Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / WhenTheWindBlows

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the film, we get to hear Jim's side of his telephone conversation with his son Ron about building an inner-core-or-refuge. From what we hear, Ron (rightly) thinks the advice given in the official leaflets is "cobblers", though Jim still thinks he knows best and berates Ron for not taking the situation seriously. The comic simply has Jim going to make the phonecall, then reporting to Hilda that:

to:

** In the film, we get to hear Jim's side of his telephone conversation with his son Ron about building an inner-core-or-refuge. From what we hear, Ron (rightly) thinks believes the advice given in the official leaflets pamphlets is "cobblers", though Jim still thinks he knows best and berates Ron for not taking the situation seriously. The comic simply has Jim going to make the phonecall, then reporting to Hilda that:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the film, Jim and Hilda hear a dog howling in the distance when they go outside after the attack(first heard in the radio adaptation). We also get to see the ruins of the nearby village, though it's unclear how many of its inhabitants are still alive, as the only signs of life are the aforementioned dog and a bird, the latter of which is in its death throes. However, as in the comic, it's all but certain that the "roast dinners" Jim and Hilda can smell are actually the corpses of people and animals caught outside during the attack and burned to death. The comic simply has Jim and Hilda standing in their garden and looking over the hedge; we don't see what's on the other side.

to:

** In the film, Jim and Hilda hear a dog howling in the distance when they go outside after the attack(first attack (first heard in the radio adaptation). We also get to see the ruins of the nearby village, though it's unclear how many of its inhabitants are still alive, as the only signs of life are the aforementioned dog and a bird, the latter of which is in its death throes. However, as in the comic, it's all but certain that the "roast dinners" Jim and Hilda can smell are actually the corpses of people and animals caught outside during the attack and burned to death. The comic simply has Jim and Hilda standing in their garden and looking over the hedge; we don't see what's on the other side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the comic, the nuclear explosion is represented by two blank white pages followed by several distorted frames which gradually straighten out to reveal Jim and Hilda crouching in their inner-core-or-refuge. In the film, we actually get to see the effects of the nuclear blast with cars crashing, a train derailing, sheep being blown across a field, and two windmills collapsing. This sequence is accompanied by the last words Hilda utters before the Bomb goes off:

to:

** In the comic, the nuclear explosion is represented by two blank white pages followed by several distorted frames which gradually straighten out to reveal Jim and Hilda crouching in their inner-core-or-refuge. In the film, we actually get to see the effects of the nuclear blast blast, with cars crashing, a train derailing, sheep being blown across a field, and two windmills collapsing. This sequence is accompanied by the last words Hilda utters before the Bomb goes off:

Added: 1756

Changed: 164

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: The film adds Jim's telephone conversation with Ron. Also, the Bloggs hear a dog howling in the distance when they go outside (first heard in the radio adaptation).

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: The film adds AdaptationExpansion:
** In the film, we get to hear
Jim's side of his telephone conversation with Ron. Also, his son Ron about building an inner-core-or-refuge. From what we hear, Ron (rightly) thinks the Bloggs advice given in the official leaflets is "cobblers", though Jim still thinks he knows best and berates Ron for not taking the situation seriously. The comic simply has Jim going to make the phonecall, then reporting to Hilda that:
--->"Ron is not going to build an inner-core-or-refuge. I remonstrated with him, but he was adamant. He says if London cops it, he'll cop it and not to worry, Dad."
** In the comic, the nuclear explosion is represented by two blank white pages followed by several distorted frames which gradually straighten out to reveal Jim and Hilda crouching in their inner-core-or-refuge. In the film, we actually get to see the effects of the nuclear blast with cars crashing, a train derailing, sheep being blown across a field, and two windmills collapsing. This sequence is accompanied by the last words Hilda utters before the Bomb goes off:
--->"The cake will be burned!"
** In the film, Jim and Hilda
hear a dog howling in the distance when they go outside (first after the attack(first heard in the radio adaptation).adaptation). We also get to see the ruins of the nearby village, though it's unclear how many of its inhabitants are still alive, as the only signs of life are the aforementioned dog and a bird, the latter of which is in its death throes. However, as in the comic, it's all but certain that the "roast dinners" Jim and Hilda can smell are actually the corpses of people and animals caught outside during the attack and burned to death. The comic simply has Jim and Hilda standing in their garden and looking over the hedge; we don't see what's on the other side.

Added: 42

Changed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding context and correcting quote indentation.


--->'''Jim:''' "Science has leapt forward with giant strides... science is still in its infancy."

to:

--->'''Jim:''' -->'''Jim:''' "Science has leapt forward with giant strides... science is still in its infancy."



* ShootTheShaggyDog
* SkewedPriorities: "The cake will be burned!"

to:

* ShootTheShaggyDog
ShootTheShaggyDog: Despite Jim and Hilda's best efforts to survive the bomb, they ultimately become little more than statistics.
* SkewedPriorities: Hilda seems more concerned with her cake being ruined than the fact that Britain is about to be nuked.
-->'''Hilda:'''
"The cake will be burned!"


[[NamesTheSame Not to be confused with]] the novel by Creator/JamesPatterson.

to:

[[NamesTheSame Not to be confused with]] with the novel by Creator/JamesPatterson.

Added: 830

Changed: 38

Removed: 469

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EmptyPromise: Jim saying that he'll run various errands to get stuff they suddenly realise they need.



* ImmediateSelfContradiction: Albeit some time apart:
--->'''Jim:''' "Science has leapt forward with giant strides... science is still in its infancy."



* StealthSequel: Fans of Briggs's work will recognise Jim and Hilda from his earlier book ''Gentleman Jim''.



* TooDumbToLive: Though they are more naive than dumb, the Bloggses, especially Hilda, just have no grip whatsoever on the true implications of "the bomb" being dropped, likening it to the nightly bombings carried out by the Luftwaffe on the British mainland during World War II. Among other things, they fail to consider their root cellar as a viable shelter, relying instead on the shoddy and useless "Inner Core or Refuge." [[spoiler: Yes, they do fail to survive.]]



* TooDumbToLive: Though they are more naive than dumb, the Bloggses, especially Hilda, just have no grip whatsoever on the true implications of "the bomb" being dropped, likening it to the nightly bombings carried out by the Luftwaffe on the British mainland during World War II. Among other things, they fail to consider their root cellar as a viable shelter, relying instead on the shoddy and useless "Inner Core or Refuge." [[spoiler: Yes, they do fail to survive.]]



* AdaptationExpansion: The film adds Jim's telephone conversation with Ron. Also, the Bloggs hear a dog howling in the distance when they go outside.

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: The film adds Jim's telephone conversation with Ron. Also, the Bloggs hear a dog howling in the distance when they go outside.outside (first heard in the radio adaptation).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WrongGenreSavvy: Jim and Hilda thinks the coming nuclear war will be like the Blitz and the Second World War. They learn the hard way that it is not.

to:

* WrongGenreSavvy: Jim and Hilda thinks think the coming nuclear war will be like the Blitz and the Second World War. They learn the hard way that it is not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per wick cleanup.


%% * GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the future, please check the trope page to make sure your example fits the current definition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CouldHaveAvoidedThisPlot: Hilda points out they could have used their root cellar instead of a makeshift shelter built out of wooden doors.

to:

* CouldHaveAvoidedThisPlot: Hilda points out they could have used their root cellar instead of a makeshift shelter built out of wooden doors. Though it's debatable whether they really would have lasted much longer had they sheltered in the cellar given the radioactive fallout in the air and rainwater.



* ForegoneConclusion: It's obvious that the shelter and all of the other measures Jim and Hilda took are completely useless and that they'll be dead of radiation poisoning within a matter of days.

to:

* ForegoneConclusion: It's Once the bomb drops, it's obvious that the shelter and all of the other measures Jim and Hilda took are completely useless and that they'll be dead of radiation poisoning within a matter of days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForegoneConclusion: It's obvious that the shelter and all of the other measures Jim and Hilda took are completely useless and that they'll be dead of radiation poisoning within a matter of days.


Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: We're spared a hopeful and happy ending. In its place we get a realistic scenario where even the few who survive the initial blast die days later from radiation sickness, while the epilogue of MAD (mutually assured destruction) suggests that what the Bloggses experienced will be the fate of most of humanity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DigitalDestruction: The Blu-ray release for the film does a good job of improving the quality of the video, but the audio quality has a slightly metallic sound for some unknown reason.

to:

* DigitalDestruction: The Blu-ray release for the film does a good job of improving the quality of the video, video quality, but the audio quality has a slightly metallic sound for some unknown reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DigitalDestruction: The Blu-ray release for the film does a good job of improving the quality of the video, but the audio quality has a slightly metallic sound for some unknown reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicked Ill Girl


* IllGirl: Both Jim and Hilda falling ill of radiation sickness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Jim:''' Ron will be all right. He won't go to pieces. The whole family will [[BodyHorror stick together]].

to:

--->'''Jim:''' Ron will be all right. He won't [[LudicrousGibs go to pieces. pieces.]] The whole family will [[BodyHorror stick together]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeInterruptThisProgram: Said on the radio before announcing the nuclear missile strike.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PopStarComposer: Music/RogerWaters did the score, Music/DavidBowie wrote the title song, and Music/{{Genesis}}, Music/{{Squeeze}} and Paul Hardcastle appear in the score too.

to:

* PopStarComposer: Music/RogerWaters did the score, Music/DavidBowie wrote the title song, and Music/{{Genesis}}, Music/{{Genesis|Band}}, Music/{{Squeeze}} and Paul Hardcastle appear in the score too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SeriousWorkComedicScene: This is a dark comic book (and movie) about a couple slowly succumbing to radiation poisoning, but there are a few moments of BlackComedy sprinkled into it, such as Hilda [[SkewedPriorities complaining that her cake will be ruined during the bombing]], and when Jim mistakes the smell of what is implied to be charred corpses for the neighbors cooking roast pork.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: In the final moments of the comic, the couple begin to pray, but cannot recall any prayers. In his desperation to say something poignant-sounding, James inadvertently quotes Tennyson's poem ''The Charge of the Light Brigade'', the famous story of a cavalry unit who followed incorrect orders to their certain deaths.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
We're not supposed to list Useful Notes pages as tropes.


* UsefulNotes/WorldWarII: Heavily referenced and invoked to show the Bloggses' naivete. Having lived through the Blitz, Jim and Hilda see the situation through a romanticised, inaccurate vision of the War ([[StiffUpperLip keep calm and carry on]], [[BlackAndWhiteMorality "all that mob on the other side"]], etc.), so much that they not only can't grasp the reality of the hell they find themselves in (thinking someone will come by eventually like an air raid warden and signal the all-clear), but [[DiscoDan that this IS just like the War]] -- Jim believes "Ike and Monty" are still in charge, and, not knowing anything about the "Russkies" or why they fell out with "Joe Stalin", sometimes accidentally calls them "Jerries", even after correcting his own wife for doing it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImagineSpot: Jim has a number of them throughout the film about World War II nostalgia. A notable one involves UsefulNotes/BernardLawMontgomery, aka "Monty", as still being in command of the British military; an image of Monty shows up next to Jim until Hilda points out that he is most likely dead. The ghost of Monty reacts, leaves Jim's side and fades away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PopStarComposer: The film adaptation's soundtrack was done by former Music/PinkFloyd bandleader Music/RogerWaters, with Music/DavidBowie additionally writing and performing the title song.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TragicMistake: Downplayed; the Bloggses mistakenly think they're only supposed to spend two days in their makeshift shelter rather than two weeks. However, given that the blast blew out their house's windows and scattered radioactive dust and debris all throughout the interior, and the shelter wasn't sealed off from the rest of the house, their mistake really just sped up the inevitable a little.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoodleImplements: Discussed as Jim and Hilda review the leaflets going over other items they should have in their refuge. Hilda even questions the use of having a pen and notepad for messages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Filk Song is about fanmade homage, and shouldn't be referenced on a work page


* FilkSong: "When the Wind Blows" by Music/DavidBowie (made for the movie, see PopStarComposer below), and "When the Wild Wind Blows" by Music/IronMaiden (which replaces the ending with [[spoiler:the couple mistaking an earthquake for a nuclear bomb and killing themselves]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!''When the Wind Blows'' provides examples of:

to:

!!''When !!When the Wind Blows'' Blows provides examples of:



* CosyCatastrophe: Deconstructed. Jim and Hilda both lived through the Blitz when they were young and look back on life during World War II with rose-tinted nostalgia, so they adopt the same attitude towards nuclear war. That attitude turns out not to help them at all, since their nostalgia has blinded them to the true horrors of war and the aftermath of nuclear war is ''much'' worse than the Blitz. It also doesn't help that the instructions the British government provides for dealing with the fallout are [[FalloutShelterFail completely useless]].

to:

* CosyCatastrophe: Deconstructed. Jim and Hilda both lived through the Blitz when they were young and look back on life during World War II with rose-tinted nostalgia, young, so they adopt the same attitude towards nuclear war. That attitude turns out not to help them at all, since their nostalgia it has blinded them to the true horrors of war and the aftermath of nuclear war is ''much'' worse than the Blitz. It also doesn't help that the instructions the British government provides for dealing with the fallout are [[FalloutShelterFail completely useless]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* WrongGenreSavvy: Jim and Hilda thinks the coming nuclear war will be like the Blitz and the Second World War. They learn the hard way that it is not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A classic weapon of the anti-nuclear weapon movement, ''When The Wind Blows'' uses its bright colours, eccentric characters and art style similar to Briggs's classic children's story ''ComicBook/TheSnowman'' to [[SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped hammer home the horrors of nuclear war]], and [[BlackComedy make dark satire]] about government leaflets advising how best to survive a nuclear attack. Naturally, its child-like style in both art and the characters' personalities make it one of the more famous examples to come from the AnimationAgeGhetto.

to:

A classic weapon of the anti-nuclear weapon movement, ''When The Wind Blows'' uses its bright colours, eccentric characters and art style similar to Briggs's classic children's story ''ComicBook/TheSnowman'' to [[SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped hammer home the horrors of nuclear war]], war, and [[BlackComedy make dark satire]] about government leaflets advising how best to survive a nuclear attack. Naturally, its child-like style in both art and the characters' personalities make it one of the more famous examples to come from the AnimationAgeGhetto.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DownerEnding: [[spoiler:Hilda and Jim eventually die from radiation sickness some days after the bombing.]] Just after this, the skies clear, and it seems that the nuclear fallout is gone, only for an off-screen telegraph to tap out [[spoiler: M.A.D. (Mutually Assured Destruction)]] in Morse code at the end of the credits. [[spoiler:Either this wasn't a one-off nuclear attack, and a war is about to ensue, or the war is over and NATO and Warsaw Pact have wiped each other out.]]

to:

* DownerEnding: [[spoiler:Hilda and Jim eventually die from radiation sickness some days after the bombing.]] Just after this, the skies clear, and it seems that the nuclear fallout is gone, only for an off-screen telegraph to tap out [[spoiler: M.A.D. (Mutually Assured Destruction)]] in Morse code at the end of the credits. [[spoiler:Either this wasn't a one-off nuclear attack, and a war is about to ensue, or the war is over and NATO and Warsaw Pact have wiped each other out. Alternatively, if peace does prevail, anyone who survived the nuclear bombing and the hell that followed may now stand a chance.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Deconstructed. The Bloggs, especially Jim, make repeated misinterpretations about the severity of the fallout (eg. believing the burning smell is the neighbours cooking dinner, or the lack of water and electric being due to the government taking wise safety precautions). The Bloggs' whimsical obliviousness leans it into BlackComedy, though as things go on, the ramifications hit in and it falls more cleanly into DramaticallyMissingThePoint.

Top