Single Proposition: Rename Metal Slime

Rename Marshmallow HellRename Metal Slime rename Metroidvania
Single Proposition
Single Proposition: Rename Metal Slime
Vote up for yes, down for no.
At issue:
-26 (yeas:16 nays:42)
Should Metal Slime be renamed? Vote UP to indicate you think it should be renamed; DOWN to indicate you think the current name should be kept.

Forum discussion is here

Do not add alternative names or other options to this crowner.

PRO RENAME
  • Understanding the name requires familiarity with the original metal slime enemy, since "metal [noun]", "[adjective] slime", and "metal slime" do not evoke the trope, though they do evoke one of the possible variants of one of the required traits.
    • Listing a monster type on a works page as a Metal Slime is counterintuitive for people who don't know the trope, since the name better fits an otherwise weak monster with very high defense—a common trait of Metal Slimes, but hardly necessary and certainly not the most important part of the trope.
  • Alternative names have been offered that are concise and considered descriptive and accurate by some. No rename will occur until consensus has been reached on an alternative.
  • Tropes are not only of interest to particular fandoms and all other site guidelines trend to not make assumptions of reader involvement in fandoms.
  • Assumptions as to the knowledge of genre fans, without any actual proof, remains subject to Fan Myopia.

ANTI RENAME
  • The trope namer is the Ur-Example
  • A many people who play RPGs are familiar with Dragon Quest and the original metal slime.
  • No reasonably concise descriptive name that accurately describes the trope has yet been offered.
Total number: 1. Number shown: 1.

Total number of votes: 58

Rename Marshmallow HellRename Metal Slime rename Metroidvania
Single Proposition
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/SingleProposition/RenameMetalSlime?openall=yes