at least one show writer ''did'' have an explicit Steve/Peggy shipping agenda and that head writer AC Bradley asked him to tone down [[spoiler:Sharon's death]] in the zombie episode because the original version was considered a gratuitous case of DieForOurShip; see the above Sharon entry for why this is so controversial despite the character's overall lack of popularity[[/note]], which resulted in further backlash from rival shippers and even some nonshippers who accused Marvel of subjecting Peggy to posthumous CharacterShilling at the expense of other characters or their relationships with Steve Rogers. Even years after ''Endgame'' was released, Peggy is still a controversial character in certain groups.

to:

* For a long time time, Peggy Carter avoided this fate, as she was originally intended to be a RomanticFalseLead to Sharon Carter (see above) and her above). Her romance with Steve in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheFirstAvenger The First Avenger]]'' was simultaneously regarded as surprisingly well-written and also well-written, ''and'' it was subjected to a pretty thorough ShipSinking in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier The Winter Soldier]]'', so she was well-liked and not considered a threat to other Steve ships. Then ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' unexpectedly refloated the Steve/Peggy ship by [[spoiler:having Steve choose to travel back in time to be with her]], and Peggy's popularity with shippers suddenly took a massive nosedive. [[RevengeFic Revenge fics]] where Steve goes to the past, breaks up with her, and immediately returns to the future to be with someone else materialized just days after the movie's release, and the more extreme haters started claiming she was either a willing HYDRA collaborator[[note]]While ''Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier'' revealed she knowingly worked with Arnim Zola after Operation Paperclip as part of the film's big message of HeWhoFightsMonsters, it's never stated how well they got along as opposed to TeethClenchedTeamwork, and Old Peggy's speech implies that she disapproved of and regretted the darker actions she took in service of SHIELD[[/note]] or an abusive PsychoExGirlfriend [[note]]While her shooting at Steve's shield after finding him with another woman was admittedly an extreme response, she knew the shield was bulletproof bulletproof, and she had no intention to seriously hurt hurt, let alone ''kill'' ''kill,'' him[[/note]]. The 2020s saw an increase in appearances storylines and spinoffs focused on Peggy, later including several entries recharacterizing that recharacterized the Steve/Peggy romance in various controversial ways, and there was at least one confirmed instance of a Peggy fan being a WriterOnBoard[[note]][[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRBdzlsQWkk&t=220s An interview]] with the ''What If?'' creative team revealed that at least one show writer ''did'' have an explicit Steve/Peggy shipping agenda agenda, and that head writer AC Bradley asked him to tone down [[spoiler:Sharon's death]] in the zombie episode because the original version was considered a gratuitous case of DieForOurShip; see the above Sharon entry for why this is so controversial despite the character's overall lack of popularity[[/note]], which resulted in further backlash from rival shippers and even shippers, as well as some nonshippers who accused Marvel of subjecting Peggy to posthumous CharacterShilling at the expense of other characters or and their relationships with Steve Rogers. Even years after ''Endgame'' was released, ''Endgame's'' release, Peggy is still a controversial character in certain groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* For a long time Peggy Carter avoided this fate, as she was originally intended to be a RomanticFalseLead to Sharon Carter (see above) and her romance with Steve in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheFirstAvenger The First Avenger]]'' was simultaneously regarded as surprisingly well-written and also subjected to a pretty thorough ShipSinking in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier The Winter Soldier]]'', so she was well-liked and not considered a threat to other Steve ships. Then ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' unexpectedly refloated the Steve/Peggy ship by [[spoiler:having Steve choose to travel back in time to be with her]], and Peggy's popularity with shippers suddenly took a massive nosedive. [[RevengeFic Revenge fics]] where Steve goes to the past, breaks up with her, and immediately returns to the future to be with someone else materialized just days after the movie's release, and the more extreme haters started claiming she was either a willing HYDRA collaborator[[note]]While ''Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier'' revealed she knowingly worked with Arnim Zola after Operation Paperclip as part of the film's big message of HeWhoFightsMonsters, it's never stated how well they got along as opposed to TeethClenchedTeamwork, and Old Peggy's speech implies that she disapproved of and regretted the darker actions she took in service of SHIELD[[/note]] or an abusive PsychoExGirlfriend [[note]]While her shooting at Steve's shield after finding him with another woman was admittedly an extreme response, she knew the shield was bulletproof and had no intention to seriously hurt let alone ''kill'' him[[/note]]. The 2020s saw an increase in appearances and spinoffs focused on Peggy, later entries revisiting the Steve/Peggy romance in various controversial ways, and at least one confirmed instance of a Peggy fan being a WriterOnBoard[[note]][[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRBdzlsQWkk&t=220s An interview]] with the ''What If?'' creative team revealed that at least one show writer ''did'' have an explicit Steve/Peggy shipping agenda and that head writer AC Bradley asked him to tone down [[spoiler:Sharon's death]] in the zombie episode because the original version was considered a gratuitous case of DieForOurShip; see the above Sharon entry for why this is so controversial despite the character's overall lack of popularity[[/note]], which resulted in further backlash from rival shippers and even some nonshippers who accused Marvel of subjecting Peggy to posthumous CharacterShilling at the expense of other characters or their relationships with Steve Rogers. Even years after ''Endgame'' was released, Peggy is still a controversial character in certain groups.

to:

* For a long time Peggy Carter avoided this fate, as she was originally intended to be a RomanticFalseLead to Sharon Carter (see above) and her romance with Steve in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheFirstAvenger The First Avenger]]'' was simultaneously regarded as surprisingly well-written and also subjected to a pretty thorough ShipSinking in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier The Winter Soldier]]'', so she was well-liked and not considered a threat to other Steve ships. Then ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' unexpectedly refloated the Steve/Peggy ship by [[spoiler:having Steve choose to travel back in time to be with her]], and Peggy's popularity with shippers suddenly took a massive nosedive. [[RevengeFic Revenge fics]] where Steve goes to the past, breaks up with her, and immediately returns to the future to be with someone else materialized just days after the movie's release, and the more extreme haters started claiming she was either a willing HYDRA collaborator[[note]]While ''Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier'' revealed she knowingly worked with Arnim Zola after Operation Paperclip as part of the film's big message of HeWhoFightsMonsters, it's never stated how well they got along as opposed to TeethClenchedTeamwork, and Old Peggy's speech implies that she disapproved of and regretted the darker actions she took in service of SHIELD[[/note]] or an abusive PsychoExGirlfriend [[note]]While her shooting at Steve's shield after finding him with another woman was admittedly an extreme response, she knew the shield was bulletproof and had no intention to seriously hurt let alone ''kill'' him[[/note]]. The 2020s saw an increase in appearances and spinoffs focused on Peggy, later entries revisiting recharacterizing the Steve/Peggy romance in various controversial ways, and at least one confirmed instance of a Peggy fan being a WriterOnBoard[[note]][[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRBdzlsQWkk&t=220s An interview]] with the ''What If?'' creative team revealed that at least one show writer ''did'' have an explicit Steve/Peggy shipping agenda and that head writer AC Bradley asked him to tone down [[spoiler:Sharon's death]] in the zombie episode because the original version was considered a gratuitous case of DieForOurShip; see the above Sharon entry for why this is so controversial despite the character's overall lack of popularity[[/note]], which resulted in further backlash from rival shippers and even some nonshippers who accused Marvel of subjecting Peggy to posthumous CharacterShilling at the expense of other characters or their relationships with Steve Rogers. Even years after ''Endgame'' was released, Peggy is still a controversial character in certain groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* For a long time Peggy Carter avoided this fate, as she was originally intended to be a RomanticFalseLead to Sharon Carter (see above) and her romance with Steve in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheFirstAvenger The First Avenger]]'' was subjected to a pretty thorough ShipSinking in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier The Winter Soldier]]'', so she was not considered a threat to other Steve ships. Then ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' unexpectedly refloated the Steve/Peggy ship by [[spoiler:having Steve choose to travel back in time to be with her]], and Peggy's popularity with shippers suddenly took a massive nosedive. [[RevengeFic Revenge fics]] where Steve goes to the past, breaks up with her, and immediately returns to the future to be with someone else materialized just days after the movie's release, and the more extreme haters started claiming she was either a willing HYDRA collaborator[[note]]While ''Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier'' revealed she knowingly worked with Arnim Zola after Operation Paperclip as part of the film's big message of HeWhoFightsMonsters, it's never stated how well they got along as opposed to TeethClenchedTeamwork, and Old Peggy's speech implies that she disapproved of and regretted the darker actions she took in service of SHIELD[[/note]] or an abusive PsychoExGirlfriend [[note]]While her shooting at Steve's shield after finding him with another woman was admittedly an extreme response, she knew the shield was bulletproof and had no intention to seriously hurt let alone ''kill'' him[[/note]]. The 2020s saw an increase in appearances and spinoffs focused on Peggy and at least one confirmed instance of a Peggy fan being a WriterOnBoard[[note]][[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRBdzlsQWkk&t=220s An interview]] with the ''What If?'' creative team revealed that at least one show writer ''did'' have an explicit Steve/Peggy shipping agenda and that head writer AC Bradley asked him to tone down [[spoiler:Sharon's death]] in the zombie episode because the original version was considered a gratuitous case of DieForOurShip; see the above Sharon entry for why this is so controversial despite the character's overall lack of popularity[[/note]], which resulted in further backlash from rival shippers and even some nonshippers who accused Marvel of favoring Peggy at the expense of other characters or their relationships with Steve Rogers. Even years after ''Endgame'' was released, Peggy is still a controversial character in certain groups.

to:

* For a long time Peggy Carter avoided this fate, as she was originally intended to be a RomanticFalseLead to Sharon Carter (see above) and her romance with Steve in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheFirstAvenger The First Avenger]]'' was simultaneously regarded as surprisingly well-written and also subjected to a pretty thorough ShipSinking in ''[[Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier The Winter Soldier]]'', so she was well-liked and not considered a threat to other Steve ships. Then ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' unexpectedly refloated the Steve/Peggy ship by [[spoiler:having Steve choose to travel back in time to be with her]], and Peggy's popularity with shippers suddenly took a massive nosedive. [[RevengeFic Revenge fics]] where Steve goes to the past, breaks up with her, and immediately returns to the future to be with someone else materialized just days after the movie's release, and the more extreme haters started claiming she was either a willing HYDRA collaborator[[note]]While ''Film/CaptainAmericaTheWinterSoldier'' revealed she knowingly worked with Arnim Zola after Operation Paperclip as part of the film's big message of HeWhoFightsMonsters, it's never stated how well they got along as opposed to TeethClenchedTeamwork, and Old Peggy's speech implies that she disapproved of and regretted the darker actions she took in service of SHIELD[[/note]] or an abusive PsychoExGirlfriend [[note]]While her shooting at Steve's shield after finding him with another woman was admittedly an extreme response, she knew the shield was bulletproof and had no intention to seriously hurt let alone ''kill'' him[[/note]]. The 2020s saw an increase in appearances and spinoffs focused on Peggy Peggy, later entries revisiting the Steve/Peggy romance in various controversial ways, and at least one confirmed instance of a Peggy fan being a WriterOnBoard[[note]][[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRBdzlsQWkk&t=220s An interview]] with the ''What If?'' creative team revealed that at least one show writer ''did'' have an explicit Steve/Peggy shipping agenda and that head writer AC Bradley asked him to tone down [[spoiler:Sharon's death]] in the zombie episode because the original version was considered a gratuitous case of DieForOurShip; see the above Sharon entry for why this is so controversial despite the character's overall lack of popularity[[/note]], which resulted in further backlash from rival shippers and even some nonshippers who accused Marvel of favoring subjecting Peggy to posthumous CharacterShilling at the expense of other characters or their relationships with Steve Rogers. Even years after ''Endgame'' was released, Peggy is still a controversial character in certain groups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Most Steve/Peggy antis prefer to demonize Steve or Peggy directly and didn't even know about the Daisy/Sousa thing. Possibly considering a Sousa entry as I've had to clean up a lot of lengthy and particularly deranged ship rants bashing him in the past, but those editors seemed to be a little fringe even by this page's standards.


* Sharon Carter/Agent 13 gets a lot of hate from all sides despite being a prominent figure in the comics, and Captain America's main love interest. Known for being Captain America's SecondLove, she's not only hated for getting between the HoYay Steve/Bucky and Steve/Tony shipping, but also gets flack from the ardent Steve/Peggy shippers. It didn't help that the ''Captain America'' films gave her very little screentime or relationship build-up with Steve, causing even non-shippers to feel that she was woefully underdeveloped as a DesignatedLoveInterest.

to:

* Sharon Carter/Agent 13 gets a lot of hate from all sides despite being more of a prominent figure in the comics, and Captain America's main love interest. comics. Known for being Captain America's SecondLove, SecondLove and also his primary love interest (which was originally going to be the case in the MCU as well), she's not only hated for getting between the HoYay Steve/Bucky and Steve/Tony shipping, but also gets flack from the ardent Steve/Peggy shippers. It didn't help that the ''Captain America'' films gave her very little screentime or relationship build-up with Steve, causing even non-shippers to feel that she was woefully underdeveloped as a DesignatedLoveInterest.



* Regarding ''Series/AgentsOfSHIELD'', Daisy also gets this occasionally from Peggy/Sousa shippers and Steve/Peggy antis thanks to her romance arc with FishOutOfTemporalWater Sousa near the end of the final season. Some saw it as an egregious case of PairTheSpares, alleging that Daisy and Sousa had no chemistry with each other and nothing in common besides their mutual lack of a love interest. Others thought the plotline that brought Sousa into the present was a major AssPull and expressed their dissatisfaction with it by hating on one half of the pairing. Not helping matters was the fact that Daisy had always been a BaseBreakingCharacter; while this was most prominent in the early seasons prior to her CharacterDevelopment and the show GrowingTheBeard, she had a small contingent of detractors right up until the series’ cancellation, and they were more than willing to use the Daisy/Sousa ship as yet another reason to rail against her.

to:

* Regarding ''Series/AgentsOfSHIELD'', Daisy also gets this occasionally from Peggy/Sousa shippers and Steve/Peggy antis thanks to her romance arc with FishOutOfTemporalWater Sousa near the end of the final season. Some saw it as an egregious case of PairTheSpares, alleging arguing that Daisy and Sousa had no chemistry with each other and had nothing in common besides their mutual lack of a love interest. Others thought the plotline that brought Sousa into the present was a major AssPull and expressed their dissatisfaction with it by hating on one half of the pairing. Not helping matters was the fact that Daisy had always been a BaseBreakingCharacter; while this was most prominent in the early seasons prior to her CharacterDevelopment and the show GrowingTheBeard, she had a small contingent of detractors right up until the series’ cancellation, and they were more than willing to use the Daisy/Sousa ship as yet another reason to rail against her.

Top