The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

@Largo: Nah, no need, we have enough stuff to review already.

@Kuro: I think all we need is for someone to sandbox a disambiguation page that the mods can swap into Main.Variable Geo that points to the other two works, and otherwise keep it locked so that none of the h-game material creeps in.

edited 18th Jul '12 10:10:42 AM by Meeble

Does this work?

We should probably add a note that we're allowing pages for the clean works in the series only, but I'm drawing a blank on how best to word that.

How about "Note that we only allow pages on the non-hentai games and first non-hentai anime."

I think "Note that we only allow pages for the non-hentai games and anime" would work just fine. (And leaves room in case future clean anime versions are released.)

edited 18th Jul '12 10:29:05 AM by Meeble

Alright. Done?

Yes, looks great! I'll holler to have that swapped in. Thanks for your help!

edited 18th Jul '12 10:29:49 AM by Meeble

Characters.The Neverending Story got flagged.

Its obvious someone hates us for us for existing. Zap it?

I don't go to this thread often so I wouldn't know, but is there anyway of flagging people who keep troll flagging entries?

No. A Moderator has to check that.

Always read the page flagged too. It's very easy for people to get the wrong message or have a reason that's not trolling either. Some may think "Really 700 Years Old" could be pedophile-pandering for example. Of course, clearly they need to check the context too, but yeah, these mistakes happen.

Besides that, could we please stop accusing people of being trolls? There's no need to.

It's not a troll, it's someone pressing the button by mistake while looking for their recent edits. Most people don't even know what the button means.

I suppose that makes a lot of sense for something that isn't a main works page.

I wouldn't be surprised if people naturally assumed that it was a magical "Needs special efforts" button that would give the page wiki magic as well. Perhaps we should give the button a easier to miss position, to help ensure that only people who know what they are doing hit it.

Ok, so I've watched a good 12 episodes of the Da Capo anime, in which really nothing whatsoever seemed to be happening. Very little in the way of fanservice (or plot progression, for that matter).

Do the later episodes, seasons, and series have anything that I should specifically be worried about in the way of sexual content? Based on the episodes I've watched this seems like one that should get a pass, but if it's not representative of the rest of the anime content, please let me know.

On the visual novels, I understand that they've got pornographic content, but that there are clean versions available, correct? If so, and assuming there's nothing else to worry about in the anime series, I'm ok with voting to keep but limit examples to the clean versions.

I just checked vndb there are multiple clean versions http://vndb.org/v264.

Yep. There are clean versions. I don't recall anything problematic happening in either Da Capo or Da Capo II apart from stuff that's removed in clean versions. It's a really fluffy, harmless sort of series.

The plot does get serious after those episodes, though nothing questionable happens after that. The later seasons are somewhat like that too

Thanks shadis, Arha, and Marche... that's what I needed to know. I will go ahead and resolve this with "Keep but restrict visual novel examples to the clean versions."

Things that currently have 2 votes one way.

• Page 1
  • Patalliro! - 2 angel, 0 devil
• Page 2
  • Ironwood - 2 angel, 2 devil
  • Morefuyu - 2 angel, 2 devil
• Page 3
  • Sengoku Rance - 1 angel, 2 devil
  • Sundome - 2 angel, 0 devil
  • Animamundi Dark Alchemist - 2 angel, 0 devil
  • Wicked City - 2 angel, 0 devil
  • Shiro - 0 angel, 2 devil
  • Maka Maka - 0 angel, 2 devil
  • Hoshizora no Memoria - 0 angel, 2 devil
  • Kamidori Alchemy Meister - 0 angel, 2 devil
  • Iron Virgin Jun - 2 angel, 0 devil

BTW can I make a page for Sakuran

Notes: English version Vertical Inc. Rating: 18+ Content: Mostly nudity, although our main character runs away once as a child(nude) Some pubic hair is seen.

I am curious as to what to do if you wanted to make a page on something you weren't sure runs afoul of content policy.

I thought you just asked here. Is that wrong?

RE: 5P-only thread on Sengoku Rance:

The thread's hung around so long because the 5Ps are deadlocked. There's neither a consensus to kill Sengoku Rance or to keep it.

@ Creating a page for a borderline work you think is safe.

I would be interested to hear the official word on that.

I'd have thought we could use our own judgement initially and create the page, allowing it to be reported if someone deems the content too questionable.

If we tihnk someone else will flag it later, we could post here that we created the page and thought it safe, list our reasons and ask Arha to index it.

Asking beforehand may save some hassle, though.