The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Oh, if that's the case, then the work should be alright to keep.

Also, what should we do with Ironwood and Ramba?

...

At least Ramba averts Bigger Is Better in Bed?

Ironwood looks incredibly sketchy by both of our parameters - underage dragon woman and porn?

Dunno, but I noticed that the Ironwood description is a Wikipedia copypaste. If they are Porn with Plot, keep them.

Underage? How old exactly?

edited 26th May '12 11:05:38 AM by SeptimusHeap

No idea, our page says he's underage but doesn't really specify how. I assume time isn't of the essence, so I could trek down to my local comic book store next week and try and find a copy of the trade paperbacks.

ATTN: @P5: Possible misclick in queue for FanVid.Touhou Note that I say possible as it explicitly states that some may be NSFW. If this is the case, presumably it can stay after cleanup.

Anyone know about Petit Roid 3? It doesn't have a Wikipedia page, so I don't know if the "3 little android girls'' who self-destruct if not fucked are too young or not.

Robots that look like little girls... who self-destruct if they don't get fucked?! Are you fucking kidding me?!

Looking through thumbnails of the manga pages, a lot of it is him having sex with adult woman, but yes, there's parts of him having sex loli robots. And most pages involve nudity.

Definitely cut-worthy.

I think Plumbers Don't Wear Ties should be taken off the list. The description, quotes and examples spoil the worst-kept secret about the game: it only pretends to be porn.

I just got a PM from Shadis, who has read part of it—he says it is neither porn nor pedo-pandering and not worthy of a cut.

EDIT: Total misunderstanding. He meant the exact opposite, that it must be cut. Flagging that.

edited 26th May '12 3:38:19 PM by FinalStarman

I saw "gameplay" of Plumbers Don't Wear Ties. It's truly awful, but it isn't porn. I think the image ought to be changed though, something that better describes the way the game actually is.

edited 26th May '12 3:45:22 PM by KrazyKopter

I didn't even know there was a page for Petit Roid 3 here. Having read it a few years ago, I can confirm it's something to cut. At the beginning, the three ridicolously human robots, who are little girls in basic form, can have sex only if they fuse all together and assume an adult form. However, after just a few chapters, a new "functionality" is unlocked and they can have sex in teen form (only two of them combining) or in the basic child form. And the "rabbit system" mentioned in the wiki page is the reason the main character has to have sex with them in any form.

Oh, and from the hoops it goes through to justify the loli sex, it gets increasingly idiotic. I had serious difficulty reaching the end.

edited 26th May '12 5:24:35 PM by GendoIkari

Well, it's certainly getting a devilhead from me.

I thought Petit Roid 3 was clearly a hentai manga? At least, that's what I recall the last time I saw any mention.

edited 26th May '12 5:44:19 PM by Pyrite

I do not agree with sex with l word robots.

As for my "case" against Sankaku Complex: browsing their gallery as I often do (I loathe the main site but I like that, there are many legitimately good pics and it's a great source to find Pixiv galleries), I noticed that on the basic settings - which means, the ones you find if you are a casual visitor - the gallery has no filters. It's not like Danbooru, which at least hides the "loli" and "shota" tags by default. And given Sankaku's stance on lolicon...

So, should I flag it to call for a re-review?

Yes you should. I think Sankaku Complex should have been nuked first round, why it got to stay with a lock, I have no idea. It's worse than Danbooru, and it's not even notable as Snark Bait outside the anime community.

OK, flagged. Here is the post where I originally expressed my concerns.

Also, I think what he's trying to say is that the translators weren't going for accuracy and may have mistranslated that line - they couldn't have known about a TV Tropes policy, but they probably wouldn't have cared either way.

Right.

There's also another possibility: the line could be accurately translated but not mean what it seems to. I can easily see some character with A-Cup Angst saying that she looks prepubescent (or being teased by someone saying she looks prepubescent). That doesn't mean that the character is actually indistinguishable from an 11 year old; it's an exaggeration for effect.

Besides, you guys let through Tenchi Muyo and that features a character who intentionally and deliberately looks prepubescent while collecting a sperm sample from Tenchi using her hands.

Which I think was a bad decision, to be honest. I think Tenchi Muyo should have been removed for consistency with our policies if this was indeed shown or even implied beyond a Fade to Black, but I guess the scene was seen as enough of a throwaway joke or something? I don't know.

Haven't seen the scene myself, but our page says she merely attempted to for an experiment before they were interrupted.

In any event, that seems to be an isolated incident from what I can gather (in my current sleep-deprived state), and cutting such a large an influential work for a one-shot scene seems unnecessarily, for lack of a better word, prudish.

Now, I'm off to bed before I say anything else I may regret later.

edited 26th May '12 8:44:43 PM by TheFoxsCloak

If it's any concern, Toonami did air a censored version of Tenchi Muyo at one point, and it was a block aimed at preteens-teenagers for the most part.

Washu, right? I don't think she ever succeeded in that.

She was basically just a short adult anyway.

Wasshu specifically states that she made herself look like a child because she doesn't want to deal with adult problems. She's a child, she's not just short.

Of course it's correct that this is a small part of a larger series.

She just looks short to me. She acts like an old woman, she doesn't get fanservice scenes or outfits for the most part (so far as I remember. I'll admit I haven't watched Tenchi in probably a decade or more) and she doesn't even show up that much.

edited 26th May '12 8:54:28 PM by Arha