YMMV / Carnosaur

YMMV tropes in the films:

  • Adaptation Displacement: There's a book. That's right, there is a book called Carnosaur.
  • Ensemble Darkhorse: Polcheck in Carnosaur 3.
  • First Installment Wins: Generally in fan circles only the first two movies are seen as having merit.
  • Ham and Cheese: Cyril O'Reilly and Tony Todd in 3 and Eden Formula, respectively.
  • Hell Is That Noise: The eerie call that the raptors make is enough to send shivers down your spine.
  • Idiot Plot: Carnosaur 3. Full stop.
  • Narm:
    • In the the first film and novel a Deinonychus gets into and kills two teenagers in a van. Unlike in the novel however, where the creature is fully grown, the animal in the film starts as a baby and grows up throughout it. The attack occurs when it is still a juvenile, so the resulting scene is a critter the size of a schnauzer killing two people.
    • Aside from the bad special effects in general, a character in Carnosaur 2 attempts to box with a velociraptor. Really.
    • The rather obvious Product Placement for Coca-Cola in the first movie's boardroom scenes.
    • Sarah Rawlins' death in the second film is extremely graphic visually. But turn the video off and just listen to the audio it... sounds like the Raptor is doing something else R rated to her.
  • So Bad, It's Good
  • Special Effects Failure: In the raptors' case, you can immediately tell they are "men-in-rubber-suits". In the T-rex's case, it often appears to be stop-motion animation of someone playing with a T-rex toy. Even though it isn'tnote .
    • The Deinonychus effects in the first film were done with a mix of antimatronics and a hand puppet of all things. It looks less like a dinosaur attacking people and more like Kermit the Frog going on a homicidal rampage.
    • The Hellish Copter in 2 is obviously a plastic figure.
    • The T. rex in the Eden Formula, when it's not stock footage from Carnosaur 1 and 2, is rendered in CGI so terrible it makes the original Carnosaur look like Jurassic Park by comparison.
    • Also from The Eden Formula, one scene has a villain hotwire a car and drive off with it. The scene of him driving is stock footage and the car in question suddenly has two passengers!
  • Spiritual Successor: Dino Croc , a Roger Corman production in which a large Prehistoric Monster is brought back by mad science that wreaks havoc on the general populace.
  • They Just Didn't Care: in regards to actually adapting the novel, they obviously didn't. Besides the premise of reviving dinosaurs by modifying chicken cells, the only thing the movie has in common with the novel is the first name of a major villain.

YMMV Tropes for the book:

  • Genius Bonus: The novel discusses atavistic fear a few times. The conceit being that because primitive mammals learned to stay away from giant reptiles, the smells and sounds they make reawaken survival instincts in humans. Similar theories are put forth in Real Life about why nails on a chalk board or sirens causes unease (i.e. that they sound like the calls of predators that hunted our ancestors while they were still small.)
  • Jerkass Woobie: You eventually get to feeling sorry for Jane Penward, despite her many character flaws.
  • Older Than They Think: This book had some key elements that Jurassic Park would later bring to the public conciousness several years before it came out. Namely, dinosaurs are portrayed as bird-like, quick, and intelligent instead of lumbering cold blooded brutes.