Discussion History Main / EightDeadlyWords

I never said that it\\\'s \\\"good\\\" because of the art, and that\\\'s not even one of the reasons I\\\'m against including it. I simply said the art isn\\\'t actually considered terrible (and a lot of people consider it to be good), so it shouldn\\\'t be mentioned as such just for the sake of having another point against it, especially with no actual explanation.

You\\\'re ignoring all of my other points. It has enough of a following from its target audience and Miller fans to keep it off. And even ignoring that, if the story is as bad as you say, then it needs to have more detail to it, not to mention that the points about the characterization and lingering plot point wouldn\\\'t be enough to get anything else on the list. Like I mentioned a few times already, if you took out the Islamophobia, you\\\'d be left with one line that doesn\\\'t explain anything. \\\"Disjointed and badly paced\\\" doesn\\\'t explain anything. Yes, the Islamaphobia is a major factor in it\\\'s supposed terribleness, but it\\\'s not enough without anything else supporting it. If I were unfamiliar with it, I would have no idea what it\\\'s even about apart from the fact it\\\'s anti-Islam and was supposed to be a Batman comic. Hell, even the bits about the Islamophobia are incredibly vague. How about some actual examples?


Also, I only took it off once after it was readded.

I never said that it\\\'s \\\"good\\\" because of the art, and that\\\'s not even one of the reasons I\\\'m against including it. I simply said the art isn\\\'t actually considered terrible (and a lot of people consider it to be good), so it shouldn\\\'t be mentioned as such just for the sake of having another point against it, especially with no actual explanation.

You\\\'re ignoring all of my other points. It has enough of a following from its target audience and Miller fans to keep it off. And even ignoring that, if the story is as bad as you say, then it needs to have more detail to it, not to mention that the points about the characterization and lingering plot point wouldn\\\'t be enough to get anything else on the list. Like I mentioned a few times already, if you took out the Islamophobia, you\\\'d be left with one line that doesn\\\'t explain anything. Yes, the Islamaphobia is a major factor in it\\\'s supposed terribleness, but it\\\'s not enough without anything else supporting it. Also, I only took it off once after it was readded.

I never said that it\\\'s \\\"good\\\" because of the art, and that\\\'s not even one of the reasons I\\\'m against including it. I simply said the art isn\\\'t actually considered terrible (and a lot of people consider it to be good), so it shouldn\\\'t be mentioned as such, especially with no actual explanation.

You\\\'re ignoring all of my other points. It has enough of a following from its target audience and Miller fans to keep it off. And even ignoring that, if the story is as bad as you say, then it needs to have more detail to it, not to mention that the points about the characterization and lingering plot point wouldn\\\'t be enough to get anything else on the list. Like I mentioned a few times already, if you took out the Islamophobia, you\\\'d be left with one line that doesn\\\'t explain anything. Yes, the Islamaphobia is a major factor in it\\\'s supposed terribleness, but it\\\'s not enough without anything else supporting it. Also, I only took it off once after it was readded.

I never said that it\\\'s \\\"good\\\" because of the art, and that\\\'s not even one of the reasons I\\\'m against including it. I simply said the art isn\\\'t terrible, so don\\\'t mention it as such just for the sake of making the entry bigger. You\\\'re ignoring all of my other points. It has enough of a following from its target audience and Miller fans to keep it off. And even ignoring that, if the story is as bad as you say, then it needs to have more detail to it, not to mention that the points about the characterization and lingering plot point wouldn\\\'t be enough to get anything else on the list. Like I mentioned a few times already, if you took out the Islamophobia, you\\\'d be left with one line that doesn\\\'t explain anything. Yes, the Islamaphobia is a major factor in it\\\'s supposed terribleness, but it\\\'s not enough without anything else supporting it. Also, I only took it off once after it was readded.

I never said that it\\\'s \\\"good\\\" because of the art, and that\\\'s not even one of the reasons I\\\'m against including it. I simply said the art isn\\\'t terrible, so don\\\'t mention it as such just to make it worse than it is. You\\\'re ignoring all of my other points. It has enough of a following from its target audience and Miller fans to keep it off. And even ignoring that, if the story is as bad as you say, then it needs to have more detail to it. Like I mentioned three times already, if you took out the Islamophobia, you\\\'d be left with one line that doesn\\\'t explain anything. Also, I only took it off once after it was readded.

I never said that it\\\'s \\\"good\\\" because of the art, and that\\\'s not even one of the reasons I\\\'m against including it. I simply said the art isn\\\'t terrible, so don\\\'t mention it as such just to make it worse than it is. You\\\'re ignoring all of my other points. It has enough of a following from its target audience and Miller fans to keep it off. And even ignoring that, if the story is as bad as you say, then you need to add more detail to it. One vague line isn\\\'t good enough.