Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / HomageToCatalonia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RagtagBunchOfMisfits: The various party militias on the Republican side. Orwell describes the POUM militia, in which he served, as a particularly {{egregious}} example of this trope - an untrained, scruffy-looking band, partly composed of teenage boys whose enthusiasm was decidedly greater than their common sense.

to:

* RagtagBunchOfMisfits: The various party militias on the Republican side. Orwell describes the POUM militia, in which he served, as a particularly {{egregious}} JustForFun/{{egregious}} example of this trope - an untrained, scruffy-looking band, partly composed of teenage boys whose enthusiasm was decidedly greater than their common sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HomeByChristmas: A general commanding the Government troops after the fall of Siétamo proclaimed that "Tomorrow we'll have coffee in Huesca." Months of brutal fighting in the city in question disproved the general's proclamation.

to:

* HomeByChristmas: A general commanding the Government troops after the fall of Siétamo proclaimed that "Tomorrow we'll have coffee in Huesca." Months of brutal fighting in the city in question disproved the general's proclamation. Orwell mused that if he ever returned to Spain he would make it a point to go to Huesca and have coffee there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedScare: Inverted-various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will (specifically mentioned is a political cartoon in which a figure representing the POUM pulls a hammer and sickle-marked mask from its face to reveal a monstrous visage adorned with a swastika).

to:

* RedScare: Inverted-various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will (specifically mentioned is a [[https://www2.warwick.ac.uk/services/library/mrc/explorefurther/digital/scw/more/simpletimeline2/sa12-12-006.jpg political cartoon cartoon]] in which a figure representing the POUM pulls a hammer and sickle-marked mask from its face to reveal a monstrous visage adorned with a swastika).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:266:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/homage_to_catalonia_cover_1st_edition.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
1. Unnecessary Editorializing. 2. Untrue. As Paul Preston pointed out. It was Nazi-Fascist interference and the absence of US-UK interference and the inability of USSR to stretch themselves that far without Atlantic support that led to Franco's triumph, in addition to weak leadership on the side of the Republicans. Contrary to general belief, the in-fighting and the anarchist attempt at "Revolution" was a minor event, albeit overexposed, part of the conflict.


* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists, Anarchists and Socialists. None of them trusted the others (there was even rivalry between different Communist factions), but they all were against the Fascists. Orwell notes that the closer one got to the front, the better the camaraderie between the different groups. The fallout behind the lines helped to lose them the war.

to:

* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists, Anarchists and Socialists. None of them trusted the others (there was even rivalry between different Communist factions), but they all were against the Fascists. Orwell notes that the closer one got to the front, the better the camaraderie between the different groups. The fallout behind the lines helped to lose them the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
They were all Republicans (i.e. supporting the Spanish Republic).


* UrbanWarfare: Happened in Barcelona, between the Anarchists on one side and Communists & Republicans on the other.
* WarIsHell: Played with. The chapters about the trench warfare on the Aragon front don't fit this trope, but not WarIsGlorious, either; rather, Orwell describes it as boring and stale. He repeatedly emphasizes that there was hardly any action, and that everyone was more concerned about food and firewood than about the enemy. What close-quarters fighting he did see he describes as harrowing.

to:

* UrbanWarfare: Happened in Barcelona, between the Anarchists on one side and Communists & Republicans on the other.
* WarIsHell: Played with.{{Played with}}. The chapters about the trench warfare on the Aragon front don't fit this trope, but not WarIsGlorious, either; rather, Orwell describes it as boring and stale. He repeatedly emphasizes that there was hardly any action, and that everyone was more concerned about food and firewood than about the enemy. What close-quarters fighting he did see he describes as harrowing.



* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists, Anarchists and Republicans. None of them trusted the others (there was even rivalry between different Communist factions), but they all were against the Fascists. Orwell notes that the closer one got to the front, the better the camaraderie between the different groups.

to:

* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists, Anarchists and Republicans.Socialists. None of them trusted the others (there was even rivalry between different Communist factions), but they all were against the Fascists. Orwell notes that the closer one got to the front, the better the camaraderie between the different groups. The fallout behind the lines helped to lose them the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--> '''Paul Preston''': Orwell's Homage to Catalonia is a brilliant and painfully honest book but it is not a "true" book. That is to say, it is not true if it is taken, as it is by most readers, as an overview of the Spanish civil war, when, in reality, it is a narrow and partisan account of one relatively marginal issue within the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The entire book can be read for free online [[http://www.george-orwell.org/Homage_to_Catalonia/ here]].

to:

The entire book can be read for free online [[http://www.george-orwell.org/Homage_to_Catalonia/ here]].
here]]. Note that two chapters that were initially published as appendices have been renumbered as chapters in this version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The entire book can be read for free online [[http://www.george-orwell.org/Homage_to_Catalonia/here]].

to:

The entire book can be read for free online [[http://www.george-orwell.org/Homage_to_Catalonia/here]].
org/Homage_to_Catalonia/ here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The entire book can be read for free online [[http://www.george-orwell.org/Homage_to_Catalonia/here]].

Added: 105

Changed: 482

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChronicBackstabbingDisorder: The Communist high command.

to:

* ChronicBackstabbingDisorder: The Communist high command. Their efforts in trying to sabotage the non-Stalinist parties ended up harming the war effort. Orwell was particularly incensed by the fact that they not only outlawed the POUM, they decided not to inform the POUM fighters at the front of this fact. This meant that any POUM members coming back from the front, whether just for rest or to recover from injuries, would unwittingly be walking right into prison, and thus they could never return to the front and continue the fight.


Added DiffLines:

* FireForgedFriends: Orwell and the POUM members he served with, particularly his commander Georges Kopp.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedScare: Inverted-various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will (specifically mentioned is a political cartoon in which a figure representing the POUM pulls a hammer and sickle-marked mask from its face to reveal a monstrous face adorned with a swastika).

to:

* RedScare: Inverted-various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will (specifically mentioned is a political cartoon in which a figure representing the POUM pulls a hammer and sickle-marked mask from its face to reveal a monstrous face visage adorned with a swastika).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OrwellianEditor: The [[BlatantLies horrible distortions of the truth]] which Orwell witnessed in Spain are the TropeMaker - they inspired the constant rewriting of the past in ''Literature/NineteenEightyFour'', which in turn [[TropeNamer named this trope]].

to:

* OrwellianEditor: The [[BlatantLies horrible distortions of the truth]] which Orwell witnessed in Spain (in particular the idea of the POUM being "Franco's Fifth Column") are the TropeMaker - they inspired the constant rewriting of the past in ''Literature/NineteenEightyFour'', which in turn [[TropeNamer named this trope]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BloodFromTheMouth: Unsurprisingly happens to Orwell himself when he's shot in the throat by a sniper.

Changed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists, Anarchists and Republicans. None of them trusted the others (there was even rivalry between different Communist factions), but they all were against the Fascists.

to:

* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists, Anarchists and Republicans. None of them trusted the others (there was even rivalry between different Communist factions), but they all were against the Fascists. Orwell notes that the closer one got to the front, the better the camaraderie between the different groups.

Added: 394

Changed: 745

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedScare: Inverted-various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will.

to:

* RedScare: Inverted-various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will.will (specifically mentioned is a political cartoon in which a figure representing the POUM pulls a hammer and sickle-marked mask from its face to reveal a monstrous face adorned with a swastika).



* WarIsHell: Played with. The chapters about the trench warfare on the Aragon front don't fit this trope, but not WarIsGlorious, either; rather, Orwell describes it as boring and stale. He repeatedly emphasizes that there was hardly any action, and that everyone was more concerned about food and firewood than about the enemy.

to:

* UrbanWarfare: Happened in Barcelona, between the Anarchists on one side and Communists & Republicans on the other.
* WarIsHell: Played with. The chapters about the trench warfare on the Aragon front don't fit this trope, but not WarIsGlorious, either; rather, Orwell describes it as boring and stale. He repeatedly emphasizes that there was hardly any action, and that everyone was more concerned about food and firewood than about the enemy. What close-quarters fighting he did see he describes as harrowing.



* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists and Anarchists.

to:

* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists Communists, Anarchists and Anarchists.Republicans. None of them trusted the others (there was even rivalry between different Communist factions), but they all were against the Fascists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Orwell also loved the Spanish revolution and thought it's end was a bad thing.

to:

** Orwell also loved the Spanish revolution and thought it's its end was a bad thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Orwell also loved the Spanish revolution and thought it's end was a bad thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: A downplayed example with the POUM, more in the sense of exaggerating their presence in events rather than in terms of their actual actions though. They were one of the smaller political groupings on the Republican side and the amount of emphasis they receive in history comes mostly from the fact Orwell just so happened to sign up with them rather than with the CNT militias. The other half is of course that later Trotskyists have lionized the POUM in spite of Trotsky's actual criticism of them at the time.

Changed: 298

Removed: 312

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cruft


* LanguageEqualsThought: The leftists refused to use ceremonial forms of address, preferring to simply call each other "thou" or "comrade".
** To clarify: In Spanish-as-spoken-in-Spain, there are two forms of the second person: the formal "usted" and the more casual "tú", and the usage of one or the other also affects how verbs are declined and other pronouns are used. The Catalonian anarchists favored usage of the latter as being less class-based.

to:

* LanguageEqualsThought: The leftists refused to use ceremonial forms of address, preferring to simply call each other "thou" or "comrade".
** To clarify:
"comrade". In Spanish-as-spoken-in-Spain, there are two forms of the second person: the formal "usted" and the more casual "tú", and the usage of one or the other also affects how verbs are declined and other pronouns are used. The Catalonian anarchists favored usage of the latter as being less class-based.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GraffitiOfTheResistance: Orwell described doing this himself, writing "Visca P.O.U.M.!" on walls in Barcelona after the P.O.U.M.'s suppression.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To clarify: In Spanish-as-spoken-in-Spain, there are two forms of the second person: the formal "usted" and the more casual "tú", and the usage of one or the other also affects how verbs are declined and other pronouns are used. The Catalonian commmunes favored the usage of the latter.

to:

** To clarify: In Spanish-as-spoken-in-Spain, there are two forms of the second person: the formal "usted" and the more casual "tú", and the usage of one or the other also affects how verbs are declined and other pronouns are used. The Catalonian commmunes anarchists favored the usage of the latter.latter as being less class-based.



* RedScare: Inverted - various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will.

to:

* RedScare: Inverted - various Inverted-various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will.



* WarIsHell: Played with. The chapters about the trench warfare on the Aragon front don't fit this trope, but not WarIsGlorious, either; rather, Orwell describes it as boring and stale. He repeatedly emphasises that there was hardly any action, and that everyone was more concerned about food and firewood than about the enemy.

to:

* WarIsHell: Played with. The chapters about the trench warfare on the Aragon front don't fit this trope, but not WarIsGlorious, either; rather, Orwell describes it as boring and stale. He repeatedly emphasises emphasizes that there was hardly any action, and that everyone was more concerned about food and firewood than about the enemy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Homage to Catalonia'' is Creator/GeorgeOrwell's account of his experiences in the SpanishCivilWar. He describes fighting as a militiaman on the side of the Republicans, as well as the gradual erosion of the Anarchist revolution in Catalonia and the [[DividedWeFall power struggle between various factions on the Republican side]]. It may well be the most famous book about the Spanish Civil War, and is widely praised for its BrutalHonesty.

to:

''Homage to Catalonia'' is Creator/GeorgeOrwell's account of his experiences in the SpanishCivilWar.UsefulNotes/SpanishCivilWar. He describes fighting as a militiaman on the side of the Republicans, as well as the gradual erosion of the Anarchist revolution in Catalonia and the [[DividedWeFall power struggle between various factions on the Republican side]]. It may well be the most famous book about the Spanish Civil War, and is widely praised for its BrutalHonesty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnarchyIsChaos: Averted. Anarchist Catalonia is portrayed largely favourably, and while the situation in Spain is somewhat chaotic, Orwell makes it clear that this is due to it being in a state of civil war rather than due to it being in a state of anarchy. The POUM troops may be a RagtagBandOfMisfits but they are also quick to stand up for one another.

to:

* AnarchyIsChaos: Averted. Anarchist Catalonia is portrayed largely favourably, and while the situation in Spain is somewhat chaotic, hardly in a condition that an outside observer might qualify as order, Orwell makes it clear that this is due to it being in a state of civil war rather than due to it being in a state of anarchy. The POUM troops may be a RagtagBandOfMisfits but they are also quick to stand up for one another. The opening pages of the book portray what conditions are like in Catalonia away from the trenches and they are anything but chaotic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnarchyIsChaos: Averted. Anarchist Catalonia is portrayed largely favourably, and despite the civil war, there isn't much in the book that could be described as "chaos".

to:

* AnarchyIsChaos: Averted. Anarchist Catalonia is portrayed largely favourably, and despite while the situation in Spain is somewhat chaotic, Orwell makes it clear that this is due to it being in a state of civil war, there isn't much war rather than due to it being in the book that could a state of anarchy. The POUM troops may be described as "chaos".a RagtagBandOfMisfits but they are also quick to stand up for one another.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnarchyIsChaos: Averted. Anarchist Catalonia is portrayed largely favourably.

to:

* AnarchyIsChaos: Averted. Anarchist Catalonia is portrayed largely favourably.favourably, and despite the civil war, there isn't much in the book that could be described as "chaos".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnarchyIsChaos: Averted. Anarchist Catalonia is portrayed largely favourably.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HomeByChristmas: A general commanding the Government troops after the fall of Siétamo proclaimed that "Tomorrow we'll have coffee in Huesca." Months of brutal fighting in the city in question disproved the general's proclamation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Avert Word Cruft.


* WideEyedIdealist: The Republicans, especially the international volunteers. Orwell himself averts this trope, ''hard''.

to:

* WideEyedIdealist: The Republicans, especially the international volunteers. Orwell himself averts this trope, ''hard''.trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''Homage to Catalonia'' is Creator/GeorgeOrwell's account of his experiences in the SpanishCivilWar. He describes fighting as a militiaman on the side of the Republicans, as well as the gradual erosion of the Anarchist revolution in Catalonia and the [[DividedWeFall power struggle between various factions on the Republican side]]. It may well be the most famous book about the Spanish Civil War, and is widely praised for its BrutalHonesty.

----
!!Homage to Catalonia provides examples of:

* AuthorTract: Orwell loved this trope; this book is no exception.
* ChildSoldiers: The party militias included many underage boys. Orwell notes that they were quite useless as soldiers, since they couldn't stand the sleep deprivation that was inevitable in trench warfare.
* ChronicBackstabbingDisorder: The Communist high command.
* CommieLand: Catalonia, although its organization was more along anarchist lines.
* EagleSquadron: The many international volunteers, including Orwell himself, who came to Spain to fight for TheRepublic.
* EverybodySmokes: Shortage of cigarettes is often brought up as a major hardship of war. Orwell even refers to it as a 'tobacco famine'.
* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Orwell's comrades weren't exactly big on UsefulNotes/GunSafety - [[TooDumbToLive even after seeing this trope in effect]].
* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Everyone in Spain, according to Orwell. 'In this war, everyone always did miss everyone else, when it was humanly possible.' It saved his life on several occasions.
* LanguageEqualsThought: The leftists refused to use ceremonial forms of address, preferring to simply call each other "thou" or "comrade".
** To clarify: In Spanish-as-spoken-in-Spain, there are two forms of the second person: the formal "usted" and the more casual "tú", and the usage of one or the other also affects how verbs are declined and other pronouns are used. The Catalonian commmunes favored the usage of the latter.
* OrwellianEditor: The [[BlatantLies horrible distortions of the truth]] which Orwell witnessed in Spain are the TropeMaker - they inspired the constant rewriting of the past in ''Literature/NineteenEightyFour'', which in turn [[TropeNamer named this trope]].
* RagtagBunchOfMisfits: The various party militias on the Republican side. Orwell describes the POUM militia, in which he served, as a particularly {{egregious}} example of this trope - an untrained, scruffy-looking band, partly composed of teenage boys whose enthusiasm was decidedly greater than their common sense.
* RedScare: Inverted - various "Red" factions accused each other of ''not'' being Red enough. Communist propaganda even accused the POUM of plotting with Franco, a "Brown Scare" if you will.
* TheRepublic: ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin.
* TheRevolutionWillNotBeVilified: Propaganda was common on all sides, something Orwell is careful to note.
* WarIsHell: Played with. The chapters about the trench warfare on the Aragon front don't fit this trope, but not WarIsGlorious, either; rather, Orwell describes it as boring and stale. He repeatedly emphasises that there was hardly any action, and that everyone was more concerned about food and firewood than about the enemy.
* WasItAllALie: After the betrayal by the Stalinists.
* WeAreStrugglingTogether: Communists and Anarchists.
* WideEyedIdealist: The Republicans, especially the international volunteers. Orwell himself averts this trope, ''hard''.
* WitchHunt: What the [[TheManBehindTheMan Soviet-backed]] Communists unleashed against the POUM.
----

Top