"When proposing a new Mumorpeger, the logical first question is: Are you fucking insane? WOW picks bigger rivals than you out of its teeth every morning!"Stop. Right now. Stop, turn, walk out the door. You do not want to do this. That is, unless you actually have a giant company backing you, a huge team of designers and a huge budget to match. Not to mention plenty of time. A major MMORPG takes a lot of work, and if you're considering making an MMO with three 20-year-old friends in somebody's basement, you'd better head over to Write A Minor MMORPG first. Because almost certainly you won't have the resources you need to make something as grand as World of Warcraft. Then again, maybe you do, so, in case it's possible, here's the advice to make it good. To make a huge, trend-setting, big-budget MMO, almost certainly 3-dimensional, with jaw-dropping graphics and the potential for millions of subscribers. And, one would hope, millions upon millions of dollars. It goes without saying, but I'll say it anyway: Don't forget to check out Write A Story for general advice on how to make people keep playing. (I suppose we'll get a videogame-specific page up sooner or later.)
Necessary TropesDeath Tropes. Even if you avoid fighting and killing as major sources of experience, you'll end up on the other side of the scale, working with Never Say "Die" and so forth.
Choices, ChoicesMany of the basic elements of RPG's apply, including the need for some sort of stats and level gain. The choice is: What sort of stats are you after? You get to design a system, from the sweet simplicity of BESM's body-mind-soul to the complexity of a dozen or more basic stats, and probably dozens or even hundreds of abilities beyond that. And then there's the question of how you want to gain experience: Mostly fighting, mostly questing, mostly role-playing of some sort? Not to mention, do stats go up automatically with each level, or does the player get a degree of control over which stats get focused on? Or do stats go up only with use? Same question about abilities.
PitfallsWhile "grinding" in the sense of "spending time gaining levels" is a given, one of the biggest pitfalls is pointless grinding, that is, making players perform pointless quests or waste their time doing things they don't want to do. Some possibilities include "Go bring me that item I could easily fetch myself" and "run around the map a few dozen times talking to NPC's who eventually send you back to me because I had the item / the answer all along". And, of course, Yahtzee's main gripe:
Potential SubversionsOne of the biggest gripes about something that seems inevitable is the gripe against Perpetually Static. If you manage somehow to avert this, you will probably usher in a whole new era of awe. And pull players away from lesser MMORPG's, which is probably something you want, overall. To avert Perpetually Static, you'll want to meet the following criteria:
Suggested Themes and Aesops
Set Designer / Location ScoutThis is where you'll get to have fun, but also the place that you could end up screwing it all up. Avoid Patchwork Map. Try to ensure that the map actually looks like it could be a real world, or go the other way and make it as LSD-induced as possible just to avoid any comparisons with reality. But don't stick forests right next to deserts, or make rivers appears out of nowhere. Also avoid Misplaced Wildlife, lest [Artistic License - Biology You Fail Biology Forever]].
Props DepartmentAh, yes. The mostly static Aesthetics. When designing and placing props for diverse environments, you should make sure that the props are diverse as well. Make sure the architecture is unique and varied. Don't just give the farmhouse a slight retexture for each environment or variation. It can also get quite repetitive if the player trudges through the forest through similar patches of trees. Please, try avoid the Copy And Paste Environments. Give the props their own characteristics and add a bit of lore into them. Don't just stick to the usual. Change it a bit, but not too much... Just like it's not a very good idea to have a bland, standard world, it's also not very good to have a world that looked like it came from Ninja Pirate Zombie Robot or Cloudcuckooland, either. You could just add so many flavors into it before it turns into a light brown gunk that tastes like caramel. You could also just coat it and change it so much before it becomes overcoated and the original intention is lost. Also, making every prop have hundreds of unique variants is not very healthy for one's harddrive, especially if you expect millions to play it. Also, don't forget to place these props in the environment! And try being creative. Use the landscape to your advantage, and all that.
The Epic Fails
Additional ResearchHere's the sort of stuff you ought to be studying: