- The scene where Kermit and Ms. Piggy sing "Love Led Us Here."
- While it's never really explored in-depth, Jim's friendship with Rizzo and Gonzo does have some cute moments, such as when they affirm their True Companions status at the Benbow, followed by a collective "I Want" Song.
- When Silver's crew turns on him:
Silver: Run for it! Save yourself, lad!Jim: ..Why are you doing this?Silver: Because I like you. I hope you didn't think I was lying about that.
- And when Silver throws Jim's compass back to him before rowing away — after refusing to kill him, no less.
- Sweetums turns out to be on the side of Jim and Cap. Smollett. Though it's got some elements of CMOF and CMOA to it as well.
Smollett: Wh— Well, thank you, but aren't you supposed to be fighting against us?Sweetums: Are you kidding? I love you guys! Ahaha!
- The scenes intercutting Kermit and Miss Piggy's duet with Silver and the pirates finding the treasure are quite heartwarming, considering how many years they spent looking for it.
- Mr. Arrow lives! If for no other reason that this is the only Treasure Island adaptation where he lives. The fact that he's played by Sam the Eagle doesn't hurt either.