Hi
The current is way too texty, while the text in the suggestion is barely legible. For the moment, I'm just voting to pull the current.
Filthy casual
Same.
(Annoyed grunt)
No, the other one.
The current doesn't even say anything about a harem. It might as well be your average Casanova or Wannabe.
Pull for being misleading.
Check out my fanfiction!
Hi
Clock is set. Anyone else for/against pulling the current?
Works as a quote but there isn't anything actually shown.
Can we pair that with something like this
◊ or an imagine spot of something similar?
Curator of Berserk
Yeah, I guess you're right after all: it's no good if he's just saying it. That imagine spot or image of what he wants is kind of necessary.
edited 13th Jul '17 12:34:08 PM by TheBigBopper
Hi
Agreed; without that it's all tell and no show.
Similar pic from To Love-Ru here
◊
(even if the seeker is the girl in the story..)
edited 16th Jul '17 1:00:19 AM by babil
![[up]](https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_up.png "[up]"){kind=icon}
Ok that one is great.
If it wasn't right to left.
Curator of Berserk
What a pity! If the text were in bubbles instead of superimposed over the image, it would be so easy to just flip it.
^ Too little context.
Curator of Berserk
Let's keep looking, but I wouldn't mind settling for 15 if nothing else can be found. It's actually pretty good.
Pull the current. Don't think that any of the suggestions are an improvement.
Spiral out, keep going.
Hi
Re-clocking. I kinda like 15.
No, the other one.
I think that shows more that she likes two characters, and she's open for suggestions than actively seeking a harem, so I don't think it works as a page image.
Check out my fanfiction!
Part of the problem is that any image that isn't text-heavy or clearly an Imagine Spot would start to encroach on other tropes. For example, 7 is similar in concept to the image on Marry Them All.
Hi
The clock's up and the only decision that has any real consensus is to pull the current pic, so it's gone and the page is tagged. Locking up.
Old pic:
 |
I am not sure how the image for Harem Seeker was originally chosen, but this guy in the image from Out There seems to just be talking about being The Casanova and not discussing anything related to wanting to have a harem of multiple steady romantic partners. As I understand it, a harem seeker isn't someone who wants to sleep with a lot of different people and dump them afterwards, but rather who wants multiple girlfriends, concubines, or spouses whom they can horde all to themselves, but who can expect a certain amount of continuous attention and commitment from them. More possessive than Polyamory, but more committed than The Casanova.
I'm going to propose this
◊ shot of Issei from High School Dx D declaring his ambition to become a harem king, and invite anybody else to come up with a better one.
edited 1st Jul '17 10:38:08 PM by TheBigBopper