I'm falling behind with these, I realize, so here's another installment in which I don't offer a recap; instead, I offer my opinions of what happened during the episode.
Tarrlok knows how to get what he wants. I respect him for that, and I respect him for trying to be proactive in fixing the problem, the fact that he's a bending supremacist and general asshole aside. In terms of effective bad guys, I cannot really complain. Not only does Tarrlok show his chops, but later on, when Korra goes alone to face Amon in a duel?
He shows up with far superior firepower. It was an excellent villain move, and had he been more ruthless, the series could well have ended at that point.
My theory is that he's waiting until she achieves the Avatar state, so he can kill her and end the Avatar cycle forever. This is what he means by "premature" - he wants her to be more than a martyr. He wants her death to be a show of anti-bending strength. This is incredibly savvy of him, though we all know it'll come back to bite him in the ass later.
So look. I have two big quibbles with this show so far, as entertaining as it is and as much as I'm enjoying its villains. Both of them have to do with Korra. First, the issue of feminism. This series hasn't been too great about passing the Bechdel Test so far. There's been a few conversations, but aside from that, a clear, immediate focus has been established - Korra likes Mako, but so does Asami, and the love triangle is being brought to the fore as a central conflict of the show. Both of our central female characters are embroiled in this. Embroiled in competing over a man.
Korra also isn't nearly as competent as Aang. In the original series, despite being frozen in a block of ice for one hundred years, Aang's antique bending allowed him to hold his own against numerous, modern, well-trained foes. Need I reiterate, he was a ten-year-old boy. During the first three episodes of his show, he won practically every fight he got into.
Korra's only won in controlled, meaningless conditions. Nearly every time a fight with actual stakes has come up, she hasn't unambiguously won. She's managed to escape, or she's lost. Every time she does win, she's punished for it. So far, she hasn't managed to do anything particularly heroic. She's won a pro-bending match, barely, and if you'd placed Aang in a similar scenario, the odds point to him being much better at it than Korra was.
Let's bear in mind: Korra has modern training. Korra has been trained by Katara, herself a Waterbending prodigy. She has been doted on by the White Lotus and offered every possible advantage and privilege. Yet, she's horrendously bad at pro-bending and has no idea how to deal with chi-blockers, even though they've been around for what, seventy-five years now? Aang had to deal with missing a century and he was far, far more competent than Korra, a bending prodigy to put Azula to shame, who knew how to handle three elements at age four.
Now, none of this would be a huge issue. The show's shifted mood, the noir feel, and the darkness inherent in the premise all suggest that the hero should, at least at first, be less successful. The issue is that a lot of what we're seeing here blatantly contradicts what happened in the original series, and it makes Korra look weak by comparison.
And none of that would be a huge issue if Korra wasn't a girl with brown skin. Whereas Aang, by contrast, was a boy with pale skin. In comparison, it just comes off looking really suspicious - rife, as it were, with Unfortunate Implications.
That said, I still like the show, and I can see what it's going for. I just don't think it's fair not to point out these things when the show itself is examining similar themes in some depth.
Comments
- spellcheck'd