Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Literature / TheHobbit

Go To

Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
And in a sense, \'\'yes\'\'. Look at the CMOA and Fridge pages for franchises like Naruto and Bleach. They get congested with bad entries that start with \
to:
And in a sense, \\\'\\\'yes\\\'\\\'. Look at the CMOA and Fridge pages for franchises like Naruto and Bleach. They get congested with bad entries that start with \\\"this troper felt\\\" and similar hyperbole.

If it doesn\\\'t fit the incredibly vague definition of the trope, should it be here? If the Laconic is too vague to censor entries, shouldn\\\'t the definition be made stricter? This shouldn\\\'t be a dumping ground for \\\"Oh, one of the cast members said this, now that makes sense!\\\"

And some of these aren\\\'t what the trope is. There are some entries I think are plain stupid, some that are okay, some that are pretty interesting, and then there [[strike:are]] were some entries that ignored the trope\\\'s definition. Some are pure speculation.

Entries like this one:

[[quoteblock]]In Vol. 2 Episode 5, Cinder is seen sewing. While the implications for the meaning behind the needle are very much wild mass guessing, the actual act of sewing makes sense in the context of her fairy tale: after all, Cinderella was expected to serve her wicked stepmother and stepsisters and do every chore, sewing included. In Vol. 2 Episode 7, we see her clothes glow like fire when she attacks and could change into a formal dress when she had to make a quick disguise. What we saw her do in episode 5 was weaving dust into her clothes.[[/quoteblock]]

\\\'\\\'\\\'That\\\'s\\\'\\\'\\\' FridgeBrilliance.

This one?

[[quoteblock]]Pyrrha takes on team CRDL in 4 on 1 fight. Who wants to bet she agreed to that because she still had a grudge for how they treated Jaune? Throw in the brutal way she finished off Cardin and it looks pretty likely. Given Glynda\\\'s protests when Mercury requested to fight Pyrrha, it even possible that fighting Team CRDL was Pyrrha\\\'s idea. Sadly, she didn\\\'t make good on her threat to break his legs.[[/quoteblock]]

\\\'\\\'Heck\\\'\\\' no.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
And in a sense, \'\'yes\'\'. Look at the CMOA and Fridge pages for franchises like Naruto and Bleach. They get congested with bad entries that start with \
to:
And in a sense, \\\'\\\'yes\\\'\\\'. Look at the CMOA and Fridge pages for franchises like Naruto and Bleach. They get congested with bad entries that start with \\\"this troper felt\\\" and similar hyperbole.

If it doesn\\\'t fit the incredibly vague definition of the trope, should it be here? If the Laconic is too vague to censor entries, shouldn\\\'t the definition be made stricter? This shouldn\\\'t be a dumping ground for \\\"Oh, one of the cast members said this, now that makes sense!\\\"

And some of these aren\\\'t what the trope is. There are some entries I think are plain stupid, some that are okay, some that are pretty interesting, and then there [[strike:are]] were some entries that ignored the trope\\\'s definition. Some are pure speculation.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
And in a sense, \'\'yes\'\'. Look at the CMOA and Fridge pages for franchises like Naruto and Bleach. They get congested with bad entries that start with \
to:
And in a sense, \\\'\\\'yes\\\'\\\'. Look at the CMOA and Fridge pages for franchises like Naruto and Bleach. They get congested with bad entries that start with \\\"this troper felt\\\" and similar hyperbole.

If it doesn\\\'t fit the incredibly vague definition of the trope, should it be here? If the Laconic is too vague to censor entries, shouldn\\\'t the definition be made stricter?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s TropeDecay.
to:
It\\\'s TropeDecay.

And in a sense, \\\'\\\'yes\\\'\\\'. Look at the CMOA and Fridge pages for franchises like Naruto and Bleach. They get congested with bad entries that start with \\\"this troper felt\\\" and similar hyperbole.
Top