These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
The ATF agents in "Devil Monkey". Not only do they ignore strange animal calls and mangled human bodies, they go out unarmed and, obviously, end up killed by the titular creatures. The Sheriff has this to a lesser extent as, instead of blasting the damn thing with a shotgun, He turns around to tell the reporter to flee and then gets jumped. However he gains some sanity points, as he is Genre Savvy enough to not leave the local legend completely out of the equation and at least tries to hold the creature off.
Narm Charm - Sometimes, the episodes fall flat on their faces (often with blatantly supernatural creatures). Other times, they manage to hit some actual tension (one featuring the giant monitor lizard Megalania and the Bigfoot episode) in the direction. Watching someone suffer from Blood Poisoning is pretty terrifying since that sort of thing can happen when bitten by certain venomous animals. Still, nothing can grant forgiveness of the terrible acting in the opening of Lizardman.
Nightmare Fuel: Sometimes, the show manages to break out of Narm Charm and actually work - Death Raptor, Vampire, Wendigo, Alien and Skin-Walker are genuinely scary.
After the Alien episode, do not be surprised if you start expecting your doctor to tell you that s/he hears two heartbeats inside of you at your daily check up.
The Owlman reaches near Slender Man levels of this, what with the fact that it spent a long time stalking an unfortunate old woman to the point that she was driven almost completely insane by it, traumatizing a young girl and somehow being aware of the presence of people who plan to get rid of it before they even show up.