List of requests for The Nostalgia Critic

My Top 11 List of things I wish The NC would review, descending order. Why Top 11? Because I Said So.

• 11. Wishbone- Aw snap, this was my childhood. It was pretty much the only reason why I even read stuff like Tale Of Two Cities and Silas Marner when I was 7. Besides, who else would like to hear him say "But What About Wishbone!"?
• 10. Pinky, Elmyra, And, The Brain: As fellow fan of the Animaniacs and Pinky And The Brain as well as Tiny Toons, I'm very curious as to what his opinions on this are. For as much Executive Meddling this had, it wasn't exactly a bad show and actually tried to stay true to the characters. That being said, it sucked horribly.
• 9. Dinosaur- Probably one of the most obscure Disney Animated Canon features made in the 2000s.
• 8. The Rugrats Movie- His Nicktoons review is one of my favorites and I'm very interested in what his thoughts were on their first The Movie.
• 7. 2010TheYearWeMakeContact- a relatively obscure sequel to the 2001 Space Odyssey classic, I'm interested in what he has to say about it since it's got mixed reviews.
• 6. Cartoon Network Originals: If you're a kid from the 90s with cable, you grew up with either one of these shows. Nickelodeon was more Since he did a review of the old original Nicktoons, it's only logical that he should review nostalgic shows from the other cartoon channel as well.
• 5. The Emperors New Groove: Funniest Disney film by far, why hasn't it been mentioned?
• 4. The Magic School Bus: Another classic show from my childhood, I don't know if he was still interested in cartoons during the time but it was one of my all time favorites.
• 3. Old Vs New The Simpsons: Seriously, there's a lot that could be done with this one. The Simpsons have arguably gotten a little more formulaic in the later seasons, becoming more about political satire than outlandish family sitcom, but some of the new episodes aren't that bad. Plus The Simpsons Movie was a really good throwback, I think I would enjoy hearing him talk about the show for 20 minutes.
• 2. Top 11 Big-Lipped Alligator Moment s- Seriously, why hasn't this happened yet? Him and the Nostalgia Chick pretty much popularized this trope and yet they've barely used it recently. It deserves a comeback and I would really like to see him review it again.
• 1. The Nightmare Before Christmas- For the sheer number of references The NC makes to this film, it's surprisingly absent from every single list he's made. I mean he didn't even list it on his Top 11 Christmas specials!

edited 2nd Mar '11 1:35:11 PM by Mattonymy

The Water Babies.

Jumanji.

Baby Geniuses.

A Fairy Tale.

Barney (TV Series).

You sadistic fiend. I wouldn't wish Barney on my worst enemy.

Raggedy Ann And Andy A Musical Adventure

edited 2nd Mar '11 5:27:34 AM by Myrmidon

Some of those are past his cut-off date. Plus, His Top 11 Mind-fucks are all basically Big-Lipped Alligator Moment(s).

edited 2nd Mar '11 6:54:08 AM by kyun

What is exactly the cut off date?

The Adventures Of The American Rabbit.

Turn of the millenium, though he's made a few exceptions for franchise sequels and fan requests.

edited 2nd Mar '11 7:36:30 AM by Filby

@Kyun. I always thought those were more like Disney Acid Sequence s rather than BLAM moments.

He should do George Of The Jungle, given that he already did Flubber and Inspector Gadget.

Hell, Rocky And Bullwinkle and Dudley Doright will also work.

The Animorphs TV show.

The Mega Man animated series.

In the same principle, I would also like to see him review Looney Tunes Back In Action. Its at the cusp of his cutoff date but since he reviewed Spider Man 3 I think it could count.

A-NY LIVE-AC-TION A-DAPT-A-TION OF A CAR-TOON.

They're all perfect for him.

Note that he touched on Spider-Man 3 only because he was reviewing all three movies in one video, and it was one of his Top 11 Lists, so that was one of the special cases.

edited 2nd Mar '11 12:00:24 PM by kyun

Keep in mind that George Of The Jungle and Dudley Doright are both 90's films, while Rocky And Bullwinkle is in the year 2000 and therefore would qualify for the to-review list.

I remember seeing two of the three (have not seen Dudley Doright). Been literally years since I saw those two...

I think George Of The Jungle is a pretty good movie.

edited 2nd Mar '11 2:57:03 PM by Nightwire

He's done good movies before. His Guilty Pleasure/So Bad, It's Good episodes are among my favorites.

I know, but he rarely reviews good movies as the Nostalgia Critic.

Then again, I guess it's been years since I've seen George Of The Jungle. Probably a Guilty Pleasure, because I didn't have a negative opinion of it when I saw it.

Dudley Doright on the other hand (haven't seen, but heard it is not good)...

edited 2nd Mar '11 3:05:36 PM by EarlOfSandvich

I've never seen that movie but a friend who can find something good in just about everything called George Of The Jungle the worst, most insipid movie she'd ever seen. So, that's actually not a bad request.

As far as personal requests go, I'd like to see a retrospect of the old PBS kids shows, like Mister Rogers Neighborhood, Sesame Street, The Electric Company, Barney, etc.

edited 5th Mar '11 9:17:07 AM by snaver

How about an old vs new of the Shaggy Dog! The new one was just shit.

I still thin he should do Animorphs, though.

The Critic. Full stop.

And maybe a general "The Disney Afternoon" episode.

edited 2nd Mar '11 5:53:45 PM by punchy

I have a list, and topping it is the Goosebumps tv show.

A Disney Afternoon retrospective in the vein of the Nickelodeon series would be awesome.

The Black Cauldron

How about we bring up some Old vs. New that he could do, those are pretty good too.

Or a list of commercials, I mean honestly, with the movies, that's one track mind.