Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AdaptationExplanationExtrication / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In both versions, Gandalf demonstrates a deep knowledge of Gollum's history, including the fact that he was once a hobbit and that he was tortured by Sauron until he gave up what little information he knew. The film doesn't really explain how Gandalf knows this, but in the book, it's elaborated on that Aragorn (at Gandalf's request) had captured Gollum some time after he was set free, which allowed Gandalf to question him and fully confirm most of his suspicions. The film also leaves out how Frodo knows Gollum's original name, though the answer ("Gandalf told him") could easily be true in either version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Updating link


** ''Film/XMenApocalypse'' doesn't waste any time explaining how [[ComicBook/{{Storm}} Ororo Munroe]] wound up living in Egypt, despite being (by all appearances) of sub-Saharan African descent. The ''ComicBook/XMen'' comics explain that she was born in Harlem to an African-American father and a Kenyan mother, but moved to Cairo as a child.

to:

** ''Film/XMenApocalypse'' doesn't waste any time explaining how [[ComicBook/{{Storm}} [[ComicBook/StormMarvelComics Ororo Munroe]] wound up living in Egypt, despite being (by all appearances) of sub-Saharan African descent. The ''ComicBook/XMen'' comics explain that she was born in Harlem to an African-American father and a Kenyan mother, but moved to Cairo as a child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The films' prologue briefly explains the story of the 19 rings that were forged alongside the One Ring (three for the Elves, seven for the Dwarves, nine for the Men); while we're told that the nine human ring-bearers became the ''Nazgûl'' (Ringwraiths) after being corrupted by their rings, audiences who haven't read the books are left to wonder what happened to the other ten. The books explain that the Dwarves' seven rings were lost after their kingdoms were consumed by dragons, while Gandalf, Elrond, and Galadriel ''still'' have the Elves' three rings.[[note]] Gandalf was given the ring ''Narya'' by the Elf lord Círdan, Elrond inherited the ring ''Vilya'' from the Elf lord Gil-galad after his death, and Galadriel has carried the ring ''Nenya'' since it was forged.[[/note]] Extra-attentive viewers might notice those three characters wearing rings that resemble the ones donned by the Elves in the prologue, but might wonder why they're able to freely wear them without being corrupted. The answer is that the Elves' three rings are a separate class of rings that were forged by the Elf smith Celebrimbor rather than by Sauron, and they're impervious to Sauron's magic.

to:

** The films' prologue briefly explains the story of the 19 rings that were forged alongside the One Ring (three for the Elves, seven for the Dwarves, nine for the Men); while we're told that the nine human ring-bearers became the ''Nazgûl'' (Ringwraiths) after being corrupted by their rings, audiences who haven't read the books are left to wonder what happened to the other ten. The books explain that the Dwarves' seven rings were lost after their kingdoms were consumed by dragons, while Gandalf, Elrond, and Galadriel ''still'' have the Elves' three rings.[[note]] Gandalf was given the ring ''Narya'' by the Elf lord Círdan, Elrond inherited the ring ''Vilya'' from the Elf lord Gil-galad after his death, and Galadriel has carried the ring ''Nenya'' since it was forged.[[/note]] Extra-attentive viewers might notice those three characters wearing rings that resemble the ones donned by the Elves in the prologue, but might wonder why they're able to freely wear them without being corrupted. The answer is that the Elves' three rings Three are a separate class of rings that were forged by the Elf smith Celebrimbor rather than by Sauron, and they're impervious therefore lacked the inherently wicked nature of the Seven and the Nine (though they were still tied to Sauron's magic.the One, and could be corrupted if Sauron ever got it back).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's explained in the book that the White Witch's Turkish Delight is [[GRatedDrug instantly addictive]], making Edmund's betrayal over a supply of candy seem far less petty.

to:

** It's explained in the book that the White Witch's Turkish Delight is [[GRatedDrug instantly addictive]], enchanted to be so addictive that a person under its spell will keep eating it until it kills them, making Edmund's betrayal over a supply of candy seem far less petty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Examples Are Not General. If you're going to cite that film, list specific examples.


* Creator/DavidLynch's ''Film/Dune1984'' is one big mess of this. Hardly anything is given a proper explanation, and the film even features a few setups to plot threads whose payoffs are not included.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The novel ''Literature/WhoCensoredRogerRabbit'' (which ''Film/WhoFramedRogerRabbit'' is based on) has a TwistEnding that explains the seemingly implausible pairing of Jessica and Roger: [[spoiler:the MacGuffin is actually a magic lamp containing a genie, which granted Roger two wishes--one of which was to marry Jessica]]. As the plot of the novel is completely different from the film, however, the movie's version of the Jessica/Roger relationship is simply treated as some strange, funny case of DeliberateValuesDissonance between humans and Toons (since humor is so prized in Toon society, ''she's'' considered the one who married up in the film).

to:

* The novel ''Literature/WhoCensoredRogerRabbit'' (which ''Film/WhoFramedRogerRabbit'' is based on) has a TwistEnding that explains the seemingly implausible pairing of Jessica and Roger: [[spoiler:the MacGuffin is actually a magic lamp containing a genie, which granted Roger two wishes--one of which was to marry Jessica]]. As the plot of the novel is completely different from the film, however, the movie's version of the Jessica/Roger relationship is simply treated as some strange, funny case of DeliberateValuesDissonance between humans and Toons (since (Toons value humor more than physical attractiveness, so Roger is so prized in Toon society, ''she's'' considered the one who married up of most desirable people in the film).Toontown).

Removed: 1175

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The explanation isn't ommited, the plot point is simply changed. There is no reason to explain why Anderton has 3 minority reports because in the movie he DOESN'T have any minority reports.


* ''Film/MinorityReport'' completely did away with the ending of the short story due to its MindScrew nature. In the short story TheReveal is that there were ''three'' minority reports, the first pre-cog reported a future where Anderton committed a murder, the second a future where Anderton read the first report and refused to commit the murder, and the third a future where he read both the two earlier reports and committed the murder; three very different futures, and some of them contingent on predictions of the others. It is also mentioned that the only reason this could happen is that Anderton, as head of Pre-Crime, had access to the raw data from the pre-cogs rather than the cleaned-up version from the analysis computer. The film favors a far simpler turn of events that places less importance on how Pre-Crime actually works. There Anderton accidentally awakens a precog, who shows him a vision of her mother's murder - which was arranged by the BigBad. Anderton retrieves the vision and shows it to the BigBad - who then decides HeKnowsTooMuch, and hires a junkie to confess to the murder of Anderton's son, the one thing that would drive Anderton to murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In both versions, the major conflict to Arwen's character is that she has the choice to become a human, and therefore mortal, or stay an elf and retain her eternal life. In the film, why Arwen has this ability is not explained, and most viewers would probably assume it to simply be an ability elves have in general. In the books, this is because Arwen is partially human, being descended from Tuor and Beren, and therefore the choice is basically whether to embrace her human heritage. Her father Elrond had the same choice, but chose to stay an elf, which goes a long way to explain his apprehensiveness at the idea (though [[AdaptationalAngstUpgrade he is far less bitter towards humanity in the book]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hammond explains at the beginning that the dinosaurs were evacuated off Site A due to a hurricane.


** The first book ended with Nublar island being carpet-bombed by the (funnily non-existent) Costa Rican airforce, hence Ingen's new ruling bureau's (and in the second book, Biosyn's) need to go to the "Site B" and get their dinosaurs there. This was actually explained in a scene of the ''Lost World'' movie but was left out of the theatrical cut, leaving the casual viewer wondering why Ingen didn't just go back to Nublar, the island with some working infrastructure left and pick some of the dinosaurs still penned up there, rather than massing "two dozen cowboys" and going to catch the entirely free ones in Sorna.
*** This question was compounded when ''Film/JurassicWorld'' established that Isla Nublar did survive in the movie continuity, meaning that either the bombing did not take place in the movie canon, or the damage from it was less than one would expect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It’s explained in the mvoie that they moved on to targeting the mutant gene dormant in humans.


* In ''Film/{{Cinderella 2015}}'', Gus Gus retains his name from [[WesternAnimation/{{Cinderella}} the animated film]], but no mention is given of his real name "Octavius," from which Augustus/Gus is a nickname of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It’s explained in the mvoie that they moved on to targeting the mutant gene dormant in humans.


** ''Film/XMenDaysOfFuturePast'' is rather vague about why the Sentinels conquered all of humanity in the film's BadFuture, despite being designed solely to hunt and kill Mutants. The comic book storyline explains that it was a twisted case of GoneHorriblyRight: Bolivar Trask programmed his robots to stamp out the Mutant race by any means necessary, but didn't consider how many ordinary humans carried the recessive "X-gene" that causes mutation; the Sentinels proved to be a little too good at their jobs, and eventually began building concentration camps for processing and detaining all humans with the X-gene, killing any humans who tried to stop them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The movie never explains how the distinctive blots on Rorschach's mask constantly shift and move, leaving some viewers to wonder how a dirt-poor street vigilante got his hands on such a seemingly advanced piece of synthetic fabric (especially since the story takes place in the 1980s, when such materials weren't widely available). The book explains that it's one of many synthetic materials developed through Doctor Manhattan's experiments with physical matter, and Rorschach acquired it when he was working in a garment shop before becoming a crime-fighter.[[note]] The fabric was originally intended to be used in a dress, but the buyer returned it because she didn't like how it looked. Rorschach claims that the buyer was none other than [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Kitty_Genovese Kitty Genovese]], whose brutal murder partly inspired his black-and-white view of morality.[[/note]]

to:

** The movie never explains how the distinctive blots on Rorschach's mask constantly shift and move, leaving some viewers to wonder how a dirt-poor street vigilante got his hands on such a seemingly advanced piece of synthetic fabric (especially since the story takes place in the 1980s, when such materials weren't widely available). The book explains that it's one of many synthetic materials developed through Doctor Manhattan's experiments with physical matter, and Rorschach acquired it when he was working in a garment shop before becoming a crime-fighter.[[note]] The fabric was originally intended to be used in a dress, but the buyer returned it because she didn't like how it looked. Rorschach claims that the buyer was none other than [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Kitty_Genovese Kitty Genovese]], whose brutal murder partly inspired his black-and-white view of morality.[[/note]][[/note]] The mask's pattern is actually a mixture of two viscous fluids (one black, one white) trapped between sheets of transparent fabric, which shift and form symmetrical patterns in response to heat and pressure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The films don't really elaborate on why the way to get through the Doors of Durin and into Moria is [[ThePasswordIsAlwaysSwordfish simply to say the elvish word for "friend"]], other than Frodo referring to it as a "riddle" (which it isn't, really; it's more of a trick question that Gandalf had misinterpreted and was overthinking). In the books, this is elaborated on a little more: the Doors of Durin were created in a time of great peace, and therefore simply naming yourself to be a friend was enough to be allowed in. The password is in an elvish language (specifically, Sindarin) rather than the dwarfish Khuzdul because at the time, the dwarves had a close friendship with the elves living nearby. Funnily, this was something the far more truncated [[WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings Bakshi version]] managed to explain properly.

to:

** The films don't really elaborate on why the way to get through the Doors of Durin and into Moria is [[ThePasswordIsAlwaysSwordfish simply to say the elvish word for "friend"]], other than Frodo referring to it as a "riddle" (which it isn't, really; it's more of a trick question that Gandalf had misinterpreted and was overthinking). In the books, this is elaborated on a little more: the Doors of Durin were created in a time of great peace, and therefore simply naming yourself to be a friend was enough to be allowed in. The password is in an elvish language (specifically, Sindarin) rather than the dwarfish dwarvish Khuzdul because at the time, the dwarves had a close friendship with the elves living nearby. nearby--in fact, a line left out of the films claims that the Doors were created by a collaboration between an elf and a dwarf. Funnily, this was something the far more truncated [[WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings Bakshi version]] managed to explain properly.touch on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Gimli:''' Those were happier times.\\

to:

'''Gimli:''' Those were happier times.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Legolas:''' So, all you had to do was say, "friend," and enter.\\

to:

-->'''Legolas:''' --->'''Legolas:''' So, all you had to do was say, "friend," and enter.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The films don't really elaborate on why the way to get through the Doors of Durin and into Moria is [[ThePasswordIsAlwaysSwordfish simply to say the elvish word for "friend"]], other than Frodo referring to it as a "riddle" (which it isn't, really; it's more of a trick question that Gandalf had misinterpreted and was overthinking). In the books, this is elaborated on a little more: the Doors of Durin were created in a time of great peace, and therefore simply naming yourself to be a friend was enough to be allowed in. The password is in an elvish language (specifically, Sindarin) rather than the dwarfish Khuzdul because at the time, the dwarves had a close friendship with the elves living nearby. Funnily, this was something the far more truncated [[WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings Bakshi version]] managed to explain properly.
-->'''Legolas:''' So, all you had to do was say, "friend," and enter.\\
'''Gimli:''' Those were happier times.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For that matter, very little about [[BigBad Sauron]] is ever explained, leaving casual viewers who haven't read the books to wonder who (and what) he actually '''is''', and how he became so dangerously powerful. In a nutshell: he's one of several lesser deities called ''Ainur'' (specifically, a lesser order of Ainur called ''Maiar'') who serve Middle Earth's supreme creator god ''Eru Ilúvatar''. Long before the events of the story, he went rogue and joined another rogue Ainu, a Vala called Melkor (aka "Morgoth") as his [[TheDragon right-hand man]], and later [[DragonAscendant took up Morgoth's cause]] after he was defeated and exiled in his attempt to destroy the world. In other words: he's a FallenAngel in the vein of Lucifer.

to:

** For that matter, very little about [[BigBad Sauron]] is ever explained, leaving casual viewers who haven't read the books to wonder who (and what) he actually '''is''', and how he became so dangerously powerful. In a nutshell: he's one of several lesser deities called ''Ainur'' (specifically, a lesser order of Ainur called ''Maiar'') who serve Middle Earth's supreme creator god ''Eru Ilúvatar''. Long before the events of the story, he went rogue and joined another rogue Ainu, a Vala called Melkor (aka "Morgoth") as his [[TheDragon right-hand man]], and later [[DragonAscendant took up Morgoth's cause]] after he was defeated and exiled in his attempt to destroy the world. In other words: he's a FallenAngel in the vein of Lucifer. Admittedly, almost all of this is in ''Literature/TheSilmarillion'': ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' itself is about as vague on Sauron's nature as the films.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
none of these are actually in the book version of lord of the rings - the idea of using the eagles is never mentioned, and tolkien deliberately left their abilities somewhat broadly defined.


** One issue that is routinely brought up as though it's a plot hole is "Why didn't the Fellowship just use the eagles and fly the One Ring to Mount Doom, then drop it in from the air?" There are a number of reasons in the books that explain why. The Eagles are forbidden by their creator from intervening directly in the War, so they won't shepherd the Ring themselves. They also would be just as likely to be tempted to take the Ring for themselves as any other sentient creature. The most obvious reason is that the whole point of the Fellowship is to avoid detection, and a flock of eagles would bring all of Sauron's forces down on their heads. For all these reasons, the Eagles are only free to arrive once the Ring is gone and Sauron is defeated. Another factor is that their power is greatly increased in the movies; while their arrival did turn the tide in the book it was the assembled armies of their entire race intervening (which had been established to be mustering much earlier), not just four guys.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The novel ''Literature/WhoCensoredRogerRabbit'' (which ''Film/WhoFramedRogerRabbit'' is based on) has a TwistEnding that explains the seemingly implausible pairing of Jessica and Roger: [[spoiler:the MacGuffin is actually a magic lamp containing a genie, which granted Roger two wishes--one of which was to marry Jessica]]. As the plot of the novel is completely different from the film, however, the movie's version of the Jessica/Roger relationship is simply treated as some strange, funny case of DeliberateValuesDissonance between humans and toons.

to:

* The novel ''Literature/WhoCensoredRogerRabbit'' (which ''Film/WhoFramedRogerRabbit'' is based on) has a TwistEnding that explains the seemingly implausible pairing of Jessica and Roger: [[spoiler:the MacGuffin is actually a magic lamp containing a genie, which granted Roger two wishes--one of which was to marry Jessica]]. As the plot of the novel is completely different from the film, however, the movie's version of the Jessica/Roger relationship is simply treated as some strange, funny case of DeliberateValuesDissonance between humans and toons.Toons (since humor is so prized in Toon society, ''she's'' considered the one who married up in the film).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The novel ''Literature/WhoCensoredRogerRabbit'' (which ''Film/WhoFramedRogerRabbit'' is based on) has a TwistEnding that explains the seemingly implausible pairing of Jessica and Roger: [[spoiler:the {{Macguffin}} is actually a magic lamp containing a genie, which granted Roger two wishes--one of which was to marry Jessica]]. As the plot of the novel is completely different from the film, however, the movie's version of the Jessica/Roger relationship is simply treated as some strange, funny case of DeliberateValuesDissonance between humans and toons.

to:

* The novel ''Literature/WhoCensoredRogerRabbit'' (which ''Film/WhoFramedRogerRabbit'' is based on) has a TwistEnding that explains the seemingly implausible pairing of Jessica and Roger: [[spoiler:the {{Macguffin}} MacGuffin is actually a magic lamp containing a genie, which granted Roger two wishes--one of which was to marry Jessica]]. As the plot of the novel is completely different from the film, however, the movie's version of the Jessica/Roger relationship is simply treated as some strange, funny case of DeliberateValuesDissonance between humans and toons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/AScannerDarkly'':

to:

* ''Film/AScannerDarkly'':''Literature/AScannerDarkly'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
terminology


** For that matter, very little about [[BigBad Sauron]] is ever explained, leaving casual viewers who haven't read the books to wonder who (and what) he actually '''is''', and how he became so dangerously powerful. In a nutshell: he's one of several lesser deities called ''Valar'' (specifically, a lesser order of Valar called ''Maiar'') who serve Middle Earth's supreme creator god ''Eru Ilúvatar''. Long before the events of the story, he went rogue and joined another rogue Valar called Melkor (aka "Morgoth") as his [[TheDragon right-hand man]], and later [[DragonAscendant took up Morgoth's cause]] after he was defeated and exiled in his attempt to destroy the world. In other words: he's a FallenAngel in the vein of Lucifer.

to:

** For that matter, very little about [[BigBad Sauron]] is ever explained, leaving casual viewers who haven't read the books to wonder who (and what) he actually '''is''', and how he became so dangerously powerful. In a nutshell: he's one of several lesser deities called ''Valar'' ''Ainur'' (specifically, a lesser order of Valar Ainur called ''Maiar'') who serve Middle Earth's supreme creator god ''Eru Ilúvatar''. Long before the events of the story, he went rogue and joined another rogue Valar Ainu, a Vala called Melkor (aka "Morgoth") as his [[TheDragon right-hand man]], and later [[DragonAscendant took up Morgoth's cause]] after he was defeated and exiled in his attempt to destroy the world. In other words: he's a FallenAngel in the vein of Lucifer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/EdgeOfTomorrow'', soldiers use variety of guns but Rita Vrataski uses a CoolSword instead. Why she and only she is using a melee weapon is never explained. ''LightNovel/AllYouNeedIsKill'' from which the movie was adapted explains why. Guns have limited ammo which means no matter how good Rita will get she can only kill so many aliens in a single battle, and a melee weapon removes this limitation. On the other hand it's DifficultButAwesome to use and the only reason why Rita is capable of using it effectively is because she was stuck in GroundhogDayLoop and had as much time to train as she wanted.

to:

* In ''Film/EdgeOfTomorrow'', soldiers use variety of guns but Rita Vrataski uses a CoolSword instead. Why she and only she is using a melee weapon is never explained. ''LightNovel/AllYouNeedIsKill'' ''Literature/AllYouNeedIsKill'' from which the movie was adapted explains why. Guns have limited ammo which means no matter how good Rita will get she can only kill so many aliens in a single battle, and a melee weapon removes this limitation. On the other hand it's DifficultButAwesome to use and the only reason why Rita is capable of using it effectively is because she was stuck in GroundhogDayLoop and had as much time to train as she wanted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheHitchhikersGuideToTheGalaxy'' has Ford approaching Arthur with a shopping trolley filled with cans of beer and packets of peanuts. In the [[Literature/TheHitchhikersGuideToTheGalaxy book]] he explains that these are necessary for combatting TeleportationSickness but not here. With teleportation not being mentioned, we also aren't told how Arthur and Ford got on board the Vogon ship.

to:

* ''Film/TheHitchhikersGuideToTheGalaxy'' ''Film/TheHitchhikersGuideToTheGalaxy2005'' has Ford approaching Arthur with a shopping trolley filled with cans of beer and packets of peanuts. In the [[Literature/TheHitchhikersGuideToTheGalaxy book]] he explains that these are necessary for combatting TeleportationSickness but not here. With teleportation not being mentioned, we also aren't told how Arthur and Ford got on board the Vogon ship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Creator/DenisVilleneuve's ''Film/Dune2021'' is somewhat vague about the finer points of [[BigBad Baron Harkonnen]]'s plan to destroy House Atreides, which might leave some viewers wondering why he goes to such great lengths to kidnap [[TheMedic Dr. Yueh]]'s wife to force him to betray the Atreides (when he could presumably have just ''bribed'' him), and why the Atreides (who otherwise pride themselves on their [[ProperlyParanoid extremely tight security]]) apparently never consider the possibility that Yueh might be a traitor. The book explains that Yueh is a graduate of the Suk School, an elite medical academy where graduates are subjected to mental conditioning that makes them physically incapable of taking a human life--making him [[BeneathSuspicion the one member of the Duke's household whom no one would ever suspect of being a traitor]].[[note]] Graduates of the Suk School are the only doctors entrusted to treat the rulers of Great Houses, who live under constant threat of assassination.[[/note]] House Harkonnen discovered that it was possible to break the Suk School's conditioning by forcing a person to take a life in order to save another life (putting them in a situation where [[MortonsFork either course of action would result in someone's death]]), which is why they could only get Yueh on their side by [[IHaveYourWife threatening to kill his wife]].

Top