Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion Main / ShonenDemographic

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
crashkey Since: Apr, 2015
Feb 2nd 2021 at 3:05:23 PM •••

What is up with this site's policy of its lists of shonen/shojo etc. series being entirely determined by what magazine a manga adaptation ran in? I mean, I get that that's literally what demographic they were marketed to, but what is even the point of defining shonen/shojo and its tropes if the truth of the matter comes down entirely to objective market facts instead of anything about their stories? I'm not even sure why I'm saying this because nothing is going to change, but hopefully I'm not the only person in history to realize how pointless this makes the articles.

ClipboardFox22 Bringing Back Asexy Since: Mar, 2013
Bringing Back Asexy
Feb 24th 2020 at 8:51:18 PM •••

not really a discussion question, just noticed that Gyro was at the top of the page image even though Steel Ball Run moved to Ultra Jump (seinen) after only a year in Shonen Jump, so the time frame of the image is between Feb 2004 and Apr 2005, found that a bit funny

Angry queer dude. Ze/zer, they/them, or xe/xyr/xem pronouns.
SMG4fan Since: Nov, 2017
Apr 11th 2018 at 4:44:54 PM •••

Isn't Princess Mononoke a Shonen? Miyazaki said that the film is aimed at older kids, which pretty much translates to shonen. I know its pretty violent and has a lot of emotional aspects for a shonen but its pretty tame compared to later stuff like Attack On Titan

Hide / Show Replies
Goku92 Since: Aug, 2018
Oct 21st 2019 at 7:25:51 AM •••

Shonen in general are primarily for teenage boys. 12-18. Not kids. Attack On Titan is for older teens 15+. And no cuz Princess Mononoke is a film and Shonen mainly attributes to manga. Only anime based on Shonen manga can be classified as Shonen anime.

Kombucha Since: Jun, 2013
Jan 11th 2017 at 12:07:27 PM •••

So what does Shonen actually mean? The article doesn't do a good job of making it clear. In fact, this is a common problem with articles here where tropes are not properly explained in the opening few paragraphs, which are instead taken up with lengthy introductions like "There is x, and there is y, and then these is this trope."

SeanRenaud Since: Oct, 2010
Nov 19th 2012 at 6:14:13 PM •••

Strategy. I know I'm asking a lot but seems like in every Shonen there is a point, usually right before or right after the main character gets their first power up but there is always a fairly early point story wise where no amount of strategy, luck or even playing the numbers game are going to do anything but piss off your opponent.

SilverWings Since: Aug, 2015
May 11th 2012 at 8:00:55 PM •••

Am I the I Ou one who thinks that the universe would explode in a singularity of awesome if all the characters in the page image met in real life?

Hide / Show Replies
sdmitch16 Since: Aug, 2011
Aug 31st 2011 at 9:37:45 AM •••

Japanese culture. Japanese culture in America. Media for teens/ boys. Animation. Action. What do you mean its drama? Just some ideas.

Edited by sdmitch16 Will I be informed if people reply to my discussion post?
Top