Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / RWBY

Go To

[002] Wyldchyld Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The example doesn\'t actually explain why there\'s dislike for the voice actor. The Forum thread has suggested it\'s because of things the voice actor has said, which would be unrelated to the work in question and therefore not characterisation. As it is, the example doesn\'t explain the reason, which doesn\'t tie it into the YMMV item description, or how wide-spread the objection is. If anything, the wording makes it sound like the issue is about replacing Monty.
to:
The example doesn\\\'t actually explain why there\\\'s dislike for the voice actor. The Forum thread has suggested it\\\'s because of things the voice actor has said, which would be unrelated to the work in question and therefore not characterisation. If anything, the wording makes it sound like the issue is about replacing Monty. It\\\'s not clear how it fits the YMMV item description.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The example doesn\'t actually explain why there\'s dislike for the voice actor. The Forum thread has suggested it\'s because of things the voice actor has said, which would be unrelated to the work in question and therefore not characterisation. As it is, the example doesn\'t explain the reason, which doesn\'t tie it into the YMMV item description, or how wide-spread the objection is.
to:
The example doesn\\\'t actually explain why there\\\'s dislike for the voice actor. The Forum thread has suggested it\\\'s because of things the voice actor has said, which would be unrelated to the work in question and therefore not characterisation. As it is, the example doesn\\\'t explain the reason, which doesn\\\'t tie it into the YMMV item description, or how wide-spread the objection is. If anything, the wording makes it sound like the issue is about replacing Monty.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
If it is wide-spread enough, I have no problem with it being a BrokenBase example.
to:
If it is a wide-spread enough enough complaint (I\\\'ve never encountered it on any forums I visit, but that doesn\\\'t necessarily mean anything), I have no problem with it being a BrokenBase example.
Top