Characters Xenoblade Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

SnakeDoctor
Topic
01:00:05 PM Apr 25th 2014
edited by 38.114.86.50
Why is Jade Face the only Face listed in combination with his Homs counterpart? I know we're not concerned with spoilers, but it makes Gadolt's Trope list confusing as to which Trope applies to which version of the character (and is inconsistent with Mumkhar/Metal Face being separate).
MrUnderhill
05:32:44 PM Nov 21st 2014
edited by 71.84.9.160
Because Mumkhar and Metal Face were initially portrayed as two separate characters (and therefore, both personas have their own trope lists), while Jade Face is identified as Gadolt almost immediately after he/it is introduced. If Jade Face had its own entry, it would be either almost empty or redundant with Gadolt's. If anything, Mumkhar is the odd one out, and his entries ought to be cleaned up so we don't have the same trope for the same character listed twice.
MrUnderhill
Topic
07:54:52 AM Dec 21st 2012
The number of spoilers in Fiora's section is almost getting to the point of being a spoiler by itself. If someone who just left Colony 9 saw her page, my bet is that their first thought would be either "she comes back at some point" or "she's a really fleshed-out Posthumous Character," with the former being more likely. Anyone else think we should split the spoilered parts into their own section?
Oreochan
Topic
06:55:49 PM Oct 27th 2012
Pulled:

Adult Child has been renamed to One of the Kids. In order for this to be an example of the trope, the character's childishness has to be from or demonstrated by interacting with children. This example can be added back with context relevant to the trope if it fits.
Kayube
09:11:01 PM Oct 27th 2012
I'd say it probably doesn't. Nopon in general act childish (because it helps them in their interactions with the other races) but they don't spend an unusual amount of time around their kids. (Though there are Nopon children around.)
SeptimusHeap
Topic
02:02:45 PM Mar 5th 2012
Collapse/Expand Topics