Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AdaptationalWimp / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/DDay'', a ForeignRemake of ''Film/{{Commando}}'', does this to the hero Ivan by adapting out certain scenes. His original counterpart John (as played by Creator/ArnoldSchwarzenegger) can rip out car seats with his bare hands and at one point lifts a phone booth (with people still inside!) off the ground; Ivan doesn't have any scenes like such to make the film more "grounded" in reality (in all fairness, '''nobody''' can out-badass The Ahnuld in his prime back in the 1980s, so there's that). The remake's BigBad is also a DirtyCoward who throws his mooks at Ivan and hides himself the entire climax (only to be blown up by a hidden IED), in comparison the original main villain as played by Dan Hedaya DoNotGoGentle and tries his best to gun down John only to be outgunned.

to:

* ''Film/DDay'', a ForeignRemake of ''Film/{{Commando}}'', ''Film/Commando1985'', does this to the hero Ivan by adapting out certain scenes. His original counterpart John (as played by Creator/ArnoldSchwarzenegger) can rip out car seats with his bare hands and at one point lifts a phone booth (with people still inside!) off the ground; Ivan doesn't have any scenes like such to make the film more "grounded" in reality (in all fairness, '''nobody''' can out-badass The Ahnuld in his prime back in the 1980s, so there's that). The remake's BigBad is also a DirtyCoward who throws his mooks at Ivan and hides himself the entire climax (only to be blown up by a hidden IED), in comparison the original main villain as played by Dan Hedaya DoNotGoGentle and tries his best to gun down John only to be outgunned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/DadsArmy2016'': In [[Series/DadsArmy the original series]], Hodges was a big, loudmouthed bully of a man who was always on the verge of a blustery rage. In this film, Martin Savage gives a much more downplayed performance than the late Creator/BillPertwee; his Hodges comes across as more of a sneering snarker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/MadameWeb'':

to:

* ''Film/MadameWeb'':''Film/MadameWeb2024'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ComicBook/SpiderWomen Julia Carpenter, Mattie Franklin and Anya Corazon go from badass arachnid action girls to three powerless damsels Webb needs to protect and babysit from Ezekiel. It is stated and briefly fleetingly shown they will be Spider-Women in the future but we still see none of their competency that will apparently make them such great superheroes.
** Richard and Mary Parker, Spidey’s parents when alive in the comics were badass ComicBook/{{SHIELD}} super spies Nick Fury himself held in high regard. In this film they’re just clueless civilians who don’t have any real bearing on the plot beyond Mary being pregnant with Peter.

to:

** ComicBook/SpiderWomen Julia Carpenter, Mattie Franklin and Anya Corazon go from badass arachnid action girls to three powerless damsels Webb needs to protect and babysit from Ezekiel. It is stated and briefly fleetingly shown in flash forwards (where they take out the Ezekiel) that they will be strong Spider-Women in the future but in the movie itself, we still see none of their competency that will apparently make them such great superheroes.
** Richard and Mary Parker, Spidey’s parents mother when she was alive in the comics were was a badass ComicBook/{{SHIELD}} super spies secret agent Nick Fury himself held in high regard. In this film they’re she’s just a clueless civilians civilian who don’t have any real bearing on the plot beyond Mary being pregnant with Peter.

Changed: 770

Removed: 166

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Literally nothing that matches Hercules in the film and Nigel Green's physique is completely unrelated.


* ''Film/JasonAndTheArgonauts'' despite being a seminal SwordAndSandal film does this to Hercules from Myth/ClassicalMythology. In the original myths Herc besides being a SemiDivine powerhouse in his own right, was a great help to Jason on his journey acting as TheBigGuy for the Argonauts, defending the ship by slaying several Gegeines (six armed giants). In the film, Hercules is portrayed more as a oaf who gets many of his men killed by foolishly stealing Talos’s brooch and comes off as a less skilled warrior than Jason, whereas in the myths Herc is the WorldsStrongestMan and WorldsBestWarrior. It also doesn’t help Nigel Green lacked the literal [[HeroicBuild Herculean physique]] most actors who play the character possess.
** Also from the same movie the Hydra much like ''Film/TheLovesOfHercules'' below goes down pretty easily, [[HydraProblem despite the whole regenerating head thing]].

to:

* In ''Film/JasonAndTheArgonauts'' despite being a seminal SwordAndSandal film does this to Hercules from Myth/ClassicalMythology. In the original myths Herc besides being a SemiDivine powerhouse in his own right, was a great help to Jason on his journey acting as TheBigGuy for the Argonauts, defending the ship by slaying several Gegeines (six armed giants). In the film, Hercules is portrayed more as a oaf who gets many of his men killed by foolishly stealing Talos’s brooch and comes off as a less skilled warrior than Jason, whereas in the myths Herc is the WorldsStrongestMan and WorldsBestWarrior. It also doesn’t help Nigel Green lacked the literal [[HeroicBuild Herculean physique]] most actors who play the character possess.
** Also from the same movie
the Hydra much like ''Film/TheLovesOfHercules'' below goes down pretty easily, [[HydraProblem despite the whole regenerating head thing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/MadameWeb'':
** ComicBook/SpiderWomen Julia Carpenter, Mattie Franklin and Anya Corazon go from badass arachnid action girls to three powerless damsels Webb needs to protect and babysit from Ezekiel. It is stated and briefly fleetingly shown they will be Spider-Women in the future but we still see none of their competency that will apparently make them such great superheroes.
** Richard and Mary Parker, Spidey’s parents when alive in the comics were badass ComicBook/{{SHIELD}} super spies Nick Fury himself held in high regard. In this film they’re just clueless civilians who don’t have any real bearing on the plot beyond Mary being pregnant with Peter.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/ResidentEvilWelcomeToRaccoonCity'':
** Leon Kennedy is easily the hardest hit in the film. In ''[[VideoGame/ResidentEvil2 RE2]]'' he’s a super rookie that could plow through countless zombies, B.O.Ws and take down ImplacableMan Tyrant Mr.X all on his first day. In this film Leon gets a hefty amount of AdaptationalDumbass and is more like Hudson from ''Film/{{Aliens}}''. He was [[ReassignedToAntarctica transferred]] to Raccoon City for accidentally shooting his partner during training, he spends most of the first act asleep (even a tanker truck crashing and exploding directly outside the RPD isn't enough to wake him up, with Irons having to save him from a flaming zombie that walked right into the station), and his rookie status is heavily played up. He’s much more comic relief than his badass game counterpart. [[spoiler: He does at least get one moment of awesomeness right at very end when he takes down Birkin with the RPG.]]
** Jill Valentine in the games is the most badass ActionGirl in the franchise who could take down Nemesis all by herself. Here Jill barely does anything of note beyond shooting a few zombies, needs to be protected by Wesker of all people and in the film’s climax she’s outright NeutralFemale who contributes nothing the fight with Birkin. Particularly odd, considering Claire who by contrast at this point isn’t nearly as experienced being a civilian, is portrayed as more competent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheAdventuresOfSpirouAndFantasio'': In nearly all albums of [[ComicBook/SpirouAndFantasio the original comics]], Spirou and Fantasio get caught at least once in a hand-to-hand combat with villains (and usually win). The first is even a [[GoodOldFisticuffs boxing expert]]. Here, Fantasio is dragged outside the hotel by security guards and don't resist. As for Spirou, he prefers to run away in front of Gantagwa's policemen. When confronted to [[DarkActionGirl Marie]], he simply throw suitcases at her (albeit it can be because of a WouldntHitAGirl case). She clearly have the upper hand anyway, and it's the squirrel [[KillerRabbit Spip]], of all people, who win the brawl. Later on, when faced with [[BigBad Zorglub]], the later have no difficulties to simply [[CharlesAtlasSuperpower throw away Spirou like a rag doll]].

to:

* ''Film/TheAdventuresOfSpirouAndFantasio'': In nearly all albums of [[ComicBook/SpirouAndFantasio the original comics]], Spirou and Fantasio get caught at least once in a hand-to-hand combat with villains (and usually win). The first is even a [[GoodOldFisticuffs boxing expert]]. Here, Fantasio is dragged outside the hotel by security guards and don't resist. As for Spirou, he prefers to run away in front of Gantagwa's policemen. When confronted to [[DarkActionGirl Marie]], he simply throw suitcases at her (albeit it can be because of a WouldntHitAGirl case). She clearly have the upper hand anyway, and it's the squirrel [[KillerRabbit Spip]], of all people, who win the brawl. Later on, when faced with facing [[BigBad Zorglub]], the later have no difficulties to simply [[CharlesAtlasSuperpower throw away Spirou like a rag doll]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Some of the main female characters of ''Literature/BloodAndChocolate'' get a case of this in [[Film/BloodAndChocolate2007 the movie]]:

to:

* Some of the main female characters of ''Literature/BloodAndChocolate'' ''Literature/BloodAndChocolate1997'' get a case of this in [[Film/BloodAndChocolate2007 the movie]]:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheAdventuresOfSpirouAndFantasio'': In nearly all albums of [[ComicBook/SpirouAndFantasio the original comics]], Spirou and Fantasio get caught at least once in a hand-to-hand combat with villains (and usually win). The first is even a [[GoodOldFisticuffs boxing expert]]. Here, Fantasio is dragged outside the hotel by security guards and don't resist. As for Spirou, he prefers to run away in front of Gantagwa's policemen. When confronted to [[ActionGirl Marie]], he simply throw suitcases at her (albeit it can be because of a WouldntHitAGirl case). She clearly have the upper hand anyway, and it's the squirrel [[KillerRabbit Spip]], of all people, who win the brawl. Later on, when faced with [[BigBad Zorglub]], the later have no difficulties to simply [[CharlesAtlasSuperpower throw away Spirou like a rag doll]].

to:

* ''Film/TheAdventuresOfSpirouAndFantasio'': In nearly all albums of [[ComicBook/SpirouAndFantasio the original comics]], Spirou and Fantasio get caught at least once in a hand-to-hand combat with villains (and usually win). The first is even a [[GoodOldFisticuffs boxing expert]]. Here, Fantasio is dragged outside the hotel by security guards and don't resist. As for Spirou, he prefers to run away in front of Gantagwa's policemen. When confronted to [[ActionGirl [[DarkActionGirl Marie]], he simply throw suitcases at her (albeit it can be because of a WouldntHitAGirl case). She clearly have the upper hand anyway, and it's the squirrel [[KillerRabbit Spip]], of all people, who win the brawl. Later on, when faced with [[BigBad Zorglub]], the later have no difficulties to simply [[CharlesAtlasSuperpower throw away Spirou like a rag doll]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheAdventuresOfSpirouAndFantasio'': In nearly all albums of the original comics, Spirou and Fantasio get caught at least once in a hand-to-hand combat with villains (and usually win). The first is even a [[GoodOldFisticuffs boxing expert]]. Here, Fantasio is dragged outside the hotel by security guards and don't resist. As for Spirou, he prefers to run away in front of Gantagwa's policemen. When confronted to [[ActionGirl Marie]], he simply throw suitcases at her (albeit it can be because of a WouldntHitAGirl case). She clearly have the upper hand anyway, and it's the squirrel [[KillerRabbit Spip]], of all people, who win the brawl. Later on, when faced with [[BigBad Zorglub]], the later have no difficulties to simply [[CharlesAtlasSuperpower throw away Spirou like a rag doll]].

to:

* ''Film/TheAdventuresOfSpirouAndFantasio'': In nearly all albums of [[ComicBook/SpirouAndFantasio the original comics, comics]], Spirou and Fantasio get caught at least once in a hand-to-hand combat with villains (and usually win). The first is even a [[GoodOldFisticuffs boxing expert]]. Here, Fantasio is dragged outside the hotel by security guards and don't resist. As for Spirou, he prefers to run away in front of Gantagwa's policemen. When confronted to [[ActionGirl Marie]], he simply throw suitcases at her (albeit it can be because of a WouldntHitAGirl case). She clearly have the upper hand anyway, and it's the squirrel [[KillerRabbit Spip]], of all people, who win the brawl. Later on, when faced with [[BigBad Zorglub]], the later have no difficulties to simply [[CharlesAtlasSuperpower throw away Spirou like a rag doll]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheAdventuresOfSpirouAndFantasio'': In nearly all albums of the original comics, Spirou and Fantasio get caught at least once in a hand-to-hand combat with villains (and usually win). The first is even a [[GoodOldFisticuffs boxing expert]]. Here, Fantasio is dragged outside the hotel by security guards and don't resist. As for Spirou, he prefers to run away in front of Gantagwa's policemen. When confronted to [[ActionGirl Marie]], he simply throw suitcases at her (albeit it can be because of a WouldntHitAGirl case). She clearly have the upper hand anyway, and it's the squirrel [[KillerRabbit Spip]], of all people, who win the brawl. Later on, when faced with [[BigBad Zorglub]], the later have no difficulties to simply [[CharlesAtlasSuperpower throw away Spirou like a rag doll]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* One complaint about ''Film/PeterPanAndWendy'' is that this happens to Franchise/PeterPan himself, seemingly in order to [[{{Xenafication}} make Wendy and Tiger Lily more badass]]. He saves each of them in the book and [[WesternAnimation/PeterPan original Disney film]]; here, we only ever see the girls saving him, and in Wendy's case, multiple times.

Top