|
Theatre A Very Potter Musical Discussion
Maybe I'm missing something obvious, but I've never understood the "Hufflepuff's are particularly good finders!" joke.
Should these be moved to Web Original perhaps?
with the inevitable "AVP3quel", shouldn't we think about giving the shows their own individual pages?
Am I the only one who thinks there needs to be a section for tropes that are used in both musicals? It would streamline this page a great deal.
(I'm brand new, so I don't know if this was addressed before. If it was, bear with me.)
Why was the bomb sandwich addressed as a Big Lipped Alligator Moment? It was for the sake of a joke, and a bit of foreshadowing to Snape killing Dumbledore.
- During the Pensieve Flashback in the "Guys Like Potter" number, Lily flirts with James Potter and accepts a date with him... Right after he tormented Snape (and before Snape called her "Mudblood"). *
mindset, and demonizing Lily here is Completely Missing The Point. While Snape was portrayed sympathetically, being a self-described "Nice Guy" is not a desirable thing.
The 'Throw It In' for Voldemort's killing people line at the end of AVPM... I've heard that they changed that line for every show, and that's the one that worked best. So it isn't a throw-it-in. But that's just what I've heard. Is there any proof it was improvised?
I changed the page image to the AVPM cartoon art — it just seemed appropriate. But if people don't like it, I can restore the original.
If I want to list AVPM or AVPS as an example on a trope page, should I put it under Theatre or Web Original?
what Tropes would apply to the following two scenes?
1) Hermione gives Harry & Ron a wrapped gift that is quite obviously a book, but they think it might be a puppy
2) Seamus using himself as a footstool for Harry, and a bench for Cho
3) Draco casually admitting that he's a racist who hates the Irish, gingers, mudbloods, and Gryffindor house, before asking Harry if he wants to be friends
why was every single edit I made just undone?
all I was doing was moving examples of the second play out of the list of tropes of the first one
Okay, is there any particular reason every single edit I just made was reverted? Including fixing a typo?
I'm going to assume it was an accident or some kind of glitch. Perhaps some of that was intentional reversion on grounds of a bad edit. However, seeing as even perfectly rational edits were reversed, I don't know which of my edits were reverted because they were bad and which were just reverted blindly.
I'm kind of inclined to just blindly restore all of those edits. Should I?
Would anyone who knows what stuff was cut for the You Tube version care to elaborate on the nature of these scenes/jokes? I think it would not be an unwarranted addition to the show's page.
Why is Ginny called a Manic Pixie Dream Girl on both the main troper page and the character tropes page— both with the explaination that she can be "A little spacey, at times." When does she open Harry up to the great, wonderful adventure of life? Did I miss something?