- The album Encore is not for the faint of heart and isn't the best music to sleep to (but then again, why the fuck would you sleep to Eminem anyway?). The last track closes with Eminem shooting his crowd and killing himself. A robotic voice ends the album saying, "See you in hell, fuckers." If you thought hearing the shooting was scary, wait until you◊ actually see it◊.
- "Stan" is fairly disturbing. It's about an Ax-Crazy fan who eventually commits a murder-suicide because Shady won't answer any of his fan letters in a timely manner. Especially as the tape is starting to end and you can hear Stan's girlfriend screaming from the trunk before the car falls into the water… At the climax of the song, Stan realizes that he can't ensure that Em will receive the tape that he's recording.
- Look in the train window after Eminem makes his realization.
- An additional example of Nightmare Fuel from the video for this troper was actually in the long version, before the song begins. We see Stan pouring bleach over his head that turns his brown hair blonde within a matter of minutes. To anyone who's bleached their hair, this indicates that the bleach is pretty strong. And then he rubs it over his face, including into his eyes without even flinching...
- "Kim", the prequel to "'97 Bonnie & Clyde" on The Slim Shady LP. The song isn't so much rapped as screamed between Eminem and his impression of Kim. It starts out innocently enough with Em watching Hailie sleep, but quickly goes south as he shoves Kim into a car and reveals he's murdered her new boyfriend and their 4-year-old son (lyrics describing this were actually left off the explicit version of the album, even though a later reference to the murder was left in; a truly explicit version called "Bitch So Wrong", which keeps the words intact, has been leaked and is still floating around online). It ends with him slitting her throat in the woods:
You were supposed to love me!Now bleed, bitch, bleed!BLEED, BITCH, BLEED!BLEEEEEEEEEEED!
- Eminem's rage builds up so quickly and so freakishly that his final scream of "BLEEEEED!" sounds inhuman.
- Em's lyrics on "Guilty Conscience" as the proverbial shoulder devil to Dre's (presumed) angel. At first, he just sounds shameless, casually encouraging a shootup and statutory rape, but in the final verse, when he encourages a man to shoot his unfaithful wife, it reaches a visceral anger similar to "Kim."
Fuck slittin' her throat! Cut this bitch's head off!!
- As far as mainstream rappers go, Eminem is pretty hard to beat when it comes to being disturbing. On the same album as "Kim" we have "Amityville", a brazen ode to Detroit which exalts its status as the then-murder capital of the country. Of note is Bizarre's guest appearance, in which he packs his weight's worth of degeneracy into a mere eight bars.
- Relapse is a album chock-full of murder fantasies and story-telling.
- In particular, there's "Same Song and Dance" which is about kidnapping, raping, torturing and murdering celebrities. The title is perhaps the worst part, as the "song" refers to his victims' screams, and the "dance" refers to their struggle to escape as he has his way with them. And to him, it's just the same ol' "song and dance", showing he's become so desensitized to the horrible things he does that it's become hum-drum to him.
- "3 a.m." is a horror movie made into music.
- "Music Box", which is possibly his most outright disturbing song to date. Cannibalism, murder, Satanism, pedophilia, stalking, rape, torture... so many great, wholesome flavors make up this little nightmare anthem.
- "97 Bonnie And Clyde" from The Slim Shady LP (originally titled Just the Two of Us). It's one of his most haunting songs, sung from the point of view of Shady talking to his daughter, Hailie after murdering his wife for infidelity. He has his little daughter help him unload the dead wife from the trunk of his car and dump her corpse in a lake.
- While Just Don't Give A Fuck's lyrics aren't too terrifying in and of themselves, the beat to both the EP and LP versions features a loop of what sounds like a large and possibly malfunctioning industrial device throughout the entire song.
- "Bad Guy" off of MMLP2. It has undoubtedly the most evil beat out of any Eminem song, and it features the same high-pitched string patch that drove Insane from Relapse. On top of that, the song is about Stan's brother trying to kill Eminem in a successful effort that ends in the same sort of murder-suicide that took Stan and his girlfriend. And that's just part one.
- The Slim Shady EP, the demo that got Em his big break, is just full of it. It starts off with an intro where Slim Shady comes back to life after having been previously "killed" and orders Eminem to look into the mirror as he resists and screams in the background, all accompanied by the sound of shattering glass...
- On 'Cleanin' Out my Closet' from The Eminem Show he mentions that his mother had Munchausen's syndrome, and led young Eminem to believe he was sick, and it's implied that he was also led to believe he was dying. He did grow up, of course, but that must have been pretty scary, since young kids don't have any real reason or inclination to disbelieve a parent.
- Em's collab with Skylar Grey called Twisted is one helluva creepy song. No rapping aside, Em sings about wanting to kill his girlfriend simply because she annoys him. The end also has the two of them giggling at the end of the track, which is even creepier.