Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Manga / NausicaaOfTheValleyOfTheWind

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Why is there so many elements that are totally absent from the manga in the \
to:
Why are there so many elements that are totally absent from the manga in the \\\"Common to both versions\\\" section? I\\\'m thinking of removing them all, it\\\'s really a mess. And by \\\"removing\\\" I mean \\\"deleting\\\", since I haven\\\'t seen the movie.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
\'\'\'I find it very hard at this stage to avoid putting him into the \
to:
\\\'\\\'\\\'I find it very hard at this stage to avoid putting him into the \\\"abusive\\\" bracket\\\'\\\'\\\'

Try.

\\\'\\\'\\\'If the danger at the Court was his priority, he would remove her from the Court and actually make some attempt at parenting.\\\'\\\'\\\'

The Court itself isn\\\'t dangerous. It\\\'s Reynard, Coyote and Ysengrin that are dangerous. The obvious solution then is to restrict her from seeing them.

\\\'\\\'\\\'And he doesn\\\'t tell Annie to hand control of Rey to someone who might actually know what they were doing - he demands that control be handed over to him, personally.\\\'\\\'\\\'

And what is your basis for believing that he doesn\\\'t know what he\\\'s doing?


* \\\"puts you down or says you aren’t good enough,\\\"
** Hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"ignores you or leaves you out of things,\\\"
** Hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"says or does things that make you feel bad about yourself,\\\"
** Maybe the makeup thing, but that\\\'s a matter for debate.
* \\\"pushes you away or makes you feel like you don’t belong in the family,\\\"
** Except for not explaining how he lost his hand, which she doesn\\\'t really need to know anyway, hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"tries to control you or push you too hard,\\\"
** He\\\'s her father. He\\\'s got every right to control her in order to protect her from the murderous fox spirit and the psychotic wolf man and the amoral god and the ToxicFriendInfluence that allows her to screw herself out of an education by cheating on her schoolwork.
* \\\"stops you from having friends.\\\"
** Again, murderous fox spirit, etc.

So out of 6 criterion, that\\\'s a grand total of maybe 2, but a highly contentious 2, more like 2 \\\"1/2s\\\", which would benefit from further evidence before prematurely labeling.

\\\'\\\'\\\'(\\\"Dad, you\\\'re missing a limb!\\\" \\\"HOW DARE YOU QUESTION ME!\\\")\\\'\\\'\\\'

Except he didn\\\'t say anything remotely like HOW DARE YOU QUESTION ME! He just said it wasn\\\'t her concern, and it\\\'s not.

You yourself admit that you\\\'re reading way to much into this, so what\\\'s the problem?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
\'\'\'I find it very hard at this stage to avoid putting him into the \
to:
\\\'\\\'\\\'I find it very hard at this stage to avoid putting him into the \\\"abusive\\\" bracket\\\'\\\'\\\'

Try.

\\\'\\\'\\\'If the danger at the Court was his priority, he would remove her from the Court and actually make some attempt at parenting.\\\'\\\'\\\'

The Court itself isn\\\'t dangerous. It\\\'s Reynard, Coyote and Ysengrin that are dangerous. The obvious solution then is to restrict her from seeing them.

\\\'\\\'\\\'And he doesn\\\'t tell Annie to hand control of Rey to someone who might actually know what they were doing - he demands that control be handed over to him, personally.\\\'\\\'\\\'

And what is your basis for believing that he doesn\\\'t know what he\\\'s doing?


* \\\"puts you down or says you aren’t good enough,\\\"
** Hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"ignores you or leaves you out of things,\\\"
** Hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"says or does things that make you feel bad about yourself,\\\"
** Maybe the makeup thing, but that\\\'s a matter for debate.
* \\\"pushes you away or makes you feel like you don’t belong in the family,\\\"
** Except for not explaining how he lost his hand, which she doesn\\\'t really need to know anyway, hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"tries to control you or push you too hard,\\\"
** He\\\'s her father. He\\\'s got every right to control her in order to protect her from the murderous fox spirit and the psychotic wolf man and the amoral god and the ToxicFriendInfluence that allows her to screw herself out of an education by cheating on her schoolwork.
* \\\"stops you from having friends.\\\"
** Again, murderous fox spirit, etc.

So out of 6 criterion, that\\\'s a grand total of maybe 2, but a highly contentious , more like 2 \\\"1/2s\\\", which would benefit from further evidence before prematurely labeling.

\\\'\\\'\\\'(\\\"Dad, you\\\'re missing a limb!\\\" \\\"HOW DARE YOU QUESTION ME!\\\")\\\'\\\'\\\'

Except he didn\\\'t say anything remotely like HOW DARE YOU QUESTION ME! He just said it wasn\\\'t her concern, and it\\\'s not.

You yourself admit that you\\\'re reading way to much into this, so what\\\'s the problem?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
\'\'\'I find it very hard at this stage to avoid putting him into the \
to:
\\\'\\\'\\\'I find it very hard at this stage to avoid putting him into the \\\"abusive\\\" bracket\\\'\\\'\\\'

Try.

\\\'\\\'\\\'If the danger at the Court was his priority, he would remove her from the Court and actually make some attempt at parenting.\\\'\\\'\\\'

The Court itself isn\\\'t dangerous. It\\\'s Reynard, Coyote and Ysengrin that are dangerous. The obvious solution then is to restrict her from seeing them.

\\\'\\\'\\\'And he doesn\\\'t tell Annie to hand control of Rey to someone who might actually know what they were doing - he demands that control be handed over to him, personally.\\\'\\\'\\\'

And what is your basis for believing that he doesn\\\'t know what he\\\'s doing?


* \\\"puts you down or says you aren’t good enough,\\\"
** Hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"ignores you or leaves you out of things,\\\"
** Hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"says or does things that make you feel bad about yourself,\\\"
** Maybe the makeup thing, but that\\\'s a matter for debate.
* \\\"pushes you away or makes you feel like you don’t belong in the family,\\\"
** Except for not explaining how he lost his hand, which she doesn\\\'t really need to know anyway, hasn\\\'t done that.
* \\\"tries to control you or push you too hard,\\\"
** He\\\'s her father. He\\\'s got every right to control her in order to protect her from the murderous fox spirit and the psychotic wolf man and the amoral god and the ToxicFriendInfluence that allows her to screw herself out of an education by cheating on her schoolwork.
* \\\"stops you from having friends.\\\"
** Again, murderous fox spirit, etc.

So out of 6 criterion, that\\\'s a grand total of maybe 2, but a highly contentious 2 that would benefit from further evidence before prematurely labeling.

\\\'\\\'\\\'(\\\"Dad, you\\\'re missing a limb!\\\" \\\"HOW DARE YOU QUESTION ME!\\\")\\\'\\\'\\\'

Except he didn\\\'t say anything remotely like HOW DARE YOU QUESTION ME! He just said it wasn\\\'t her concern, and it\\\'s not.

You yourself admit that you\\\'re reading way to much into this, so what\\\'s the problem?
Top