Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / ASongOfIceAndFireHouseTully

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThemeNaming: You may notice a pattern in this era of the Tully family, in that they're all named after characters from ''Sesame Street''.


Added DiffLines:

* OddNameOut: Sort of. Of the four Tullys of his era, he's the only one technically not named after a character from ''Sesame Street'' (Kermit debuted in ''Series/SamAndFriends'', in 1955).


Added DiffLines:

* GrumpyBear: Oscar was not the friendliest person around. One could even say he was a grouch.

Added: 1398

Changed: 1938

Removed: 193

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeelFaceTurn: Led forces in the Battle beneath the God's Eye, but as soon as Jaehaerys support began to increase, he quickly switched sides.

to:

* HeelFaceTurn: Led forces in the Battle beneath the God's Eye, but as soon as Jaehaerys Jaehaerys' support began to increase, he quickly switched sides.



[[folder:Lord Elmo Tully]]
!!Lord Elmo Tully
[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/elmo_tully_woiaf_7090.png]]

Grandson of Lord Grover Tully, Ser Elmo defied his bedridden grandfather's wishes during the Dance of the Dragons and entered the war in support of Queen Rhaenyra Targaryen instead of Aegon II.

to:

[[folder:Lord Elmo [[folder:Lady Lucinda Tully]]
!!Lord Elmo !!Lady Lucinda Tully
[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/elmo_tully_woiaf_7090.png]]

Grandson
The wife of Lord Grover Tully, Ser Elmo defied his bedridden grandfather's wishes Prentys Tully and Lady of Riverrun during the Dance reigns of the Dragons and entered the war in support of Queen Rhaenyra Maegor I Targaryen instead and Jaehaerys I Targaryen. Formerly of Aegon II.House Broome, she was famed across Westeros for her piety. She served as a lady-in-waiting, as well as governess to the household of Queen Alysanne Targaryen during her minority.



* AHouseDivided: He and his grandfather disagreed over who should inherit the Iron Throne, and Elmo actually ignored his grandfathers command to support Aegon. At first, he simply kept the Riverlands out of the war, but soon led their army against Aegon's forces.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: He considered Queen Rhaenyra was the rightful successor to the Iron Throne and defied his grandfather's legitimate commands to support Aegon II to ensure she and her heirs won it.
* ShortRunner: Unfortunately he only lasted as Lord of Riverrun for 40 days before dying en route to King's Landing, forcing his son Kermit to take over.
* YouAreInCommandNow: Grover died shortly after the battle at Second Tumbleton, making Elmo lord in name and fact.

to:

* AHouseDivided: He LadyInWaiting: She was one of several dispatched to Dragonstone by Dowager Queen Alyssa Velaryon to serve her daughter, Alysanne (though Rogar Baratheon had Lady Lucinda and the other women sent to Dragonstone try to convince Alysanne to break off her marriage to her brother, Jaehaerys).
* ProperLady: What she is described as being.
* [[RealMenLoveJesus Real Women Love Jesus]]: Lady Lucinda was famed for her piety. When the Faith Militant rose in revolt, despite Maegor disbanding them, she convinced her husband to give shelter to Ser Joffrey Doggett
and his grandfather disagreed over who should inherit men at Riverrun and tried (unsuccessfully) to convince King Jaehaerys to repeal his uncle's abolishment of the Iron Throne, Faith Militant.
* TogetherInDeath: She
and Elmo actually ignored her husband died within a day of each other during the Shivers pandemic in 59AC.
* TheWomanBehindTheMan: She convinced her husband to look the other way to Ser Joffrey Doggett and
his grandfathers command to support Aegon. At first, he simply kept Faith Militant guerrillas roaming the Riverlands out of the war, but soon led their army against Aegon's forces.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: He considered Queen Rhaenyra was the rightful successor to the Iron Throne
and defied his grandfather's legitimate commands to support Aegon II to ensure she and her heirs won it.
* ShortRunner: Unfortunately he only lasted as Lord of Riverrun for 40 days before dying en route to King's Landing, forcing his son Kermit to take over.
* YouAreInCommandNow: Grover died shortly after the battle at Second Tumbleton, making Elmo lord in name and fact.
Westerlands.



[[folder:Lord Kermit Tully]]
!!Lord Kermit Tully

Son of Lord Elmo, Kermit inherited his command of the Riverlands army, and eventually became overall commander of the forces loyal to Aegon III. Under his reign, House Tully reached the peak of its power and influence in Westeros.

to:

[[folder:Lord Kermit Elmo Tully]]
!!Lord Kermit Tully

Son
Elmo Tully
[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/elmo_tully_woiaf_7090.png]]

Grandson
of Lord Elmo, Kermit inherited Grover Tully, Ser Elmo defied his command bedridden grandfather's wishes during the Dance of the Riverlands army, Dragons and eventually became overall commander of entered the forces loyal to war in support of Queen Rhaenyra Targaryen instead of Aegon III. Under his reign, House Tully reached the peak of its power and influence in Westeros.II.


Added DiffLines:

* AHouseDivided: He and his grandfather disagreed over who should inherit the Iron Throne, and Elmo actually ignored his grandfathers command to support Aegon. At first, he simply kept the Riverlands out of the war, but soon led their army against Aegon's forces.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: He considered Queen Rhaenyra was the rightful successor to the Iron Throne and defied his grandfather's legitimate commands to support Aegon II to ensure she and her heirs won it.
* ShortRunner: Unfortunately he only lasted as Lord of Riverrun for 40 days before dying en route to King's Landing, forcing his son Kermit to take over.
* YouAreInCommandNow: Grover died shortly after the battle at Second Tumbleton, making Elmo lord in name and fact.
[[/folder]]

[[folder:Lord Kermit Tully]]
!!Lord Kermit Tully

Son of Lord Elmo, Kermit inherited his command of the Riverlands army, and eventually became overall commander of the forces loyal to Aegon III. Under his reign, House Tully reached the peak of its power and influence in Westeros.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ElementalMotifs: Water. Unlike House Greyjoy, whose motifs are built around the violent and volatile nature of the ocean, House Tully evokes the nurturing role of rivers, especially in a politically turbulent region. Their house colors are blue and red, their seat is Riverrun, and their sigil is a leaping trout. Their house words are "Family, Duty, Honor", reflecting their heavy focus on family.

Added: 1185

Changed: 80

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassHasAPoint: While giving a commander an audience just to mock them is a bit cruel, the Blackfish is completely correct that Jaime's word about being civil to the surrendering Tullys can't be trusted. As he puts it, the Lannisters violated SacredHospitality through the Red Wedding and it sets a precedent for them being dishonorable. He's all but laughing as Jaime sensibly decides to leave, realizing the negotiations will go nowhere.



* {{Troll}}: As he admits, he was never going to negotiate with Jaime when they were parleying. He just wanted the guy to show up to mock him.



* FaceDeathWithDignity: One impressive character trait is he can stare death in the face and not lose his nerves. Jaime finds out that he was threatened with hanging every day and refused to help his captors, complete with a noose around his neck. [[spoiler:His wife and unborn child, however, are another matter]].



* PerfectlyArrangedMarriage: Despite how the wedding itself turned out, it seems that [[spoiler:Edmure and his wife, Roslin Frey]] do genuinely love each other. [[spoiler: Edmure expresses extreme relief when Jamie promises him in AFFC that after she gives birth, Roslin and their child will join him at Casterly Rock. It's said that Roslin prays every day for a daughter so Edmure won't be killed by her family - the birth of a Tully/Frey son and heir means they would have no use for him anymore.]]

to:

* PerfectlyArrangedMarriage: Despite how the wedding itself turned out, it seems that [[spoiler:Edmure and his wife, Roslin Frey]] do genuinely love each other. [[spoiler: Edmure expresses extreme relief when Jamie Jaime promises him in AFFC that after she gives birth, Roslin and their child will join him at Casterly Rock. It's said that Roslin prays every day for a daughter so Edmure won't be killed by her family - the birth of a Tully/Frey son and heir means they would have no use for him anymore.]]



* ThisIsUnforgivable: He surrenders Riverrun to Jaime [[spoiler:to save Roslin, but makes it clear that while he's relieved Roslin and his child will be alive, he's never forgetting that Jaime's family caused the Red Wedding. Jaime brushes it off, because he got what he wanted]].



* NiceGirl: A rarity among her family.

to:

* NiceGirl: A rarity among her family. [[spoiler:Not so nice that she hide important details about the Red Wedding]].

Added: 589

Changed: 1

Removed: 589

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling and alphabetization.


* ComesGreatResponsibility: To almost BlessedWithSuck degree. Aegon probably gave the most difficult job to Edmyn Tully: administrate a land with no real culture that hold them together (like the North or the Westerlands) and that is pretty much a nest of FeudingFamilies. The reason why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk -- is they are usually quite pratical, reasonable and even-handed. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they have made for a stable and refreshing change of pace during their stewardship.

to:

* ComesGreatResponsibility: To almost BlessedWithSuck degree. Aegon probably gave the most difficult job to Edmyn Tully: administrate a land with no real culture that hold them together (like the North or the Westerlands) and that is pretty much a nest of FeudingFamilies. The reason why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk -- is they are usually quite pratical, practical, reasonable and even-handed. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they have made for a stable and refreshing change of pace during their stewardship.



* FoolishSiblingResponsibleSibling: Catelyn was the Responsible to Edmure/Lysa's Foolish.



* FoolishSiblingResponsibleSibling: Catelyn was the Responsible to Edmure/Lysa's Foolish.



* PerfectlyArrangedMarriage: Despite how the wedding itself turned out, it seems that [[spoiler:Edmure and his wife, Roslin Frey]] do genuinely love each other. [[spoiler: Edmure expresses extreme relief when Jamie promises him in AFFC that after she gives birth, Roslin and their child will join him at Casterly Rock. It's said that Roslin prays every day for a daughter so Edmure won't be killed by her family - the birth of a Tully/Frey son and heir means they would have no use for him anymore.]]



* PerfectlyArrangedMarriage: Despite how the wedding itself turned out, it seems that [[spoiler:Edmure and his wife, Roslin Frey]] do genuinely love each other. [[spoiler: Edmure expresses extreme relief when Jamie promises him in AFFC that after she gives birth, Roslin and their child will join him at Casterly Rock. It's said that Roslin prays every day for a daughter so Edmure won't be killed by her family - the birth of a Tully/Frey son and heir means they would have no use for him anymore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The reason the "Sensible" characters complain is because Edmure is specifically allowing peasants into the castle during a seige that could hypothetically last for weeks on end where they barely have enough food for the Lords. They're not complaining that he tries to protect his smallfolk in general.


** This may be a case of ArtisticLicenseMilitary on GRRM's part, as sheltering peasants in your castle was exactly what a medieval lord was ''supposed'' to do - for all that the "sensible" characters bemoan Edmure's kindness as stupidity, it's actually a good idea to keep your smallfolk alive, because just leaving all your workers and farmers to get killed would render your land useless, and even new soldiers have to come from ''somewhere''.

Added: 554

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreudianTrio: Hoster's three children.
** Catelyn: TheReliableOne, devoted to family and duty (Superego).
** Lysa: Overtly unstable, resentful, and [[spoiler:took out her frustrations by murdering her husband and causing a CivilWar]] (Id).
** Edmure: Brash and impulsive, but not psychopathic (Ego).



* {{Foil}}: To Jaime Lannister.

to:

* {{Foil}}: To Jaime Lannister.


Added DiffLines:

** Edmure can be considered the opposite of Robert Baratheon. Both are HotBlooded men who would rather face problems head-on, but Robert is a fantastic wartime leader who languishes in peacetime while Edmure is a poor general who works better in peacetime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GetOut: Edmure was on the receiving end of this; Catelyn remembers that Littlefinger never [[ThisIsUnforgivable forgave Edmure]] for being TheSquire to Brandon Stark at their duel, and sent him away when Edmure tried to pay Petyr a visit while he was convalescing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReliableOne: Aegon trusted him first with the Riverlands wardenship (tough job), and then with being Hand of the King (even tougher). It's easy to see him as such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComesGreatResponsibility: To almost BlessedWithSuck degree. Aegon probably gave the most difficult job to Edmyn Tully: administrate a land with no real culture that hold them together (like the North or the Westerlands) and that is pretty much a nest of FeudingFamilies. The reason why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk is they are usually pratical, reasonable and even-handed. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they have made for a stable change of pace during their stewardship.

to:

* ComesGreatResponsibility: To almost BlessedWithSuck degree. Aegon probably gave the most difficult job to Edmyn Tully: administrate a land with no real culture that hold them together (like the North or the Westerlands) and that is pretty much a nest of FeudingFamilies. The reason why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk -- is they are usually quite pratical, reasonable and even-handed. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they have made for a stable and refreshing change of pace during their stewardship.



* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Probably the only thing the Riverlords can agree on is that the Ironborn really suck. When House Tully gained leadership of the Riverlands, it had to deal with the Ironborn, the feud between the Blackwoods and the Brackens, stewarding a region that had never been a distinct, independent region, and protect its territorial integrity from the five other kingdoms with which it shares a land border. In at least two different wars, the Riverlords were split between different factions. In hindsight, Aegon probably gave Edmyn Tully one of the hardest jobs in the Seven Kingdoms.

to:

* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Probably the only thing the Riverlords can agree on is that the Ironborn really suck. When House Tully gained leadership of the Riverlands, it had to deal with the Ironborn, the feud between the Blackwoods and the Brackens, stewarding a region that had never been a distinct, independent region, and protect protecting its territorial integrity from the five other kingdoms with which it shares a land border. In at least two different wars, the Riverlords were split between different factions. In hindsight, Aegon probably gave Edmyn Tully one of the hardest jobs in the Seven Kingdoms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This may be a case of ArtisticLicenseMilitary on GRRM's part, as sheltering peasants in your castle was exactly what a medieval lord was ''supposed'' to do - for all that the "sensible" characters bemoan Edmure's kindness as stupidity, it's actually a good idea to keep your smallfolk alive, because just leaving all your workers and farmers get killed would render your land useless, and even new soldiers have to come from ''somewhere''.

to:

** This may be a case of ArtisticLicenseMilitary on GRRM's part, as sheltering peasants in your castle was exactly what a medieval lord was ''supposed'' to do - for all that the "sensible" characters bemoan Edmure's kindness as stupidity, it's actually a good idea to keep your smallfolk alive, because just leaving all your workers and farmers to get killed would render your land useless, and even new soldiers have to come from ''somewhere''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This may be a case of ArtisticLicenseMilitary on GRRM's part, as sheltering peasants in your castle was exactly what a medieval lord was ''supposed'' to do - for all that the "sensible" characters bemoan Edmure's kindness as stupidity, it's actually a good idea to keep your smallfolk alive, because just leaving all your workers and farmers get killed would render your land useless, and even new soldiers have to come from ''somewhere''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScatterbrainedSenior: As he lays dying from illness and old age, his memory becomes faulty. At one point when Catelyn comes to see him, he thinks she's Lysa and begs her forgiveness for [[spoiler:the moon tea]], promising that she'll have healthy, trueborn children.

to:

* ScatterbrainedSenior: As he lays dying from illness and old age, his memory becomes faulty. At one point when Catelyn comes to see him, he thinks she's Lysa and begs her forgiveness for [[spoiler:the moon tea]], promising that she'll have many healthy, trueborn children.

Added: 269

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MyGreatestFailure: [[spoiler:He utterly destroyed his own daughter. He is entirely responsible for Lysa's crippling insecurities and irrational behavior by forcing her to abort her child with Littlefinger and damaging permanently her capacity to bear children after preaching healthy, plump babes to her. He dies buried in guilt and apologizing to an empty room, since Lysa has no interest in ''ever'' forgiving him.]]

to:

* MyGreatestFailure: [[spoiler:He utterly destroyed his own daughter. He is entirely responsible for Lysa's crippling insecurities and irrational behavior by forcing her to abort her child with Littlefinger and damaging permanently her capacity to bear children after preaching promising healthy, plump babes to her. He dies buried in guilt and apologizing to an empty room, since Lysa has no interest in ''ever'' forgiving him.]]


Added DiffLines:

* ScatterbrainedSenior: As he lays dying from illness and old age, his memory becomes faulty. At one point when Catelyn comes to see him, he thinks she's Lysa and begs her forgiveness for [[spoiler:the moon tea]], promising that she'll have healthy, trueborn children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWisePrince: It is noted that, despite not being a strategist, Edmure would make a superb ruler in peace times. And, this is reflected in how the smallfolk of the Riverlands respond to the Lannister-Frey alliance that is trying to control them. They want ''their'' "he cares about us" Edmure Tully back about as much as they want the "they really don't give a toss" Freys thrown out of Riverrun. And, will support the Brotherhood Without Banners to make that happen.

to:

* TheWisePrince: It is noted that, despite not being a strategist, political strategist of note, Edmure would make a superb ''superb'' ruler in peace times. peacetime. And, this is reflected in how the smallfolk of the Riverlands respond to the Lannister-Frey alliance that is trying to control them. They them: they want ''their'' "he actually cares about us" Edmure Tully back about as much as (or more than) they want the those "they really don't give a bloody toss" Freys thrown out of Riverrun. And, will support the Brotherhood Without Banners to make that happen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** During the '''three days''' Tywin was held up in the Riverlands, he receives word of Renly's death, the Lannister alliance with the Tyrells, and Stannis's impending attack on King's Landing, and is able to take the bulk of his forces east to link up with the Tyrells and smash Stannis at the Blackwater. Without the seventy hour delay, Tywin would already have been trapped between Robb's cavalry army and Edmure's Riverlands army by the time he learned of Stannis's attack. Robb and the Blackfish then planned to ride south to blockade the only road between the Westerlands and King's Landing, while Edmure held the border with the Westerlands and retook the Lannister-occupied Riverlands. By a mere stroke of fate, Tywin managed to grab an unlikely victory from the jaws of certain defeat, all thanks to the above micommunication.

to:

** During the '''three days''' Tywin was held up in the Riverlands, he receives word of Renly's death, the Lannister alliance with the Tyrells, and Stannis's impending attack on King's Landing, and is able to take the bulk of his forces east to link up with the Tyrells and smash Stannis at the Blackwater. Without the seventy hour delay, Tywin would already have been trapped between Robb's cavalry army and Edmure's Riverlands army by the time he learned of Stannis's attack. Robb and the Blackfish then planned to ride south to blockade the only road between the Westerlands and King's Landing, while Edmure held the border with the Westerlands and retook the Lannister-occupied Riverlands. By a mere stroke of fate, Tywin managed to grab an unlikely victory from the jaws of certain defeat, all thanks to the above micommunication.miscommunication.

Added: 785

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBabyOfTheBunch: He is treated this way by his family and later, ''by his own nephew'' Robb Stark. On one hand its implied that he has had a very spoilt and indulgent upbringing, being taken care of by his father, his elder sister and his uncle, on the other hand this has put a sizable chip on his shoulder and a need to be "taken seriously" which results in a major mess for Robb Stark's cause.

to:

* TheBabyOfTheBunch: He is treated this way by his family and later, ''by his own nephew'' Robb Stark. On one hand its it's implied that he has had a very spoilt and indulgent upbringing, being taken care of by his father, his elder sister and his uncle, on the other hand this has put a sizable chip on his shoulder and a need to be "taken seriously" which results in a major mess for Robb Stark's cause.



* ReplacementGoldfish: He was the next Hand after Orys Baratheon's resign from the job. Whatever he did during his rule, it must have difficult to replace the king's closest friend and (possibly) half-brother.

to:

* ReplacementGoldfish: He was the next Hand after Orys Baratheon's resign resignation from the job. Whatever he did during his rule, it must have difficult to replace the king's closest friend and (possibly) half-brother.


Added DiffLines:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: He, along with his brother and his ally Benjicot Blackwood, got [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech chewed out]] for this by a furious Cregan Stark, who [[JerkassHasAPoint accurately]] pointed out they were idiots for just taking Corlys Velaryon and Larys Strong's word the war was over and remaining in King's Landing celebrating, when plenty of Aegon II's former loyalists remained at Oldtown, Casterly Rock and Storm's End and could still cause trouble if they weren't destroyed.


Added DiffLines:

* KnowWhenToFoldEm: Kermit and his allies quickly aligned themselves with Cregan Stark's plans to attack any remaining loyalists of Aegon II. Grand Maester Munkun claims they agreed for the prospect of more glory and plunder, while Mushroom claims they were just scared shitless of Cregan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThePeterPriniple: On a tactical level, he's arguably brilliant: he defeated Tywin at the Battle of the Fords, taking advantage of the terrain to deal the Westermen heavy losses and smash them in every engagement despite having only 11,000 men to Tywin's 16,000-18,000. However, he's not exactly fit to conduct a country-scale war effort: his initial handling of the conflict gets his forces scattered, damaged, and separated by the more strategically minded Tywin despite the Riverlands and Westerlands being about equal in wealth and population (though Tywin had the advantage of the initiative), and he ends up indirectly screwing over Robb's plan to draw Tywin into the Westerlands. If this plan had succeeded, the Riverlands would have been free to raise their full strength (without Tywin reaving the area and effectively cutting the northeast Riverlands off from the rest by squatting at Harrenhal) and Tywin would have been trapped between Robb, Edmure, and Roose's hosts, effectively dooming him. Stannis wiping out his only other extant host in a CurbStompBattle at King's Landing (killing the royal family in the process) would have sealed Tywin's fate even further.

to:

* ThePeterPriniple: ThePeterPrinciple: On a tactical level, he's arguably brilliant: he defeated Tywin at the Battle of the Fords, taking advantage of the terrain to deal the Westermen heavy losses and smash them in every engagement despite having only 11,000 men to Tywin's 16,000-18,000. However, he's not exactly fit to conduct a country-scale war effort: his initial handling of the conflict gets his forces scattered, damaged, and separated by the more strategically minded Tywin despite the Riverlands and Westerlands being about equal in wealth and population (though Tywin had the advantage of the initiative), and he ends up indirectly screwing over Robb's plan to draw Tywin into the Westerlands. If this plan had succeeded, the Riverlands would have been free to raise their full strength (without Tywin reaving the area and effectively cutting the northeast Riverlands off from the rest by squatting at Harrenhal) and Tywin would have been trapped between Robb, Edmure, and Roose's hosts, effectively dooming him. Stannis wiping out his only other extant host in a CurbStompBattle at King's Landing (killing the royal family in the process) would have sealed Tywin's fate even further.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThePeterPriniple: On a tactical level, he's arguably brilliant: he defeated Tywin at the Battle of the Fords, taking advantage of the terrain to deal the Westermen heavy losses and smash them in every engagement despite having only 11,000 men to Tywin's 16,000-18,000. However, he's not exactly fit to conduct a country-scale war effort: his initial handling of the conflict gets his forces scattered, damaged, and separated by the more strategically minded Tywin despite the Riverlands and Westerlands being about equal in wealth and population (though Tywin had the advantage of the initiative), and he ends up indirectly screwing over Robb's plan to draw Tywin into the Westerlands. If this plan had succeeded, the Riverlands would have been free to raise their full strength (without Tywin reaving the area and effectively cutting the northeast Riverlands off from the rest by squatting at Harrenhal) and Tywin would have been trapped between Robb, Edmure, and Roose's hosts, effectively dooming him. Stannis wiping out his only other extant host in a CurbStompBattle at King's Landing (killing the royal family in the process) would have sealed Tywin's fate even further.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheReliableOne: Usually they are: Catelyn, Hoster, Brynden, even their FamousAncestor Edmyn Tully was that to Aegon I. Probably the reason why thay were made Paramounts of the Rivelands and stayed so for 300 years despite the long and unstable history of the region. [[spoiler: Till the War of the Five Kings at least.]]

to:

* TheReliableOne: Usually they are: Catelyn, Hoster, Brynden, even their FamousAncestor Edmyn Tully was that to Aegon I. Probably the reason why thay they were made Paramounts of the Rivelands and stayed so for 300 years despite the long and unstable history of the region. [[spoiler: Till the War of the Five Kings at least.]]



** For all more ruthless characters, like the Blsckfish, criticise his "care for the people; look after the land" instincts for messing things up, it's not the Blackfish or others who prioritise strategic manoeuvres that screw the little guy over that the smallfolk actually want back in charge.

to:

** For all more ruthless characters, like the Blsckfish, criticise Blackfish, criticize his "care for the people; look after the land" instincts for messing things up, it's not the Blackfish or others who prioritise strategic manoeuvres that screw the little guy over that the smallfolk actually want back in charge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReliableOne: Usually they are: Catelyn, Hoster, Brynden, even their FamousAncestor Edmyn Tully was that to Aegon I. Probably the reason why thay were made Paramounts of the Rivelands and stayed so for 300 years despite the long and unstable history of the region. [[spoiler: Till the War of the Five Kings at least.]]

Added: 263

Changed: 529

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComesGreatResponsibility: House Tully = diplomatic, responsible and even-handed (they kind of have to be, since they cannot do the [[DisproportionateRetribution House]] [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney Lannister]] or [[SkyCell Arryn]] things and simply expect their vassals and neighbours to suck it up without immediate blow-back): it's actually why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they have made for a stable change of pace during their stewardship.

to:

* ComesGreatResponsibility: House Tully = diplomatic, responsible To almost BlessedWithSuck degree. Aegon probably gave the most difficult job to Edmyn Tully: administrate a land with no real culture that hold them together (like the North or the Westerlands) and even-handed (they kind that is pretty much a nest of have to be, since they cannot do the [[DisproportionateRetribution House]] [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney Lannister]] or [[SkyCell Arryn]] things and simply expect their vassals and neighbours to suck it up without immediate blow-back): it's actually FeudingFamilies. The reason why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk.smallfolk is they are usually pratical, reasonable and even-handed. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they have made for a stable change of pace during their stewardship.


Added DiffLines:

** Lord Edmyn Tully was the first Riverland lord to join Aegon's cause, probably because he was clearly the best chance to get rid of the Iron-born. Aegon rewarded him by making him Lord Paramount and trusting him as Hand of the King when Orys Baratheon resigned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ReplacementGoldfish: He was the next Hand after Orys Baratheon's resign from the job. Whatever he did during his rule, it must have difficult to replace the king's closest friend and (possibly) half-brother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Lord of Riverrun during the reign of Maegor I Targaryen and Jaehaerys I Targaryen. After Maegor's death he was named Master of Laws under Jaehaerys until his replacement by Lord Albin Massey. Married to Lucinda Broome, who proposed her sister Ella as candidate for the young Jaehaerys. Died during the outbreak of the Shivers in 59 AC.

to:

Lord of Riverrun during the reign of Maegor I Targaryen and Jaehaerys I Targaryen. After Maegor's death he was named Master of Laws under Jaehaerys until his replacement by Lord Albin Massey. Married to Lucinda Broome, who proposed her sister Ella as marriage candidate for the young Jaehaerys. Died during the outbreak of the Shivers in 59 AC.



Grandson of Lord Grover Tully, Ser Elmo defied his bedridden grandfather's wishes during the Dance of the Dragons and entered the war in support of Queen Rheanerys Targaryen instead of Aegon II.

to:

Grandson of Lord Grover Tully, Ser Elmo defied his bedridden grandfather's wishes during the Dance of the Dragons and entered the war in support of Queen Rheanerys Rhaenyra Targaryen instead of Aegon II.

Added: 295

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheMillstone: For some reason, his tendency to charge first and barely think even afterwards causes problems. What's worse is that Edmure is aware of his reputation as a millstone and this leads him to want to overcorrect at every error rather than take responsibility and learn from his mistakes. After Robb and Blackfish pointed out his error, Edmure asked for another chance to prove his worth in the field of battle to make amends. Catelyn on hearing this thinks to herself, "[[GloryHound For amends, Brother? Or for glory?]]"

to:

* TheMillstone: For some reason, his tendency to charge first and barely think even afterwards causes problems. What's worse is that Edmure is aware of his reputation as a millstone and this leads him to want to overcorrect at every error rather than take responsibility and learn from his mistakes. After Robb and Blackfish pointed out his error, Edmure asked for another chance to prove his worth in the field of battle to make amends. Catelyn on hearing this thinks to herself, "[[GloryHound For amends, Brother? Or for glory?]]"glory?]]"
** For all more ruthless characters, like the Blsckfish, criticise his "care for the people; look after the land" instincts for messing things up, it's not the Blackfish or others who prioritise strategic manoeuvres that screw the little guy over that the smallfolk actually want back in charge.



* TheWisePrince: It is noted that, despite not being a strategist, Edmure would make a superb ruler in peace times. And, this is reflected in how the smallfolk of the Riverlands respond to the Lannister-Frey alliance that is trying to control them. They want ''their'' "he cares about us" Edmure Tully back about as much as they want the "they really don't give a toss" Freys out of Riverrun. And, will support the Brotherhood Without Banners to make that happen.

to:

* TheWisePrince: It is noted that, despite not being a strategist, Edmure would make a superb ruler in peace times. And, this is reflected in how the smallfolk of the Riverlands respond to the Lannister-Frey alliance that is trying to control them. They want ''their'' "he cares about us" Edmure Tully back about as much as they want the "they really don't give a toss" Freys thrown out of Riverrun. And, will support the Brotherhood Without Banners to make that happen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MyNaymeIs: Roslin, not Rosalyn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComesGreatResponsibility: House Tully = diplomatic, responsible and even-handed (they kind of have to be, since they cannot do the [[DisproprtunateRetribution House]] [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney Lannister]] or [[SkyCell Arryn]] thing and simply expect their vassals and neighbours to suck it up): it's actually why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they make a stable change of pace.

to:

* ComesGreatResponsibility: House Tully = diplomatic, responsible and even-handed (they kind of have to be, since they cannot do the [[DisproprtunateRetribution [[DisproportionateRetribution House]] [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney Lannister]] or [[SkyCell Arryn]] thing things and simply expect their vassals and neighbours to suck it up): up without immediate blow-back): it's actually why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling it, they make have made for a stable change of pace.pace during their stewardship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComesGreatResponsibility: Tully = responsible and even-handed: it's why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk. After some of the disasters the region has had ruling them, they make a stable change of pace.

to:

* ComesGreatResponsibility: House Tully = diplomatic, responsible and even-handed: even-handed (they kind of have to be, since they cannot do the [[DisproprtunateRetribution House]] [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney Lannister]] or [[SkyCell Arryn]] thing and simply expect their vassals and neighbours to suck it up): it's actually why most of the Riverlands ''like'' having them as Lords Paramount -- particularly the smallfolk. After some of the absolute diplomatic disasters the region has had ruling them, it, they make a stable change of pace.

Added: 68

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EpicFlail: Wielded a morningstar when he fought and killed Borros.



[[folder: Ser Oscar Tully]]

to:

[[folder: Ser [[folder:Ser Oscar Tully]]

Added: 919

Changed: 3604

Removed: 427

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FamousAncestor: Lord Prentys Tully was chosen as Master of Laws for King Jaehaerys I.

to:

* FamousAncestor: Lord Prentys Tully was chosen as Master of Laws for King Jaehaerys I.FamousAncestor:



[[folder:Lord Elmo Tully]]
!!Lord Elmo Tully
[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/elmo_tully_woiaf_7090.png]]

Grandson of Lord Grover Tully, Ser Elmo defied his bedridden grandfather's wishes during the Dance of the Dragons and entered the war in support of Queen Rheanerys Targaryen instead of Aegon II.

to:

[[folder:Lord Elmo Prentys Tully]]
!!Lord Elmo Tully
[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/elmo_tully_woiaf_7090.png]]

Grandson of Lord Grover
Prentys Tully, Ser Elmo defied his bedridden grandfather's wishes Master of Laws

Lord of Riverrun
during the Dance reign of the Dragons and entered the war in support of Queen Rheanerys Maegor I Targaryen instead and Jaehaerys I Targaryen. After Maegor's death he was named Master of Aegon II.Laws under Jaehaerys until his replacement by Lord Albin Massey. Married to Lucinda Broome, who proposed her sister Ella as candidate for the young Jaehaerys. Died during the outbreak of the Shivers in 59 AC.



* AHouseDivided: He and his grandfather disagreed over who should inherit the Iron Throne, and Elmo actually ignored his grandfathers command to support Aegon. At first, he simply kept the Riverlands out of the war, but soon led their army against Aegon's forces.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: He considered Queen Rhaenyra was the rightful successor to the Iron Throne and defied his grandfather's legitimate commands to support Aegon II to ensure she and her heirs won it.
* ShortRunner: Unfortunately he only lasted as Lord of Riverrun for 40 days before dying en route to King's Landing, forcing his son Kermit to take over.
* YouAreInCommandNow: Grover died shortly after the battle at Second Tumbleton, making Elmo lord in name and fact.

to:

* AHouseDivided: He and his grandfather disagreed over who should inherit HeelFaceTurn: Led forces in the Iron Throne, and Elmo actually ignored his grandfathers command to Battle beneath the God's Eye, but as soon as Jaehaerys support Aegon. At first, began to increase, he simply kept the Riverlands out quickly switched sides.
* PunchClockVillain: He only sided with Maegor because his lands had front row seats (as always) of most
of the war, but soon led their army against Aegon's forces.fighting during the Faith Militant Uprising.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: TogetherInDeath: He considered Queen Rhaenyra was the rightful successor to the Iron Throne and defied his grandfather's legitimate commands to support Aegon II to ensure she and her heirs won it.
* ShortRunner: Unfortunately he only lasted as Lord of Riverrun for 40 days before dying en route to King's Landing, forcing his son Kermit to take over.
* YouAreInCommandNow: Grover
wife Lucinda died shortly after the battle at Second Tumbleton, making Elmo lord in name and fact. within a day of each other.



[[folder:Lord Kermit Tully]]
!!Lord Kermit Tully

Son of Lord Elmo, Kermit inherited his command of the Riverlands army, and eventually became overall commander of the forces loyal to Aegon III. Under his reign, House Tully reached the peak of its power and influence in Westeros.

to:

[[folder:Lord Kermit Elmo Tully]]
!!Lord Kermit Tully

Son
Elmo Tully
[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/elmo_tully_woiaf_7090.png]]

Grandson
of Lord Elmo, Kermit inherited Grover Tully, Ser Elmo defied his command bedridden grandfather's wishes during the Dance of the Riverlands army, Dragons and eventually became overall commander of entered the forces loyal to war in support of Queen Rheanerys Targaryen instead of Aegon III. Under his reign, House Tully reached the peak of its power and influence in Westeros.II.



* TheAce: His Riverlands rulership and command of the Blacks forces is considered the absolute peak of House Tully's prominence.
* InSeriesNickname: He and the other young Riverlords who fought during the Dance of the Dragons were known collectively as the Lads.
* UnderestimatingBadassery: Lord Borros was dismissive of him and his army, thinking it was led by nothing but green boys and women. That army crushed his and the young green boy slew Borros.
* YouAreInCommandNow: He unexpectedly became the new Lord Tully and head of the Blacks forces when his father died during the march towards King's Landing.
* YoungAndInCharge: At the end of the Dance, he was the chief commander of the Black host that attacked King's Landing.

to:

* TheAce: His AHouseDivided: He and his grandfather disagreed over who should inherit the Iron Throne, and Elmo actually ignored his grandfathers command to support Aegon. At first, he simply kept the Riverlands rulership and command out of the Blacks forces is war, but soon led their army against Aegon's forces.
* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: He
considered Queen Rhaenyra was the absolute peak of House Tully's prominence.
* InSeriesNickname: He
rightful successor to the Iron Throne and the other young Riverlords who fought during the Dance of the Dragons were known collectively defied his grandfather's legitimate commands to support Aegon II to ensure she and her heirs won it.
* ShortRunner: Unfortunately he only lasted
as the Lads.
* UnderestimatingBadassery:
Lord Borros was dismissive of him and Riverrun for 40 days before dying en route to King's Landing, forcing his army, thinking it was led by nothing but green boys and women. That army crushed his and the young green boy slew Borros.
son Kermit to take over.
* YouAreInCommandNow: He unexpectedly became the new Lord Tully and head of the Blacks forces when his father Grover died during shortly after the march towards King's Landing.
* YoungAndInCharge: At the end of the Dance, he was the chief commander of the Black host that attacked King's Landing.
battle at Second Tumbleton, making Elmo lord in name and fact.



[[folder: Ser Oscar Tully]]
!!Ser Oscar Tully

Second son of Elmo Tully and younger brother of Kermit. He fought alongside his brother during the Battle of the Kingsroad, better known as the Muddy Mess. He eventually left Westeros to found his own sellsword company called the Stormbreakers.

to:

[[folder: Ser Oscar [[folder:Lord Kermit Tully]]
!!Ser Oscar !!Lord Kermit Tully

Second son Son of Elmo Tully and younger brother of Kermit. He fought alongside Lord Elmo, Kermit inherited his brother during the Battle command of the Kingsroad, better known as the Muddy Mess. He Riverlands army, and eventually left Westeros became overall commander of the forces loyal to found Aegon III. Under his own sellsword company called reign, House Tully reached the Stormbreakers.peak of its power and influence in Westeros.



* AllThereInTheManual: Only mentioned in ''Literature/FireAndBlood''.
* GlorySeeker: He was eager to prove himself, and technically achieved it during the Muddy Mess.
* {{Knighting}}: He was only a squire but was knighted because of his valor during the Battle of the Kingsroad.
* SiblingTeam: With Kermit.

to:

* AllThereInTheManual: Only mentioned in ''Literature/FireAndBlood''.
* GlorySeeker: He was eager to prove himself,
TheAce: His Riverlands rulership and technically achieved it command of the Blacks forces is considered the absolute peak of House Tully's prominence.
* InSeriesNickname: He and the other young Riverlords who fought
during the Muddy Mess.
Dance of the Dragons were known collectively as the Lads.
* {{Knighting}}: He UnderestimatingBadassery: Lord Borros was only a squire dismissive of him and his army, thinking it was led by nothing but was knighted because of green boys and women. That army crushed his valor and the young green boy slew Borros.
* YouAreInCommandNow: He unexpectedly became the new Lord Tully and head of the Blacks forces when his father died
during the Battle march towards King's Landing.
* YoungAndInCharge: At the end
of the Kingsroad.
* SiblingTeam: With Kermit.
Dance, he was the chief commander of the Black host that attacked King's Landing.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Ser Oscar Tully]]
!!Ser Oscar Tully

Second son of Elmo Tully and younger brother of Kermit. He fought alongside his brother during the Battle of the Kingsroad, better known as the Muddy Mess. He eventually left Westeros to found his own sellsword company called the Stormbreakers.
----
* AllThereInTheManual: Only mentioned in ''Literature/FireAndBlood''.
* GlorySeeker: He was eager to prove himself, and technically achieved it during the Muddy Mess.
* {{Knighting}}: He was only a squire but was knighted because of his valor during the Battle of the Kingsroad.
* SiblingTeam: With Kermit.
[[/folder]]

Top