Western Animation / When Dinosaurs Roamed America
When Dinosaurs Roamed America
(2001, sometimes shortened to When Dinosaurs Roamed
, especially outside North America) was the Discovery Channel
's first major attempt to cash-in
on the dinosaur
trend started by BBC
's famous Walking with Dinosaurs
. Similar to that program, this also aimed for a Speculative Documentary
format, and used CGI
to recreate its dinosaurs, pterosaurs, and various other prehistoric animals
, placing them into real-life
scenery. The stories were told in chronological order, from the beginning to the end of the dinosaurs' reign.
Unlike its predecessor/competitor, however, WDRA
included short cut-away scenes to paleontologists and at times froze the animation to reveal the skeletal structure behind the animals' skin, using solid facts to explain the science
that went into creating the program.
Other things that make it different from WWD
is the fact that it concentrates purely on American dinosaurs
, and condenses its stories into small segments, instead of devoting full episodes to them.
While disliked by some due to how quickly Discovery churned it out after hearing of the dinosaurs' marketability from Britain, the product was generally well-received by the viewers, especially compared to some later works, such as Clash of the Dinosaurs
and Monsters Resurrected
The work contains examples of the following tropes:
- All There in the Manual: Notice that small, unnamed theropod from the very beginning of the last segment? The website reveals it's The Cameo of Ornithomimus.
- Always a Bigger Fish: Allosaurus to Ceratosaurus. Also counts as an example of The Hunter Becomes the Hunted.
- The Megapnosaurus (Kayentavenator?) suddenly cease their attack on the Anchisaurus. It turns out that the Dilophosaurus has shown up.
- Animals Not to Scale: Most likely the result of the animators not paying attention. When the first T. rex shows up, it doesn't seem out of scale with the rest of the animals. But the narration claims it's a juvenile. Later, when his mother appears, she is hulking huge, even compared to the "Anatotitan" which is supposed to be the same size as a rex!
- Similarly Megapnosaurus is said to be 10 feet long; how come the not-even 7 foot Anchisaurus is more than twice their size (this could be a case of Science Marches On as the larger Ammosaurus is sometimes considered Anchisaurus)?
- Apocalypse How: A Class4 event at the end of the Cretaceous, but interestingly, the documentary also starts with an even larger meteor-strike, that was supposed to represent the great extinction event that ended the Permian and made way for the evolution of dinosaurs in the Triassic. A lesser meteor-related extinction also separates the Triassic and Jurassic.
- Beware My Stinger Tail: Stegosaurus and Desmatosuchus.
- Eagle Land: Back when eagles still had teeth.
- Eats Babies: Ceratosaurus.
- Everything's Better with Dinosaurs
- Failed a Spot Check: The deinonychosaurs fail to notice a forest fire, even when being surrounded by flames.
- Behind the Black: And the Ceratosaurus doesn't notice the hulking huge, oncoming Allosaurus either, until it's right on top of it. To the ceratosaur's credit, though, it was off-screen, even if out in the open, plainly visible from all sides.
- Family-Unfriendly Death: What happens to the poor Apatosaurus that trips and falls.
- Feathered Fiend: The documentary famously depicted many dinosaurs with feathers, including "raptors" and the bizarre-looking Nothronychus.
- Follow the Leader: To Walking with Dinosaurs.
- Foregone Conclusion: The extinction at the end of the Cretaceous period.
- Giant Flyer: Quetzalcoatlus.
- Hemisphere Bias: It's in the title.
- The Hunter Becomes the Hunted: Allosaurus does this to Ceratosaurus.
- Infant Immortality: Averted, the Ceratosaurus catches a juvenile Dryosaurus.
- Mighty Roar: Tyrannosaurus, obviously, but Dilophosaurus also has an awesome roar (which sounds oddly metallic).
- Narrator: John Goodman.
- Never Smile at a Crocodile: Averted by the herbivorous Desmatosuchus, but the (likely) non pseudosuchian Rutiodon does the job.
- No Pronunciation Guide: Desmatosuchus and Anatotitan are mispronounced "Demastosuchus" and "Anatatotitan", respectively.
- Dubs fared no better. For instance all three Hungarian narrations (yes, there's that many) had trouble deciding where to use soft "C"s and hard "K"s, which lead to mispronunciations like "Koelophysis", "Keratosaurus" and "koelurosaurus" — on the other hand, the third version got Desmatosuchus right for once.
- Noisy Nature: For a dinosaur-show, this is almost prerequisite. A particularly glaring example is the Dilophosaurus. Justified in the part where the Syntarsus (now Megapnosaurus) steal his food, since he is trying to scare them away, but for the most part he can't seem to shut up even when he's stalking prey (Ironically, Science Marches On and it is fairly certain most dinosaurs were not incredibly noisy animals).
- Prehistoric Monster: Avoided, although the animals do behave as aggressive as its intended audience expects them to.
- Ptero Soarer: The Quetzalcoatlus may seem outdated by today's standards, but that's the result of science marching on.
- Raptor Attack: Somewhat justified, as the CGI team couldn't get their feathers to be quite as birdlike as they should be.
- Real Is Brown: Practically all the animals are shades of brown.
- Roger Rabbit Effect: The CGI creatures are dropped into Real Life scenery.
- Science Marches On: The lower arms of the raptors are suspiciously scaly. We now know that they had properly feathered wings.
- The theropod hands shouldn't be pronated (kangaroo-like). Their palms actually faced towards each other.
- Syntarsus is called Megapnosaurus now, and it may be synonymous with Coelophysis.note
- According to the Narrator, Megapnosaurus and Dilophosaurus are ceratosaurs. According to recent classifications, both creatures fall outside this group.
- "Anatotitan" now appears to be synonymous with Edmontosaurus, which does not otherwise appear in the show.
- Most of the animals shown would probably be much more colourful rather than just shades of brown or grey.
- It's likely a meteor strike was not the primary cause of the Permian or Triassic extinction.
- Anchisaurus would have run on two legs; if not have done everything on two legs.
- Icarosaurus was not the first reptile to evolve the ability to glide (this is more of Artistic License – Paleontology as earlier gliding animals like Coelurosauravus and Sharovipteryx were known many years before the documentary's creation).
- Ceratosaurus was by no far stretch the last ceratosaur; if anything, it was one of the earlier ones.
- Megapnosaurus and dromaeosaurids are now thought to be primarily nocturnal hunters.
- Sauropod eggs have been found in Morrison formation, even of Camarasaurus, a sauropod featured in the show.
- Dromaeosaurids are now thought to have used their claws for gripping and clinging rather than slashing.
- Although Ornithomimus was portrayed with feathers; it is now known they had much more than shown, having fully feathered wings like birds or dromaeosaurids.
- Quetzalcoatlus is portrayed as a vulture-like scavenger that was "a fish out of water" (to quote the narrator) when it wasn't flying. It is now pretty certain that it was quite proficient at walking and would probably be able to gallop after live prey up to the size of humans.
- It is also depicted as being scaly (all pterosaurs probably had coats of "pycnofibres") and said to weigh only 200 pounds (present estimates put it at over twice this weight).
- There is no evidence that female Tyrannosaurus were larger than males.
- Grass had evolved by the end of the Late Cretaceous.
- The juvenile T. rex are depicted very similar to adults and scaly, while more recent discoveries show they were much more lithe and slender than shown in the documentary (it is said in the documentary that the juveniles' legs were longer but the CGI showed little difference) and may have had a downy coat.
- Hadrosaurs could not chew by moving their mouths from side to side, they actually moved their top jaw front to back.
- Screams Like a Little Girl: The Ceratosaurus, as the Allosaurus kills it.
- Seldom-Seen Species: Desmatosuchus, Icarosaurus, Rutiodon, Anchisaurus, Camarasaurus, Nothronychus, and Zuniceratops.
- Sexy Discretion Shot: When the Stegosaurus pair get ready to mate, the camera tilts skywards. This was the only solution, though: we don't really know just how they did it.
- Shown Their Work: The scenes of paleontologists inserted in between the dinosaur clips.
- Feathered raptors and therizinosaurs.
- Small Taxonomy Pools: Averted. Many stock creatures appear, but so do a number of animals that have rarely ever been shown on television, notably the (then) newly-discovered Nothronychus and Zuniceratops, as well as yet undescribed and unnamed Zuni coelurosaur.
- Speculative Documentary
- Stock Dinosaurs: Coelophysis in the Triassic (the only dinosaur in that segment), along with Allosaurus, Apatosaurus, Stegosaurus, Ceratosaurus and Dilophosaurus from the Jurassic and Tyrannosaurus, Triceratops, "Anatotitan", and Quetzalcoatlus from the Cretaceous.
- Too Dumb to Live: The dromaeosaurid attacking the Nothronychus head on, although both survive the attack. They then die when they're burned alive because they were too busy eating to run away from the fire.
- Tyrannosaurus rex: The arguable "star" of the final segment.
- Wolverine Claws: Nothronychus.