Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Blog / BetterBonesAU

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


** Hollytuft and Larksong are fused into one character, Hollylark, who has Hollytuft's lineage as a Firestar descendant and Cinderheart's kit, and Larksong's romance with Sparkpelt. This allows Nightheart to be related to Firestar despite Sparkpelt no longer being related to Squirrelflgiht.

to:

** Hollytuft and Larksong are fused into one character, Hollylark, who has Hollytuft's lineage as a Firestar descendant and Cinderheart's kit, and Larksong's romance with Sparkpelt. This allows Nightheart to be related to Firestar despite Sparkpelt no longer being related to Squirrelflgiht.Squirrelflight.



* DisabledInTheAdaptation: The rewrite also autistic cats like Yellowfang and many of her direct descendants, Bluestar, Scourge and Mothwing. Squirrelflight has ADHD, Cindeheart, Squirrelflight, and Breezepelt have borderline personality disorder, Sorreltail has epilepsy, Dovewing is deaf after [[BroughtDownToNormal losing her powers]], Whitewing and Stonewing are also deaf, Bumble has dyspraxia, and Thunder Storm (Thunder) is missing a leg.

to:

* DisabledInTheAdaptation: The rewrite also autistic cats like Yellowfang and many of her direct descendants, Bluestar, Scourge and Mothwing. Squirrelflight has ADHD, Cindeheart, Cinderheart, Squirrelflight, and Breezepelt have borderline personality disorder, Sorreltail has epilepsy, Dovewing is deaf after [[BroughtDownToNormal losing her powers]], Whitewing and Stonewing are also deaf, Bumble has dyspraxia, and Thunder Storm (Thunder) is missing a leg.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KansasCityShuffle: When Thunder's Clan needs to escape from their camp to go on hunts and diplomatic patrols, but they are constantly watched by Clear Sky's larger group which could easily beat them in a head-on battle, Bright Storm comes up with a plan. She builds a thick, impenetrable briar wall around the camp, knowing that Clear Sky is proud of his intelligence and will figure out that the fence can be circumvented by climbing the trees around it, thinking he has outsmarted her. However, this means Clear Sky's Clan is now equally trapped inside the camp, and a few guards can keep them stuck there while the rest of the Clan goes on patrol.


Added DiffLines:

* ReluctantWarrior: Bright Storm prefers not to fight, particularly against her former mate Clear Sky. Unlike canon Gray Wing (who she is a CompositeCharacter with), she is quicker to realize when fighting is nonetheless necessary.


Added DiffLines:

* TheStrategist: Bright Storm, as a CompositeCharacter with the original Gray Wing, acts as the strategist of Thunder's Clan, always coming up with tricks to fight Clear Sky (preferably ones that involve little violence, due to being a ReluctantWarrior).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EndOfAnAge: The SuccessionCrisis in ''Riverstar's Heir'' marks the end of the era of free and peaceful relations between the River Kingdom and the Clans, as the way so many cats got pulled into the civil war by having family and friends in the River kingdom makes this seem like a better idea, and the law of loyalty prohibiting cross-Clan relationships follows shortly afterward. It also marks the end of the River Kingdom and Wind Coalition as entities culturally separate from the Tribe-descended Clans, with them being known as [=RiverClan=] and [=WindClan=] from then on.

Added: 489

Changed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralityPet: Russetfur acts as this to Blackstar as well as a MoralityChain, with Blackstar being inspired to be a better cat because of her.

to:

* MoralityPet: MoralityPet:
**
Russetfur acts as this to Blackstar as well as a MoralityChain, with Blackstar being inspired to be a better cat because of her.her.
** Rock is generally a disinterested observer who will make no effort to help anyone, but has a soft spot for Jayfeather due to him being the reincarnation of his beloved "priest" Jay's Wing. When he and other apprentices get stuck in the flooding tunnels rescuing the [=WindClan=] kits, Rock would have let them all drown were it not for Jaypaw being there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroicRematch: Jaypaw loses his first fight with Owlpaw badly, as in canon, and it crushes his already low confidence in himself, but during [=ShadowClan's=] marsh reclamation project they get into another fight, and Jaypaw wins this time.

Added: 549

Changed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Leafpool and Crowfeather still run away together, but Leafpool isn't obsessed with Crowfeather after their breakup as she is in canon, and never tries to name her kit after him.

to:

** Leafpool and Crowfeather still run away together, but Leafpool isn't obsessed with Crowfeather after their breakup as she is in canon, and never tries to name her kit after him.him (instead Crowfeater is the obessed one).


Added DiffLines:

** While in canon Breezepelt and his unknown siblings Lionblaze, Hollyleaf and Jayfeather never liked each other, with Breezepelt always serving as a rival to them, in the BB AU he is close to the three, especially Lionblaze, before TheReveal leads him to dramatically turn against them.
** Briarlight in canon is not really seen much outside of the medicine den and is never shown to have any friends besides Jayfeather, the cleric who treats her. Here she is very popular and is friends with, and spends a lot of time with, Lionblaze and Hazeltail.

Added: 549

Changed: 305

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AProtagonistShallRuleThem: In addition to Firestar and the various leaders who star as protagonists of super editions portraying their rise to power in canon, there is also Flowerstar, who is the protagonist of ''Riverstar's Heir'' and ends up becoming leader at the end of the book's SuccessionCrisis, bringing peace to [=RiverClan=].

to:

* AProtagonistShallRuleThem: AProtagonistShallLeadThem: In addition to Firestar examples like Firestar, Heartstar (Tigerheart) and the various leaders who star as protagonists of Bluestar (in her super editions portraying their rise to power edition) as in canon, there is also canon:
**
Flowerstar, who is the protagonist of ''Riverstar's Heir'' and ends up becoming leader at the end of the book's SuccessionCrisis, bringing peace to [=RiverClan=].[=RiverClan=].
** Tallstar serves as a [[DeconstructedCharacterArchetype deconstruction]] of this trope, with him seeing the suffering and problems of his Clan and believing he has to abandon the happy life he could have had with Jake/Sparrow to lead them to a better era... but he proves naive and overly compromising when it comes to actually making changes, leading to him not accomplishing much.

Added: 3662

Changed: 70

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Can't remember what Oatwhisker's name in this is, but "Oatmeal" is definitely an autocorrect and not the actual name.


** The cast of ''Riverstar's Heir'', all originally cats with typical Clan names from Code of the Clans, have their names changed to reflect how the story takes place before these name traditions had evolved, to two-word Tribe like names (Maplewhisker to Maple Whisker), to Wind Coalition names (Jumpfoot to Jumping Foot) or to River kingdom names (Flowerstem to Flowers Came First, Mothpelt to Dead Moths Pelt, Mossfire to Mossfire Alight).



** Several names get changed due to OneSteveLimit - Tigerheart's leader name is now Heartstar, Cloudberry (the [=ThunderClan=] cleric who preceded Goosefeather) is Cloudbelly, Frecklewish (the [=SkyClan=] cleric) is Frecklewing, Rainfur (the [=SkyClan=] warrior) is Rainbloom, Mudclaw (Lizardstripe's mate in [=ShadowClan=]) is now Mudfoot, Applefur from Tigerclaw's Fury is now Appledapple, Darkstar (the originator of the "leader's word is the Code" law is now Dalestar, Molewhisker from Code of the Clans is now Moletooth, Snaketooth from Code of the Clans is now Snakestream, Shimmerpelt the modern-day warrior is now Shimmerbright, Shadepelt who first appears in ''A Vision of Shadows'' is now Shademuzzle, Emberdawn from ''Leopardstar's Honor'' is now Emberdusk, Mintfur from [=RiverClan=] is now Mintflower, the modern [=ShadowClan=] Flowerstem is now Flowerscar, Seedpelt from ''Mapleshade's Vengeance'' is now Seedwhisker, Seedpelt from ''Pinestar's Choice'' is now Seedfall, the [=ThunderClan=] Oatwhisker is now Oatmeal, and [=ThunderClan=] Beechfur is now Beechfeather.

to:

** Several names get changed due to OneSteveLimit - Tigerheart's leader name is now Heartstar, Cloudberry (the [=ThunderClan=] cleric who preceded Goosefeather) is Cloudbelly, Frecklewish (the [=SkyClan=] cleric) is Frecklewing, Rainfur (the [=SkyClan=] warrior) is Rainbloom, Mudclaw (Lizardstripe's mate in [=ShadowClan=]) is now Mudfoot, Applefur from Tigerclaw's Fury is now Appledapple, Darkstar (the originator of the "leader's word is the Code" law is now Dalestar, Molewhisker from Code of the Clans is now Moletooth, Snaketooth from Code of the Clans is now Snakestream, Shimmerpelt the modern-day warrior is now Shimmerbright, Shadepelt who first appears in ''A Vision of Shadows'' is now Shademuzzle, Emberdawn from ''Leopardstar's Honor'' is now Emberdusk, Mintfur from [=RiverClan=] is now Mintflower, the modern [=ShadowClan=] Flowerstem is now Flowerscar, Seedpelt from ''Mapleshade's Vengeance'' is now Seedwhisker, Seedpelt from ''Pinestar's Choice'' is now Seedfall, the [=ThunderClan=] Oatwhisker is now Oatmeal, [=ThunderClan=], and [=ThunderClan=] Beechfur is now Beechfeather.



* BrutalHonesty: Flowerstar tends to run into issues due to this trait, like admitting that Mossfire Alight is too young to be ready for leadership yet despite trying to promote her claim to power, which just gives ammunition to those who want to promote themselves or their favored candidate for their own reasons.



* ChessmasterSidekick: Maple Whisker acts as a loyal friend and second in command to Flowerstar, being the one that comes up with the clever plans whereas Flowerstar is kind but can be guileless and [[BrutalHonesty overly honest.]]



* CorruptTheCutie: Mossfire Alight in ''Riverstar's Heir'', the good natured and innocent adopted heir of Riverstar who the protagonist Flowers Came First is a [[BigBrotherMentor Big Sister Mentor]] to. Being attacked from all sides due to the SuccessionCrisis leads to her becoming increasingly angry and confrontational ending in her attacking Jumping Foot to kill him, and them [[KillTheCutie both drowning together.]]



* FamilyExtermination: Dead Moths Pelt and all of his children end up being killed at once when, at the celebration for the former becoming the next king of the River Kingdom, they all eat from the same ceremonial pot which was poisoned by the [=ThunderClan=] diplomat.



* InSeriesNickname: Clan cats have nicknames, but they always have to incorporate parts of the prefix and suffix to avoid being disrespectful to the cat's rank (i.e Squirrelflight = Squilf, Nightcloud = Nico). Ancient River kingdom or Wind Coalition cats didn't follow this rule, so we have Flowers Came First being called "Flow", Jumping Foot as "Jump", Mossfire Alight as "Moss" and Dead Moths Pelt as "Moth".



* KillTheCutie: Mossfire Alight, Flowerstar's kindhearted ward and adopted little sister, ends up being unfortunately caught in the middle of a SuccessionCrisis due to being Riverstar's adopted heir and dies trying to kill Jumping Foot for all he's done to disturb the peace (and his supposed poisoning of Dead Moths Pelt and his children).



** Dead Moths Pelt actually has a name that refers to him saving a bunch of pelts by killing the moths inside before they laid eggs, with a meaning more like "Killed the moths to save the pelts", but this is hard to translate into a three word title.



** Mossfire and Jumpfoot do this as in canon, though the circumstances are different; during a battle between all the Clans except [=ShadowClan=] to determine the next [=RiverClan=] leader (the two are [=RiverClan=] cats and not [=ShadowClan=] ones in this AU), they fight in the river and their crowns get tangled in each other, leading to them both drowning.

to:

** Mossfire Alight (canon Mossier) and Jumpfoot Jumping Foot (canon Jumpfoot) do this as in canon, though the circumstances are different; during a battle between all the Clans except [=ShadowClan=] to determine the next [=RiverClan=] leader (the two are [=RiverClan=] cats and not [=ShadowClan=] ones in this AU), they fight in the river and their crowns get tangled in each other, leading to them both drowning.


Added DiffLines:

* AProtagonistShallRuleThem: In addition to Firestar and the various leaders who star as protagonists of super editions portraying their rise to power in canon, there is also Flowerstar, who is the protagonist of ''Riverstar's Heir'' and ends up becoming leader at the end of the book's SuccessionCrisis, bringing peace to [=RiverClan=].


Added DiffLines:

* SelfPoisoningGambit: Suspecting that the [=ThunderClan=] diplomat was responsible for poisoning Dead Moths Pelt and his children, Flowerstar repeats the exact situation that got them killed by celebrating her ascension to leadership and eating out of a special ceremonial pot, claiming she doesn't have to worry because the supposed culprit Jumping Foot is dead. The diplomat falls for it and poisons the food, only for Flowerstar to ask them to share the food with her. Unbeknownst to the diplomat, Flowerstar has already gotten her nine lives from [=StarClan=], so when they both die, Flowerstar comes back while the diplomat stays dead.

Added: 7850

Changed: 3566

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Snake Claw (named Snake in canon) still starts out as a vicious supporter of Clear Sky as in canon, and again as in canon he turns against him for letting One Eye take over and abuse Clear Sky's Clan. However, while in canon his motives get retconned so he now just preferred One Eye over Clear Sky all along and ends up joining the ObviouslyEvil Slash, in this AU he follows through on his defection and joins Thunder's Clan.



** Petal Claw (originally Petal in canon) keeps her villainous qualities from canon as a strong supporter of Clear Sky, but here her taking in Misty's kits isn't presented as a [[PetTheDog redeeming quality]], instead being the predecessor of the kit stealing tradition that plagues the Clans for generations, with her not being very warm to Birch Claw and Alder Claw.



** The cats of Dawn of the Clans now have a name scheme using last names, where the second part of their name is inherited from one of their parents. To keep this consistent, Quiet Rain is now Quiet Wing so as to give her name to Gray Wing, Fluttering Bird is now Fluttering Wing, and Quiet Rain's second mate Stone Song is now Stone Peak to give his name to Jagged Peak (Clear Sky's father is an unnamed cat who died before the arc starts). Thunder is now Thunder Storm after his mother, who is named Bright Storm as a composite character between Bright Stream and Storm. Silver Stripe and White Tail are now Sun Shadow's kits so they are now Silver Shadow and White Shadow. Lightning Tail is now Lightning Cry after his father, likewise Falling Feather is Falling Cry to match with her brother. Shaded Moss is now Shaded Flower to match with his daughter. Acorn Fur is now Acorn Swoop to match with Hawk Swoop. Turtle Tail, Dappled Pelt, and Sparrow Fur are now Turtle Heart, Dappled Heart and Sparrow Heart to match with Pebble Heart (Owl Eyes starts out as Owl Heart but gains his name as an honor title from learning to hunt from an owl). Shattered Ice is now Shattered Frost, matching with Frost.

to:

** The cats of Dawn of the Clans now have a name scheme using last names, where the second part of their name is inherited from one of their parents. To keep this consistent, Quiet Rain is now Quiet Wing so as to give her name to Gray Wing, Fluttering Bird is now Fluttering Wing, and Quiet Rain's second mate Stone Song is now Stone Peak to give his name to Jagged Peak (Clear Sky's father is an unnamed cat who died before the arc starts). Thunder is now Thunder Storm after his mother, who is named Bright Storm as a composite character between Bright Stream and Storm. Silver Stripe and White Tail are now Sun Shadow's kits so they are now Silver Shadow and White Shadow. Lightning Tail is now Lightning Cry after his father, likewise Falling Feather is Falling Cry to match with her brother. Shaded Moss is now Shaded Flower to match with his daughter. Acorn Fur is now Acorn Swoop to match with Hawk Swoop. Turtle Tail, Dappled Pelt, and Sparrow Fur are now Turtle Heart, Dappled Heart and Sparrow Heart to match with Pebble Heart (Owl Eyes starts out as Owl Heart but gains his name as an honor title from learning to hunt from an owl).
** This also applies to cats who in canon were outsiders to the Tribe and thus did not have their naming system, but in the BB AU are Tribe cats. For instance, Frost is now Sunlit Frost (with
Shattered Ice Ice, who is now RelatedInTheAdaptation to him, thus being renamed Shattered Frost, matching with Frost. Frost), and Petal, Fox, Snake, Alder and Birch are not in the same family as Red Claw so they all get Claw at the end of their names.



* DefectingForLove: Red Claw defects from Sky's Clan and joins Thunder's Clan due to falling in love with Acorn Swoop.



** Petal Claw (Petal from ''Dawn of the Clans'') dies in battle as opposed to dying of a sickness in canon.



* DontCelebrateJustYet: The eldest surviving child of Riverstar, taking power after a brief SuccessionCrisis, delays naming a successor while celebrating his victory and is killed by being poisoned during that time, starting up the battle for succession again. This inspires the law of the warrior code that demands a deputy be named before moonhigh after the previous leader or deputy's death or retirement.



* TheGoodKing: Riverstar is a beloved and competent king, with his wisdom being respected by everyone. However, this doesn't stop his carelessness about naming a clear successor causing a lot of war and strife when he dies.



* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: InUniverse, as part of glorifying kit stealing in the times before it was banned, Birch Claw gets remembered as a heroic exemplar of it for staying loyal to Clear Sky's group who "won him through honor", even if that group was villainous in reality.
** HistoricalVillainUpgrade: For the same reason as Birch Claw is venerated, his family members Red Claw, Snake Claw and Alder Claw are looked upon negatively by history for all defecting from Clear Sky's group, being seen as an example of the dangers of nepotism and valuing family over Clan, even though there was a very good moral justification to defect.



* HopeSpot: Early on in ''Riverstar's Heir'', the succession crisis seems to be resolved with the eldest surviving child of Riverstar taking power. Unfortunately he delays naming a successor while celebrating his victory and is killed by being poisoned during that time, starting up the battle for succession again. This inspires the law of the warrior code that demands a deputy be named before moonhigh after the previous leader or deputy's death or retirement.



* MutualKill: Applefur and Marshwing siblings on opposite sides of the Dark Forest battle, kill each other during the battle's second wave.

to:

* MutualKill: Besides the preserved canon example of Onestar and Darktail;
**
Applefur and Marshwing siblings on opposite sides of the Dark Forest battle, kill each other during the battle's second wave.wave.
** Mossfire and Jumpfoot do this as in canon, though the circumstances are different; during a battle between all the Clans except [=ShadowClan=] to determine the next [=RiverClan=] leader (the two are [=RiverClan=] cats and not [=ShadowClan=] ones in this AU), they fight in the river and their crowns get tangled in each other, leading to them both drowning.



* OutlivingOnesOffspring: There are many examples as in canon, some which are lost from canon and some added due to the switching around of deaths. Notably, this trope poses a particular problem for the River kingdom's succession after Riverstar's death. Riverstar had lived such a long life due to having nine lives and not getting involved in battles that, by the time he dies, his oldest children have predeceased him, leading to both his oldest living child and the oldest descendant of his actual oldest child claiming a right to the throne.



* RelatedInTheAdaptation: Redtail and Spottedleaf are now Rosetail's kits instead of Adderfang and Swiftbreeze's. Instead of being Robinwing and Fuzzypelt's kit, Frostfur is the biological daughter of Featherwhisker adopted by Stonepelt and Weedwhisker. Sandstorm and Longtail are siblings and the kits of Redtail and Runningwind. Swiftpaw is Tigerstar's son. Dovewing and Ivypool are Lionblaze and Cinderheart's children (biologically Jayfeather and Poppyfrost's and adopted by them) instead of Whitewing and Birchall's. Sparkpelt and Alderheart are Jessy's kits instead of Squirrelflight's. Onestar no longer has siblings. Graystripe and Darkstripe are Dappletail's kits instead of Willowpelt's. Marigoldkit and Mintkit are Rowanberry's kits instead of Brightflower's. Littlecloud and Rowanclaw are brothers and are Brokenstar's kits. Pebble Heart, Sparrow Fur (now Sparrow Heart) and Owl Eyes are still Turtle Heart (Turtle Tail) and Tom's biological kits, though Bumble is now also their adoptive mother and Turtle Heart's mate. Hollyleaf, now called Fallenleaf after her ordeal in the tunnels, is now Snaptooth, Flywhisker, and [[CompositeCharacter Hollylark's]] other mother. Rainflower is now the grandchild of Appledusk instead of Shellheart (making Crookedstar still his great grandson), with Duskwater as the kit of Appledusk and Reedshine who becomes Rainflower's mother. Silver Stripe and White Tail are now Sun Shadow's kits instead of Gray Wing and Slate's (Black Ear is now in Rainswept Flower's family). Graystripe is actually Fang/Honeysuckle's father, though neither of them know it. Sparrowpelt and Sandynose are siblings. Quailfeather, Birdwing and Finleap are kits of Sandynose and Egg. Voletooth is the father of Mintfur's kittens. Cherrytail's kits are biologically Echosong's instead (Cherrytail is spayed), though Echosong is still not involved in raising them at all and is just a surrogate. Rockshade is the father of Plumwillow's kittens (which no longer includes Finleap). Rainstorm and Rippletail are the kits of Swallowtail and Rainwhisker. Shell Claw is Acorn Swoop (Acorn Fur) and Red Claw's kit instead of Thunder and Violet Dawn's. Appledapple (a renamed Applefur from Tigerclaw's Fury) is now Snowbird and Ratscar's mother. Aspentail is Darkstar's sister and Perchshine (Perchpaw) is her kit with Splashheart. Greenflower and Duckfur (a WordOfGod-given "missing kit" who here lives to become a warrior) are siblings. She is mates with Sedgecreek and Swallowtail is their daughter (the biological kit of Greenflower and honor sire Loudbelly). Swansong (Graypool and Rippleclaw's son) is now Mosspelt's mate instead of Frogleap and the father of her kits, which include Stonestream in addition to Mosspelt's canon offspring Dawnflower and Willowshine. Stonestream in turn is the father of Mossyfoot and Troutstream. Shadepelt is the mother of Pouncetail and Graymist. Gullswoop is the daughter of Ivytail and Darktail instead of Snowbird and Scorchfur, and Ivytail herself is the daughter of Fernshade and Wolfstep. While Shinecloud is still Birchface and Frecklewish's mother as per WordOfGod, Beetail is their father instead of Oakstar, and Flowerpot and Nettlebreeze are their half-siblings (Beetail's kits but not Shinecloud's). Squirrelwhisker is Beetail's sister. Seedpelt (''Pinestar's Choice'') is now named Seedfall and is Adderfang's sister.

to:

* RelatedInTheAdaptation: RelatedInTheAdaptation:
**
Redtail and Spottedleaf are now Rosetail's kits instead of Adderfang and Swiftbreeze's. Swiftbreeze's.
**
Instead of being Robinwing and Fuzzypelt's kit, Frostfur is the biological daughter of Featherwhisker adopted by Stonepelt and Weedwhisker. Weedwhisker.
**
Sandstorm and Longtail are siblings and the kits of Redtail and Runningwind. Runningwind.
**
Swiftpaw is Tigerstar's son. son, as opposed to having an unknown father in canon.
**
Dovewing and Ivypool are Lionblaze and Cinderheart's children (biologically Jayfeather and Poppyfrost's and adopted by them) instead of Whitewing and Birchall's. Birchall's.
**
Sparkpelt and Alderheart are Jessy's kits instead of Squirrelflight's. Onestar no longer has siblings. Squirrelflight's.
**
Graystripe and Darkstripe are Dappletail's kits instead of Willowpelt's. Marigoldkit and Mintkit are Rowanberry's kits instead of Brightflower's. Willowpelt's.
**
Littlecloud and Rowanclaw are brothers and are Brokenstar's kits. kits.
**
Pebble Heart, Sparrow Fur (now Sparrow Heart) and Owl Eyes are still Turtle Heart (Turtle Tail) and Tom's biological kits, though Bumble is now also their adoptive mother and Turtle Heart's mate. mate.
**
Hollyleaf, now called Fallenleaf after her ordeal in the tunnels, is now Snaptooth, Flywhisker, and [[CompositeCharacter Hollylark's]] other mother. Meanwhile canon Hollytuft's siblings, Snaptooth and Flywhisker, are still Lionblaze's kits but the other parent is Toadstep instead of Cinderheart.
**
Rainflower is now the grandchild of Appledusk instead of Shellheart (making Crookedstar still his great grandson), with Duskwater as the kit of Appledusk and Reedshine who becomes Rainflower's mother. mother.
**
Silver Stripe and White Tail are now Sun Shadow's kits instead of Gray Wing and Slate's (Black Ear is now in Rainswept Flower's family). family).
**
Graystripe is actually Fang/Honeysuckle's father, though neither of them know it. it.
**
Sparrowpelt and Sandynose are siblings. siblings.
**
Quailfeather, Birdwing and Finleap are kits of Sandynose and Egg. Egg.
**
Voletooth is the father of Mintfur's kittens. kittens.
**
Cherrytail's kits are biologically Echosong's instead (Cherrytail is spayed), though Echosong is still not involved in raising them at all and is just a surrogate. ** Rockshade is the father of Plumwillow's kittens (which no longer includes Finleap). Finleap).
**
Rainstorm and Rippletail are the kits of Swallowtail and Rainwhisker. Rainwhisker.
**
Shell Claw is Acorn Swoop (Acorn Fur) and Red Claw's kit instead of Thunder and Violet Dawn's. Dawn's.
**
Appledapple (a renamed Applefur from Tigerclaw's Fury) is now Snowbird and Ratscar's mother. mother.
**
Aspentail is Darkstar's sister and Perchshine (Perchpaw) is her kit with Splashheart. Greenflower and Duckfur (a WordOfGod-given "missing kit" who here lives to become a warrior) are siblings. She Greenflower is mates with Sedgecreek and Swallowtail is their daughter (the biological kit of Greenflower and honor sire Loudbelly). Loudbelly).
**
Swansong (Graypool and Rippleclaw's son) is now Mosspelt's mate instead of Frogleap and the father of her kits, which include Stonestream in addition to Mosspelt's canon offspring Dawnflower and Willowshine. Stonestream in turn is the father of Mossyfoot and Troutstream.
**
Shadepelt is the mother of Pouncetail and Graymist. Graymist.
**
Gullswoop is the daughter of Ivytail and Darktail instead of Snowbird and Scorchfur, and Ivytail herself is the daughter of Fernshade and Wolfstep. Wolfstep.
**
While Shinecloud is still Birchface and Frecklewish's mother as per WordOfGod, Beetail is their father instead of Oakstar, and Flowerpot and Nettlebreeze are their half-siblings (Beetail's kits but not Shinecloud's). Squirrelwhisker is Beetail's sister. Seedpelt (''Pinestar's Choice'') is now named Seedfall and is Adderfang's sister.sister.
** Snake Claw (originally Snake) and Red Claw are Tribe cats rather than outsiders here, and are siblings, with Petal Claw (formerly Petal, also now a tribe cat) as their mother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AttackOfTheFiftyFootWhatever: Sol makes an 80-pound Wels' catfish grow to a 300-pound, cat eating monster, which gets named Ripwater by [=RiverClan=] and threatens to eat its warriors and apprentices. [[DownplayedTrope Downplayed]] as Wels' catfish are really capable of growing to that size naturally (although that usually happens in warmer climates), speeding up the growth thus allows Sol to cause mayhem without breaking his deal with Midnight.


Added DiffLines:

* GaiasVengeance: When the giant catfish Ripwater attacks [=RiverClan=], they notice the attacks tend to happen when they are collecting mussels and, although this is in fact coincidental, falsely believe the mussels to have something to do with the attacks. Willowpaw (the future Willowshine), who wants [=ThunderClan=] to help them, takes advantage of this by telling them of a vision she had that encourages them to ask for help. While most of the vision she describes is true, she lies about some parts, one of which is that this trope is in effect and [=StarClan=] sent Ripwater to punish them for overexploiting the resource of mussels in their new home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Falls somewhere in the middle, but leans towards idealism, noticeably more so than [[Literature/WarriorCats the books it is based on.]] Many idealists end up as [[DoomedMoralVictor Doomed Moral Victors]] (Deerfoot, Larkstripe and Ripplestar)), falling prey to people who want to manipulate their goals for cynical ends (Sleekwhisker and the rest of the [=ShadowClan=] rebels) or suffering for their determination to change things until they completely break (Bluestar), but others like Firestar transform their society for the better in a way that sticks, even if they get eventually killed for it and the cruel mindsets they thought keep resurfacing as threats over and over again, unlike in the canon series where the thread of changing the system largely seems to be dropped. [[RousseauWasRight No one is inherently evil]], unlike what is implied in canon, groups of foreigners can be negotiated with rather than canon's use of invading hordes that can't be reasoned with, and many characters change for the better, but it is also shown that some cats are BeyondRedemption because they choose not to change and trying to redeem them will only lead to heartbreak. Supernatural threats are often too powerful to be beaten, leading to [[TheBadGuyWins the bad guy winning]] or [[BrokeYourArmPunchingOutCthulhu sacrifices for a temporary victory.]] Characters perform awesome and sometimes self-sacrificial acts of heroism that generally matter and achieve their intended goals. HonorBeforeReason can sometimes pay off, but sometimes ViolenceReallyIsTheAnswer. The resident WideEyedIdealist, Tallstar, is not naive because of thinking he could improve the world but naive for not going ''far enough'' outside of his ingrained cultural mindset to make lasting change. The overall message is that cultures constantly change, whether for the better or for the worse.

to:

* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism: Falls somewhere in the middle, but leans towards idealism, noticeably more so than [[Literature/WarriorCats the books it is based on.]] Many idealists end up as [[DoomedMoralVictor Doomed Moral Victors]] (Deerfoot, Larkstripe and Ripplestar)), falling prey to people who want to manipulate their goals for cynical ends (Sleekwhisker and the rest of the [=ShadowClan=] rebels) or suffering for their determination to change things until they completely break (Bluestar), but others like Firestar transform their society for the better in a way that sticks, even if they get eventually killed for it and the cruel mindsets they thought keep resurfacing as threats over and over again, unlike in the canon series where the thread of changing the system largely seems to be dropped. [[RousseauWasRight No one is inherently evil]], unlike what is implied in canon, groups of foreigners can be negotiated with rather than canon's use of invading hordes that can't be reasoned with, and many characters change for the better, but it is also shown that some cats are BeyondRedemption because they choose not to change and trying to redeem them will only lead to heartbreak. Supernatural threats are often too powerful to be beaten, leading to [[TheBadGuyWins the bad guy winning]] or [[BrokeYourArmPunchingOutCthulhu sacrifices for a temporary victory.]] Characters Many characters perform awesome and sometimes self-sacrificial acts of heroism that generally matter and achieve their intended goals. HonorBeforeReason can sometimes pay off, but sometimes ViolenceReallyIsTheAnswer. The resident WideEyedIdealist, Tallstar, is not naive because of thinking he could improve the world but naive for not going ''far enough'' outside of his ingrained cultural mindset to make lasting change. The overall message is that cultures constantly change, whether for the better or for the worse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Falls somewhere in the middle, but leans towards idealism, noticeably more so than [[Literature/WarriorCats the books it is based on.]] Many idealists end up as [[DoomedMoralVictor Doomed Moral Victors]] (Deerfoot, Larkstripe and Ripplestar)), falling prey to people who want to manipulate their goals for cynical ends (Sleekwhisker and the rest of the [=ShadowClan=] rebels) or suffering for their determination to change things until they completely break (Bluestar), but others like Firestar transform their society for the better in a way that sticks, even if they get eventually killed for it and the cruel mindsets they thought keep resurfacing as threats over and over again, unlike in the canon series where the thread of changing the system largely seems to be dropped. [[RousseauWasRight No one is inherently evil]], unlike what is implied in canon, groups of foreigners can be negotiated with rather than canon's use of invading hordes that can't be reasoned with, and many characters change for the better, but it is also shown that some cats are BeyondRedemption because they choose not to change and trying to redeem them will only lead to heartbreak. Supernatural threats are often too powerful to be beaten, leading to [[TheBadGuyWins the bad guy winning]] or [[BrokeYourArmPunchingOutCthulhu sacrifices for a temporary victory.]] Characters perform awesome and sometimes self-sacrificial acts of heroism that generally matter and achieve their intended goals. HonorBeforeReason can sometimes pay off, but sometimes ViolenceReallyIsTheAnswer. The resident WideEyedIdealist, Tallstar, is not naive because of thinking he could improve the world but naive for not going ''far enough'' outside of his ingrained cultural mindset to make lasting change. The overall message is that cultures constantly change, whether for the better or for the worse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Cats like Houndleap have keloid scars in spite of this being impossible for cats in real life. Brightheart's scars are also, as in canon, more striking than they would be in real life, where fur would eventually grow over them.

Added: 6799

Changed: 956

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Nightcloud in canon is only seen fighting once, where she loses to Squirrelflight (who is never shown to be a particularly strong fighter). In the Better Bones AU, she is one of the strongest fighters in [=WindClan=] along with Willowclaw.
** All of the Clans besides [=ThunderClan=] get this in general. [=ThunderClan=] no longer wins all of their battles or has all of the cats shown in the narrative to bed the best fighters; every Clan [[ProudWarriorRaceGuy strongly values prowess in battle]] so every Clan has strong fighters.



** Stonewing in canon is a supporter of the bigoted Berryheart, but here he is a strong supporter of Heartstar (the former Tigerheart) and opposes Berryheart, due to the bonds he formed with Dovewing and Strikestone in being [[DisabledInTheAdaptation deaf cats]] trying to form a community and create a sign language.



* AndroclesLion: After helping find the wild hog Marguerite's children, Marguerite rescues Nightcloud by charging an animal that was about to kill her. [[DownplayedTrope Downplayed]] in that it is made ambiguous what Marguerite's motivation is and Bonefall is clear that she is still a wild animal and not able to become Nightcloud's "friend".



* AnimalMotif: Nightcloud is associated with wild sows, liking the animals a lot and helping to reunite one's babies with their mother in ''Nightcloud's Pannage''. She is one of the largest and strongest warriors in her Clan, and the sow is the largest and most dangerous predator in the forest, and both sows and Nightcloud are maligned for just protecting their children.



** The female [=ThunderClan=] warriors of ''The Prophecies Begin'', who in canon were largely out of focus compared to their male counterparts, get expanded roles. Frostfur is an ally of Firestar's who has to reckon with Tigerstar's ideology after he was exiled, Goldenflower is a former supporter of Tigerstar who quickly changes tune after his exile and tries to get others to do the same, and Dappletail, as the Clan educator, has an expanded role as Firestar's original teacher, who teaches him how to speak Clanmew when he previously just knew Townmew.
** Firestar has more friends from other Clans who show up in the aftergatherings, many who were cats who got next to no focus in the canon books like Wetfoot, Mosspelt, and Cinderfur (though the latter stops attending the meetings as the political situation gets more tense).



** Fallenleaf (Hollyleaf), who was already this in canon, is even more so here due to the [[AdaptationalVillainy many more evil things she did]] in the Better Bones AU, much of which happened so long in the past thanks to time travel that no one even remembers it and she bears their burden alone.



* BookEnds: While the scene happens later in this AU than it does in canon, Firestar has his collar ripped off by Longtail early on in the rewritten ''The Prophecies Begin''. At the end of that arc, Firestar shows he has defeated Scourge by ripping off his collar, and remembering the feelings he had over his own collar, sees it as something meaningful to Scourge and goes back to return it, starting their diplomacy in the epilogue.



* BreakingTheCycleOfBadParenting: Nightcloud is determined to not be like her mother Hillrunner, both in terms of not being an [[AbusiveParents abusive parent]] and not going as far as she did with her xenophobia. Unfortunately, though she is nothing but loving towards her child Breezepelt, her mate Crowfeather is cruel to him and her attempts to defend Breezepelt just leads to her being seen as the one in the wrong by her Clan.



* DisabledInTheAdaptation: The rewrite also autistic cats like Yellowfang and many of her direct descendants, Bluestar, Scourge and Mothwing. Squirrelflight has ADHD, Cindeheart, Squirrelflight, and Breezepelt have borderline personality disorder, Sorreltail has epilepsy, Dovewing is deaf after [[BroughtDownToNormal losing her powers]], Whitewing is also deaf, Bumble has dyspraxia, and Thunder Storm (Thunder) is missing a leg.

to:

* DirtyBusiness: Mistystar is horrified by killing Leopardstar, even though she believes it was necessary to stop the spread of Thistle Law, and is haunted by it the rest of her life.
* DisabledInTheAdaptation: The rewrite also autistic cats like Yellowfang and many of her direct descendants, Bluestar, Scourge and Mothwing. Squirrelflight has ADHD, Cindeheart, Squirrelflight, and Breezepelt have borderline personality disorder, Sorreltail has epilepsy, Dovewing is deaf after [[BroughtDownToNormal losing her powers]], Whitewing is and Stonewing are also deaf, Bumble has dyspraxia, and Thunder Storm (Thunder) is missing a leg.



* LetsFightLikeGentlemen: Firestar attempts to negotiate with Scourge to not use deathberry-poisoned claws against [=BloodClan=] in the upcoming FinalBattle, in exchange for [=BloodClan=] not using their claw extenders. Scourge mocks him for claiming to be honorable when [=BloodClan=] has been consistently betrayed by Clan cats, and mocks him further that if he really does mean what he says, it would be foolish indeed. However, most of both groups, including Scourge himself, stay true to their word. Firestar also defeats Scourge without killing him, with Scourge agreeing to order [=BloodClan=] to retreat rather than being killed.



* RebelliousRebel: Tall Shadow breaks off from [=SkyClan=] with a good portion of the Clan due to anger at Clear Sky's actions of kicking out cats for their disabilities, and Thunder Storm in turn decides to break off and create a new Clan because Tall Shadow not taking Bumble into the group after Turtle Heart's death due to being a house cat incapable of fighting makes Thunder Storm see her as no different from Clear Sky.

to:

* RebelliousRebel: RebelliousRebel:
**
Tall Shadow breaks off from [=SkyClan=] with a good portion of the Clan due to anger at Clear Sky's actions of kicking out cats for their disabilities, and Thunder Storm in turn decides to break off and create a new Clan because Tall Shadow not taking Bumble into the group after Turtle Heart's death due to being a house cat incapable of fighting makes Thunder Storm see her as no different from Clear Sky.Sky.
** Crowfeather joins Mudclaw's rebels when they are plotting to overthrow Onestar, but betrays them and reveals their scheme when he feels Mudclaw is going too far by recruiting other Clans' Thistle Law supporters and attempting to sabotage a muirburn.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Because Crowfeather is seen as a hero by [=WindClan=] for his role as one of TheChosenMany in their journey to a new home and for exposing Mudclaw's rebellion, and just being charismatic, [=WindClan=] takes his side over Nightcloud even as he is abusive to her and their son Breezepelt, and Breezepelt ends up written off by many as a "problem child" because that is what Crowfeather told them. This is not helped by how Nightcloud was a participant in the aforementioned rebellion, even though she is trying to atone for it. This changes when Hollyleaf reveals her and her siblings as Crowfeather and Leafpool's siblings at a gathering, and Crowfeather declares he still loves Leafpool and doesn't regret any of this; the scandal causes Onestar to strip him of his name and exile him and the Clan's opinion turns more against him and toward Nightcloud.


Added DiffLines:

* WorfHadTheFlu: Scourge only takes one of Firestar's lives rather than taking them all in one blow like he did to Tigerstar because, due to the mutual agreement of both parties in the battle to not use weapons or poisons, he no longer has the claw extension that allowed him to pull that move. Firestar anticipating the attack still causes him to slip up and get "normally" killed.
* WorkingWithTheEx: Crowfeather and Nightcloud, who have split up by this time, work together to help their son Breezepelt and others stage a grand rescue of captives from the Kin, including rescuing Breezepelt himself.

Top