Yeah, Steve, whilst I entirely agree with you that it's a shit fic and that the author doesn't have a clue how to characterise Shirou, if we were supposed to delete fics from the list on the grounds of being shit, then I would have deleted about 50% of the ones currently listed, because some of the fics listed on here are bloody awful. However, this is simply a page for people to recommend fics that they like, regardless of quality. If you don't like them, then just don't recommend them, and take note of the person doing the recommending so that you know not to trust their judgement in the future.