History YMMV / PanicAtTheDisco

** On their cover of "Skid Row" from ''LittleShopOfHorrors, Brendon does one hell of a job [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-33B84fsKE doing the opening]], which is typically belted out torch singer-style.

* FridgeBrilliance: One can notice that Brendon is wearing his wedding ring during the music video for 'Nicotine,' which was probably an accident, as the character is supposed to be bringing flowers to his lover (which could unintentionally imply YourCheatingHeart) But when his lover is revealed [[spoiler: to have been DeadAllAlong, one could interpret that she was his wife and he still wears his wedding ring]]

* EveryoneIsSatanInHell: Naturally the music video for ''The Emperor's New Clothes'' gotten this from Christian conspiarcy theorists.

* EarWorm: At least one song on every album can qualify as this.
** A lot of the 6 second songs Brendon posts on his Vine qualify as well

** ''Series/StrangerThings'' jokes about the "LA Devotee" video abound, due to its protagonist being placed by Noah Schnapps, aka Will Byers.

* PoorMansSubstitute: Inverted. No one really gives much thought anymore to original bassist Brent Wilson (Probably because Jon Walker was around longer and much more willing to smile in photo shoots)
** It seems like Dallon Weekes and Ian Crawford are about to become this, after Ross' and Walker's departure. Though many fans adore them, many are still quite bitter over the split.

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Dallon for a lot of people, the fact he had [[TheBrobecks a discography]] before he entered the band helped.

** Jokes about Brendon secretly wanting Ryan to come back are also popular

* OneOfUs: Brendon is a fan of video games and other such nerdy pursuits.

* HeReallyCanAct: Brendon pulled this off in his role in Razia's Shadow, which is an actual story-driven musical rather than a standard album.

** On the YouTube page for ''The Ballad Of Mona Lisa'', a frequent comment is about the netgun used to capture Mary at the end.

* AwesomeMusic: At least a few songs on every album.

* CrowningMomentOfFunny:

* FriendlyFandoms: Music/FallOutBoy and Panic! fans often overlap. This isn't surprising considering their similar music styles, shared origins and penchant for [[LongTitle Long Titles]].They overlap a lot with the Music/MyChemicalRomance fanbase, too. This is probably due to the witty and intelligent rebellion lyrics. It's more like, which one did you become a fan of first.

-->'''Brendon:''' ...It's just us...
-->'''Spencer:''' It always has been

* SweetDreamsFuel: Pretty much all of ''Pretty. Odd.''. Especially "Behind The Sea", "She Had The World", and "When The Day Met The Night".

* VisualEffectsOfAwesome: The entire music video for "Emperor's New Clothes" is about Brendon slowly transforming into a demon, and is a beauty of editing and makeup effects.

** ''Pray For the Wicked'' was either a great followup to ''Death of a Bachelor'' with the Kinky Boots influence warmly received, or a [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks mainstream]] letdown full of AlbumFiller.

** ''Pray For the Wicked'' was either a great followup to ''Death of a Bachelor'' with the Kinky Boots influence warmly received, or a mainstream letdown full of AlbumFiller.

* SophomoreSlump: Apart from "Northern Downpour," ''Pretty. Odd.'' was much less well-received both critically and commercially than the debut ''A Fever You Can't Sweat Out,'' due in large part to the dramatic shift in sound. ''Vices & Virtues,'' while not being lauded, was better-received critically and enjoyed better album sales, though a true return to positive reception wouldn't come until ''Too Weird To Live, Too Rare To Die!''
* SurprisinglyImprovedSequel: After ''Pretty. Odd.'' and ''Vices & Virtues'' underperformed as follow-ups to ''A Fever You Can't Sweat Out'', ''Too Weird To Live, Too Rare To Die!'' was extremely well done, even attracting people who were ambivalent about the first three albums.

* SophomoreSlump: Apart from "Northern Downpour," ''Pretty. Odd.'' was much less well-received both critically and commercially than the debut ''A Fever You Can't Sweat Out,'' due in large part to the dramatic shift in sound. ''Vices & Virtues,'' while not being lauded, was better-received critically and enjoyed better album sales.
* SurprisinglyImprovedSequel: While ''Pretty. Odd.'' was not this for ''A Fever You Can't Sweat Out'', for most people, and ''Vices & Virtues'' also fell flat, ''Too Weird To Live, Too Rare To Die!'' was extremely well done, even attracting people who were ambivalent about the first three albums.

* AlbumFiller: A decent amount of ''Pray for the Wicked''.

* SignatureSong: "I Write Sins Not Tragedies", to the extent that performances often involve [[AudienceParticipation Brendon and/or Dallon pointing the mic at the audience as they sing a majority of the song]]

* CrowningMomentOfAwesome: At the AT&T Block Party in 2016, they performed "Bohemian Rhapsody". Yes, ''that'' Bohemian Rhapsody.
** They opened up "Sugar, We're Going Down". Brendon got to the third word, and made it into an IncrediblyLongNote. Then, suddenly, after he's done, he yelled "April Fools, ''motherfuckers!''" and transitioned into "This Is Gospel".
** Any live performance of "The End Of All Things" where Brendon Urie hits [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=abH4yGNpxSQ all the high notes.]] Good lord!
* CrowningMomentOfFunny: A lot of the things Brendon says on stage can qualify as this, but one example is when Brendon was performing with a bad cold and said something along the lines of "This might be a paradox, guys, but I think God is punishing me for being an atheist."

* AwesomeMusic: At least one song on every album.

** As of 2015, Dallon is now just a touring member. He doesn't write songs or contribute in the studio anymore. "Death of a Bachelor" is literally a Brendon Urie solo album.