Needs Help: Fully Clothed Nudity

"Woman logic" jokes are probably bad news.

I don't understand what the problem is. The picture looks fine to me.

Nor do I. Unclear double entendres (I assume) do not good arguments make.

What I believe he means is that people might find a "hah, woman logic, amirite?" joke to be offensive.

And we're not at all obliged to listen to the argument. The pic works fine; at most, I'm voting Keep Until Better Image Suggested.

Echoing what Willbyr said. Keep Until Better Image Suggested.

I'm pretty sure this isn't the first time a topic has been made about the image picking for this trope. Last time it was voted Keep Until Better Image Suggested before that even existed.

Not quite; last time was what chose the image in the first place.

That image is pretty unnecessarily sexist. It's not woman logic, it's society logic. Swimwear at a beach is okay because it's a sort of safe zone for skimpy clothes. Go to a sauna and you'll have people running around stark naked because they're in a place where it was publicly agreed that nudity is okay, and unless someone's actively acting erotic, the nakedness won't even register as sexual because of that public agreement, even though it would in just about any other place. It's just an oddity of everyday human life.

I think that sounds like a good reason to keep the image, as it shows that it illustrates the trope. Yes, it's sexist, but are people who're not me that sensitive?

^^ IAWTC. The exact same image without "women's logic" written on it would be far better.

Pretty much this and what Fawriel said. Otherwise, it is a good image.

edited 26th Feb '13 9:06:07 AM by Hodor

I think the current image is fine.

I agree that "Society Logic" or just "Logic" would be better, but as-is it's pretty good.

But if someone makes an edit, I'd be all for a swap.

URGH, trying to find the orginal pictures to do a better edit is just turning up all sorts of gross sexism in GIS.

Also fridge logic is setting in now; underclothing is almost always thinner and more transparent than outer clothing, including bathing suits. So they are not really the same thing at all :\

At most, this needs a caption change. The image itself is fine.

This◊ is probably too memey, but it's about all I could find.

Yes. Also doesn't illustrate as much as say it.

The current image is great except for the whole "women sure are stupid, amirite?".

If someone could work some Photoshop magic and take that out, that would be great.

And yet if you walk around in your underwaer on a beach, people tell you to put some clothes on.

Anyways, I still like the current image and see no serious issues with it.

My problem with it is the text makes it look like an image macro. I'd remove the "women logic" part and it would be fine.

The problem is that that is the original and there is no textless version so my suggestion is for someone to find two new "comparison" images if they're bothered by the current version.

edited 1st Mar '13 9:02:30 PM by Lionheart0

I think there's nothing wrong with the current and arguments to the contrary are silly.

I think it would be a little better without "WOMAN'S LOGIC" at the top, but it's fine.